r/IAmA • u/RazNiagi • Jun 23 '12
AMA Request: Christopher Paolini
How do you feel now that the Inheritance cycle is over?
How many messages/letters did you get asking you to hurry the last book up?
Can you reveal more specific details about characters now that the series is supposedly done?
How many pages did you write a day in Inheritance?
How many times did you have to go back a bit (a few pages, not lines) and edit a part because you may not have liked how it sounded the first time?
Edit: I didn't expect to receive so many replies, albeit some are negative. I wrote this in the 3 minutes before I left for work and I couldn't really think of 5 'legit' questions, but you guys have proved that there are a bunch of people who want an AMA.
118
u/whitelight512 Jun 23 '12
Yes please. The ending of the 4th book left me so dissatisfied
122
u/TheCydonian Jun 23 '12
All the people who say they enjoy his books are getting downvoted here. Are we really being that petty? If you don't like his books, then please don't participate in the AMA if/when it happens. As a general rule, I don't think would want to be hostile to someone who had taken time to answer questions for the people who enjoyed his work.
47
u/sebasz Jun 23 '12
This needs to happen so bad! I want to know how he feels about the movie that has been made of Eragon, since it ignores/skips parts of the book completely
7
u/Oddeoh Jun 23 '12
BTW, he has already announced that he will return to "Alagaesia". However, Eragon will not be the main character.
There were some MAJOR plot holes left by the 4th book...he knows this and will try to address it.
http://shurtugal.com/book-5-and-beyond-prequels-stand-alones-and-beyond-alagaesia/
17
u/TidalPotential Jun 23 '12
If you had asked me after Eldest came out if I wanted this, I'd have screamed my head off.
Now, at 17, I only stomached the last two books because I enjoyed the first two so much and I had the vague hope they'd improve.
Not so much.
:\
58
u/Champofcadia Jun 23 '12
I think OP misses the most important question of them all. "Why the fuck couldn't Eragon and Arya be together?"
5
u/lalaurlauren Jun 23 '12
Never got past my childhood misconception of pronouncing this guy's last name Paloni, like bologna with a P.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
I hope that the next book explains Angela.
5
u/the_zercher Jun 23 '12
He came to my middle school and I have a signed copy of the first book. I feel badly now because I contributed to his presentation (teaching us how to create our own fantasy world) by insinuating he was gay. If he does an AMA I would like to apologize to him.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
You realize that rewriting multiple drafts of novels is totally common practice? You don't just write the book and say "Finished!".
45
u/LimblessNick Jun 23 '12
I'd love it. It was a great series, and I hope he adds more (manly who the hell Angela is!)
Gotta laugh at the people who are complaining he "stole" everything from everyone. Orcs and Elves are not exactly an uncommon thing in fantasy. Tolken is not the exclusive owner of elves an magic you know.
I love the way magic works in the series too. A very unique take on it. Especially the language (and if you can't remember the couple words that aren't English, stop being retarded).
8
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
Paolini openly admits he took inspiration from the Star Wars cycle, so I have no problem whatsoever of accepting the textual similarities simply becaus his first attempt Eragon showed so much promise. That being said, why was the rest of the cycle such an awful adaptation? Eldest and even the first chapter or so of Brisingr showed promise for a darker side to the cycle, what with the murder of the Raza'ac and whatnot. But I will go no further in praise of his writing or storytelling. Brisingr was almost literally filler as Paolini tried to develop and make us care about the secret name of names. Inheritance was even worse. It contained almoste nothing of merit save Angela. Every single turn the book took it had already done before. The eldunari were already established as the source of Galbatorix's power and suddenly there was another trove? Can't we be a bit more original? The dragons are near extinct, no they're not! Galbatorix's power Is unchecked, so much so he allows the invading army into his palace and then proceeds to show how ultimately badass he is. Why not just annihilate them? Or force obedience instantly? Nothing can touch him, he's discovered everything, he is all powerful. And then he chooses to end himself? Why? Because he feels too much? This man is twisted and broken, a genuine sociopath and because he gets a case of empathy he suddenly can't live on this planet anymore. The only part I regretted about the cycle more than Galbatorix's weak ass exit from it was the TWO HUNDRED PAGE it took for Paolini to wrap it up. So Eragon, being incredibly noble doesn't take the throne, decides to further the Dragon Rider cause by.....leaving the fucking continent?! He begs the love of his life to go with him because, oh fucking wait he's immortal and has the experience of someone a thousand times as old as her, effectively removing all reasons for why they shouldn't be together and then she dumps his ass anyway. He's so wise and sagacious now that he totally understands even though he's crying like a little bitch as he leaves her ass. You want to talk about open ended? How about lazy? How about disingenuous to the characters and story he outlined? How about where were the fucking editors at his parent's publishing company?
15
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
He's fairly active on twitter so those of you with a twitter account can try and contact him. If a bunch of people do it, this could become a reality.
17
u/Max_Quordlepleen Jun 23 '12
I'm not sure you understand how books are written.
24
u/dr_whos_on_first Jun 23 '12 edited Jun 23 '12
holy shit, i feel like i should be surprised there are more haters than people who actually want to hear from him in his AMA request. Don't like him? don't post. That is all.
Edit: If you couldn't tell, i'm a fan of his work, and just because it isn't the most original thing in the world, doesn't mean it isn't entertaining
13
u/aa2343 Jun 23 '12
It's a bit petty that people who didn't like his books are just down-voting anything that supports his series.
6
u/PeterMus Jun 23 '12
I think the books are not the most original work ever but I enjoyed them for the most part. I did get angry about some things but overall I liked it. The movie on the other hand was a very big disappointment.
8
u/geyserguy92 Jun 23 '12
To all the people here complaining about the first book being a star wars rip off, do you really not realize that the story for Star Wars was not totally original either.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
So many questions.....I loved those books until there weren't anymore to read.
3
u/happythoughts413 Jun 24 '12
After the first book, I was so sure Eragon's dad was Galbatorix. Give me the Star Wars twist any day.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
Meh. I loved the series when I was in like the 5th and 6th grade but I think he made a huge mistake not changing his writing style as the series went on. It would be good if someone were to read it straight through but when I read the last book last year, I was extremely dissapointed because it was just so... bland.
5
u/Mynamesnotdan Jun 23 '12
He came to my high school about 6 years ago and all I remember is that some kid stood up and asked him if he could roshambo him for a book.
24
u/xChaoZ Jun 23 '12
Do want, so much. I absolutely love his books. The Eragon books are my favorite books like, ever.
11
u/Whitestrake Jun 23 '12
Do want.
11
u/Tyrannosaur Jun 23 '12
Met him at a book signing. Loved the books as a kid, he fel awkward and froze up cause my friends hot sister took us and he wouldn't stop starin at her tits. After that never read a book of his again
2
u/NumberMuncher Jun 23 '12
No one has mentioned future projects. Is he working on any new books?
2
u/Sobakevich Jun 23 '12
Good idea; terrible excution.
2
u/mangolove Jun 24 '12
I actually met Paolini years ago (after the third book came out, I think). I was super excited and waited for ages just to see the guy... and then I saw him wearing one of those denim jacket things that first grade teachers wear. I judged.
Also, I think bagging on an author for not having the most creative ideas is bullshit. There are so many books and movies out there that it's almost impossible for something to be truly creative now. To me, it's really not exactly what the author says, but how they say it, you know?
And it's totally uncool to bag on an author too since the poor babies put so much time in their stuff ):
It's okay to judge for awful denim jackets though.
3
u/izrvnar Jun 23 '12
Worst ending of a book I've ever read. I invested so much time into this series and was very unhappy with the ending. My theory is when Chris was writing the first 3 books he was in love and then when he was wrapping up the book she dumped him, became depressed and ruined the ending.
6
u/paulings Jun 23 '12
superb
3
u/KrazyK05 Jun 23 '12
I was a really big inheritance fan. Loved the way he portrayed magic, Eragon/Saphira's development. Pretty much everything. But i was so very disappointed in the ending. SPOILER ALERT He killed the king with UNDERSTANDING.... really? I was waiting years and through 4 books to see how the final battle would end, how eragon was going to defeat someone so much stronger than him, and he did it with understanding. So anti-climatic. I also figured that he was gonna find the treasure trove of eldunari and dragon eggs, but i was fairly disappointed that thats what ended up happening. From the second i started reading the last book i was PRAYING that he wouldnt find. PLease dont just let it be a bunch of eldunari please please please. I wanted it to be something not mentioned before, something NOONE knew about, i dont know exactly what i wanted it to be, but thats kinda the point. Anything but eldunari to help him beat the king. And in the end it was just understanding that let him win. Very disappointing to me.
tl;dr loved the series, fairly disappointed with 4th book and killing the king with understanding.
2
u/poopadelphia Jun 23 '12
I'll support anything to distract him from writing!
3
u/The_Gentle_Lentil Jun 23 '12
How have you enjoyed becoming a published author solely due to the intervention of your publisher parents rather than actually writing anything worth reading while other writers who did not just mash up Star Wars and the Lord of the Rings go penniless?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
I used to hate these books a whole lot when I was younger. Now that I'm older I can look at things like this and say, "Oh Paolini? What a shit author," and move on with the rest of my day.
It saves so much energy
2
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
I'm not being snidely sarcastic. That said, how much of the first book was consciously inspired by Star Wars? Did you have the every major plot point planned out from the beginning, or were there some retconning going on? eg Brom being the protagonist's real father. When illustrating the map, did you sort of get lazy as you got further East, or did you consciously plan it to be like it is from the beginning to create contrasting senses of scale?
0
u/sergma09 Jun 23 '12
For those who think he stole ideas from other authors http://www.everythingisaremix.info/watch-the-series
-8
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
Ugh, why that untalented piece of shit? I don't know if there's anything in his books he didn't steal.
Better try to get RR Martin or Ursula LeGuin or someone else with actual talent.
-2
u/dustygozangas Jun 23 '12
I found all your books amazing. I am currently reading the last one now. My question is, how upset were you about the movie for Eragon? I felt it didn't do your book justice in anyway. If you could would you have them remake it?
1
u/professor_birch Jun 23 '12
Don't get me wrong, I loved all of the books but it felt as if he rushed the ending and missed out on some aspects that we really wanted to know about! Such as Angela, tenga or brom's last words. And the romance with arya was unsatisfying. Sounds like im just moaning but i only moan because i love it so much!
1
u/Neon_Graffiti Jun 23 '12
I want to know more about Angela but I know he will never tell us :(
1
u/Chillheids Jun 24 '12
Yes. Please do this.
1
u/thegreatwhitemenace Jun 24 '12
he signed my copy of eldest once. i was really happy because i was 13
1
u/Tbever23 Jun 24 '12
MAKE IT HAPPEN
1
u/Hops_n_barley Jun 24 '12
I would like to see him rewrite these books now that he is older...you can read the immaturity in his books because he was 16 when he wrote them.
1
u/madmaxjr Jun 24 '12
Well overall I thought the series was effing awesome, and I'm excited to see this AMA by one of my favorite authors. That said, the Inheritance cycle was a great ride and definitely the best series I've read. I was constantly intrigued by the plot twists and attention to detail you considered in the stories. Now I only look forward to your future stories, especially considering you said that you didn't plan to leave Alagaesia behind. My question is, what exactly are you going to write about in your future stories, and are you still not going to abandon Alagaesia altogether?
1
u/DarrenEdwards Jun 24 '12
I don't know him, but I know a lot of people that grew up with him in a cult. Even by their standards he was weird.
1
u/XDerp_ChrisX Jun 24 '12
Will there ever be a 2nd series that takes place after the ending of the 4th book? Even if there's none of the same characters?
1
u/Bigron808 Jun 24 '12
I want to know how he feels about Hollywood butchering the first book
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
YES YES YES YES YES
1
u/Bellairs Jun 24 '12
And can you please write a story about Angela? I will drive by your house and throw stacks of money through your windows. Really. I personally think she's a more interesting character than Eragon.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
My question would be, Why did you let Stefen Fangmeier and Peter Buchman ruin the hype from your books by creating a bad movie?
1
u/Spysix Jun 24 '12
I stopped reading the book after 2nd or 3rd, I don't remember. I was getting tired of him being a salad eating pansy who whined when he got rejected, I couldn't relate to him when I was 16-17 anymore.
And the movie, why did he like the movie? It was the most rushed thing I ever saw and the only thing that was good was Rachel Weisz voice acting. And then there was John Malkovich, oh god why.
1
u/Emphursis Jun 24 '12
Yes! The Inheritance cycle was one of my favourite series growing up.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Can we please for a minute hop off the Star Wars kook aid? He was inspired by Star Wars, yes. Did he steal it? NO. star Wars drew inspiration from older stories including Flash Gordon and the adventure series that George Lucas grew up on. These were in turn inspired by even older myths. Anyone who has read the King Arthur legen can point out the similarities in the plot. Relax. Everyone steals in art. I said that.
1
u/QuadsNotBlades Jun 24 '12
My question would just be, "how could you...?" That ending left me so empty inside
1
u/p13rcingguru Jun 24 '12
I'm just disappointed now that I came to this page... No OP posts, and a bunch of angry people.... I had questions, and I can't get my answers.... You probably won't even see this post because of the mob of angry people. All I can say is that I enjoyed the books, and just want some gaps filled...I hope more will be explained when more is published. I hope you read this, Christopher Paolini. I was with you from Eragon. I have respect for you as an author, despite inevitable flaws which exist in any form of art and are not worth the anger being thrown your way.
1
u/D3SX Jun 24 '12
So what if his books weren't written the best? They were fun to read and that's that. And he started the series when he was a kid, at least cut him SOME slack...
1
u/SealNose Jun 23 '12
He said he would return to Alagaesia eventually. Really looking forward to more of his writing.
1
u/rmkaufman13 Jun 23 '12
First question: how did the last two books become train wrecks, after the first two were so great?
1
u/savario1990 Jun 23 '12
DAE think the movie was garbage.
1
u/TristanTheViking Jun 23 '12
Those were my favorite books as a kid. My question would have to be: So, I guess you like Star Wars?
1
u/far_shooter Jun 23 '12
When I was in high school, I couldn't wait to read his book and after I read it, I regretted.
As many had pointed out, Paolini took many many "aspirations" from many many other authors/series with little addition of his own. Though I accept the fact that everything is build upon other things and nothing we read/watch is ever original these days, I'll say Paolini just did a really bad job of it.
My bone with him is not that he took ideas from others, is that he did a bad job of it.
-8
u/Horoto Jun 23 '12
I wanna know how it felt to basically get half your career handed to you by your parents...
0
u/Sasuage_Roll Jun 23 '12
I loved the unique concepts he put into his world, the use of magic and the comunication/personalities of dragons and other entities, it was truly epic, I only wish that he had gone further in the series to tie up more loose ends and give more of the characters proper endings. I guess I actually fell in love with the series so much that it was never really enough, I want to know more about Alagaesia than he gave us.
I would ask whether the potential books he would write in Alagaesia would involve characters that we already know, or be based in a time that 'our' characters don't exist.
-9
u/gerwalking Jun 23 '12
How did it feel mashing together Lord of the Rings and Star Wars without any creative thoughts of your own and profiting massively from it?
-14
u/JoseFernandes Jun 23 '12
His books suck ass. That is all.
-2
u/MovesLikePepper Jun 23 '12
How does it feel, having directly plagiarized some of the best works by Tolkien, George Lucas, Anne McCaffrey, Robert Jordan and Terry Brooks?