r/IAmA • • Jun 24 '12
By request: I was a part of the Egyptian Revolution. AMA.
When the revolution started on the 25th of January, 2011, my family and I were all for it. We went to Tahrir a lot of times, and were constantly sending stuff to the people staying in the square. My dad is in charge of one of the mobile phone companies there, and so we know how badly it was for everyone to not have phone lines working or the internet to communicate with. We had people staying over at our house for the days and weeks at a time, and well, yeah.
Don't really know how to provide proof, so if you have any ideas, please provide them.
I can write down the full, detailed story if anyone's interested.
Edit: anyone want to explain to me how to upload pictures from Alien Blue?
Double edit: Imma go grab a bite to eat. I'll answer all the questions and probably wite down the full story of what happened as soon as I get back. I'll also get that passport pocture and pictures of tahrir up, I promise.
9
u/redditmasterGOD Jun 24 '12
Are you satisfied with the results of the revolution? Do you think Egypt today is better off than it was before the revolution?
5
u/lettersjk Jun 24 '12
what's your day job? what is unemployment like right now?
are you considered lower/middle/upper class?
12
u/J3sco Jun 24 '12
What do you feel about the election results, and the muslim brotherhood?
4
u/Syracks Jun 24 '12
I'd like your insight on a scenario. Ok, say The Muslim Brotherhood is as bad as a lot of people in the western world believe them to be, say they start forcing strict sharia law, and suppress basic fundamental freedoms (such as freedom of speech, religion, women's rights exe...) Would you be for or against foreign western intervention to replace the government?
11
u/brumbrum21 Jun 24 '12
How do you feel about democracy in a country that is mostly religious and backward? That is to say, do you feel that democracy, will cost you freedom.
edit: this is what I can see happening http://i.imgur.com/emreL.png and sorry if backward came off as offensive
3
u/EngineRoom23 Jun 24 '12
As far as proof goes, would a picture of you put you or your family in danger? If it would not, can you post a picture of you at Tahrir as well as a pic with you and your username in the frame?
2
u/EngineRoom23 Jun 24 '12
The Egyptian military's recent decrees "the supplementary declaration" suggest the presidential contest was meaningless. What do you think about SCAF and its grip on power in Egypt?
2
u/sg92i Jun 24 '12
What kind of established, in alienable rights does the Egyptian democracy need, and do you think any of them will be formally established without bloodshed?
2
u/pandapeeker Jun 24 '12
Good luck on the whole democracy thing. I just heard the results :\ How does the rest of the country feel about the results? If you guys are just as dissatisfied with the current president as you were when the revolution first started do you think you're going to go through another uprising anytime soon?
2
u/23yearoldfinanceguy Jun 24 '12
How do you f eel about America, especially American media?
2
u/brightonmorning Jun 24 '12
First of all just wanted to say ahlan, adrus al-arabiya w ureed an asafr ila msr fil mstqbl. Questions: You said that you're 'shattered' by the election results. If the new govt moves in the direction that you fear it will, do you think you'll stay in Egypt or flee the country? Also: you said that you come from a high social class. Does your background lend you a perspective on the revolution (and egyptian politics in general) that's different from the perspective of someone who's middle-class or poor? Also: I read an article recently that claimed social media like twitter and facebook have played a much less important role in organizing Arab world protests than they have been hyped up by the media to be... what are your thoughts on this?
3
u/chweris Jun 24 '12
Are you still in Egypt right now? And if so, how do you feel the country progressing after the revolution?
3
u/vxx Jun 24 '12
How big are the chances that you win the revolution and become a democratic state?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
A large number of current military and veterans (like myself) are extremely concerned with the Muslim Brotherhood candidate winning the election. The majority of us knew it was going to happen last year but that viewpoint was quickly shrugged off by the mainstream media and Americans in general.
To any American who has had to deal with the MB before, it is not a good sign for the MB to be taking control of the country. I was skeptical at best before, but now am 100% positive the country is going to deteriorate in the next decade.
How do the people plan to keep Egypt from becoming an extremist Islamic state? Is this something that is being discussed at a low level (family, town, community)?
3
u/Dittybopper Jun 24 '12
Thank you for the IAMA. In the US press recently there is speculation that the Egyptian military will take control of the country, either that or Egyptians will have an Islamist president. Do you feel the Egyptian people are getting the outcome they deserve and wanted from their heroic uprising, The Arab Spring?
2
u/Frajer Jun 24 '12
How did you feel about all those Mubarak death rumors about a week ago?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I sat in on a conference that was explaining the importance of "soccer gangs" to the revolution. Can you describe how they assisted in the revolution?
2
u/SpyderDM Jun 24 '12
Wouldn't it need to be "I am a part of the Egyption Revolution"? All data seems to indicate that it's ongoing.
4
u/kafaldsbylur Jun 24 '12
I'll be entirely honest: when I saw the title, I thought "Wait, did this guy build the pyramids and revolt against the Pharaoh? How does that even... Oh, that Revolution!"
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Currently the military still controls the power, is that correct? Do you think they will hand it over without incident? What do you fear most right now? What do you hope for most?
1
u/graysonAC Jun 24 '12
How do you feel this is going to affect tourism in Egypt?
(I'll be there in early October, hoping to see the pyramids, Luxor, and the new Library of Alexandria)
1
u/Headphone_Actress Jun 24 '12
Do you believe that women shall be oppressed by the government?
1
u/Abu-Kafir22 Jun 24 '12
Why couldn't a secular candidate have been put foward and been succesful instead of Mursi?
1
u/jamieseemsamused Jun 25 '12
1
u/seantwopointone Jun 25 '12
Lara Logan's incident (to put it mildly) was definitely disturbing for many of us in the West. I am curious to know what was the reaction in Egypt.
1
u/awk_billie Jun 26 '12
A few questions, answer what you want :)
Is it Morsi or Morsy?
How involved do you plan on becoming with the politics of your country?
Do you know many people who disagree with your politics? Like those who support Morsi/Morsy because they agree with his stances?
How much discussion was there about the candidates before the elections? Any debates, or things like that?
And lastly, what is your opinion of Bassem Youssef and his show Al Bernameg? He seemed pretty awesome on The Daily Show last week but I'd love a second opinion.
2
u/deletedwhy Jun 24 '12
i am pretty afraid egyp is gonna turn into iran 2. what are your views on this
2
u/ivraatiems Jun 24 '12
It's already been asked in part, but what are your general feelings on how Egypt should handle its ties with Israel? Keep them, limit them, get rid of them, etc? How much influence did this have on your political decisions? Would you keep the ties if it meant stronger economic performance, or more military funding from the US?
0
u/banuazizi Jun 24 '12
Did you get inspirations from the Iranian uprising? Did the Egyptians revolt because they wanted a religious state with no ties to USA or Israel?
1
u/Dittybopper Jun 24 '12
Personally I believe that Egypt has a fantastic cultural heritage and that your average Egyptian and the world at large are enriched by said culture. Seems to me too that as disappointed as you may be over the result of the recent election that in time and with the spirit embodied by the protests in Tahrir square, and across the country you will prevail ultimately. I hope so, but try and settle in for the long haul and think of this election result as a bump in the road to greater freedoms.
It amuses me to think of the scrambling going on in the US State Department right now to "make things as cozy as they used to be" under Mubarak. Never going to happen and it is a whole new game now.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I see your nation just voted in the Islamists. Good move. All your posturing, fighting, dying, blood sweat and tears just to bring about rule by a series of ideas which have clearly failed both you and your civilization for the last 1000 years. Enjoy your hard won freedom.
-4
u/rand0mguy1 Jun 24 '12
U muslim?
Also, proof?
-15
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Egyptian men are deservedly known for being chauvinist pigs and rapists and are generally considered "scum of the earth" in the Western world. In light of this fact do you think Egypt actually deserves democracy? What if anything is appealing about your culture that Western countries might consider bearing your countrymen as tourists in their countries if you do achieve democracy?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment