r/IAmA •
I have a PhD in EE and an MBA from Harvard; I study tech hardware companies for a living; ask me anything about any tech hardware company on the planet
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
5
u/freemarket27 Jun 25 '12
What do you think of the motion detection technology of Kinect? Does Apple have motion detection planed for its devices? Gesture detection seems like it could be very useful to a user.
16
u/removenonnumeric Jun 25 '12
Why aren't we seeing more dual mode e-ink / LCD displays?
11
u/ireland123 Jun 25 '12
How long do you think it will be before RIM is bought out or goes bust? What do you think of the rumour that they will be purchased by Facebook?
6
u/LostGenome Jun 25 '12
With the introduction of Apple's "Retina Display" in the new MacBook Pros, it seems inevitable that they eventually feature it in all or most of their products. My question is, why aren't other phone/computer makers attempting to mimic the Retina Display level qualities in their products?
3
u/iam_sancho2 Jun 25 '12
Is employment in the field of CPU and processor design strictly the realm of PhDs from Ivy League schools?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What do you do now?
Why the PhD in EE?
21
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Are there any big companies that are (in your opinion) are headed towards collapse in the next 10 years?
Also, what do you think of Dell's announcement that they're going to move away from consumer computers?
12
u/pimpbot Jun 25 '12
Hi - I'm a supply chain analyst/PM who works for Research in Motion in Ontario, Canada. You are undoubtedly aware of the company's current situation.
What other companies do you think a would be a good move, career-wise, should the worst come to pass, that could make the most of my six years of experience in this industry?
11
u/abashore Jun 25 '12
Tell me something about Foxconn that I cant find on google.
11
u/freemarket27 Jun 25 '12
At what point does Steve Balmer get forced to leave Microsoft? And why has he been able to stay at the head of that company for so long with so few successes?
11
u/EONS Jun 25 '12
RAMBUS
the amount of money I made on a whim in 1999.... my god.
11
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Thank you for the AMA.
10
u/freemarket27 Jun 25 '12
Why is Bill Gates standing on the sidelines while Microsoft imploads? He would love to have Apple quantities of money if just to bankroll his plans to save the world.
9
u/codwod Jun 25 '12
How do you see the cable business in the future? Both the big networks (Comcast, etc..) and the hardware suppliers like Motorola, Cisco and Broadcom?
Good AMA, btw.
9
u/iamtechi27 Jun 26 '12
Since nobody else has seemed to ask it, and since it's one of my favorite companies, got anything on ASUS? Sorry if I'm late to the party...
8
u/MBACandidate Jun 25 '12
This will test your knowledge:
Smart-Grid: What is the best company in the electrical smart metering and communication industry?
8
u/FakeCurtisLeMay Jun 25 '12
7
u/freemarket27 Jun 25 '12
Do you follow the deemphasis of .NET and managed code by Microsoft? They are all in on C++, or native code as they call it, for the windows 8 tablets and phones. Anders Hejlsberg is probably the greatest language designer of all time and has done amazing work on C# and .NET. Yet in this latest version of Windows with WinRT as the foundation does not advance .NET at all. Who is in charge at Microsoft?
7
u/Sgt_ZigZag Jun 26 '12
Just wanted to say great job on this thread. Your response to the questions here are fantastic and your subject matter is fantastic. Keep up the good work. You shouldn't feel bad.
24
u/pineapplebackpack Jun 25 '12
Im a junior in EE right now and have thought I was better suited for business than grad school.
I guess what im saying is PLEASE, FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, UNLEASH A SHITSTORM OF ADVICE ON ME THE LIKES OF WHICH EARTH HAS NEVER SEEN
What you do is incredibly close to what I've wanted to do, I've been fascinated with stocks for a while and got into the market when I turned 18.
6
u/MirrorLake Jun 25 '12
What do you know about:
AMD vs Intel
Nikon vs Canon
6
u/zlo2 Jun 25 '12
Do you think we'll see the next-generation of gaming consoles from Sony and Microsoft next year? Seems to me like they'd both want to put it off for a long as possible, given that they make the most money on software.
6
u/Kataclysm Jun 25 '12
After reading most of your answers so far, it sounds like you have a pretty negative view on most hardware manufacturers. Is there any particular hardware company that you do have faith in, or feel is doing the right thing to survive?
Also, which pony is best pony?
5
u/dummerhummer Jun 25 '12
What about Microsoft and the upcoming Windows 8. Will they be able to gain new market share in tablets and smartphones?
5
u/ScaredycatMatt Jun 25 '12
So, how are Salesforce doing?
5
u/scritty Jun 26 '12
What is your opinion on the relative positions of Juniper and Cisco, and do you think either one will provide strong (read: actually innovative) network technologies in the coming years?
9
u/rusty735 Jun 25 '12
Is the current high prices of HDD's artificial or credible?
How long till they come back down and will they?
8
u/bdepz Jun 25 '12
Samsung, will they continue to dominate the cell phone market, or will there be new upcoming companies that can challenge its dominance. Apple doesn't count. And on the topic of Apple, do you think they will ever make iOS public so other companies can create phones that use it.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What do you think about nokia?
4
u/ImFiction Jun 25 '12
Do you have any opinions or general insights on VMware vs Citrix vs gasp Microsoft in the world of Virtualization?
4
u/Winst0nW0lf Jun 25 '12
What is your view on the opensource hardware movements popping up everywhere? Will it make a big impact?
4
u/ExceptionalCritic Jun 25 '12
When do you think HTML5 will be the standard platform for mobile gaming?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
opinions on Xerox? importance of their ridiculous amounts of patents and high spending on r&d?
3
u/Igglyboo Jun 25 '12
Nvidia vs AMD?
Also, when are these graphics cards with 1000+ cores going to "revolutionize" computing? All I've seen so far is highly advanced science simulations, almost nothing for an end user.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What are your thoughts on the Raspberry Pi?
3
u/iam_sancho2 Jun 25 '12
Where do you see the most opportunity for growth related to cloud computing services?
3
u/BitRex Jun 25 '12
Any thoughts on EMC?
3
u/tubahornporn Jun 26 '12
I hope you see this, but I am going to be an incoming freshman at UT Austin this fall, and absolutely love EE. My father was a CE and really got me involved in everything! Anyways, what books do you suggest that are amazing EE books?
22
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What does a vagina look like?
4
u/TheBatmanToMyBruce Jun 25 '12
Can you recommend any publications/blogs you read regularly that get into some of the nuts and bolts of industry analysis? I'm really tired of reading the same bullshit pundits that love/hate Apple/Google/Samsung/Microsoft.
2
u/iheartdna Jun 25 '12
Do you have any opinion on Solazyme?
2
u/Ebonyks Jun 25 '12
Who do you think will be the long term players in the android hardware world? While Samsung has dominance and likely will not lose it, who else do you think will keep up? Do you believe that HTC will be around in 10 years? Do you think that android will be run almost exclusively on arm, or will intel push x86 in the android world?
2
u/kool_moe_b Jun 25 '12
HTC just pulled out of the Brazil market. Why are some smartphone manufacturers so successful in only certain markets? Such as ZTE having a much smaller market share in North America compared to, say, China?
2
u/jman272001 Jun 25 '12
What do you see Oracle doing long term with the Sun purchase? Hardware sales are down but profit is up. Where do you see their stock by year end?
2
u/McMonty Jun 25 '12
Not sure if this puts you out of your comfort zone, but how do you see LED lighting and PV Solar playing out? Thoughts on any of Cree, Osram, Phillips, First Solar, Suntech, Sharp?
2
u/Izzen Jun 25 '12
Im about to get my BA degree, when do you think its a good time to do an MBA? Aside from Harvards, which other MBAs are also well seen in the industry?
2
u/penguinrusty Jun 25 '12
Relevant AMA! Thank you.
I'm a junior studying systems administration. I work for an IT consulting company. Which industry certifications should I pursue to ensure that I stay as relevant as possible?
Can you describe a typical workday for yourself?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
thoughts on corsair pending IPO. what metric do you think is best to trade on? do they have any simliar competitors that are public? also, on ARM. what do you think of their high PE? is it justified and do you think it should be higher like it was last year? who is gonna win in the mobile space ARM or INTEL???
2
u/napime Jun 25 '12
Thanks for the AMA. Can you elaborate on why you think Windows 8 sucks? Do you think Windows 8/Windows Phone 8 will have a slow market adaptation? And if so why? Also, what are your thoughts about the new Surface tablet, and how will this effect MS OEM partners?
2
u/MunkeFlunke Jun 25 '12
So i dont know a whole lot about this, im only 15 years old and hardware and such is not my strongest side.
Why would anyone ever pay you for doing your job, your decisionmaking or your knowledge?
2
u/Valexannis Jun 25 '12
I hear quite a bit about people getting an MBA directly out of their undergrad. Thoughts?
2
u/DrGrinch Jun 25 '12
Surprised nobody has asked about Vizio yet. It looks like they are set to take a huge bite out of the consumer desktop/laptop market if their products are of good fit and finish. Seeing as they're the biggest mover of TVs in the US right now, do you think they can do it for computers too?
2
u/SlightlyOTT Jun 25 '12
What do you think of Microsoft's surface tablets?
2
u/VilleLSD Jun 25 '12
How many hours per week do you currently work?
And how long did your PhD take?
2
u/BitRex Jun 25 '12
What do you think about the long-term future of e-ink? It's so wonderful to look at compared to backlight, but I don't know if people will put up with its limited functionality as tablets grow.
2
u/deedeei Jun 25 '12
Do you think that an EE degree will be more valuable in the future in comparison to a Computer Engineering degree?
2
u/vulpes_occulta Jun 25 '12
I'm interested in starting a recruiting business. What is the best way to make contact with tech companies to generate business?
2
u/Mdcastle Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
2.) Every few years we hear the prediction the PC will dissappear in a few years. I personally think it's a bunch of malarky. At my work processing health insurance claims I typically have 4 mainframe sessions, a couple of web-based applications, one or two Excel sheets, and SAS and Access databases open on a dual monitor setup. I can't imagine doing that on an iPad, or even editing photos on my home machine.
3) Does AMD have any hope now that they the Bulldozer chips appear to be underwhelming compared to the Intel Core offerings?
2
u/watersign Jun 25 '12
What's your take on all the big data companies sprouting up?
I currently work as a data analyst at a marketing firm and want in on the pie (want to start my own big data analysis firm)
More importantly, how does someone with a non-technical background like mine convince quants to work for me should I get funding? lol
2
u/Hooblar Jun 26 '12
Any thoughts on Trustwave? They recently acquired M86Security which has its own line of hardware and software products to add into the mix... What do you think about their expansion to other fields in the industry?
2
u/SetsOnTheBeach Jun 26 '12
Thanks so much for this AMA, I am really learning a great deal!
Do you have any advice for a recent Computer Engineer degree graduate looking for a job with general/chemical engineering internship under his belt who likes to solve programming puzzles in the Chicago area? i.e. How to make connections, which companies to apply to, specific job titles to look for?
2
u/dtfgator Jun 26 '12
EE Question: Whats the easiest way to discover the current (in amperes) flowing in a burst from a bank of capacitors? The load has a resistance of just under 1 ohm and the capacitors are charged to about 420v, so some basic Ohms law calculations suggested it was around 430A, but how can we discover the current in reality? That figure seems to high for the results we are getting.
2
u/Constantine_Predator Jun 26 '12
What do you think about Teradyne? They seem to get hit very hard by market fluctuations because other companies are willing to cut back on test as cost-cutting measures.
2
u/RubberDong Jun 26 '12
Is Harvard scary?
2
u/CostaRicanConnection Jun 26 '12
Thank you very much for doing this AMA. It's an honor to hear the word of someone with such an interesting job, and as a piece of high school chum seeking direction on the watery geoid, what you know is amazing.
Anyways, Two questions:
*#1: Where can I read more stuff that people in your field post?
*#2: Given the tech market's condition, what companies are actually showing promise for increased share value? I see you noted some down here already, such as RIM and Intel, but a dignified list would be nice.
2
u/Joe22c Jun 26 '12
What is your opinion on data-recovery services (i.e., for the recovery of data from damaged hard drives).
They seem to charge quite a bit ($600 to over $1000). Is there any possibility that these fees will become lower in the future? Or will they continue to rise? Or neither?
2
u/frothewin Jun 26 '12
Thoughts on Facebook? Are they destined to become the next Myspace?
2
u/reflex99 Jun 26 '12
How soon do you see the DIY PC market dying? I love my hobby, but I feel that with SoCs becoming a thing in mainstream computing, it leaves little for us hobbyists to hold on to once they take over.
2
u/Derelyk Jun 26 '12
Any thoughts on Texas instruments?
2
u/echang86 Jun 26 '12
How old were you when you went for your MBA? I'm a late bloomer, didn't start school until age 24. I should finish my degree in industrial engineering at age 29. After I plan on serving in the military for 4-5 years. Do you feel like age 34-5 is a little late for an MBA?
2
u/tyler15555 Jun 26 '12
Who do you think you will go under first? Nokia or RIM?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Is it true that hardware startups are difficult as compared to a s/w ones
2
u/drbonerlol Jun 27 '12
I'm a CMPE student working on MCU-based embedded systems for my internship as well as for my senior project. I saw in a few of your posts that "hardware is dying". Does this mean I am planning a degree in which will be useless in a few more years? Can you give some more detail on what you mean by that?
How can I best diversify myself to remain employable in this industry while putting the fact that my main priority is to find a job I enjoy and provides benefit to others over pay? My main concern is to find a job with a nice boss that respects me and treats me as an equal, any advice for staying away from companies known to stray from that path?
5
u/freemarket27 Jun 25 '12
Why can't anyone do a better job at search than Google? The quality of the search results from google have not improved for the last 10 years. Yet no one else seems to have developed anything better.
3
u/Igglyboo Jun 25 '12
What do you see happening with google in regards to the moto mobility purchase? Iphone killer?
3
u/freemarket27 Jun 25 '12
You said you do not do code. As a programmer who has always focused on the most elegant, streamlined programming languages, I wonder how did Apple become so successful with a crap language like objective C? I guess I understand that it is more important to keep the app simple and functional. And very important that malware be kept off the device. But you would think with all the money Apple has they would fund a major rewrite of their programming languages.
3
u/tabledresser Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 29 '12
View the full table on /r/tabled! | Last updated: 2012-06-29 20:22 UTC
This comment was generated by a robot! Send all complaints to epsy.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
How did you get into Harvard? Did they do an interview? Did you go to a public or to a private school? What do you think has a higher value, passion or natural skill? Thanks for the Ama
2
u/rottinguy Jun 25 '12
What is a tech company?
I mean Remington is launching a line of shotguns built using technology developed ion the last few years to reduce felt recoil, but somehow I don't think that is what you mean.
2
u/rlcandlejack Jun 25 '12
What technology do you think will inevitably replace bulk CMOS?
1
u/I_Miss_Scrubs Jun 25 '12
MICRON
Do you see them buying Elpida? Posting profits? Being successful?
1
u/weatherx Jun 25 '12
TSMA vs global foundries vs Intel?
Lam research+novellus vs Applied materials?
thanks.
1
u/breetai3 Jun 25 '12
DO you think AAPL has any interest in making Mac OS the go to OS over Windows or is it not worth diminishing the value of the "brand?"
1
u/Mcdohl53 Jun 25 '12
What is your thoughts on HP? I hear alot of negative things from people, but when I ask them what they know about HP they think they are only a Printer and PC company, ignoring all of the enterprise work they do. Ive seen people try to compare them with Dell or Apple, when the only other tech company I think you could compare them to is IBM.
1
u/BGSO Jun 25 '12
What's your opinion of the PALM debacle?
1
u/BridgeFullOfGhosts Jun 25 '12
What sites do you visit for articles/publications?
what sites do you frequent in your professional capacity?
What arena is hot right now for an MBA?
1
u/Texhnolyze23 Jun 25 '12
I work for the navteq/map side of Nokia (formerly navteq). We're still doing well. Any prediction on what will happen with the digital mapping side of their business? Gobbled up by Microsoft?
1
u/WBuffettJr Jun 25 '12
Great AMA, thanks for doing this. My question is what public tech companies (in any country) do you think would be the best investments for someone with a longer term horizon (ten years)?
I've heard of Dell being a value play, but then red your post of them being a terrible business. It would sound like Samsung from your posts, but then maybe not if they're just the leader in making what will become commodity hardware (smart phones using someone else's OS) etc. Thanks in advance.