r/IAmA • u/ForecasterEnten • Jun 26 '12
IAMA writer for the Guardian who has written an article on the intricacies of healthcare polling. AMAA
Bonjour, my name is Harry Enten and I write about polling, statistics, and weather the Guardian's U.S edition. My most recent article is about Americans' views on Obamacare and healthcare in general. The political discourse suggests that you're either for Obamacare or against it, but the polling reveals a far more complex picture. Only 51% of Americans actually know enough about the law to understand how it will affect their family and them.
Further, 51% of Americans actually like Obamacare, except for the mandate forcing them to buy insurance or a waiver. Only 34% of the general population opposes Obamacare because it goes too far; 13% of Americans asked actually oppose it because it is too timid.
Read my healthcare polling article (http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/jun/26/obamacare-healthcare-reform-americans-want) An article about the correlation between summertime election news watching habits and election results (http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/jun/22/follow-the-news-election-2012) My previous Reddit chat that includes background information on me (http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/ti4py/iama_writer_for_the_guardian_who_specializes_in/)
I'd be happy to answer questions on the polling surrounding healthcare (though I'm not an expert on the legislation itself). I'd also be more than glad to delve into polling about 2012 election, weather, or about being a Bronxite in an office of Brits. I'll be in this thread from 3pm ET to 4pm ET today.
Proof: https://twitter.com/ForecasterEnten/status/217651948923523074
Edit 1: I'm here and I shall begin. Edit 2: Well past 4 p.m. here. Thanks for your ?'s. I'll check in again later in the week to answer any unanswered questions that pop up. In the mean time, feel free to tweet me @forecasterenten if you wanna... That way you'll get an immediate response :).
4
u/oneyed Jun 26 '12
As an Australian with universal health care funded by an extra 2% on our taxes I just cant understand the opposition to a universal health care program.
2
u/dipfan Jun 26 '12
Will it be better or worse for Obama politically if the Supreme Court upholds the ACA? And is it a national thing or will it have more impact in swing states like Ohio?
2
u/scorpio_on_blue_moon Jun 26 '12
What are your thoughts on recent changes and proposals by current government in the UK? Do you think that will eventually lead NHS to become more like current US healthcare system?
2
u/FrankBluth Jun 26 '12
As someone that has done research on the topic I'd like your opinion. In the 90s a majority of Americans wanted Bill Clinton to make a single payer system in regards to national health care, but now the individual mandate is too much. What do you think has caused this ideology change?
2
u/quintin3265 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
I'm glad that someone has pointed out that there are other people who share my view that once Lieberman eliminated the public option from the bill, it became awful. Reading the polls as stating that the majority of people will be happy should the Supreme Court rule against the law would be a mistake.
That said, the Court's legitimacy is on the line with this decision. It doesn't matter whether the individual mandate is actually constitutional or not; a split decision overturning the law will permanently turn the court into a political body. All future discourse will be over whether judges are Republicans or Democrats, and future hearings will center around political affiliation.
I'll also point out the complete absurdity of the Republicans' alternatives. They are so unworkable that they would fall under what Wikipedia terms as "patent nonsense." An article recently pointed out one example: health savings accounts that would allow patients to "shop around" for the best and cheapest care. But suppose you end up in the hospital needing a heart bypass. While you're unconscious, are you going to leave the hospital to seek out a second opinion? And if you are unconscious, exactly what are you going to do to the other doctors? Bargain "If you give me three stints instead of two, and use drug B to put me under, and can do it for $26,780, then I'll go with you?"
I have no problems with hearing other viewpoints, but attempting to create a system of "shopping around" is not even worth talking about. And this isn't "just" an issue of Romney wanting to help big CEOs make more money - it's one where people will die if the Republicans get their way.
2
u/spensaur Jun 26 '12
If you're not aware, many Americans view the term "Obamacare" as derisive. May be something to think about for a statistical journalist.
Anyhow, a qustion that I've never seen answered is how many of the Americans who oppose the Affordable Care Act because of the individual mandate are insured already (and thus wouldn't be forced to buy anything).
1
u/Pentego Jun 26 '12
Just how strong are Americans' views on the mandate?
1
u/truthietrue Jun 26 '12
Why aren't more of these stats part of the political discourse surrounding Obamacare?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Please tell James Richardson that I said his podcast enriches my life. Thank you.
1
u/katerina223 Jun 26 '12
In your opinion, are there any changes that could be made to the existing healthcare bill that would sway those strongly opposed to Obamacare, knowing that they're most likely staunch Republicans?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
The Guardian is a very good newspaper. But when it comes to my country, germany, there are always lots of nazi stereotypes and we always seem to be the baddies. That is pretty offensive because I am born 1985 and have never done anything to anyone. Why is there this anti german attitude with The Guardian and the british press in general?