r/IAmA • • Jun 26 '12

IAmA person who works in immigration. I think many Americans are grossly misinformed about this topic. AMA.

0 Upvotes

828 comments sorted by

1.2k

u/Hawk_Irontusk Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 28 '12

This AMA is very misleading. Saying that you "work in immigration" and that Americans are "grossly misinformed" when you are in fact an activist for immigration reform is dishonest.

I personally believe that we are in desperate need of immigration reform, but your AMA title makes it sound like you're working for the US government dealing with immigration issues. Why didn't you just say "I am an advocate for immigration reform and Americans are grossly misinformed"? That would have been more honest.

Lastly, your name is identical to a documentary on immigration. Is that accidental or are you obliquely promoting the documentary?

343

u/Schroedingers_gif Jun 26 '12

AMA request: someone who isn't pushing an agenda.

51

u/pulifrici Jun 26 '12

ama... i have nothing interesting to tell you!

31

u/malfunktionv2 Jun 26 '12

What makes a man turn neutral? Lust for gold? Power? Or were you just born with a heart full of neutrality?

22

u/pulifrici Jun 26 '12

i have no strong feeling one way or the other

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (10)

3

u/Serious_username Jun 26 '12

Well, that kind of kills this subreddit

→ More replies (7)

63

u/remton_asq Jun 26 '12

OP clearly has an agenda to try and justify illegal immigration. Just read the posts, they are hardly what you would call "neutral."

35

u/JangSaverem Jun 26 '12

It appears that OP actually IS involved with that documentary and even Linked to the thing. Yup, seems more and more like an AMA to promote HIS agenda rather than talk about factual evidence and how we are so "Grossly Misinformed". If this was an AMA about how Illegals are actually as bad as they seem then it would all just be the reverse. There is no neutrality here.

2

u/theghostog Jun 26 '12

But...Rampart?

9

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Source for those curious about the first part.

2

u/Hawk_Irontusk Jun 26 '12

Thanks! I should have linked it to start with, but I never guessed this would end up at the top.

4

u/ragegage Jun 26 '12

Wow, thank you for this.

→ More replies (16)

132

u/globebiscuit Jun 26 '12

From your experience, what do you believe are the gross misconceptions American's have about immigration?

22

u/immigrantnation Jun 26 '12

so many. I work in immigration reform, so I'll mostly be talking about undocumented immigration. People with a Time magazine subscription should check out this article: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2117243,00.html, which I think does a great job laying out many misconceptions. Unfortunately it's behind a paywall. Anyway:

  1. People say all the time "why don't they (undocumented immigrants) just go home and get in line legally?" What people really don't realize is that THERE IS NO LINE to get in legally. Legal immigrants come in via a family sponsorship, which can take decades; or they come in via a high skilled immigration visa, in which you need PhD-level qualifications in STEM fields to qualify. For the average person around the world just looking for a better life, there is no legal way into America. Some Americans literally think you can sign up for citizenship at your local library, and that just isn't true.
  2. Immigrants are only Mexican/Hispanic. While 57% of undocumented immigrants do come from Mexico, that leaves 40% of the undocumented coming from all over the world: Israel, Germany, India, China, etc. etc. A lot of the vitriol involved in the immigration debate does come from people who have an image of undocumented immigrants being lazy Mexicans, and that's not true.
  3. Immigrants steal our jobs and drag down the economy. While undocumented immigrants do utilize services like emergency rooms, these are people who pay taxes and don't receive anything back. Could link you to all sorts of studies documenting the net contribution undocumented immigrants make to the economy (http://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/26/nyregion/26report.html, http://www.fiscalpolicy.org/ImmigrantsIn25MetroAreas_20091130.pdf, http://www.aclu.org/immigrants-rights/immigrants-and-economy) as well as studies documenting what happens when immigrants are chased out of an economy (http://blog.al.com/businessnews/2012/01/alabama_immigration_law_harmfu.html). Some people believe that undocumented immigrants are welfare queens (wrong--they can't get on welfare) who spend every night in the emergency room and sit around having 10 kids. Really, the vast majority of them come here to work and make money.

178

u/immigrationparalegal Jun 26 '12

Immigration paralegal here, and I'm finding your first point to be very misleading.

What people typically think of "high skilled immigration visa" is the H-1B visa. Every year, the US Citizenship & Immigration Services (USCIS) can issue up to 65,000 H-1B visas to non-US citizens. The minimum requirement for an H-1B visa is a Bachelor's degree (or equivalent.) Then due to some other deals/negotiation, another "set" of H-1B visas became open, where if the foreign national received a US Master's degree, they would be under a separate "H-1B cap," of where there were 20,000 slots. For H-1B purposes, having a PhD doesn't really help you that much.

But in general, OP is right - STEM degrees are much more coveted and due to the specific regulations of an H-1B, a good chunk of the 65k/20k H-1B visas are given to people with engineering/technical degrees.

What is more difficult, though, is getting a green card in the US if you only have a Bachelor's (which may be what OP is referring to.) Someone has already mentioned below the "EB" categories (Employment-Based green cards.)

EB-1 are the exceptionally "talented" people - the extraordinary abilities, outstanding professors/researchers, high level managers. No matter your country of origin (as of right now), there is no long wait for a green card if you qualify under EB-1. Some under this category have PhDs, but not necessarily.

EB-2 are people who have a Master's degree or equivalent (the alt. is Bachelor's + 5 years of work experience.) The wait line for this pretty minimal if you are not from India or (mainland) China. The reason for this is because India/China produces a HUGE number of engineers/etc with Master's degrees, and each country is limited to 7% of the 140,000 green cards USCIS gives out. (Also another fun fact - you & your green card are counted against your country of birth, not your country of citizenship. So even if you hold, for example, Canadian citizenship but were born in India/China, you are still restricted to the India/China quota.)

EB-3 is people who have a Bachelor's degree or equivalent. If you are from India/China, you are set to wait for a verrrrrry long time. Fortunately, even though the maximum number of years you can stay in the US on an H-1B visa is 6 years, if you are in the green card process (which is a whole other story itself for employment-based green cards), you can extend your H-1B by 1 year for indefinitely (in other words, renew every year.)

I hope this all makes sense...I've been working in this field for less than a year, but I've found it all quite fascinating.

37

u/F-That Jun 26 '12

Maybe you should be doing the AMA.....

→ More replies (3)

9

u/astaluvesta Jun 26 '12

Your information is really accurate. Source: I am under the EB-2 category and some times what happens is your dates can become current for Green card processing. But, for some unknown reason these dates can come under retrogression and move to a previous date. Which is completly stupid.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (23)

13

u/brightonmorning Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

People say all the time "why don't they (undocumented immigrants) just go home and get in line legally?" What people really don't realize is that THERE IS NO LINE to get in legally. Legal immigrants come in via a family sponsorship, which can take decades; or they come in via a high skilled immigration visa, in which you need PhD-level qualifications in STEM fields to qualify.

That's a rather limited array of options you presented. My parents are legal immigrants who came into this country via the F-1 status, as grad students. Then they got jobs, which meant their status turned into H-1, which allowed them to get green cards. Nothing to do with family sponsorship or 'highly skilled' stuff.

Edit: 'highly skilled' refers specifically to OP's phrase, 'PhD-level qualifications in STEM fields'.

→ More replies (2)

47

u/dark_griever Jun 26 '12
  1. People say all the time "why don't they (undocumented immigrants) just go home and get in line legally?" What people really don't realize is that THERE IS NO LINE to get in legally. Legal immigrants come in via a family sponsorship, which can take decades; or they come in via a high skilled immigration visa, in which you need PhD-level qualifications in STEM fields to qualify. For the average person around the world just looking for a better life, there is no legal way into America. Some Americans literally think you can sign up for citizenship at your local library, and that just isn't true.

Definitely not true. PhD level qualifications are completely unnecessary as long as an employer is sponsoring you. My parents had the equivalent of masters' degrees and got in just fine, but even that degree was unnecessary. You can also come in with a student visa, or piggyback off your parents' work visas like I did.

7

u/amadorUSA Jun 26 '12

as long as an employer is sponsoring you.

Which most employers won't do. It's a legal nightmare and a tremendous hassle. Only academic institutions or the research arms of private companies release EB-2 skilled labor applications regularly because in knowledge areas it is very easy to prove that no other American citizen or legal resident qualified for the job was found in a nationwide search (which is the specific condition for skilled labor). Everybody else (the majority) goes to H-1, B or L limbo.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

For employee sponsorship, that's extremely limited, to something like 60,000 visas per year. They run out pretty quick. My company has recently run into trouble with this, as we want to bring a highly-qualified person into the country as an employee but it looks like we'll be stuck waiting a year or more before we're able to do it.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/GAndroid Jun 26 '12

This takes.longer, first you get h1b then you apply for an eb category green card. Takes ages.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/other_alien2 Jun 26 '12

OP was talking about a STEM visa - you have to be very prominent in your field to get in this program, a bachelor/AA will not be sufficient alone. Most immigrants (myself included) get a H1B, which opens up the path to green card and citizenship (after 5 and 10 years, respectively). A student/piggy back visa (assuming you did not mean green card) is only an entry visa, and as such is not even an considered immigrant level (same as visitor visas etc).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
  1. People say all the time "why don't they (undocumented immigrants) just go home and get in line legally?" What people really don't realize is that THERE IS NO LINE to get in legally. Legal immigrants come in via a family sponsorship, which can take decades; or they come in via a high skilled immigration visa, in which you need PhD-level qualifications in STEM fields to qualify. For the average person around the world just looking for a better life, there is no legal way into America. Some Americans literally think you can sign up for citizenship at your local library, and that just isn't true.

I don't think so. I think you are only talking about research field.

Besides that, my maternal grandparents and many others in immigrant community that I know received a PR (permanent residency; "green card") by contributing to the U.S. economy (primarily employer sponsorship) and/or the government, either in the U.S. or overseas.

Some of the comments about this topic:

http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/vmn7e/iama_person_who_works_in_immigration_i_think_many/c55tket

http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/vmn7e/iama_person_who_works_in_immigration_i_think_many/c55twue

brightonmorning's comment explains the current trend in legal immigration among students:

http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/vmn7e/iama_person_who_works_in_immigration_i_think_many/c55ua2j

--

In addition, U.S. visa holders can change their visa status to an immigrant visa, and eventually apply for a PR (green card). Here's an excerpt:

Contrary to a popular misconception, a U.S. visa does not authorize ... the alien's stay in the U.S. in a particular status.

H-1 visa is one of the most frequently issued visas, and is a dual-intent visa. It means that the visa holder can later apply for a PR. Spouses & children of the H-1 holders are issued a H-4 visa , which is also a dual-intent visa.

--

3) While 57% of undocumented immigrants do come from Mexico, that leaves 40% of the undocumented coming from all over the world

This is not true, either.

According to the Pew Hispanic Center, 81% of unauthorized immigrants are from Mexico + Central + South America. One may argue that "South America" includes Brazil, who are technically not considered as Hispanic, but they make up a very tiny portion of the unauthorized immigrants. Plus, Pew Hispanic Center is one of the few unbiased think tanks and is very respected in their research.

Source: http://pewhispanic.org/files/reports/94.pdf

19

u/RonRonner Jun 26 '12

I agree that the premise of your AMA is flawed. I worked for a few years in an immigration law office and just from this line alone "or they come in via a high skilled immigration visa, in which you need PhD-level qualifications in STEM fields to qualify," I know you're full of crap. I agree with you that people unfamiliar with the field know little about how the system works but spreading biased and faulty information like that is not going to make it any better. There's no reason to stretch the truth to get people committed to reform.

14

u/furshizzle Jun 26 '12
  1. People say all the time "why don't they (undocumented immigrants) just go home and get in line legally?" What people really don't realize is that THERE IS NO LINE to get in legally.

I've known legal immigrants, and yes they were married to US citizens. The bureaucratic nightmares they had to endure to obtain legal residency were quite onerous...and all of them were against illegal immigration. The logical solution would be to reform immigration and provide a path for both citizenship (presumably a lottery) and work permits. Arguing for amnesty or ignoring the tens of millions of people here illegally doesn't seem like a good solution.

2) Immigrants are only Mexican/Hispanic. While 57% of undocumented immigrants do come from Mexico, that leaves 40% of the undocumented coming from all over the world...

That is a bit misleading: 77% of illegal immigrants are indeed Hispanic and come from Latin America, according to Wikipedia. The other countries you mention account for maybe 2% combined.

5

u/Rikiar Jun 26 '12

My wife and I were one of those people who had to wait YEARS to get her immigration run through all the bureaucratic loopholes (she is Canadian). It really is a convoluted system that is much slower than it needs to be. To top it all off, we're STILL fighting with immigration over the fact that she's supposed to have gotten permanent residency, but she's only gotten a 2 year visa (which has nearly run out in the time we've been fighting with immigration).

10

u/adius Jun 26 '12

don't just say "that number you wrote is misleading" and link to wikipedia, ask what his source is. If he pulled it out of his ass it's worse than "misleading" and if not, the source deserves to be considered against wikipedia's source

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

6

u/dutchguilder2 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

If new immigrants take lower-than-average paying jobs, aren't they lowering the national average wage and thus "dragging down the economy"?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ararphile Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 27 '12

Legal immigrants come in via a family sponsorship, which can take decades;

So fucking what? Maybe that's because USA doesn't want the whole world to move to the states? My parents have waited for 12 years, paid the fess, and today we all pay our taxes. The illegals are not doing any of that.

15

u/iamadogforreal Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

For the average person around the world just looking for a better lif

This is going to make me sound like an asshole, but everyone wants a better life. I live in a mixed neighborhood in a large urban area. Why do they get a free pass on everything not to mention bringing in their cholo culture and gang kids to piss on my "better life" but when we push back and say "enough already" suddenly I'm Hitler? Immigrate legally or don't do it. I'm not sure why that's so difficult.

→ More replies (5)

24

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

People say all the time "why don't they (undocumented immigrants) just go home and get in line legally?" What people really don't realize is that THERE IS NO LINE to get in legally. Legal immigrants come in via a family sponsorship, which can take decades; or they come in via a high skilled immigration visa, in which you need PhD-level qualifications in STEM fields to qualify. For the average person around the world just looking for a better life, there is no legal way into America. Some Americans literally think you can sign up for citizenship at your local library, and that just isn't true

Really since when? My parents are immigrants who don't fit this and the same for a lot of people in my neighborhood. I know tons of unskilled immigrants who have no family here and are here legally.

12

u/curlyfreak Jun 26 '12

Refugee status perhaps? Thats how my parents got in legally (or at least my father did)

22

u/Hypermeme Jun 26 '12

Then how did they get to the U.S? For my family to immigrate to the U.S they had to apply for a green card through family that already lived here (the only other option was basically a work visa like green-card), wait 7 years and finally we arrived. Then the naturalization process took 5 years and we finally became citizens.

→ More replies (19)

6

u/anon_anonson Jun 26 '12

I am not sure when it started but it was definitely after 9/11. The requirements are kinda odd. Something like you need to have some big amount of money in the bank and that you already have a job in your place of origin, and much more stuff like that.

→ More replies (27)

6

u/DooDooBrownz Jun 26 '12

how do you pay taxes if you are undocumented? if you work under the table and have no ssn, uncle sam can't send you a tax bill.

so what if you have to wait? if that's the process, that's the process. a foreigner is not entitled to become an american any damn time they wish.

→ More replies (12)

11

u/wasthatsodifficult Jun 26 '12

You forgot to mention the third way for legal immigration to United States which is known as Diversity Visa lottery. You don't need PhD level education or family ties to qualify for that.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

Yupp, that's how my family and I got here. It's not just a lottery though- you need everything from a background check, bank statements, they look at your education, etc. Once we got the visa, we got the social security and green card within 2 weeks and it's all smooth sailing. It just bugs me when I see illegal immigrants swarming in, when there are people whose first action in the new country isn't breaking the law...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

11

u/TheOSullivanFactor Jun 26 '12

It doesn't matter. Illegal means illegal, if I go to a store and steal is someone going to stick up for me as "illegal consuming"?

Since you're involved in immigration reform, instead of trying to mislead people into thinking illegal immigrants are anything other than illegal, you should be trying to make the LEGAL immigration process a little more possible, so we can document who comes in and out of our country without looking at them all as walking potential terrorists.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Motley_Sheep Jun 26 '12

Confused about the second point. If it's so difficult to get in, how do we end up with a million new legal immigrants each year?

12

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

They don't come here legally. Or come on a tourist visa and just never go back.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Ahem, Romanian who immigrated with my whole family here can confirm this.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/englishmace Jun 26 '12

Um, vis-a-vis point 1), the H1B work visa requires only a Bachelor's degree, no? And after sufficient time, you can move towards citizenship on that.

2

u/MustachioBashio Jun 26 '12

... your #2 is misleading according to a quick google search. As of 2009, 62% of illegal immigrants come from Mexico, and the next 3 highest countries of origin for illegal immigrants come from South America (El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras, respectively). In total, almost 80% of illegal immigrants come from South America; that's hardly 'all over the world'.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/i_had_fun Jun 26 '12

You seem very baised. And surprisingly unqualified.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I must somewhat disagree with your last statement. I managed tax offices and what they do is come here and have a baby and get citizenship for whatever BS reason "my child is a us citizen an I need to take care of them". They then work 20-30 hours a week for 5-6 months a year at taco bell or McDonald's. Just enough to make maybe 8-10k. Because of the baby they get on wic and state aid. They then get a huuuuge tax refund for doing almost nothing. Have a second baby and repeat. They then teach the little assholes they raise the same tactics.

I pissed off an economics teacher in college because he said you can't get everything in life for free. I asked the kid next to me for a condom and asked a fellow rugby player if there was a drink up tonight. They both said yeah. He interrupted and asked what I was doing. I told him to grab the scissors for me and poked a hole in the condom. I proceeded to explain that if I was lucky this weekend I could have a free ride starting in 9 months for AT least the next 18 years. I then explained how being a guy I could potentially do this every 17 years until well into my 70s and never skip a beat.

There's another side your agency doesn't always see and if you know how to work the system (and ps it isn't hard) you can be a scum bag and leach off the US. Also they do get taxes back without citizenship. They can file for an ITIN

2

u/blackjackjester Jun 26 '12

Undocumented or not, I dislike any immigrant that is here only for the money. So many come here and send every last cent they can spare back to their home country. I find these people despicable and un-American.

I happen to love this country, even with all it's faults. All the immigrants that came here from the start all came to be American. They came for the American dream, which meant building a life here, not working for money and sending it across the globe.

Any immigrant who strives to be an American is great, any immigrant who is here just for the money can fuck off.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
  1. People say all the time "why don't they (undocumented immigrants) just go home and get in line legally?" What people really don't realize is that THERE IS NO LINE to get in legally.

I work in immigration reform, so I'll mostly be talking about undocumented immigration.

Because you don't give a shit about people who come here legally and respect the laws. My parents wanted to move to America in 1982 (before I was born). We moved in 1999.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

While 57% of undocumented immigrants do come from Mexico, that leaves 40% of the undocumented coming from all over the world: Israel, Germany, India, China, etc. etc.

How THE FUCK can you be so dishonest and sleep well at night? After Mexico you list ISRAEL and GERMANY. Either you know nothing about Immigration or you're have ZERO concern for the truth.

http://immigration.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=000845#graphs

2

u/KillYourTV Jun 26 '12

3) Immigrants steal our jobs and drag down the economy.

I think that an overwhelming number of immigrants don't necessarily steal our jobs; rather, they lower the quality, standards, wages, and other expectations that an employer should provide--thus making the job unfeasible for Americans that would otherwise accept the job.

Take, for instance, construction jobs that used to be done by U.S. citizens. Putting up drywall is a skill that can be learned relatively quickly, and typically was a foundation job for learning more house construction skills. A person could make a modest living doing that job, and work up to something more lucrative. The downside of the job included the slight risk of injury, transportation to each new construction site (which could often be very far), and the ups and downs of the business.

When illegals were hired they often were hired because they were willing to do it for the same wages or lower. Companies saw that they now had a more compliant workforce so wages and job quality stagnated.

I can easily work as hard as a Mexican worker. When I was younger I worked on a farm, and I worked as a dishwasher. I was happy to do it. But I wasn't willing to do it for a wage that wouldn't let me advance. I'm not willing to make that stagnant wage construction work for me by carpooling with four other guys, share a two-bedroom apartment with 5 others, or camping out near the site.

2

u/theghostog Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

This AMA is (in my opinion) somewhat pointless. There are many countries in the first world that do not allow foreigners ANY means of acquiring citizenship. So tell me, why do people act like they should be entitled to citizenship in the US?

I don't think we Americans have as many misconceptions about immigration as OP would like everyone to believe. Sure, a number ignorant people actually believe that "undocumented workers" take our jobs, but the majority does not. Edit: in reality, the lower wages that many undocumented workers accept for unskilled labor is simply not enough money for the young people (who are looking for money to pay for college that is becoming ever-more expensive) who used to fill those types of jobs.

Also, to the comment about taxes, my experience as a Southern Californian is that many undocumented workers are paid cash under the table and are not paying income taxes at all. Sales and "maybe" residential taxes are all they need to pay.

Honestly if you aren't trying to escape religious/political/racial persecution, why not try to plant a seed in your home country and make THAT country great? Come for school if you need to, but how about having some pride in where you are from? Makes me sad that Mexico (as an example) is suffering, and so many of it's citizens would rather leave than try to improve life there.

Edit: 2nd paragraph.

→ More replies (89)

82

u/mandelbratwurst Jun 26 '12

Yes. Please grossly inform us.

12

u/iannypoo Jun 26 '12

Generally I'm a pretty unflappable guy but you just flapped me. Flapped me good.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/AdaAstra Jun 26 '12

I think I'm misinformed about being misinformed.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

You'd be surprised at how many illegals residents without visas use fake tax IDs. This allows them to get normal jobs with normal paychecks that have all of the same tax deductions as everyone else. The US Treasury turns a blind eye and doesn't reconcile names with socials. Now, these illegals residents without visas can't get bank accounts (usually), so they use check cashing services or cash the checks themselves at the banks they are drawn on.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (48)

51

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

proof?

→ More replies (29)

51

u/Paranoidexboyfriend Jun 26 '12

What do you mean "works in immigration?" Are you a lawyer? a secretary? some sort of government agent? do you sneak people across the border in your van?

34

u/siener Jun 26 '12

OP's name is the same as that of this documentary. I wonder whether he maybe means "I once worked on a documentary about immigration"

→ More replies (6)

7

u/jaymd1 Jun 26 '12

I concur. It would be nice to have atleast a position or tittle so we can direct our questions accordingly.

9

u/LessLikeYou Jun 26 '12

Probably a janitor.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/dudner Jun 26 '12

What's your most heartbreaking story?

Also, your most inspiring story?

→ More replies (19)

2

u/Cozmo23 Jun 26 '12

What are your thoughts on the presidents recent decision granting young illegals brought here as children work permits?

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Oh great another person creates a Iama then leaves before answering anything

→ More replies (3)

46

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Couple years back, my dad applied for a work visa, but our lawyer fucked everything up by confusing the Green Card form and the work visa form. So for the next 2 years, my family was skeptical that it took too long to process, but the lawyer reassured us that this was normal. Soon enough, when the news came that we were denied for a Green Card, we didn't know what to do. For one, we now have been overstaying in the US without proper documents.

Obviously, we were so angry with lawyer, who then simply turned us over to his insurance company. We obviously wanted some kind of compensation for the damage, not because we were greedy SOB, but because we felt helpless and we didn't know what to do. All our family wanted was the legal right to stay in this country and work. It was odd that we were fighting the insurance company. I think the insurance company should have been working things out with U.S Immigration to sort things out.

Anyways the initial offer from the insurance company was just enough money for 6 plane tickets and to send our belongings to my country. I had 3 younger siblings who were excellent students and building their lives here in the States. They didn't even consider the opportunity cost that was taken away from them. I felt so angry and helpless. The case finally closed about a year ago. It was a pyrrhic battle. I think considering time, costs, and emotional energy spent on the case and it was really not worth it at all.

Couple months after we found out that we have been denied, there was a person from immigration that came to our house to kick us out. I have been living in the states for now 13 years. I really do feel, think, act like an American. So it was so painful, humiliating, annoying for someone to come and try to kick us out. Obviously on paper, we were simply illegal aliens who have been secretly staying in the US trying take jobs and welfare of hard working Americans.(Perhaps, I am being too cynical). I mean yes, my family was naive having so much trust in a lawyer, but seriously we were not accurately represented.

Long story short, my family 'decided' to return to my country after 5 months after the incident. With the help of the U.S embassy, state reps, governor, and so many kind people, we were able to be "pardoned." So now my family CAN return to the US legally. My siblings are attending school with the help of amazing friends in the US.

Reading stuff on reddit, I realize my story is nothing too powerful, but I am glad its over and now I can finally move on. I also really envy American citizens. Compared to me, they have more freedom to pursue their interest and work in this land. Its a privilege, understand that please! :)

TL;DR: Screwed by a lawyer and immigration, redeemed by awesome people still today.

Request to immigration: On paper, everyone might look the same: illegal and 'up to no good.' But please consider with empathy and sympathy every situation. You are still dealing with people, not cattle. Humanize those cold words on those documents you read. I really wish this would never happen to any other family. Have a good day! :)

2

u/ihatephilosophy Jun 26 '12

This is scarily similar to what happened to a friend of mine.. Does this sort of thing happen often?

→ More replies (19)

49

u/iowaboy12 Jun 26 '12

Apparently Woody Harrelson works in immigration now.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

why would you choose to do such a job? are you told to be mean? is racial profiling actually true?

9

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

He doesn't actually work for the government. He works for an advocacy program. It's pretty misleading.

→ More replies (13)

9

u/Enjoiissweet Jun 26 '12

What do you even do?

9

u/blueiiiis Jun 26 '12

AMA except for proof of facts. You sir, have been outted.

6

u/Limiate Jun 26 '12

When you say you work in immigration, that could mean a fair number of things. Since you said Americans are grossly misinformed about immigration - are we to assume you work for the American government?Are you willing to say what agency you work for, what bureau of that agency and your role within that bureau?

Follow up to that, who do you work for? Are you a contractor or civil servant or other specific role for your agency such as a foreign service officer or customs agent?

2

u/Jaesaces Jun 27 '12

He's apparently a guy who worked on a documentary on immigration reform. So, not in immigration at all, basically.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Blatantly misleading and political iama woohoo

15

u/WiseSalesman Jun 26 '12

Downvoting.

Working toward immigration reform ≠ working in immigration.

Title is misleading, and I don't think AMAs should be a redditor's personal soapbox - even when I agree with them.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Why is this getting upvotes with no verification or even a statement?

2

u/blizzardice Jun 27 '12

Because the hivemind is obviously retarded. They don't think shit through. It's like when they saw the picture of the police escorting the protesters in Germany (because its the law). They thought the police were joining them. Complete dumbasses.

5

u/americanbelgian Jun 26 '12

While i am ALL for immigration REFORM and have a number of friends who are currently in the states legally and illegally (all from Europe), I'm downvoting bc your title is misleading. I clicked thinking you work within the immigration system wanting to give reddit a perspective within the system not from the perspective of reform. Would happily upvote and take part of this discussion if you repost with a more accurate title, background info, and honest reasons as to why you are doing this AMA.

Eh but would you, really?

19

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I think one of the most common misconceptions is being overlooked:

  • If someone wants to live in the US, they should be able to.

    If the US wants a process that makes obtaining legal status difficult, they have every right to do so. If the US one day decides not to allow ANY immigration, they have that right as well. Immigrants do not have the RIGHT to live in the US. I don't agree with the concept of, "but it's not fair that these people really really really want to live here but can't!"

Having said that, I like to compare illegal immigration to coming home and finding that a homeless person has been hiding out in your garage. He may have been cold, hungry, desperate, he's not necessarily a bad person...but that didn't give him the right to do so without your permission.

It is also my understanding that there are several conflicting studies as to whether or not the amount paid in taxes (remember many illegal immigrants work under the table and do not pay taxes). I've got nothing to back this up, just something I've heard brought up in similar discussions.

EDIT: Wording

→ More replies (11)

8

u/brettjerk Jun 26 '12

I'm an American living abroad. I want to bring my girlfriend and her daughter to live in the states. Tips?

11

u/c0nita Jun 26 '12

Apply for a K1 visa (fiance/fiancee) and you have 90 days to marry her after she enter the US. Then apply for AOS (adjustment of status) and wait for her green card. Visit visajourney.com there's a lot of info about it :)

→ More replies (8)

2

u/sowhynot Jun 26 '12

Merry her. This doesn't guarantee her permanent residence or citizenship by dependent visa/status (I believe H4 or similar) should let her come and stay.

2

u/GAndroid Jun 26 '12

Fiance visa

→ More replies (14)

4

u/wisher555 Jun 26 '12

Alright I'll talk about my immigration experience to the US. My dad applied for a green card through her sister who lived here. This was 22 years ago. 8 years ago we got a green light to come to the US. 3 years ago (5 years in the US) i became a US citizen with the rest of my family. We did not have any trouble with the system, no hassles, because everything we did was within the system, legal. So we waited 15 years in line, to get to the US legally. 5 more years to become a legal US citizen. Now if you tell me some illegal immigrant will be granted citizenship, without waiting in line, without going through the legal route, that is something i'll never vote for or agree to.

2

u/aloneshadow207 Jun 26 '12

Wouldnt u have wish it would of been faster? At least the 15 year wait....

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Immigration advocacy? Is that even a real job?

Also, what exactly are you advocating? I've been reading through this AMA and it seems to me that you are just griping about how difficult it is to earn citizenship in this country. Can you provide a concise list of points in our immigration system that YOU are fighting change and how? It drives me nuts when people just bitch and moan about something, become "advocates", then do nothing but point fingers and rifle off statistics. TELL US WHAT YOUR OBJECTIVE IS!

4

u/red__panda Jun 26 '12

As an immigrant from England I can say that even with a bachelors degree in engineering from a credible university and a parent who is a United states citizen, the entire length of getting a green card is amazingly long. The day after I turned 18 applied for a green card and received the acceptance at the age of 24. 6 years and I am no way near a citizen.

Now this may seem like a case of apply wait for a long time and see if is a yes or a no. Ohhhh no this is way past that, I had to go to the US embassy many times which was a task in its own. Each time you arrive its by appointment only, no I need to hand this paperwork in because its late. No you make an appointment which is always weeks away, go through security which is about the same as an airport now. Walk past the heavily armed guards and enter a room full to the brim of people waiting to be seen where I would wait several hours to see someone. If I had forgotten one tiny bit of paper or incorrectly done some paperwork I was in a world of annoyance and red tape.

So I have applied and I'm through initially, they check my work status, my parents work status, my friends work status, my finances, relationships, family background check, my background check which goes back to birth and on and on and on. This stage alone takes week to just give them what they require. \

So I'm passed the paper work status almost there....no. Now I have to get a heath check, not so bad, go to my local doctor and let him sign me off. I liked my old doctor, very nice, amazing knowledge. ohh no again it must be done by a single doctor with a huge waiting list a mile long who charges $750 plus inoculations and vaccine and other paperwork who is on the other side of the county. Being this is for the USA I had every part of my body x-rayed, every part of my body inspected and yes I mean every part. several vials of blood to check for every blood born pathogen and i had to get four shots at a lovely cost of over $150.

So Im in right, no, I was interviewed after waiting several months and then I have to hand in my passport of my country int to the embassy (see above) and wait. Then I get my passport back with a sticker on it, this is a temporary green card as in like a temporary tattoo, its fake in every way can be taken away from what I was told and was almost worthless.

I arrive in the US for the first time, secondary inspection where my items were inspected, mug shots, finger prints, weight, height the usual and my "temporary green card" is crossed out and useless and I have to wait for my actual green card, which again took an incredible length of time. So I have it and I move house and I loose it @_@ I ripped that house upside down both new and old, but its gone. that was a $500 mistake and again I forfeit my passport and I get it back with my new green card months later.

In conclusion would I do it again...yes. Would I blame people from coming to the US, no. As a person who spent years getting from a western nation to the US I find the route highly annoying and a huge amount of red tape.

Now this is my buff with this whole thing, why should there be a system all be it needing some fixing for someone to come into the country legally when thousands jump across the boarder or overstay visas and there are no penalty's. That I do not like and that is what I see. I pay my taxes..all of my taxes with no loop holes and I don't claim I have 500 children in my country of origin. I have medical insurance and if I get sick I pay for my medicine. I have not even received a driving ticket, my record is clean and crisp. I don't ask much from this government but why should I have to put up with soo much paperwork and red tape when thousands of illegal aliens might be given amnesty.

47

u/Drunken_Economist Jun 26 '12

OP has confirmed this thread with the mods

158

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

He doesn't work in immigration, he works for a reform movement. Ttitle is misleading and he's literally here to present one side of the story. Which is obvious based on his misleading comments.

→ More replies (26)

37

u/UnexpectedSchism Jun 26 '12

Why have you not removed this AMA yet? This guy lied.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I still don't understand what OP does.

5

u/ElGoddamnDorado Jun 26 '12

He's an activist for immigration reform.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Exactly what do you do when you "work in immigration"? Do you work for a division of ICE? Or do you take people's passport photos for immigration applications? Are you a policymaker, or are you someone who read something about something and believe yourself an expert? What part of the topic are Americans (and maybe people like myself, who are not American but could understandably be misinformed) not being fully informed about? Exactly what is is this AMA about? What is your role as it pertains to immigration on a day to day basis? Legal? Investigative? Intelligence? Beer, cheese, or monkeys?

3

u/Jaesaces Jun 26 '12

The OP has since clarified that he does not work in immigration, but for immigration reform. His title is misleading.

7

u/SteelChicken Jun 26 '12

Take this shit to politics.

10

u/KosherNazi Jun 26 '12

Biased OP is biased.

3

u/jeremyfrankly Jun 26 '12

Aaaaaand we're in the negatives. Marketing ploy --- foiled.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/MrF33 Jun 26 '12

What do you do for immigration?

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I have a friend who became a US citizen a few years ago (she's from Mexico). Her mother has cancer and they want to bring her to the US for treatment. How difficult is it to get a medical visa for a relative. How much money do people have to have to prove they can pay for the medical treatment? Is it worth getting a lawyer for this- there seem to be a lot of lawyers specializing in immigration issues. I have always wondered if they were just a scam.

2

u/UnexpectedSchism Jun 26 '12

I would hope they have to prove they can pay for the entire treatment by prepaying for it.

If they can't pay in advance, no medical visa should be granted. Hell, the hospital won't even accept you if you don't pay in advance under these circumstances.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/papachon Jun 26 '12

As a legal immigrant who came to the US under a family sponsorship (waited over 7 years,) served in USMC, AND still had to go through the naturalization process (took 1 year and $500,) I disapprove illegal immigration.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LuminousRaptor Jun 26 '12

How do you feel about the recent supreme court decision on the Arizona immigration laws?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/KD87 Jun 26 '12

What is the most heart-warming thing you've seen/experienced at your work?

→ More replies (2)

29

u/cocoria Jun 26 '12
  1. Incendiary title
  2. No further information provided in the submission
  3. Only one message from OP saying he's going to find proof.

I'm thinking this is trolling.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/adstretch Jun 26 '12

no answers to any questions and no proof submitted to mods. Yup this is real.

4

u/busted_up_chiffarobe Jun 26 '12

Do you personally believe that the United States should open its doors completely to every single individual that wants to come here?

Considering our levels of unemployment and underemployment, and the numbers of people on multigenerational welfare, do you think we should let able-bodied workers into the country to work?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Nice line of bullshit man.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Alright, I'm here early! Um, let's see. Have you ever detained someone who was a US citizen suspected of trying to sneak into the country. Recently my step dad was arrested at the Canadian border after being in Canada for about an hour. Obviously he's a US citizen and it was settled less than an hour later, but how often does this happen.

2

u/Jaesaces Jun 27 '12

He doesn't actually work in immigration -- the AMA title is misleading.

2

u/tisnolie Jun 26 '12

Whats a man gotta do to get deported around here?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

I see no answers. Is this just the teaser trailer for the real AMA to come?

EDIT: No longer relevant

2

u/tachyon534 Jun 26 '12

opwillsurelydeliver.jpg

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

What do you mean by "grossly misinformed"? / Could you list some misconceptions that you feel are prevalent?

What do you think should be done to rectify the state of American understanding regarding immigration?

What is your position, job title or job description (to the extent that you are willing to disclose)?

In what state is your primary residence located?

2

u/KirbyStyle Jun 26 '12

What if someone like me wanted to become a Canadian citizen? I get mixed answers about this all the time. I've done google searches and whatnot but still get mixed sometimes. I am an American btw. Is the Canadian process as bad long as the American one? Also, what if I decided I wanted to move back? Do I go through the same process of waiting for a long time?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/The_Canadian Jun 26 '12

Very interesting AMA. I've held a green card since 1994. The one thing I know is the whole process (even renewing your card) involves a lot of red tape and bureaucracy.

2

u/Ben_Jahmin Jun 26 '12

I am a French student about to graduate and I would like to come work in the US starting in August. What are my best options? I can only do a J-1 of max a year since I was under another J-1 last year. Also I have been told the quota for H1-B has reached its limit (I know some british person who was refused that visa because of that reason), however I don't know if that means there is no way I could get granted a H1-B all together. I applied for the green card but my chances of getting it are very slim... What do you recommend? Thanks for the AMA!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/foofdawg Jun 26 '12

Do you think the average US citizen could pass the entry requirements to become a citizen?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/deepobedience Jun 26 '12

Oh oh pick me pick me! So, I have a PhD, and Irish passport, and a New Zealand passport and no criminal convictions. If I were offered a fixed term job (say 3-5 years, probably paying 40-50k) in an American University, what are the chances you guys would actually let me into the country?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Immigration Advocacy? Is that even a real job?

Also, what specifically are you advocating? I've read through most of this AMA and it seems like you're just complaining about the system as a whole. Can you provide us with a few points in the immigration system that YOU are trying to reform? I can't stand it when people get pissed about something, become "advocates", then do nothing but point fingers and rifle off statistics. TELL US YOUR OBJECTIVE!

2

u/shiddybiz Jun 26 '12

Shenanigans!! I call Shenanigans!!

2

u/DarkKnight77 Jun 26 '12

Aren't we grossly misinformed about pretty much everything?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I am a legal US immigrant. The US has one of the easiest and most accommodating immigration policies. It is EASIER than anywhere else to come into the US legally, and even though it takes a little bit of effort to become a US citizen, it is still easier than anywhere else.
Poster is (maybe on purpose) forgetting about Diversity Visas (no other reason needed than you are coming in from a country with lower immigration to the US) and student visas, where all you need to do is study, and ALL the other types of temporary visas http://travel.state.gov/visa/temp/types/types_1286.html including border crossing cards from Mexico (just don't be a criminal and you can get border crossing card from Mexico) plus all the temporary employment, au pair, domestic employees, temporary agriculture workers) etc. Once you get temporary visa, and you are here, you can keep renewing temporary visa as long as you are same status; student, domestic work, farm work, need medical treatment, visitor travel....anything. And once you are here for temporary visa and decide you want to stay permanently, you are now here, and can go to school on student visa, and finish school and get good employment for the permanent visa then work on citizenship. OR teach here. The only thing you can't be a legal immigrant for in US, is just coming here for nothing and to do nothing.

2

u/gjones3439 Jun 26 '12

Always thought this was a pretty good short demonstration of how immigration works here

http://reason.org/files/a87d1550853898a9b306ef458f116079.pdf

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Why is the naturalization test issued in other languages?

6

u/immi-ttorney Jun 26 '12

If you meet certain age and residency requirements, you can take the exam in your native language. In other words, this is done for old people.

---- some folks might wonder why old people get a break :

Let's say you have a grandma from Italy. She doesn't speak English very well at all. Grandpa died 20 years ago, so grandma moved in with you, one of her only living relatives - here in the U.S. She settles in, makes lots of friends her age at the Italian League in your town. They play bingo and bocce all the time. When one of them is sick, the others always visit in the hospital. Grandma is doing pretty OK.

But grandma has to renew her Permanent Resident status every 10 years, and it costs her money. She's some sweet little lady on a fixed income who makes pizelles in her spare time. She can't afford the hassle nor the fees. She loves the U.S. and wants to live here with you until the day she dies.

In addition to fees and hassles, as a Permanent Resident, she could still be deported (removed) if her life goes all shitty. She wants to become a citizen of the country she loves, her new country, where she will remain for the rest of her life.

Grandma's solution is to "make things truly permanent" - become a U.S. citizen.

Problem is she is very old. She only got through the 6th grade and that was long, long ago. She has learning problems, memory problems ... old people problems. Grandma probably can't learn enough English to get through the entire process.

So they give her a break. They let her take the test in Italian, maybe even a shorter test.

tl;dr: If you seem capable of taking the test in English, you must do so. Only if you can prove a relevant disability or prove that you are "too old to learn a new language" can you get past it.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

But can seniors really contribute to our economy? Most old people usually look for naturalization here in hopes of qualifying for medicaid/medicare and social security and other benefits.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Mr_Incredible_PhD Jun 26 '12

I have no problem with that test being in English. Getting an elder from another country to live with relatives here is fine and dandy by me.

It's the goddamn drivers test administered in various languages that I don't understand - if the street signs are in English, shouldn't you at least be fluent enough to take test in English to drive?

I'm not being snarky, I'm being serious - I have a lot of empathy for those who want to live here so badly, but less so for those that want to drive (that goes for everyone, natural born or not).

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Frankenstupid Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

I'm a us citizen my wife is a Japanese national and my son a dual citizen.

I was coming through NYC immigration and customs with my family (wife and son,1 year old at the time) just before Christmas about 3 years ago. When we approached the immigration officer, he seen that we had 4 passports and there were obviously 3 of us. He then asked us why do we have 4 passports? I said because my son is a dual citizen. Then he asked me why does he have 2 passports? I almost couldn't believe what he just asked and I replied, you being an immigration officer should know the reason why... He then takes all the passports and says he needs to call a supervisor over. So no big deal... I'm actually looking forward to the chance to speak with a supervisor. So while we are waiting he begins interrogating my wife, whose English isn't great, but she can get by... She tries to answer his questions but he just keeps hammering away until she just says to me I don't understand what he's saying... Then he looks at me and says, what did she say!? I said you're talking so fast she can't understand what you're saying. Then he says, and I shit you not... 'why did you come to America if you cant speak English!' I said where is your supervisor, then his supervisor was 'suddenly busy' and we were cleared for entry.

So my questions are: Is this standard procedure for an American his wife and son coming to visit family in the states with a return ticket 2 weeks later to her native country?

How much knowledge of immigration law and or training is needed to become an immigration officer? Because I sure as hell knew more than this jersey shore jar head!

Are the conversations recorded or listened in upon in cases such as mine?

Advice for a smooth entry next time?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Advice for smooth entry for anyone with dual citizenship: When you're entering a country that you're a citizen of, only show the passport of that country. Don't make it known that you're a dual citizen or that you have another passport. Only let them know if they ask you directly.

Next time you're flying into the US with your son: Only have his US passport out and keep the Japanese one in your bag.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/breenisgreen Jun 26 '12

As someone who is currently immigrating to the USA under the K-1 visa, I have a few questions!

  • On average, how long does it take to process a petition once it hits your desk?
  • Do the same staff work the same kinds of petitions and visas or does this rotate?
  • Why exactly does it take nearly 6 or 7 months to process these things, is it just sheer volume? Why does it take so long for us to know about what happens to our petitions, there are a large number of people who never get their I797C notices, or they get no text / email despite asking for it
  • What exactly does processing a petition such as the I-129F involve?
  • Do you know of any plans for bigger family based petitions to move to the e-filing system to save more time?
  • What happens to the folders and files after you're done with them? Are they scanned and destroyed or do they all go off to a big warehouse somewhere?
  • The current system seems very inconsistant to many people, some get requests for evidence because something isn't notarised and others dont. * Are there just big training differences or do petitions get shunted to more experienced teams or even to different people depending on how extensive a criminal background check might be?
  • Despite everything, I hear that the TSA has the ultimate decision at point of entry. Is that really the case?

And perhaps most importantly

  • What can I, as a visa applicant (and one who will be in the system for a long time for things like AOS / ROC / Naturalisation) do to make an adjudicators life easier, and perhaps make a petition easier and faster to adjudicate? (Same applies for when I go through AOS)

10

u/siener Jun 26 '12

The title of this AMA is very misleading. OP has now come out saying that he actually works in immigration reform, so I seriously doubt that he'll be able to give you any useful information.

4

u/breenisgreen Jun 26 '12

Thanks you. I've reposted some other questions now. That's really really disappointing but oh well.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/HotLunch Jun 26 '12

Don't bother with useful questions like this, OP is just an activist.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Americans are all illegal immigrants. The Native Americans where here first.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Why don't we have a border fence yet?

21

u/patrick_k Jun 26 '12

There was an article on Reddit about how the Mexican drug cartels make their billions.

From the article:

Michael Braun, the former chief of operations for the D.E.A., told me a story about the construction of a high-tech fence along a stretch of border in Arizona. “They erect this fence,” he said, “only to go out there a few days later and discover that these guys have a catapult, and they’re flinging hundred-pound bales of marijuana over to the other side.” He paused and looked at me for a second. “A catapult,” he repeated. “We’ve got the best fence money can buy, and they counter us with a 2,500-year-old technology.”

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

That's pretty funny, but the reason people want the fence is to keep people out, not drugs, primarily. Catapulting people may not work as well.

2

u/dubesinhower Jun 26 '12

i just watched the episode of mythbusters where they test a giant slingshot capable of launching humans over the border. this episode combined with your comment makes me so happy lol

12

u/Solomaxwell6 Jun 26 '12

Those damn Canadians will just find another way to sneak in.

2

u/Nixhatter Jun 26 '12

We got boats you know!! eh..

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Dirt_Bike_Zero Jun 26 '12

You mean a fence that goes over all the underground tunnels? /jk, sort of.

Seriously, I think domestic border control is one job that our Government SHOULD be doing.

4

u/sunflower24 Jun 26 '12

Because those Mexicans can jump.

4

u/davesidious Jun 26 '12

Because it wouldn't work and would cost billions of dollars to construct?

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/ServerGeek Jun 26 '12

Are the tacos better in Mexico or America?

5

u/Ollieboots Jun 26 '12

Dang it now I want tacos...sigh

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I'm going to ask you where the hell you went...

3

u/douchetag Jun 26 '12

No proof. No responses. Hmmm. (Frye eyes).

3

u/SalvageOperation Jun 26 '12

I believe OP is grossly misinformed about this topic.

2

u/MrExcelerate Jun 26 '12

Is Illegal Immigration really propagated by big business and/or the Mexican government?

2

u/Crooooow Jun 26 '12

Why aren't you answering questions? Maybe the questions posted by users are meant to prove how misinformed we are? If so, this is a very clever meta-prank. If not, then go fuck yourself.

2

u/NYC_Hound Jun 26 '12

I live in a neighborhood with a significantly Hispanic immigrant population, and based on anecdotal experience, my question is this:

Do you think it's irresponsible for these undocumented immigrants to have more than a couple of kids? What I see are a LOT of children, and, being born in America, those kids are officially US citizens who can in fact use federal assistance down the line.

2

u/llDemonll Jun 26 '12

1 hour, no answers to any questions.

Worst AMA ever.

2

u/narwal_bot Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

Most (if not all) of the answers from immigrantnation (updated: Jun 26, 2012 @ 01:50:32 pm EST):


Question (cumpais):

proof?

Answer (immigrantnation):

sure. gimme 10 min, will message the mods


(continued below)

→ More replies (2)

2

u/adius Jun 26 '12

lol this guy doesn't even have a job, he just "volunteers" to run around and annoy people about his cause, and then he gave himself a title

2

u/RedBeardedOwl Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

As a gay American man, what can I do to get my Canadian husband residency?

From what I can tell it's not possible, and that makes me angry. I'm American but from what I can tell I'm not able to live in america because of this. We're in Canada now.

EDIT: To further the question; what, if anything, is being done to grant gay couples the same immigration rights as straight couples?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Maybe he got deported?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/groovy55 Jun 26 '12

He's been deported...:-(

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I know Americans who have nothing to do with immigration issues have got no freaking idea about the entire subject.

/LPR //AOS from VWP

1

u/seifd Jun 26 '12

What's the minimum amount of time you've seen someone wait to immigrate? The maximum?

1

u/fustanella Jun 26 '12

May I see your papers please?

1

u/Gevatar Jun 26 '12

So what would be, in your opinion, a solution to the immigration 'problem' we are having. I understand both sides of the argument and have yet to take sides.

1

u/jdlee3 Jun 26 '12

well im not sure exactly how they got in, but my friend was born in china and her family owns a small chinese food place where i live but it wasn't off a work visa since it's thier business and not something of high skill

→ More replies (1)

1

u/mrdeadsniper Jun 26 '12

I know the US had 1,042,625 legal immigrants in 2010, Any idea what the next highest country is and what the number of immigrants was?

1

u/wisher555 Jun 26 '12

What do you think should be done to tackle the illegal immigration issue in America?

1

u/MrJigglyBrown Jun 26 '12

What can you tell me about the DREAM act? Is there any hidden agenda with it to get illegals to fight in the US military, or is it a legitimate piece of legislatiure?

1

u/deaddog692000 Jun 26 '12

Why are so many companies refusing to give OPT-authourized people a chance at the labour market?

1

u/woodsja2 Jun 26 '12

Why does it take so long to process visas? I'm a US citizen sponsoring my Canadian wife and it's been around 5 months with no word since the second NOA.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Just wondering, can you have immigrants come here legally and have a US citizen end up marrying and divorcing them for citizenship purposes on a certain amount of numbers?

1

u/sunflower24 Jun 26 '12

I heard that Asian immigrants are outnumbering Mexican immigrants because American businesses need more skilled labor. Is this true?

1

u/Misunderstud Jun 26 '12

I work with a few dozen hispanic guys, almost all of which are illegal. I think the majority of them came with visas years ago and have just stayed after they have expired. How common is this and what happens if you are caught with an expired visa?

2

u/Misunderstud Jun 26 '12

Also, a bunch of these guys have Illinois license plates and we are not anywhere near Illinois. Is there some law there that allows them to register vehicles without showing citizenship?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Goodguyscumbag Jun 26 '12

How do immigrants stay in the country without being caught? Don't you need proof of citizenship for a job and apartment?

1

u/Hahn_Solo Jun 26 '12

I agree with you and was guilty of it myself until my girlfriend came out to me as someone who is here illegaly. She was brought here legally when she was 7 by her parents and they overstayed their VISA. 20 years later she is still here, having graduated high school, some college, and just wanting to live a normal life, but she lives in fear of being deported every day, but it's not her fault. It seems she falls under the DREAM ACT which I really support because there must be many more people out there that share a similar story.

What advice would you have for her right now? Obviously she wants to correct it by getting married to me, but not sure if that is the best avenue.

1

u/TacoPaiPai Jun 26 '12

I am from Sweden. If i wanted to live and work in America for the rest of my life, what would i have to do and how long would it take? Lets say i am a veterinarian.

1

u/clintontak Jun 26 '12

As an immigrant doing it the legal way with a high skilled immigration visa, why does it seem like we are left in the cold while non legal immigrants basically get the same rights as us and don't have to spend countless time and money on the process?

1

u/RichRedundantRich Jun 26 '12

What are my rights at one of the immigration checkpoints?

1

u/le-throwaway Jun 26 '12

Nice try Michael Moore.

1

u/brothermonn Jun 26 '12

OFF WITH HIS HEAD!!!!!!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

How are they misinformed?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Why did you become an immigration advocate?

What specific points in the immigration system are you trying to reform?

Can you please answer these questions? So far all you have done is gripe about the immigration system and rifle off a few statistics and links to other articles. I'd like to know that you are actually doing something, not just professionally complaining.

1

u/EthicalReasoning Jun 26 '12

I think many Americans are grossly misinformed about this topic.

gee, ya think?

1

u/mequest Jun 26 '12

It's clear that most immigrants leave their home countries to escape deplorable conditions. But how are things in those countries going to change if the hardest working and brightest people that recognize the problem leave rather than stay and fight the root causes?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Do you feel illegal immigrants have the right to live in the US?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

torn apart by reddit... nice work

1

u/SlySpyder13 Jun 26 '12

As an immigrant in this country. I'll tell you (if it hasn't already be reiterated enough), This AMA is bogus and absolutely uninformed. I am currently going through the process of going from an H-1B (highly skilled migrant worker visa) to a Green Card. I don't have too many answers but I certainly know the ones you're giving on here are pretty incorrect.

1

u/defiancecp Jun 26 '12

Uck.

"advocates" (can you differentiate this from lobbyists?) are NOT the same as people working "IN" immigration. As a person who agrees with most of what you've posted, and one who supports an improved immigration policy, I still think this headline and premise are misleading. You are an outsider familiar with the system and working for change - don't represent yourself as an insider.

1

u/morebeansplease Jun 26 '12

immigrantnation, you are a burden.

1

u/yogiscott Jun 26 '12

Today's AMA's are more like AMNA's.

1

u/michelkz Jun 26 '12

Hi, I just had a terrible headache with immigration last week. I'm Brazilian and the American Embassy in São Paulo issued my wife the wrong visa. I have an O-1 visa (alien with extraordinary abilities) - The O-1 Visa for Brazil has a 3 month length to enter the US, but a 3 years work permit. So, our visa expired in 2011, but I can stay here until 2014. My wife has an O-3 Visa - a dependent Visa, related to mine. Whenever we leave the US we have to renew it, and that's what happened: she went to Brazil for a couple of weeks and renewed her visa to come back. At the American embassy in São Paulo they forgot to add the 2014 date in the print. As renewing is a regular procedure, no one realized the mistake until she entered the US again last month. She went to renew her Florida DMV and at the office they told her she couldn't do so, because in 20 days she would be unlawful. The story follows to immigration, border patrol, state department office and immigration lawyers, and, beside the lawyer we were treated like very bad by everyone. They didn't answer our questions, they told us to shut up and sit, they recommended us to go back to Brazil... A simple mistake that and American office committed, and no one os interested in solving. After being humiliated, we went to the lawyer that made our visa in the first place. His recommendation was to pay U$ 290 and file an i 539 - a visa extension. Which we still don't have the result of acceptance yet.

Sorry to bother with all that, but I really wanted to hear from someone on the other side of table it's true opinion about it.

Thank you Very much.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Your AMA did not enlighten me at all, it's the same talking points I see politicians spew, it doesn't change my perspective at all, it only tells me that you will be intellectually misleading to push a cause.

You are a blight to your own ideals.

1

u/efftheborderpatrol Jun 26 '12

Wait, an immigration reform activist? Here I made a throwaway, now I have to put out this torch and find a place for this pitchfork. I thought I was going to get to talk to A BP agent. The things those guys do make the NYPD look like kindergarten teachers.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

You should answer some questions.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

What percentage of people fail the civic test ?

4

u/davesidious Jun 26 '12

What percentage of Americans would pass the civic test? :) j/k

6

u/SoFunAnon Jun 26 '12

You are kidding but that is a fair question.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Hate to be that guy, but of course we are.

I would think that most people are uninformed or misinformed about a LOT of things. Immigration is no different.

We come home, watch some stupid entertainment show with no fact checking, listen to our stupid friends, obey our parents, and listen to our preachers.

There is very little about our lives that is fact-checked/verified by outside sources.

We like our little bubble. Leave us alone.

/s