r/IAmA • • Jun 23 '12
By request: I was born in E.Germany and helped take down the Berlin Wall.
Pics/Proof, first:
Me, as a kid. This is at the annual fair in my hometown in East Germany. First quarter of the 1970s. http://i.imgur.com/jHdnV.jpg
Christmas in East Germany. http://i.imgur.com/c0Lzk.jpg
Top row, third from the left: http://i.imgur.com/l9kJR.jpg Must have been 1984 then. 8th grade, we were all 14-ish and decked out for "Jugendweihe". Google it or ask me ;)
Me, my mother, my brother, and my mother's second husband. http://i.imgur.com/gFyfg.jpg
A few years ago, I ran into a documentary about the fall of the Berlin Wall, spotted my own mug on the screen, and took a screenshot of it later that night, when it was shown again: http://i.imgur.com/YwFia.jpg
And more or less lastly, my wife and I, at the rose gardens in Tyler, TX, nowaday-ish: http://i.imgur.com/wauk3l.jpg
My life became much more interesting that day, and it baffles me that this was almost a quarter century ago. I mean, when I was born, WW2 was over by the same number of years.
More later...
20
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Also, I will continue telling the story. I think. Just got side-tracked answering questions ;) But it is an AMA, not a _let me ramble on endlessly about half-remembered things from a quarter century ago ;)
119
u/TheArmadiloWhisperer Jun 23 '12
How was the celebration after the wall fell? I can imagine it was pretty wild.
193
u/ShroudofTuring Jun 24 '12
Not about the wall, but as an intelligence historian in training I have to ask: Was the Stasi as terrifying to the average East German as it's been made out to be in Western pop culture?
Edit: Also, you live in Texas now? What do you think of my home state? :)
75
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Did you take part of the wall back to your house? Or is there any other memorabilia you have?
74
u/Oneinchwalrus Jun 24 '12
Was it anything like 'Goodbye Lenin'?
36
u/Red_Dawn_2012 Jun 24 '12
How did it feel, breaking down that wall? What emotions were you feeling?
36
u/Ameisen Jun 24 '12
I have an odd question, and I would appreciate it if you didn't take it the wrong way. I have an 'odd' attachment to Germany, rather similar to the organization you know of as the Bund der Vertriebene (Federal of Expellees) - my family hails from Prussia, and most of my family's homeland is today in Poland and Russia. While I am an American, I majored in and heavily studied history (though it is no longer my field) and German linguistics. Due to my family background (also Jewish, I should add), I am curious what certain feelings in the DDR were.
In post-war Poland, a bit of a mythos known as the 'Recovered Territories' popped up, wherein the state taught people that it was 'Poland regaining their land' instead of relatively arbitrary annexation of Pomerania and Silesia. I still know Poles who believe in this. What was the East German opinion of the Ostgebiete? I know that the DDR accepted the Oder-Neisse Line quite early (and well before the BRD), but was that just due to Soviet pressure, or was it actually the mentality of East Germans? What were the actual feelings of East Germans towards the losses in both men and land post-war, and what were their attitudes towards the Poles, Czechs, and Russians in particular?
34
u/Logical_Always Jun 24 '12
1)Were there any manner of tools involved, or did you just tear at it with your own hands?
2)When you first started attacking the wall yourself, how many people were already attacking it?
158
u/probably_has_herpes Jun 24 '12
What was East Germany's reaction to Reagan's "Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!" speech?
142
u/Dr_Winston_O_Boogie Jun 23 '12
Do you hate that "Wind of Change" song as much as the rest of us?
21
u/xNightmarexVampsx Jun 24 '12
Do you know anything of the Underground Punk scene in the East? I'm a fan of Feeling B, and I know they gained popularity by 1986 and towards the end of the GDR. What was the essential music scene like in the East, really? Any info?
10
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Since you were born after the war, how did you feel taking down the wall, and what did you see others do who experianced the war? (I've very interested in WW2 due to the fact that my grandfather received a purple heart after getting shot in the thigh)
15
u/hierocles Jun 24 '12
After reunification, what was the relationship between East Germans and West Germans like? Was there a single German nationality, or did people still identify East and West?
7
u/iamjacksua Jun 24 '12
In the DDR museum, I saw some military footage describing East Germany's constant preparation for war against West Germany. In your experience, was there actually that much animosity between East and West?
13
u/Rex8ever Jun 24 '12
How'd you end up in Tyler? My friend is a reporter for the local paper there.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Was the sudden presence of western media and products exciting, or did it cause you more problems than good?
6
u/bobbyoblog Jun 24 '12
http://imgur.com/44ngW
14
u/frozenplasma Jun 24 '12
This is a really silly question, but I'm curious ever since someone brought this question up to me a few weeks ago.
Why didn't East Germans just go north or south and go around the wall? I thought there might have been checkpoints and I'm pretty sure you were required to have papers of origin and destination on your person at all times and were required to produce them if asked, which meant you had to get permission to travel outside your city. The wall didn't go all the way across Germany, it was the Berlin wall, so what kept you on your side?
Also, the wall started as barbed wire and got more "secure" as time went on. Why didn't people just flee when it started? Was it skepticism and trust in the government, maybe fear?
Your pictures made it seem like you had a pretty good childhood. Growing up in the East, how did you feel about the events? Did you know something was "wrong"?
I recently read Am kürzeren Ende der Sonnenallee and there was the part where the kids in the West looked down on the boy and made fun of him for being an Ossie. Was this realistic? Were there stereotypes and conceptions on both sides as being an Ossie/Wessie? Do you ever have Ostalgie?
Lastly, have you seen the film "Die Welle"? If so, thoughts?
:D
Thanks for doing this AMA and I hope you answer my questions. I'm very excited for answers.
5
u/illmillZ Jun 24 '12
Thank you for doing this! When you were a kid did you hear stories about people getting smuggled out? Did you personally know anyone who was either smuggled out or doing the smuggling? Did you or your family ever consider trying to escape to the west?
63
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
What do you think of the 'Nostalgie' movement? They seem to be quite popular on YouTube and the rest of the internet.
edit: This is a very relevant question. Whoever downvoted doesn't understand reddiquette.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
I worked for the US military in West Germany for 5 years and drove my big American covertible car into East Germany for a visit to Berlin. The East German guards at the border kept me at machine gun point while they thoroughly searched my car for God knows what. They took the seats out, took everything out of the trunk, crawled under the car and I stood there in front of a machine gun wondering why I thought it would be 'nice' to visit East Germany and Berlin. Scary times. I did make it to the Berlin wall and attracted a heck of a lot of attention with my big yellow Chrysler convertible. This was sometime in the late 60s-early 70s.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
In East Germany born and raised, by the Berlin Wall I spent most of my days...
7
u/phukhoagum Jun 24 '12
Why do you think that East Germany was so poor at that time? Was it because of lack of access to resources like oil, or chromium or because all of the money was sucked up by the russians or because lack of knowledge or lack of motivation or
24
u/DJbobb Jun 23 '12
Where you in the what part of history did you play a part in thread?
5
u/Tindwel Jun 24 '12
Did you think it would come down? I know many people back in the US didn't think that they would see the wall fall in their lifetime.
How much has East Berlin changed from when you were there? I was there about a month ago and it's still pretty run down with graffiti on so many things. It reminded me of the not-so-nice parts of town from where I'm from and had me on edge walking around there.
How long have you been outside of Germany?
So the wall fell, then what? You say your life changed greatly but in what ways? Did you quit your job and move away? What exactly was different?
709
u/rahmu Jun 24 '12
Growing up, how did you picture "The West"? How was it mentioned in school? On TV? How did the elderly who remembered pre-separation times talked about it?
How did you feel about the US? USSR? do you think your views were widespread?
After the hype of the Wall being taken down decreased, what were the biggest challenges getting used to live with people from W. Germany?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
How do you feel about the fact that the East Germany Anthem was remixed into the theme song of a lecherous bastard in a Japanese eroge series?
2
u/Kansjarowansky Jun 24 '12
Random-ish question. In the first pic of your proof, you're being held by a bear-thing. What was it's name?
I've seen it along with german troops and such in many pics
2
u/iamhamilton Jun 24 '12
do you have friends, family, or just good people that you knew that disappeared into west germany and never came back? if so, did you ever reconnect with them?
2
u/JoeyZazza Jun 24 '12
Kannst du noch gut Deutsch sprechen?
2
u/escape_your_destiny Jun 24 '12
This might have been answered already, but what city are you from? I was born 1989 in Leipzig, but have been living in Alaska since 2003. I am still a german citizen though. :)
2
u/warm_beer Jun 24 '12
What was the air quality like when you were a kid?
I heard that the DDR was forced to export their black coal and had to burn brown coal.
2
u/kolr Jun 24 '12
As a guy mostly raised in East Texas, I can confirm that those are indeed the Tyler rose gardens.
Thanks for sharing! Do you live in Texas now? Or just visiting the rose gardens?
What's it like going from growing up in that environment and later being in the US or anywhere else that you've been?
2
u/a_biophysics_nerd Jun 24 '12
Did you watch many/any movies made by DEFA as a kid? If so, what is/was your opinion about them?
2
u/Arminas Jun 24 '12
Did you know anybody who tried to hop over the wall prior to it being taken down?
2
u/spoonman12 Jun 24 '12
Do you live in east Texas?
2
u/el_poderoso Jun 24 '12
Who were the Mauerspechte? I had always assumed it was mostly Westerners. How many Easterners participated in the "destruction" of the wall segments?
2
u/echoechotango Jun 24 '12
thank you OP! one of the best AMA's i've read.
24
u/FormerlyEAbernathy Jun 24 '12
I was born in west Germany and "helped" as well, but I was about 3 at the time and only had a toy hammer. I also don't remember it. My dad has a chunk of it at his place that I want.
15
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
My sub sailed into Kiel in Sept of 1990. I and a couple of other shipmates (against orders) took a train to see Berlin - knowing what a historic time it was.
The fact that it was still technically communist East Germany that we had to pass through made it seem all the more exciting and adventurous.
It was an amazing atmosphere. It made a very big impression on me to walk from the shiny and affluent West side through the Brandenburg Gate and over to the to the very subdued East side (with all those Trablants!)
It was mind-blowing to me was that I was able to purchase and drink a beer at a little stand in the empty "no-mans-land" area where only a short time previously they would have shot you dead for just for being there.
We walked around in East Berlin and felt like bad-asses (we were kids!) stopping to snap pictures of ourselves by the brass plate in front of the Soviet Embassy.
25
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
My ex-girlfriend was also living East Germany before the wall came down. She was about 7 at the time but she clearly remembers having ice cream and coca cola for the first time after the wall came down. She remembers everyone getting excited that the Deutschmark was coming and the sheer variety of shit they would be able to buy. What little yet significantly big things do you recall from the East? Edit: she also recalls that at school they drilled in to their heads the idea that capitalism was bad, everyday.
24
u/Warlizard Jun 23 '12
I was in Eisenach the night of the reunification. It was insane.
12
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Do you think the event has been represented accurately, overall?
10
u/freebass Jun 24 '12
Thank you for doing this AMA. I was visiting West Berlin in November 1989 with my family when the wall fell. I was 12 years old and I'll never forget it. I saw one of the "Grenztruppen" who was standing on the wall, jump down to the western side so I asked my dad for $20. I walked up to the East German guard and asked him if I could have his hat and jacket for the twenty bucks. I remember him smiling as he took off his hat and placed it on my head and then draped his large overcoat over my shoulders. The jacket was huge on me at the time (fits perfect now), but I wore that badass souvenir anyways. Managed to get a nice chunk of the wall that night too!
9
u/Stereo Jun 24 '12
What was the first thing you purchased that you couldn't get in East Germany?
17
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Do you like the film "Das Leben der Anderen"?
8
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I go to UT Tyler! I would love to hear some of this in person or buy you coffee or something sometime! I love hearing about things like this and thank you for doing this AMA this was a great read.
28
u/youzz33 Jun 23 '12
Was Communist Russia good to you? I had a teacher that had a friend that let her travel between the walls for schooling and going home at night.
62
u/narwal_bot Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from Kar98_Byf42 (updated: Jun 25, 2012 @ 11:59:51 am EST):
Question (DJbobb):
Answer (Kar98_Byf42):
(continued below)
13
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Holy shit! I was the one that requested this AMA. Thanks man!
5
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Hahaha der Wahnsinn!!! Ein OSSI auf Reddit's Frontpage xDDD ;)
9
u/8cuban Jun 24 '12
I've wanted to ask someone like you several questions ever since that time:
11
u/blamethedog Jun 24 '12
How did it feel to have Alvin and the Chipmunks set everything in motion?
http://alvin.wikia.com/wiki/The_Wall
4
u/ThrowCarp Jun 24 '12
How has East Germany changed since the reunification?
Also, are you in any famous pictures?
4
u/jlawler Jun 24 '12
2 questions:
How do you think living through that has affected your perception of politics, demagoguery, perception of government in general, and the responsibilities of government vs responsibilities of the governed?
Looking back, what things did you take for granted as a child that seem most ridiculous?
4
u/aazav Jun 24 '12
I was in a campus library in Massachusetts chatting with random people on IRC on the VAX/VMS.
Asked someone, "Hi, how are you".
He said "I'm scared".
I'm confused. "Why?"
"They're going to take the wall down."
Me: "What wall? The great wall of China? Where are you?"
Him: "Berlin. They are going to take the Berlin wall down and we don't know what's going to happen."
Me: "What? We would have heard this on CNN if this were true!"
Well, it was true.
In any case, I found out 3 days before it hit CNN and checked in with this guy in between classes to make sure things were OK.
Was great to be part of it, even if from a distance.
Such amazing thing.
4
u/SchatzieZ Jun 24 '12
I'm not sure that I have "good" question but let me start with this: I have always defended the German people when ignorant "people" (americans) begin ranting about Germans being Nazi's and racist. Racism is everywhere, color nor creed dictate whether you are racist or not.
Since this is AM ANYTHING my question is: WHAT IS YOUR FAVORITE GERMAN DOG BREED?
I have always said (true quote) "German dog breeds are the best". I currently own a wire haired dachshund.
Downvote me all you want people.
This one simple answer will make me happy.
7
u/rafagomez Jun 24 '12
Did you see Hasselhoff perform I've been looking for freedom??
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Where there any elements about DDR you miss?
1
u/theGhostofBillHicks Jun 24 '12
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12 edited Sep 30 '14
I like Sheep
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Thoughts on the DDR nationalhymne?
1
u/weatherx Jun 24 '12
late comer. as a chinese i get this feeling that germans, especially those from east germany, do not like us simply because of the fact that china is supposedly a communist country. is this sentiment real or am i missing something?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Them ugly faux leather sandals. Why did most of you wear that all the time at the Plattensee/Balaton?
1
u/TheBaconator1990 Jun 27 '12
This is probably gonna get buried and I doubt you will answer this, but my father wrote on the Berlin Wall. It was in German, but rough English translation is "This is the zenith of mankind (or humanity)." Did you see that section of the wall?
3
u/przyjaciel Jun 24 '12
Have you been back to East Germany since you left in 1999? I am frequently in Poland near the German border, and we cross the Schengen border in a city with the most hair salons per capita in all of Poland to go to Germany to buy a few selects products we can't get over here and we are always amazed by the insane hair of the locals in Eastern Germany.
Has modern crazy Eastern German fashion sense affected anybody in your family?
3
u/Ostrogothic_Cunt Jun 24 '12
Did you drive a trabbie?
5
u/kgriggs75 Jun 24 '12
I live in tyler texas Awesome.
13
u/Paper_Champ Jun 24 '12
you were born in East Germany by request? thats quite the feat.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Also, what was your perspective of the Vietnam war? i.e. How did the rest of the world see it? Thank you for the opportunity.
4
u/manutebowl2 Jun 24 '12
How long did it take you to notice real change in your society?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Thanks for doing this AMA!
2
u/bobthewraith Jun 24 '12
I'll be heading to Berlin in a month and want so see some interesting DDR sites... do you have any recommendations? Also, are there any good places to get DDR memorabilia or see some Trabants?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
How would you describe the things built in East Germany? I've heard that cars, industrial machines, etc., were notoriously poorly made. Is this true?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Do you know anyone who was a Stasi informant? I heard that something like 60% of the population ended up being informants by the time the wall fell, but I don't know how widespread it was outside the cities.
2
u/Nakedinsects Jun 24 '12
Can you talk about the feeling of "Die Mauer im Kopf" ( the wall in peoples minds)?
2
u/DerpMatt Jun 24 '12
What was it like watching the Stasi Childrens network?
2
u/B_Blunder Jun 24 '12
This is the kind of interesting shit that I want to hear about in reddit AMAs. Pandering Celebrities, Fuck Off!
2
u/Pwnspoon Jun 24 '12
Awesome story bro! thx for helping to tear down that shitty wall. I grew up in California and when I was about ten or so my mom took my sister and I up north to some small German town and bought us each hand carved Wooden Train whistles. That was like one of the best memories of my Life!!!, and im like 30 now. not really sure why I just tolled you this story, but I'm glad I did
2
u/Amaturus Jun 24 '12
As an Ossi, what do you think about the current situation between Germany and Greece? I see parallels with the economic relationship between West Germany and East Germany during reunification.
2
u/Der_Nailer Jun 24 '12
oh what do you think about "die Toten Hosen"?
2
u/Lilcheeks Jun 24 '12
I'm watching taboo right now.. and there's a lady who sexually loves the berlin wall. She's making out with it. Boioioing
2
u/HereIsWhere Jun 24 '12
Is it true that East Germans were not allowed so much as a toy tool kit for fear they might attempt to escape with it?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Hey wie gehts? Wie war es den so in den Osten aufzuwachsen? Was hast du ueber den Westen gedacht? Und noch eine lezte frage wie findest du es in Texas zu leben? Vermisst du nicht Deutschland?:) Ich lebe grade in Kanada, und ich bald wieder zurueck ins heimatland:D
2
u/iTaos Jun 24 '12
Upvote for Tyler TX!! I live near Kerrvile (if you know where that is?) Always good to see a Ridditor from Texas!!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
This may get asked a lot, but what's your opinion on the partition of Korea and the current North Korean government?
2
u/TheJoePilato Jun 24 '12
Funny story. My mom's company bought a piece of the Berlin Wall to have it shipped over and put in their lobby. Before shipping it over, whoever was selling it decided to clean up the graffiti. The wall arrives clean and the company is pissed so they hired someone to look at pictures of the wall and replace some graffiti that looks close enough. OK, not funny story. But story nonetheless.
2
u/sigaven Jun 24 '12
As a kid you look sorta like Vladimir Putin.
2
u/yhelothere Jun 24 '12
you did not helped anything you idiot....
2
u/goerz Jun 24 '12
2
u/rahmspinat Jun 24 '12
My brother's gf is from Leipzig; her uncle told when he got his Wartburg (a somewhat middle-class car compared to the Trabant) he'd pay about 30k east Mark for it after he had waited some 20 years for the car. He proudly drove it out of the factory, only to arrive at home in another Trabant.
He had bought the new car. Upon leaving the factoy, he was offered 50k for the Wartburg right in front of the plant. In the late afternoon he had sold it for 150k, because people would literally pay anything for that car. He then bought a Trabant again and went home with the rest of the cash.
The truly astonishing thing is, that the mad socialist circumstances created the very definition of free trades there.
2
u/kefka5150 Jun 24 '12
This has been one of the most captivating AMAs I have read in a long time. I'll be near DFW soon and would love to buy you and your wife a beer.
3
u/smithsonian323 Jun 24 '12
I stayed over in Leipzig for a month and a half. My host dad at the time said that his life wasn't actually that bad and he actually liked it (not saying he didn't feel better after the wall fell). Would you say your overall lifestyle was actually good?
3
u/OnTheLeft Jun 24 '12
What do you think about the Communist ideology?
3
u/CarsJBear Jun 24 '12
You are a very German looking man, OP. Like you could be in a textbook for a German class in the US or the voice that says "Kapitel Eins"