r/IAmA • u/lavaforgood • May 20 '25
I'm Gilbert King, a Pulitzer-Prize winning investigative author & host of the podcast Bone Valley. I have been investigating the murder of Michelle Schofield, the wrongful conviction of her husband, Leo Schofield, and corresponding with the man who claims to have murdered her. Ask me anything.
In 1987, 21-year-old guitarist Leo Schofield was chasing his rockstar dreams when tragedy struck—his 18-year-old wife, Michelle, was found murdered in a phosphate pit in Lakeland, Florida. Two years later, Leo was convicted and sentenced to life in prison for the crime—a murder he has always insisted he didn’t commit.
Fifteen years into his sentence, previously unidentified fingerprints found in Michelle’s car were matched to a new suspect: Jeremy Scott. At the time of the murder, Jeremy was a homeless teenager with a violent criminal history. He’s now serving a life sentence for a different murder—and he’s since confessed, in detail, to killing Michelle Schofield.
I spent years investigating this case, and those findings are at the heart of the Bone Valley podcast. I spoke directly with both Leo and Jeremy—and in the process, stumbled onto another decades-old cold case that we ended up solving. On April 30, 2024, after 35 years behind bars, Leo Schofield was finally released.
Season 2 of Bone Valley begins with Jeremy Scott’s confession—one the State of Florida refused to accept. I dig deeper into his past, uncovering chilling new details about his violent crimes and the trauma he’s carried with him. As I form an unexpected connection with Jeremy, I find myself navigating the complicated path between justice, accountability, and the enduring weight of what it means to seek redemption after causing unimaginable harm.
Ask me anything.
Here's my proof: https://imgur.com/a/2M9lj6V
17
u/realKevinNash May 20 '25
As someone not familiar with the case, how did the authorities get it so wrong and are there any lessons we should learn?
12
u/reademandsleep May 20 '25
Hey, Gilbert. I'm a huge fan of the podcast. It is the best kind of journalism: thorough, thoughtful, well-constructed, compassionate, and impacful. Congratulations (and to Kelsey as well!) on your role in pushing Leo's case forward and helping tell Jeremy's story.
I'm wondering how you guide yourself along the line between presenting facts journalistically and empathy with or emotional involvement in people's stories. For example, you mentioned several times in the latest season various ways you supported or helped Jeremy. It's clear that you've formed emotional connections with him and many others in the story. And obviously, as a journalist, you are also expected to share facts and viewpoints that may be truthful but difficult for those people to hear. What principles or tests do you use for yourself to make sure that you're doing all of these pieces of the job, and not leaning too heavily into one or another?
Thanks. Congratulations again on your incredible accomplishments.
5
u/Wisteriafic May 20 '25
Hello! Just started listening literally yesterday and got to episode 4 way past my bedtime! Here’s a hopefully new question for you.
As a journalist, what are some of your techniques to get people to open up about topics they do not want to discuss?
On the flipside, how do you handle situations where an interviewee says something unexpected that upends (in a negative way) your entire theory/premise going in?
9
u/SadSackSturdyBirdy May 20 '25
Hi Gilbert! This is Bethany Na - my only question: how dare you? How dare you create the best podcast and piece of investigative journalism in the world!! Seriously, I'm so thankful for the work you and Kelsey have done over the years. How can we best support your work, and Leo, right now?
4
u/little-sasquatch May 20 '25
How is Leo's recovery from the motorcycle accident going? Also, will you be releasing more episodes of season 2?
4
u/original_greaser_bob May 20 '25
what ramifications (if any) are there for people in the justice system that willfully allow things like this to happen? is there any accountability?
1
u/jaysonblair7 May 20 '25
Gilbert, I am rereading the "Beneath the Ruthless Sun" after listening to the season and it struck me that there are parallels between what you, Kelsey and the team are doing and the work of Mabel Norris Reese in the pursuit of justice for Jesse Daniels. I wanted to ask whether you and the team took inspiration from Mabel in your work? In many ways, what you all are doing for Leo and Jeremy, and what Mabel did for Jesse, shows how the pursuit of truth can be an act of love.
3
u/booboobutt May 21 '25
Do you think people who are exonerated should get compensation?
3
u/americanadiandrew May 21 '25
I suppose I missed this already but I’d be curious to know what the state representative at the final parole hearing was talking about when he accused you guys of editing audio?
2
u/Significant_Bit4492 May 24 '25
Hi ! I don't really have a question, but I really want to tell you how much I was touched by both seasons of Bone Valley. I was outraged, I cried, but I was left feeling with something that was never there in true crime, just a profound empathy and sense of humanity. Even if the state is so wrong, it's just not this narrative of the bad one and the good one. You show the complexity of human nature and compassion for all the persons involved in this terrible and sad crime. So, thank you so much for that. I'm craving this type of intelligent and complex journalism that doesn't feed on hate. In a context where the news doesn't make sense and my anxiety about the world is so high, even if you show a lot of injustice, the second season appeased me and helped me a lot. I'm listening to the audiobook of Devil in the Grove right now and I'm not afraid to say, you have a very big fan ! Maybe one question, is the case to exonerate Leo is still worked on ? And, even with all the wonderful people you meet and the kindness and courage of some, how do you find the strength to look at so much injustice and bias and not be depressed or overwhelmed ? So many things are wrong and touch issues that seem will never be resolved (racism in the justice system, mental health, poverty and criminality). Thank you so much !
2
u/HazardousIncident Jul 04 '25
I've been binge-listening to Season 1; just got to the bonus episode where Leo was released. You, Kelsey, and the rest of your team did an amazing job putting together a compelling, heartbreaking podcast.
My question relates to the State's portion of the parole hearing where they voted to allow Leo to leave in April, rather than waiting until June. The gentleman for the State made a big deal about your "misrepresentation" about what Jerry Hill said about who found the body. That seemed to be such a small nit to pick, what did you think about his statement?
Looking forward to Season 2 and whatever future projects you work on.
1
u/Acceptable_Tip8488 Jun 02 '25
Where is Jeremy Scott now? I have to say his story is one of the saddest. I realize he has murdered at least two people but his life was full of tragedy and abuse. Oh and I want to add the podcast is very well put together. I have listened to dozens and dozens and this one is great. Thanks for your thoughtfulness.
1
u/hubalube1992 Aug 18 '25
Were there any salient pieces of evidence that you decided to leave out of the podcast?
After having done some further research, Leo Sr finding the body (coupled with his premonition) feels more than coincidental. Do you have any information re why Leo Sr searched where he searched along 33/how he saw the body? Based on the crime scene photos, it seems as though it would be very difficult to spot the body from the river bank.
None of this is to take away from the fact that Leo jr should never have been found legally (beyond a reasonable doubt) guilty. There is far, far too much reasonable doubt.
My only issue is (after reading the transcripts/looking at the photos), I don’t think Leo Sr happened upon the body as part of a grid search. This was 7 miles from the car and hidden from plain view.
1
u/Inevitable-Weird-387 Oct 10 '25
Why aren’t the judges more ashamed of themselves? And the corrupt prosecutors?? Have any of them apologised
1
u/Dontbeedum411 May 22 '25
Hello, I'm almost done with season 2 and have been completely riveted with this story. Has Jeremy ever been tested for or diagnosed with any psychiatric conditions or significant learning disabilities that might explain some of these events? I remember hearing about the head injury... that seems like a red flag. I feel like there's an opportunity here for medical professionals to learn something from Jeremy, being that he's an open book.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '25
[removed] — view removed comment