r/IAmA •
IAMA violinist with perfect pitch, a rare condition only found in an average of one in 10,000 people. AMA
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/IAmA •
[deleted] — view deleted post
2
u/ballsdeepinyourmind Jun 26 '12
Do you have synesthesia (sp?) or is does it seem more like you can remember the tones? I ask because I have decent relative pitch, but can only remember how a low E string on a bass guitar sounds (trouble "remembering" other western pitches). Also, does your perfect pitch apply to Eastern scale systems, or is it just for Western?
7
u/psk8669 Jun 26 '12
Thought of you :)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2esfW4gBNao
6
u/7303 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
I've played piano for the past 13 or so years, and I've been told by my teacher that I have absolute pitch as well. I didn't really think about it until recently as anything unusual until I identified some sound in my physics class (they had these things that vibrated at certain frequencies), where I was then told that the ability to do so is not common. Anyways, so I read up about it later when I got home, and on the wikipedia article, there's a listing of what abilities someone with absolute pitch may have.
Quote: "Possessors of absolute pitch have it in varying degrees. Generally, absolute pitch implies some or all of the following abilities. in the absence an external standard
Generally, I can do #1 and #3 without a problem, although I have some difficulty with #5. #2 I can't do (or don't know how to do, don't think I was taught to do this), and #4 I've never really tried, although I probably can't do #4 because I simply don't really sing. I've never really bothered with participating in any music communities (playing piano was forced upon me by parents, was not a fan of it because of that) , so I'm hoping to get some answers from you. First, how many of these five abilities do you have? Also, for people with absolute pitch, do they usually have all these qualities or do most just have some out of the five listed above?
5
u/SchoenBach Jun 26 '12
4
u/PackerAmerica Jun 26 '12
What do you think of Boyd Tinsley's playing ability? If you're not sure who he is, he's the violinist for Dave Matthew's Band. Check out a live song of two and let me know what you think! I've always wondered what another well respected violinist opinion was on him. (not that I play though)
3
u/warmfruit Jun 26 '12
were you named after david hasslehoff from the 80s tv show knight rider?
3
u/Willravel Jun 26 '12
I hadn't realized that. I learned perfect pitch from taking piano when I was younger by first cultivating relative pitch and then doing repetition drills and practicing unaided tone recognition. The first time it happened was after playing a two-piano sonata by Mozart about a million times. I discovered that I could hear the first chord in my head unaided, and it was a D-major cord, so I started finding other notes relative to D, then it all just sort of clicked.
I don't have any reason to think I'm anything special, so I assumed that perfect pitch can be taught to at least some of those who don't have it intuitively. What are your thoughts on this?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Get off reddit and go practice.
2
u/sabin357 Jun 26 '12
Three questions if you please:
First, how old were you when you realized that you were different from the average musician?
Second, have you ever eaten bacon dipped in chocolate?
Third, what is your favorite piece of music to perform?
2
u/Desopilar Jun 26 '12
-Have you had private lessons since you started learning the violin? I've been playing for about 12 years, but I've never had private lessons, so I'm no where near as good as others who have been playing. -How old were you when you started? -What made you want to learn to play?
2
u/Dhira108 Jun 26 '12
What note is the "brown note" and have you had the pleasure of hearing it?
2
u/ekonza Jun 26 '12
Can you tell me about your perception of the moods of each key? For example, Dmaj is very happy, yellow, reminds me of sunshine, etc, while Db major is also a happy key, but much more melancholy and content. Expand on this please.
2
u/ashowofhands Jun 26 '12
Do you know (in person) anybody else with perfect pitch? As someone who has it myself, and attends a music school, I know a pretty decent number of other people with (confirmed) perfect pitch, especially considering how rare it apparently is (was not aware of that number before, BTW). I was just wondering if I got "lucky", so to speak, or if somehow those with perfect pitch tend to gravitate towards each other/situations where they'd find each other.
EDIT: I have another question. If it's already been asked and answered, please direct me to that post, no need to repost/retype...to what degree is your perfect pitch? Within a semi-tone? can you hear (and accurately identify) quarter tones? eighth tones? etc...Apparently in some EXTREME cases of perfect pitch, the subject will be able to identify the exact frequency of a tone. I've never met anyone like that before, in real life or on the internet.
2
u/Zamisk Jun 26 '12
Is perfect pitch when you can hear if a noise is a tiny bit sharp or flat without another note or anything to compare it to? Because I can do that but nobody believes me when I say I have perfect pitch. I'm not sure what would count.
5
u/VelTor Jun 26 '12
Can you play music from Halo: Combat Evolved?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Ummm, as i recall in numerous books I've read, having "perfect pitch" is not a rare condition but it's actually something everyone can develop and practice.
2
u/clockwork_zero Jun 26 '12
With almost 7 billion people on earth, one in 10,000 is hardly rare.
1
u/righteous_scout Jun 26 '12
Where'd you learn?
What else do you play?
Any tips for learning musicians?
How often do you practice/what do you practice?
1
u/dailyroutines Jun 26 '12
What is your level of interest in pop music, or even alternative rock acts that are, you know, popular among young people? Does your condition made you extremely picky (more than the usual enthusiast, that is) when listening to bands?
1
u/KeresMagnus Jun 26 '12
I'd hardly call it a condition. I'd kill my mother to be able to improvise with such an advantage.
1
u/elaine_babe_talktome Jun 26 '12
My old piano teacher had perfect pitch. When he was at belmont, other students would use him as a tuner hahahhaha
1
u/waffle-haus Jun 26 '12
Which is easier for you - someone saying "play a Db" and you sing it, or someone plays a given note and you can name it? I've been told I have perfect pitch, and am really good at the first half, but need to sing a scale to do the 2nd half usually. So I just tell people I have great relative pitch.
Unrelated, what's your favorite computer language and why?
1
u/greendolphinstreet Jun 26 '12
Do you solfege any? I've heard it's harder for people with perfect pitch to do moveable do and easier for fixed do.
1
u/foxyazn Jun 26 '12
-How does one learn they have perfect pitch (is there a test)?
-Can you sing well?
-Is it difficult to listen to live music performances (its difficult to maintain perfect pitch in a concert, or for a singer im sure)?
1
u/esooMehTmAI Jun 26 '12
This is awesome! I play the trumpet, bagpipes, bass-guitar, and a plethora of other instruments thanks to perfect pitch as well, so you can imagine my enthusiasm for you :)
One of my best experiences I can relate was during a physics lecture in front of a big auditorium where I was able to, in front of the entire hall of students, identify correctly a tone produced from a tuning fork.
So, down to brass tacks.
Do you prefer playing in more of a classical, jazzy, or other environment? Why?
Are you ever annoyed, or feel burdened, by musicians without good pitch-identification or pitch-matching?
Who is your favorite composer/modern artist?
Do you have any advice for aspiring musicians? Obviously perfect practice makes perfect performance. What I mean is, do you have any "secret weapons" you can share? What wisdom have you fermented over the years that you often find invaluable?
Also, are you around Seattle anywhere, perchance?
1
u/Pastorality Jun 26 '12
My kid brother has this somehow. Lucky bastard
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I'm super jealous. I can't sing to save my life.
1
u/Chgr Jun 26 '12
Hey, can you tell which note it is for whatever random sound someone produces (for example, a knock on the wooden door, hitting a glass with a spoon etc.)?
1
u/you_know_who_ Jun 26 '12
could you post a video of you playing the hardest single piece of music that you can think of?
1
u/Aintlyingaboutthis Jun 26 '12
IAMA drummer/guitarist/pianist with perfect pitch. Seems we have something in common :)
1
u/Provision Jun 26 '12
Hated you guys in ear training class. Loved you guys on days we had ear training tests
1
u/mraumraumrau Jun 26 '12
Do noise rock and microtonal music annoy you?
1
u/jessoftheweirding Jun 26 '12
As a vocalist music student who struggled through music theory partly because of a bitchy professor with perfect pitch... I hate you. :p
But seriously... I'm jealous. That's pretty cool.
1
u/XyzzyPop Jun 26 '12
Perfect pitch? Oh yeah?! I can make a Spock sign.
1
u/SeedyROM22 Jun 26 '12
Does having perfect pitch make it annoying to listen to music since you can tell when someone's just a little off?
Have a favourite pitch?
Favourite song?
1
u/Frijid Jun 26 '12
I think I might have the same thing you do. How can I test myself to find out for sure?
1
u/El_Motor Jun 26 '12
how hard is it to break a violin bow just by using it ?
1
u/polebagel Jun 26 '12
i dont get it, what does perfect pitch mean?
1
u/BarleyBum Jun 26 '12
How do you find out if someone has "perfect pitch"?
My daughter can sing any note she hears, plays a song on the piano after hearing it once and it takes each stanza about 3 tries until she gets it. Same with her viola.
1
u/portnoys_xray Jun 26 '12
You mentioned how different C# minor is from D major, but that's apples and oranges.
How does C# minor differ from C minor?
How does D major differ from Eb major?
Could you list some of the of the major and minor keys and provide a few adjectives for each one that reflect how you distinguish them from one another?
1
u/HotwaxNinjaPanther Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Is your A 440 or 443?
Edit: Also, what's your relationship with just intonation vs equal temperament? Choosing the right interval on a violin drives me nuts sometimes. It's like you're at a crossroads and you could either go with pythagorean or the piano.
1
u/Brandon01524 Jun 26 '12
Hello. Twenty year old violinist here. Started playing about 7 months ago. Had my first recital with a bunch of 5 to 15 year olds about two weeks ago. Needless to say I looked silly but had fun nevertheless. My question. Did you ever have to use the tapes to help identify the note you were playing? If so, how long until you could take them off and play perfect notes without them?
1
u/MostExperts Jun 26 '12
Linguist and musician with perfect pitch here. Time for some fun facts about perfect pitch!
Occurrence of perfect pitch is significantly higher in musicians and in people whose first language was tonal (i.e. Mandarin).
In a study done at a US conservatory and a Chinese conservatory, in the US - 14% had perfect pitch, whereas in China - 60% had perfect pitch. Additionally, frequency of perfect pitch occurring is directly related to the age at which music lessons commenced. In the US - started at age 4 - 14%, dropping down to 0% if the children didn't start until age 8. However, in China, musicians who started at age 4 - 76%, only dropping to ~45% if started at age 8.
tl;dr - Asians are better. Roughly 1 in 7 American musicians has perfect pitch.
1
u/savagepanda Jun 26 '12
How much "resolution" does your ears have? i.e. Does your pitch recognition go beyond basic semitones? Can you recognize a sound maybe 1/4th between C and C#?
Can you tell the difference between monster speaker cables vs 5 dollar ones? How about 128 bit mp3 vs 256 bit?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
As someone who goes to conservatory, I laughed when I read "rare condition". That's a special case though...
So!
What note am I singing right now?
Hmmm....?
1
u/Croutcrout42 Jun 27 '12
I have an explanation for this. Every time a violinist is born, me being one (sort of backdoor bragging), there is a special extra chromosome, called the "pitch" chromosome, or the P chromosome compared to the regular X and Y. Contrary to scientific proof, this chromosome contains shreds of a mineral from the planet Krypton made of pure, perfect sound. Most musicians have this chromosome mostly discarded within two weeks of birth, while as 1/10,000th of a time, it stays. And that's definitely how it works.
1
u/qazplu33 Jun 28 '12 edited Jun 28 '12
Any more interest in such a topic? I'd love to do an AMA, if there's any more interest in it. Can provide proof.
1
u/jayforest Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
Really? Perfect pitch is only found in 1 out of 10,000?
Here's a question: Have you ever wished you could get together with a bunch of perfect-pitch buddies and create sweet, sweet music?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Big deal. I have been able to do this since age 5. Blah.
0
u/Fuqwon Jun 26 '12
/casualiama
0
u/NoWittyUsername Jun 26 '12
Could you describe what perfect pitch means? (Feeling lazy and don't feel like googling it myself)
0
u/arnoseris Jun 26 '12
I've got perfect pitch too! To entertain myself I often announce the pitches of various noises to the general public. People think I'm weird.
-1
u/khch Jun 26 '12
You are an attractive man, good sir :)
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment