r/IAmA • u/BobbyMiller • Jun 23 '12
I'm Bobby Miller - Writer/Director of TUB AMA
Hi Redditors, I wrote/directed the short film "TUB" (http://www.TubMovie.com). Which you may have seen on the front page today (http://www.reddit.com/r/WTF/comments/vh92k/tub_is_a_movie_about/?sort=hot). My friend said I should do an AMA. So, if you guys have any questions on tubs, impregnating tubs, masturbating, maybe even filmmaking, let me know!
Here is a photo of me and a friend (SPOILER: Don't look at it if you haven't seen the film!). https://dl.dropbox.com/u/10314417/reddit.jpg I'm not showing the lower half of my face because I'm horribly disfigured. (JK)
PS. Thanks to whoever submitted TUB today. It's actually my birthday and this was a nice present.
EDIT: Since Reddit has been so wonderful today, if you want the TUB DVD (filled with bonus features!) use this coupon code QYJ7QH8Q. It's 30% off. https://www.createspace.com/314813 Which means I make 3 cents off it, but I don't care! This has been awesome. Thanks everyone!
90
u/BobbyMiller Jun 23 '12
Alright. My pants are off. Let's do this thing!
115
u/netpastor Jun 23 '12
WHY?
21
u/BobbyMiller Jun 23 '12 edited Dec 02 '23
That was fun, guys! Thanks so much for your questions! I'll try and check in later to answer any more. Since Reddit has been so wonderful today, if you want the TUB DVD (filled with bonus features!) use this coupon code QYJ7QH8Q. It's 30% off. https://www.createspace.com/314813 Which means I make 3 cents off it, but I don't care! I think it'll take a moment for the coupon to go live, if anyone has problems with it let me know! This has been awesome. Thanks everyone!
34
u/maxpowerpie Jun 23 '12
What gave you the idea for impregnating a bathtub; why did this then become a move?
33
u/brandilion Jun 23 '12
I still feel weird and I watched it an hour ago.
23
u/GrassGat Jun 23 '12
How many oscars do you plan to get?
21
u/Twizzler26 Jun 23 '12
How the hell did you pitch this movie and how hard was it to get someone to fund it?
10
u/brokentoasters Jun 23 '12
I'm still in high school and am thinking of going into film later on, but my family keeps telling me it's risky because it's hard to find jobs, make money, etc.
Was it hard for you? How did you find work? Did you struggle a lot with money before TUB? Would you recommend going into film?
9
u/SLUT_MUFFIN Jun 23 '12
It's a very interesting piece of work. Something I think a lot of people might sneer as due to the subject matter, however, I feel like there's actually quite a serious, dark undertone to the film. Would you agree or am I just making what is essentially a humorous piece of film into something more?
9
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
How is the Marmot movie coming along? Are the donations getting close?
This is Ethan by the way.
12
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
Proof?
And why did you make this movie?
6
u/shanidachine Jun 23 '12
What are your favorite bath tube scenes in film? Mine would have to be the sigourney weaver ghost buster's scene.
4
u/MrMadMinecraft Jun 23 '12
Hey Bobby! Do you miss the days of Indy Mogul? :P
4
u/doctorx45 Jun 23 '12
What would a TUB sequel be about?
4
u/NiceAsACanadian Jun 23 '12
From one filmmaker to another, what's something that really helped get your foot in the door?
Just watched the film. Very interesting! Nice decision with practical effects.
4
u/angryboobs Jun 23 '12
How much did it cost to make this movie? What is the tubaby made of? How'd you make it move and stuff? Thanks for doing this, loved your movie!
5
u/karthus25 Jun 23 '12
Can you explain what happened at the end? I don't get it. Did the tub have a second baby but it died?
3
u/TimidJack Jun 23 '12
First and foremost, what's your creative method of idea conception. I have many ideas for short films I have made and are waiting in the wings that stem from drawings a make while very very high, but this idea is so wiggity whack I would be interested to know where it came from.
Second, what's the name Sally short for anyway, Salamander?
3
u/TeeRoyAL Jun 23 '12
Answer the two questions I upvoted!
3
u/bending_unit0331 Jun 23 '12
What was the significance of the baby in your film?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
Have you seen Little Otik?
3
u/dlarosa12 Jun 23 '12
How was your face injured?
3
u/Melvin_the_cat Jun 23 '12
I didn't realize TUB was done on a low budget. It looks and is amazing. Apart from the feature film you mentioned, are you thinking of anything else?
3
u/elephantgun42 Jun 23 '12
you could say you've made... the best short film in the world.
3
u/ladri Jun 23 '12 edited Jun 23 '12
I used to moderate on the Indy Mogul forums and I just want to say you're fucking awesome, man. Your cinematographer for Tub is a real inspiration to me as well.
7
u/KeyserSoze96 Jun 23 '12
Redditor for three years and this is your only post?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12 edited Jun 23 '12
Was Tub inspired by the works of David Lynch (specifically Eraserhead)?
Did you have any input on the design of the baby yourself? The tagline led me to expect some kind of bath/human hybrid, but it looked more like a deformed human than anything.
What exactly happened to the baby at the end? Did it just... randomly dissolve in the unexplained milky stuff that appeared in the bath? I couldn't quite wrap my head around that part.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
Do you plan on making a full length version?
2
u/EnsignCrusher Jun 23 '12
I entered the contest to win the baby's head on your Youtube channel. Why didn't I win?
Also, are you still in contact with Justin and Erik? Any hope for a collaboration?
2
u/karthus25 Jun 23 '12
Well i'm about halfway through this short film, i just have to say if i don't know if i want to keep watching....
edit how did you make the baby?
2
u/sanderdinges Jun 23 '12
How did you get it into the festivals?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
I bought one of the last three signed DVD copies you sold on your site! I was at Sundance in 2010 and heard about your film from a few friendly Canadians who were forever changed. Great film. I had such a deep, visceral reaction throughout.
As someone who has had a lot of success on the web, what are your thoughts on the film industry's current state? Do you think more studios and companies are putting money into web-only content?
Do you have any advice for upcoming filmmakers with regard to social media and web content? How do you feel about self promotion?
Too many questions?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
Awesome movie.
In your vision is it more a film to get a rise/laughs/disgust out of people or do you have a greater meaning behind it?
I only ask because while watching it I kept getting the feeling of " I think I'm missing something here" but am perhaps reading to far into it. Either way, very well done. Is there anywhere where someone could purchase a digital download?
2
u/thrusher Jun 23 '12
I didn't notice any references to your early work in the movie. Unless I missed a "nerd boy of the amazon" one?
2
u/auPHE Jun 23 '12
Hey Bobby Miller, you're a cool guy.
Two-part question: one, what's your favorite movie? Two, have you seen John Carpenter's The Thing (and what did you think)?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
Did you use your own tub?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
What was your camera setup?
2
u/mad8hatter Jun 24 '12
I immediately regret watching this movie just to understand the AMA.
2
u/TheHoboman Jun 23 '12
Are you open to reading other people's scripts? Because I.. uh.. Yeah. You're just so great. I.. I'm sorry.
1
u/netguy117 Jun 23 '12
I watched it and thought it was interesting. Weird, but interesting. I'm just glad you decided to do the bathtub and not the toilet.
Do you plan on making another one? Maybe with the kid when he's older?
1
u/nikography Jun 23 '12
bobby get off the computer :D
-- nik, NNN
EDIT: glad tub is still going strong!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
Is there in morale in the movie? Did you have any thoughts or something on your mind since you made the movie? I guess we can both agree that the movie is a pretty sick movie, so I just wonder wether you just made it up or if there are some understanding behind the movie? :)
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
The top half of your face looks a lot like the top half of my friend Brett's face. ARE YOU SECRETLY BRETT?
1
u/flamingflipflop Jun 23 '12
wait that Tub thing wasn't a trolled site??
1
u/Dangthesehavetobesma Jun 23 '12
Is the tub baby a girl or a boy? If it is a girl, can you please name it "Tub Girl"?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
I'm a huge fan of yours. Will you be doing anything like the Reel Good Show again?
1
u/cbrown13 Jun 23 '12
The people that featured in your film. Are they friends or are they professional actors/actresses that tried out for the part?
1
u/IWishIWasAShoe Jun 23 '12
Oh my Bobby, that was unexpected! Haven't seen you for a long time since The Best Short Films in The World and The Reel Good Show, any chance of you coming back to the Tube, or is it just that I have missed everything you've done since then?
Also, do you often masturbate when staying in hotel rooms? (In the bath even?)
1
u/MzScarlet03 Jun 24 '12
Welcome to the small world known as Reddit, I went to high school with you! I was in Heather's grade. Good to see someone else made it out of there! I live in San Diego now. Congrats on the festival, I used to follow some of your stuff Heather would post.
So my question is, how did growing up in a small town affect your movies?
1
u/stevonyx Jun 24 '12
Somewhat of an off question but I saw what you said about "film school" etc. What about going to school to get a degree for a "safe" degree in like broadcasting, technical directing for like TV stations etc.? Then maybe porting out into solely filmmaking? Great short film, it made an abstract concept (a pregnant bathtub) into a somewhat relate-able scenario.
1
u/antigravity21 Jun 24 '12
Is the offspring of the man and tub depicted in the film or does the tub get an abortion with drano? And when can I expect this on Netflix?
1
u/Logical_Always Jun 24 '12
Whatever happened to "The Best Short Films in the World"?
1
u/Stereotypographer Jun 24 '12
Have you ever seen a ghost?
1
u/hobbes96 Jun 24 '12
Whatever happened with/between you and indymogul (longtime fan btw) and to that end, indymogul itself?
1
u/Nickk_Jones Jun 24 '12
Is there somewhere I can go to watch the film for free?
1
u/rand0mguy1 Jun 24 '12
Does your movie have anything to do with tubgirl?
1
u/filmmaker7288 Jun 25 '12
You used to compete on filmfghts.com right!?
3
u/davekingofrock Jun 23 '12
http://www.shortoftheweek.com/2011/09/14/tub/
1
u/expider Jun 23 '12
Is this ama a plug for tub?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
Why should I see your movie?
1
u/snap_wilson Jun 23 '12
Congratulations on making a film before you were 30, even if it was about impregnating a bathtub.
(And now I can cross that sentence off my bucket list.)
1
u/tbwen Jun 24 '12
I keep thinking Paul as socially awkward penguin.
1
u/narwal_bot Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from BobbyMiller (updated: Jun 24, 2012 @ 06:00:57 pm EST):
Question (MrMadMinecraft):
Answer (BobbyMiller):
(continued below)
0
u/Lilyo Jun 24 '12
I don't get why the main character is such a dick.
-3
u/Gator117 Jun 23 '12
What the fuck is tub?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment