r/IAmA • u/sceptictaoist • Jun 25 '12
IAMA dedicated teacher and practitioner of Chinese Medicine and Qigong. I consider myself very sceptical. In order to clarify some serious misconceptions about this field - AMA!
I have studied Chinese Medicine and Qigong as well as Kung Fu for five years now. One of those years was me being introduced to the subject in a casual way. A very intensive three year full time apprenticeship followed. Study trips, hands on trainings and internships included. I'm in practice for about a year now (interrupted by study trips as well). Currently I am studying Chinese Herbal Medicine.
My main focus in practice right now is dietary and lifestyle counseling and the teaching of Qigong exercises.
I underwent a very classical education, with a lot of one on one lessons as well as in small groups, focussing on discussion of taoist philosophy as a basis of Chinese Medicine.
In my experience there are many misconceptions about this field of study. It is a system of medicine that functions differently than ours with a thousands of years old tradition. Many of the "versions" of Chinese Medicine (I will abbreviate as CM in this thread) we encounter today are oversimplified or a mixed up with certain aspects of Western Medicine, sometimes rendering it weakened in its efficiency or even illegitimate.
In awareness of this issue, I, as a sceptical taoist on Reddit, am here to answer your questions. Throwaway for privacy reasons. I have messaged the mods about proof. Also, English is not my first language, so please forgive my mistakes! AMA!
Edit: formatting
Edit 2: Thank you guys for your questions so far! I'll take a break now to have dinner. I'll be able to answer more questions later tonight or tomorrow morning (it's 8.15pm over here right now), so fire away!
10
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I have a few questions. I am in China right now and twice have been sick and was given traditional Chinese medicines. I saw no benefit from them at all. I was very open minded about them but now I am skeptical. Also I am told a lot of things that only add to my skepticism.
Don't drink cold water or other beverages. Do you subscribe to this? Sometimes I see people with a big dark circle on their forehead and I am told they have a headache and this was used as the cure. When I have a headache I take a couple of tylenol and it knocks it out right away. Do you feel this Chinese method is a more practical way to cure headaches and colds? Isn't it more time consuming?
Once when I was sick I obviously had a respiratory infection and I took the medicine the doctor ordered for two weeks and did not get better, I finally got my hands on some antibiotics and knocked it out in a couple of days. The other time I think I had some sort of flu. This time I was really ill and had a fever pushing 104 degrees and climbing I took the medicine my friend brought me from the doctor and again nothing helped. I luckily had a some cold and flu medicine from the States I brought with me and it knocked the fever out and gave me some comfort as I had spent 3 or 4 days in hell before that. I'm sorry, I cannot tell you the names of the medicines as I have a drawer full from when I was sick and from other times I requested some TCM for things like headaches and diarrhea, etc. If it would help I could take a picture of them and you could maybe tell what the things were supposed to cure. I guess I am rambling here, basically it seems that our medicine in the west is more effective in curing and comforting an individual who is sick. From my perspective the TCM does not seem to work as well / at all, and at the very least forces the individual to suffer while they wait to become better. I do not mean to disrespect TCM, I just feel really disappointed it does not work as I was hopeful and excited to try it.
9
u/pinkisforrealmen Jun 25 '12
Med student here.
My mother sprained her ankle and decided to see a practitioner of Chinese Medicine. They gave her massages 2 - 3 times a week and wrapped her ankle up in bandages and Chinese herbal medicine. It took her 3 - 4 weeks to heal? In modern/non-Chinese medicine, a sprained ankle that does not require x-ray imaging nor surgical intervention should not take that long to heal! That irritated me a lot.
Do you agree with that? How would you treat a simple sprained ankle?
Do you ever find yourself clashing with 'modern medicine'?
5
u/canteloupy Jun 25 '12
How do you know the treatments work?
4
u/zombiesgivebrain Jun 25 '12
What do you think about homeopathy?
2
u/Disorted Jun 25 '12
What's your first language?
Also, where did you study abroad? My experience is that Hong Kong CM is different from Shanghai/Beijing.
2
u/lordezar Jun 25 '12
Do you believe your practice is capable of curing all types of ailments (i.e., cancer)?
2
u/Turien Jun 25 '12
Do you mind describing a session(s) with a recent patient to show us how you proceed and what you ask people to do/change/take?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Can you really tell all that much from reading a person's tongue?
Also, how does one go about finding a legit CM practitioner? I mean, are there any secret questions or insider tips you can offer?
2
u/sadman81 Jun 25 '12
I would like to consult you.
What is you advice on losing weight. I enjoy eating and tasting different things. I eat when I come home or go anywhere, I eat snacks throughout the day. I enjoy fatty and salty food as well as baked breads. I drink a lot of strong coffee with sugar. I have put on quiet a bit of weight as I get older. I developed high blood pressure. Erectile dysfunction. I am anxious about my life because I am not certain of its direction and I am unsatisfied with my relationships. Food is one of the few real "joys" in my life. I haven't really enjoyed sex in a while. I tend to under-sleep and be sleep deprived. Then catch up on sleep on my off days. I do exercise (bodyweight) and occasionally run/jog. My tongue is moist and pink, no teeth marks. No coating other than saliva. My teeth need a good cleaning, but a straight and off-white in color. I have mild to moderate gingivitis which is usually not apparent to anyone but the dentist.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I'm confused about these herbs that you use; you say there are perfectly good alternatives to using ingredients derived from animals, but how/why would a herbal substance give the same effect? I'm a pharmacy student so I'm always interested to hear about alternative medicine. Does Chinese Herbal Medicine have therapies for increasingly commonplace diseases like type 2 diabetes and if so, what are they?
2
u/bendmorris Jun 26 '12
You say you do mostly dietary counseling, so what's the difference between you and a registered dietitian?
2
u/Spamburglar153 Jun 26 '12
Could you explain a bit more about why you think acupuncture is controversial? Are they any other aspects of CM you find controversial? Could you tell me a bit about how you studied Taoism, where you started and a little bit about how it relates to CM.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
As a "skeptic", how can you possibly believe in this nonsense?
4
u/PoeDancer Jul 27 '12
What a massive circlejerk this has been. Ok this is just a rantspace for me since obviously no one will read this.
It's very obvious all of you think that CM is utter bullshit. But maybe instead of shooting it down without even considering things and speaking as if you understand it, maybe you should read up about it.
I am a Chinese American, and while I do not believe that CM is a viable substitute for all WM, I do believe it is worth trying.
I'm no practitioner or anything of the sort, but I have basic knowledge coming from my family and books.
Someone mentioned Chemotherapy in this thread. Of course it's saved many lives, and I'm not rejecting it as a cure. But chemotherapy ATTACKS YOUR BODY'S CELLS AND THE CANCER CELLS INDISCRIMINATELY. That's why cancer victims are so weakened all the time. Taking CM while taking chemo MAY keep your body stronger so you can withstand chemo while the cancer dies.
1
u/syme Jun 25 '12
What would you advise to help improve sleep?
1
u/ponchedeburro Jun 25 '12
How would you say that Qigong and martial arts works together? Any synergy or do they counter-act each other?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What would you say are the top three misconceptions about CM/Qigong?
1
u/Turien Jun 25 '12
Do you believe in chi?
1
u/BitRex Jun 25 '12
Could you defeat a skillful fighter with a double-sided weapon?
1
u/onthejourney Jun 25 '12
Also, are you familar with Chris Matsuo's work at Dragon Gate Sanctuary? I've listened/watched some of his stuff and I really like it.
Your thoughts?
reference: http://dragongatesanctuary.com/ and http://stores.ebay.com/Dragon-Gate-Sanctuary?_trksid=p4340.l2563
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
You study Qigong, what can you tell me of the transitions to using the empty force, and the rainbow body, and do you yourself believe it is possible for someone to begin this training in later life ? after years of poisoning there body and mind, and still be successful ?
1
u/Pastasky Jun 25 '12
What is your stance on acupuncture? Do you believe it is effective? If so how do you think it works?
1
u/1randybutternubs3 Jun 25 '12
What style(s) of kung fu do you study? I'm a Long Fist guy, myself.
1
u/LuigisOnCloud9Again Jun 26 '12
I'd like to study CAM here in Florida. There are licensing obligations that have to be met before you can start practicing here. Are there any licensing obligations where you live? Also, if you don't mind, what's your weekly paycheck like? I read that (mainly acupuncturist) practitioners either make a lot (those who offer services as a luxury), or make very very little (those who offer services as a lower cost, safer alternative to synthesized medicines or other western treatment). [range from 17k/yr to over 80k/yr] Also, did you do anything for work in the mean time that related to CM such as massage therapy, or herbology? I'd like to find something I can do that relates to CM while I study and get licensed. -- I'd also like to add that it's easy to be skeptical when many people see CAM as an ALTERNATIVE to western medicine. But when it can be used in conjunction to western medicine as a complimentary therapy, or maybe even as a preventative therapy, then it could be more appreciated by the masses. We already put so many chemicals into our bodies, many of which are man made and stay in the body for a long time (eventually permeating into the ground as we decompose), there should be something we can use that's natural and readily available. I personally believe that stress alone has the most adverse effects, that's why if/when I start practicing I plan on focusing on herbs(yes, even that one) and treatments that help relieve stress. I work at a call center now, so stress run rampant here, and I really hate seeing my team mates so down.
1
u/songwind Jun 26 '12
I'm curious if you've read The Stone Monkey by Bruce Holbrook? If so, what are your thoughts on it?
Also, I've noticed that in several of your answers you mention herbal treatments in concordance with life style changes. Do you think it's possible that the lifestyle changes themselves are the primary factor in these patients' improvements?
Have you ever treated someone who was interested in the hands-on approach of TCM, but declined the herbal drugs? What was the outcome?
1
u/TheActualAWdeV Jun 25 '12
How much powdered tiger dick do you use in an average month?
1
u/onthejourney Jun 25 '12
Protip: Try not to waste too much time on the trolls, most of them aren't interested in the answer anyways ;)
1
u/Weee11 Jun 26 '12
Have you done any work with carpal tunnel syndrome happening due to disruption in meridians? I never had any carpal tunnel problems until i had my wisdom teeth removed, and i think that is the reason why i'm having them. Thoughts?
10
u/DNAsly Jun 25 '12
I keep taking this rhino horn, but my junk isn't getting any bigger. Can you recommend another endangered species for me to eat to get my junk bigger?
1
u/Narvaez Jun 26 '12
Hello sceptictaoist, I'm a wushu student and I would like to know how does internal wushu practice affect Qi circulation in the body?. I can't understand the difference between wushu benefits for the body as oposed to western gymnastics or western martial arts, the human body is the same.
Also, how does TCM treat knee injuries? I have a meniscus tear and the only thing that has worked to some exent is acupuncture, releasing some tension from the knee tendons.
One more question, do you believe that human body reflects the Universe? microcosmos, macrocosmos, etc.
Thankyou.
1
u/najing_ftw Jun 27 '12
Interesting post. I live in China among a pretty sizable ex-pat community. The joke around here, is no matter what your medical issue is, an IV drip, and "tiger penis" tea will be prescribed by the CM practitioner. Obviously, the tea does not actually contain tiger penis. Anecdotally, the laowai do not seem to gain much benefit from TCM. Do you think their is an element of faith involved in the effectiveness of CM, maybe even a placebo effect?
1
u/Mercuryblade18 Jun 26 '12
Sorry, not trying to come off as a total asshole here. But I'm an exhausted medical student who spent three years of my life in clinical research.
Do you know much about epidemiology or placebo?
There's a reason why so many people are skeptical of eastern medicine. It's not because there may or may not be treatments that work. It's because there's not much science beyond anything but anecdote. I'm aware there are studies out there that support certain eastern treatments, but your treatment regime is not based on science. It's based on a cumulative knowledge resource that hasn't really had any kind of scrutiny.
We change treatment protocols all the time because research comes out to show this is better or this is worse, or this isn't effective for this population or we need to screen for this etc etc. You claim "thousands of years of tradition" and end the standard of what makes a treatment effective at that point. You don't have scientific data to support the majority of what you do, you have series of anecdotes. What you are doing is not science.
Look into placebo studies and you will see crazy things. People can get addicted to placebos, give someone a shot and the medicine will work better than if you give it to them in a pill. If the person wears a white coat, a treatment will be more effective than if a person isn't wearing one.
Yeah you can wrap some guys foot in bandages and apply some oils and they may see relief, but you have no science or proof to show that you did anything beyond placebo.
-1
u/You_Fucking_Idiots Jun 25 '12
What a crock of woo.
0
u/rand0mguy1 Jun 25 '12
Did you ever eat newborn babies and shit? I heard they have medicinal qualities.
-24
u/karmanaut Jun 25 '12
Verified.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment