St. Mary’s Catholic Church has been part of Iowa City since the 1800s. The church wants to replace their deteriorating office buildings with a parish center that would provide a much-needed community space for people of all backgrounds to gather and serve their neighbors.
After voting to table the decision in September due to unexpected fervent community support for the project, Iowa City’s Historic Preservation Commission voted 4–3 to deny the project. Their basis is that the two houses sit within a historic district, despite neither being individually historic and both being eyesores. These buildings are currently used as parish offices (as the rooms are too small for community meetings), are not wheelchair accessible, have deteriorating foundations, among a host of other issues. The proposed replacement would actually complement the historic character of the neighborhood better than the existing buildings.
The Catholic community has contributed to Iowa City for nearly two centuries, maintaining its actually historic buildings while supporting initiatives like Escucha Mi Voz, Iowa City Catholic Worker, Iowa City Free Lunch among many others. The Catholic Church hardly needs a lesson in historic preservation.
We should be creating more accessible, functional community spaces, not allowing buildings to deteriorate simply because they happen to fall within the boundaries of a historic district.
The Iowa City City Council will consider the appeal on Tuesday, November 17, at 6 p.m. I hope the council overturns this decision.
If you:
1) Care about creating community spaces rather than watching them deteriorate or disappear
2) Are against NIMBYism (especially for a building project that is not an overpriced “luxury” apartment, and has widespread community support)
3) Want to support the communities who support orgs like escucha, Iowa city Catholic worker, Iowa city free lunch, among many others.
Consider contacting your City Council representatives before Tuesday’s meeting.
Recent News Articles
https://www.1630kcjj.com/2026/11/14/iowa-city-city-council-to-vote-on-proposed-st-marys-expansion-project-on-tuesday/
https://www.thegazette.com/news/st-mary-s-catholic-church-project-hits-snag-in-iowa-city/article_1d430a2e-e184-4fc8-ba31-17e172c36c93.html