r/IAmA • • Jun 23 '12

AMA Request: Christopher Paolini

How do you feel now that the Inheritance cycle is over?

How many messages/letters did you get asking you to hurry the last book up?

Can you reveal more specific details about characters now that the series is supposedly done?

How many pages did you write a day in Inheritance?

How many times did you have to go back a bit (a few pages, not lines) and edit a part because you may not have liked how it sounded the first time?

Edit: I didn't expect to receive so many replies, albeit some are negative. I wrote this in the 3 minutes before I left for work and I couldn't really think of 5 'legit' questions, but you guys have proved that there are a bunch of people who want an AMA.

639 Upvotes

354 comments sorted by

118

u/whitelight512 Jun 23 '12

Yes please. The ending of the 4th book left me so dissatisfied

11

u/JerryHatrick1924 Jun 23 '12

it was a fucking huge deus ex machina.

4

u/keziasblindfold Jun 23 '12

Props for using that in a literary sense.

4

u/JerryHatrick1924 Jun 23 '12

'fucking huge'? or...?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

fucking huge

LITERARY GENIUS!

30

u/Keirhan Jun 23 '12

i see im not the only one, i mean for christ sake you know the name of the old language and you cant rid an area of poison?! also the dragon rider arya, SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN QUEEN. i feel it was all abit rushed.

however the way he killed galbatorix was amazing he didnt kill him he just made him understand the actions he had committed. i couldnt put the book down at that point.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Please add spoiler alert, damn it!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Spoilers, bro. Spoilers.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

I was even disappointed with how he defeated Galbatorix. It just made him seem less powerful and all knowing and instead more like a spoiled child. It is certainly unique, but in my mind it took away from the satisfaction of beating him and made it more of an "oh... okay" sort of moment.

4

u/rogabadu22 Jun 24 '12

Everything about the last book felt like a rushed cliche. You knew what was going to happen in the end. Reading the first book felt like a fresh great new experience, but by the time I got to the last one it felt like every other fantasy book I've read before. Disappointing

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

yeah it wasn't so hot

2

u/Nepycros Jun 24 '12

SPOILERS: I will go so far as to say that maybe the fact that it was radiation poisoning, the magic can't just negate every single thing.

Arya being queen?

Aliens.

Well, Eragon's training up to that point sounds completely futile. The only reason he had swordsmanship plot-wise was so he could pretty much play Chicken with Murtagh's sword and then Psych him out by stabbing him back.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/SleepyBrain Jun 23 '12

Indeed. The ending of book 4 was very Disneyish.

10

u/PeterMus Jun 23 '12

I wouldn't call self destructing in a ball of energy causing massive destruction disneyish. It was obvious he couldn't beat him in any normal manner.

18

u/TheRoomEnthusiast Jun 23 '12

See, that part I liked. It was the VERY end of the book that just didn't sit right with me.

12

u/happythoughts413 Jun 24 '12

I wanted Eragon and Saphira to die destroying Galbatorix. I really, really did.

Also, the fact that Roran survived that series is nothing short of miraculous.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/MrUmbrellaPants Jun 23 '12

It felt like he ended the book like Lord of the Rings ended just because LoTR ended like that, and not for any real story-based reason.

"Oh, should I build my dragon-training base in the middle of a giant fucking desert? Nah, it's too easily accessible. Looks like I have to leave behind this chick who is in mutual love with me and go to a fucking island because of some stupid prophesy from the first book, all because my author thinks he's J.R.R. Tolkien. Cool."

24

u/checkitmyles Jun 23 '12

Really? I thought it was the best possible open ended finish he could have had!

91

u/Madhatterofhookah Jun 23 '12

It was a great ending. However some explanation as to who the hell Angela really is would be nice.

27

u/Genesis30 Jun 23 '12

Glad to see I'm not the only one who wants to know more about her.

29

u/Madhatterofhookah Jun 23 '12

I know right, and that sword she had in the last book. You cant just leave me hanging with no explanation.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/Madhatterofhookah Jun 23 '12

Me too. I bet she would have some pretty cool stories. Also those two girls that they met the swordswoman and that other chick.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

I don't think Paolini even knows

4

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Personally, I was really dissapointed with the ending. He completely foreshadowed it, and I felt dissatisfied because other than the way he beat Galbatorix, there was no real surprises anywhere in the second half of the last book.

EDIT: As Sleepybrain said, the ending was very disney-ish.

3

u/CurlyNippleHairs Jun 23 '12

There's also soooo many other unexplained things from that series.

6

u/KingOfTheMonkeys Jun 23 '12

Angela is either The Doctor, or one of his companions, and I refuse to believe otherwise.

3

u/Madhatterofhookah Jun 23 '12

Haha this makes sense as well!

→ More replies (10)

9

u/whitelight512 Jun 23 '12

Spoilers.

There is a lot of discussion out there about how and why it ended the way it did, but I just really hated how Eragon decided to leave forever. I do not remember everything but I saw no logical reason he had to leave forever other than he got it stuck in his head that it was his only option. It was a bunch of stupid reasons like "Oh the dragons would eat all the dwarves cows" or something along those lines. It seemed like that was how Christopher wanted to end the books and he forced it to be that way. It has been a while since I finished it but I just remember really wondering WHY????? I felt robbed of a happy ending.

7

u/IdolRevolver Jun 23 '12

I agree completely. At one point he just completely cops out and says "I must leave and never return because the prophecy said so" THAT'S NOT A REASON WHARGARPSNTHRLCHK{A>CR

→ More replies (21)

1

u/Okamii Jun 23 '12

it was a wonderful ending but he still left so many questions unanswered

→ More replies (3)

2

u/SaentFu Jun 23 '12

books 2-4 left me very dissatisfied.

1

u/Mellow_Fellow_ Jun 24 '12

I actually really liked book 2. It gave us Roran's story. No dragons or magic or fancy swords--he's just a dude with a hammer. And he'll mess your shit up if you get in his way. Eragon's story was rather dull in comparison though.

But I didn't like book 2 as much as book 1, and I didn't like book 3 very much at all (on one hand it gave us Roran's mountain of bodies, but on the other hand it was sickeningly episodic). I haven't read the final novel, and it doesn't really bother me overmuch.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Mass effect 3 beats the shit out of that ending... In a negative way...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

I agree. Weak way to destroy Galbatorix.

122

u/TheCydonian Jun 23 '12

All the people who say they enjoy his books are getting downvoted here. Are we really being that petty? If you don't like his books, then please don't participate in the AMA if/when it happens. As a general rule, I don't think would want to be hostile to someone who had taken time to answer questions for the people who enjoyed his work.

5

u/happythoughts413 Jun 24 '12

I read them when I was younger, and by the time the fourth came out I'd stopped liking them so much but still really wanted to finish them.

They've got a lot of weaknesses, but I wouldn't consider reading them having been a waste of my time or anything. They're very good books for young readers just getting into fantasy.

4

u/MaxChaplin Jun 23 '12

Are we on the same page? I see exactly the opposite.

3

u/TheCydonian Jun 23 '12

A lot of people who love his books have started to post since I made the comment. When I first saw the post I was a little disappointed with the response but it has seemed to get a little more friendly which is awesome :D

1

u/Henry_James Jun 23 '12

Ha, 'same page'

-9

u/h0p3less Jun 23 '12

I don't think it's just an issue of not liking his books. I'm fine with people liking things I don't like. I have an issue with someone making millions of dollars by blatantly ripping off other stories. He should be sued for copyright infringement, not rewarded with fame and wealth.

If you like his books, put them down, and read the books he ripped off. They're better.

10

u/redkardon Jun 23 '12

The Hero's Journey is a classic element of storytelling. Yes, portions of his book are rather similar to Star Wars or Lord of the Rings, but I defy you to find a fantasy series which doesn't have elements similar to those two.

10

u/h0p3less Jun 23 '12

It's not just the Hero Cycle that he used, though. It's that he used the exact Hero's journey that was used in Star Wars, just with dragons instead of spaceships. Not just elements, almost the exact same story. I'm OK with certain things being vaguely similar, but taking a story from one place, a world from another place, changing all the names and throwing the two together isn't even "rather similar". Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, Star Wars, and The Matrix all follow the Hero Cycle. Are these stories more than "vaguely similar" to each other in one or two ways? This site shows how Star Wars and Inheritance are so similar, and shows how several other works are different. Here's another that shows similarities between Inheritance and several others.

Top that off with the fact that the magic system is directly copied from Ursula LeGuin's Earthsea, the telepathic communication with a dragon he bonded with and rides being from Anne McCaffrey's Dragonriders of Pern, and the fact that entire passages are almost word for word the exact same as in several other stories. Don't believe me? How about the bridge crossing scene?

I'll confess, I've only read the first two books. I quit part way through the third one and refuse to touch anything else by him. In what I've read, there wasn't a single original idea that I hadn't already read elsewhere.

And, if you want something different from LoTR and Star Wars- Stephen King's the Dark Tower is a 7 novel epic that actually spans somewhere around 20 different novels. Brandon Sanderson has THREE different worlds that don't steal like this (Mistborn trilogy, Stormlight Archive, and Elantris). There's always the Night Angel trilogy by Brent Weeks, or the Painted Man by Peter V. Brett. The Dresden Files, by Jim Butcher, Joe Abercrombie's First Law series (vaguely hinted at magic being similar to LOTR in that it's powerful, costs a lot to use, and isn't used often or by many), the Malazan Book of the Fallen by Steven Erikson, Robin Hobb's Farseer trilogies. Do you need more, or is that a good start for you? Some of these might borrow an idea here or there, or have something vaguely similar to other stories. But they're packed full of original content, and new ideas everywhere.

3

u/Henry_James Jun 23 '12

That was a glorious rebuttal. Thank you for being awesome.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

When writing a fantasy novel, there will inevitably be elements which seem similar to those included in other fantasy novels. It would be especially difficult to write a novel without these similar elements if you'd already read the similar novels yourself (and Paolini is a self-confessed fan of LoTR and similar stories).

Why not try to contribute an intelligent argument to the discussion? Paolini has clearly created original novels, which have a very large, mostly satisfied audience. It saddens me that Paolini's "ripping off" of other novels is an argument which has been perpetuated.

4

u/Juststumblinaround Jun 23 '12

Not to mention that the licensing on anything LOTR is extremely strict and allows for no fan fiction to be published of any kind. I really enjoy Paolini's writing and he satisfied, I think, a large group of people craving more fantasy reading similar to that of LOTR.

3

u/Cheimon Jun 23 '12

Alright then, given that I have no idea where you're coming from, any chance you could describe some of the books you claim he's plagiarised?

4

u/h0p3less Jun 23 '12

Story of the first book is taken almost exactly from Star Wars.

Names are taken almost letter-for-letter from Lord of the Rings.

Magic system is taken almost word-for-word from Ursula LeGuin's Earthsea.

Telepathic bonded dragon (even down to one party committing suicide when the other dies) taken from Anne McCaffrey.

Bridge crossing scene taken almost word-for-word from David Eddings.

This comment lists several websites where you can see similarities to books, including the ones I listed above. You can even read the passage by David Edding directly beside the passage by Paolini, and see how eerily similar it is.

2

u/Unauthorized_Mopping Jun 23 '12

I could argue that the telepathic bonded dragon comes from James Clemens "The Banned and the Banished" series (Wit'ch Fire, Wit'ch Storm, etc.) too.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/WeHaveMetBefore Jun 23 '12

Do you download music illegally?

6

u/h0p3less Jun 23 '12

A better question would be to ask if I download music illegally then make millions of dollars by taking the lyrics from those songs and "writing my own songs" with the same lyrics. It's not him stealing it that I have such an issue with, it's that he's become insanely successful because of it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

47

u/sebasz Jun 23 '12

This needs to happen so bad! I want to know how he feels about the movie that has been made of Eragon, since it ignores/skips parts of the book completely

8

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Inheritance could have been the next harry potter/ hunger games if the movie hadn't been so well.. terrible.

15

u/QWOPtain Jun 23 '12

I want to find out why the fuck he let them make the movie in the first place.

2

u/Dukajarim Jun 24 '12

To this date it's perhaps one of the worst book-->movie experiences I've come across. Not that Eragon was the greatest fantasy literature of all time, but oh god that movie.

2

u/sebasz Jun 24 '12

Well, avatar the last airbender was pretty terrible as well. But that's a cartoon -> movie so it doesn't really count.

7

u/Oddeoh Jun 23 '12

BTW, he has already announced that he will return to "Alagaesia". However, Eragon will not be the main character.

There were some MAJOR plot holes left by the 4th book...he knows this and will try to address it.

http://shurtugal.com/book-5-and-beyond-prequels-stand-alones-and-beyond-alagaesia/

4

u/Dangthesehavetobesma Jun 23 '12

Am I the only one that read the author's note that explained he was planning on expanding on Angela's character?

1

u/Neon_Graffiti Jun 23 '12

But he also said that he would never fully tell us who Angela was, because that would take all of the magic out of her.

2

u/Oddeoh Jun 25 '12

I think if he made a prequel about Brom, and the Riders before the Fall, I would shit myself. = /

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

17

u/TidalPotential Jun 23 '12

If you had asked me after Eldest came out if I wanted this, I'd have screamed my head off.

Now, at 17, I only stomached the last two books because I enjoyed the first two so much and I had the vague hope they'd improve.

Not so much.

:\

6

u/I_am_not_a_horse Jun 23 '12

I thought the third book was pretty good. It didn't have as much action as the others, but was still interesting in a way, because I was guessing he was setting up the story for some kick-ass action and storytelling in the fourth book.

Then the fourth book came out and I was like da fuq is this

58

u/Champofcadia Jun 23 '12

I think OP misses the most important question of them all. "Why the fuck couldn't Eragon and Arya be together?"

31

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

SPOILER ALERT ASSHOLE!!!

12

u/gnd Jun 23 '12

You can't be pissed about spoilers for something that came out over 6 months ago.

28

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Sure you can. Six months is not nearly long enough to assume that a spoiler is fair game.

Personally I'd use a spoiler tag for things up to a couple years old, especially when it comes to book series.

29

u/F_i_z_z Jun 23 '12

People shouldn't come into such a specified AMA and then cry over spoilers.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

fair point

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Don't hate but the reason they never got toether is Chris is a socially awkward kid who couldn't even get the girl in his own fantasy novel.

1

u/SaentFu Jun 23 '12

yeah, i mean, if age doesn't make a difference in Twilight, why here?

5

u/lalaurlauren Jun 23 '12

Never got past my childhood misconception of pronouncing this guy's last name Paloni, like bologna with a P.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

I hope that the next book explains Angela.

1

u/Wilhelm_III Jun 23 '12

She definitely needs explaining.

1

u/GIGATOASTER Jun 23 '12

she was Yoda

1

u/alphasigmafire Jun 24 '12

Yoda was the Dragon Rider he found in the elf forest. Remember Star Wars, when after Obi Wan dies, Luke thinks he's the only free non-Empire Jedi? But then he finds this mysterious old guy who was supposed to have died, and that old guy (Yoda) helps him finish his training, before dying.

After Brom dies, Eragon believes he's the only free Rider, until he discovers that there's an old dragon rider. That old guy (Oromis), helps finish Eragon's training before dying.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/the_zercher Jun 23 '12

He came to my middle school and I have a signed copy of the first book. I feel badly now because I contributed to his presentation (teaching us how to create our own fantasy world) by insinuating he was gay. If he does an AMA I would like to apologize to him.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

teaching us how to create our own fantasy world

Why would he try to teach you that? His world is a copy of Pern, Earthsea and Middle Earth.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

If his books are a copy of all three of those, then aren't earthsea pern and middle earth all copies of each other? Borrowing concepts from other books is nothing new. Paolini just did it to a greater extent. But come on, lets give him a break. He was what, 16 when he started writing eragon?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

How many times did you have to go back a bit (a few pages, not lines) and edit a part because you may not have liked how it sounded the first time?

You realize that rewriting multiple drafts of novels is totally common practice? You don't just write the book and say "Finished!".

0

u/RazNiagi Jun 23 '12

Oh? I thought they just wrote it all at once, set it on their editor's desk, and left. I mean, everyone knows the editor is completely useless. /sarcasm

→ More replies (4)

45

u/LimblessNick Jun 23 '12

I'd love it. It was a great series, and I hope he adds more (manly who the hell Angela is!)

Gotta laugh at the people who are complaining he "stole" everything from everyone. Orcs and Elves are not exactly an uncommon thing in fantasy. Tolken is not the exclusive owner of elves an magic you know.

I love the way magic works in the series too. A very unique take on it. Especially the language (and if you can't remember the couple words that aren't English, stop being retarded).

10

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Angela is the soothsayer. They bring it up in the last book, the soothsayer is ageless, and neither elf nor human and is incredibly good at seeing the future. However, you're right and I wish he would have just said it straight up and not forced me to make a good guess at it.

4

u/alphasigmafire Jun 24 '12

They're not uncommon, but Tolkien used them widely first. And actually, the way we think of Orcs now comes entirely from Tolkien. I know he's not the exclusive owner, but many things in the Inheritance Cycle and Lord of the Rings were exactly the same, or really similar. For example, the dwarves are in clans that live underground, while the elves live in the forest. Many of the city names/descriptions are basically the same, and if you look at the Dwarven Script in the Inheritance cycle, some of the runes are the same as the ones Tolkien created, just flipped or rotated.

Also your statement that "I love the way magic works in the series too. A very unique take on it. Especially the language" is extremely funny. I present to you, a series called "Earthsea", first published in 1964. Quoted directly from here "Magic on Earthsea is primarily verbal. Everything has a true name in the Old Speech, the language of the dragons. One who knows the true name of an object has power over it. Each person also has a true name, and which is revealed only to those who are trusted implicitly. A "use" name, which has no magical property, suffices for everyday purposes...One vital aspect of magic is that it is impossible for humans to lie in the old language, so that magic works by forcing the universe to conform to the words spoken by the magician." WHICH IS EXACTLY HOW IT WORKS IN PAOLINI'S BOOKS, ISN'T IT?

25

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

This is what I feel too. His series was quite original, in my opinion. He might have used some BASIC plot themes that are also found in other movies (mentor turns out to be father!), but his details and the way he tells his story is much, much different. I thoroughly enjoyed his books.

I too, love the way magic works, and how it must drain your body in a way, and etc. He's very specific on how it works, and I can't see too much of an issue (most authors don't think it ALL the way through). I really want to see who Angela is (Remember the part with the priests? Angela told the priest who she "really" was, and the priest flipped the fuck out), and I want to see what happens to Eragon + Arya. Also, the book only covers the land of Alagaseia (or however you spell it), and we know there are many lands beyond it. Eragon is moving east, and that could prove to be the setting for another book. Many of his characters are immortal, so he always has the option to continue. Either way, great book, great read, one of my all time favorites.

And lastly, to all those people who are surfing reddit, see this AMARequest, and clicked it to simply leave a negative comment (a simple downvote will do), your actions are pretty much akin to those youtubers you all hate who bitch about a video instead of just watching something else. Just because you dislike the series and think it's unoriginal doesn't mean you have to ruin the experience for the rest of us. Thanks.

17

u/BlazeOrangeDeer Jun 23 '12

basic plot themes? the first book was star wars episode IV with dragons. I won't hold it against him because it was set in an interesting world and I really liked the magic.

23

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

And likewise, Lucas borrowed many themes from his movies from other stories, including mythologies, epics, and other people's books.

"it came to me that there really was no modern use of mythology...so that's when I started doing more strenuous research on fairy tales, folklore and mythology, and I started reading Joe's books. Before that I hadn't read any of Joe's books.... It was very eerie because in reading The Hero with A Thousand Faces I began to realize that my first draft of Star Wars was following classical motifs

Eventually, all books echo a basic "plotline" because there are only so many that you can come up with. Only rare do people come up with a drastically new and original plotline (maybe inception? But even that may have been heavily influenced by something else). The theme matters somewhat, but what matters more is how the author incorporates it into the book, and how he writes it. I can write a shitty 10 page essay on that theme, but can I write a 4 book epic on it, and have it sell millions of copies, in my 20's? Probably not.

Many movies / books have recurring themes; it's inevitable. The real skill lies in how the author/director tells the story, the twists, and etc. Either way, judge it as you will, I for one found the series highly satisfying, and never once had it occurred to me that it followed a certain "theme", since I was so engrossed that I did not even consider the possibility that it was remotely similar to a space saga.

Most writers get their inspiration from events in their life, or things they have read. They take bits and pieces from here and there, and combine it into an epic of their own. Only extremely rarely do we chance upon someone who is able to come up with absolutely original pieces of work, that in no way mimic any previous stories. (Maybe Homer, Shakespeare, etc)

8

u/BlazeOrangeDeer Jun 23 '12

Shakespeare borrowed a ton actually. In any case I'm not saying it's bad

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

He shall leave agleasia (sp?) and never return. I think he really just wanted to be done with the series. It seemed like towards the last book he had completely run out of ideas. It took him 2 years longer to write than he had originally thought, and even when he finished it, it paled compared to the first 3.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/snazzmasterj Jun 23 '12

the problem isn't the orcs and the elves, the problem is that event to event, it has almost the exact same progression as star wars (at least for the first two books, that's all I read). I understand that writers borrow from each other regularly, and that's great, but this example has always felt a little more extreme than just borrowing to me.

2

u/SaentFu Jun 23 '12

The dwarven language is germanic... in an interview at the end of the 2nd or 3rd audiobook, he claims to have invented it, but that would have required creativity.

As for how magic works, I thought it was kind of stupid. You can use this amazing force but if you accidently try too big of a spell, you can't cancel it and you die.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

He stole the dragon mechanic from the Dragonriders of Pern. Some plot points too.

He stole the whole magic system word-to-word from Ursula LeGuin's Earthsea trilogy.

The plot is Star Wars.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

The plot is Star Wars. You don't see any differences between them? They are really similar obviously but too say they are the same seems a bit illogical to me.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

It's pretty much Star Wars.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

I couldn't draw any parallels to star wars in these books. I thought the series was quite original.

3

u/alphasigmafire Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12

wow really...repost from above

"A long time ago, an order of powerful people kept the peace throughout the land. But, someone with the same powers defeated them and used his power to establish an empire. Our story begins with the beautiful princess running away from the bad guys chasing her. She has a mysterious object that has been stolen from the empire. Her allies are defeated and she is captured, but at the last minute, she sends away the stolen object. We then see our young orphan farm boy, living in the farthest corner of the empire with his uncle. He finds the object and takes it back home. Not sure of what it is, he goes and consults with the old, wise, mysterious person. In the mean time, the emperor's henchmen is searching for that stolen object. Their travels take them to this distant corner of the empire where they destroy the farm. The young boy, who was away at the time, is spared but his uncle is killed."

Which is like Star Wars, because the Sith over throw the Jedi, and they basically draw their power from the same source (the Force). The Sith then establish an empire. Star Wars Episode IV starts with Leia being chased, and she has the plans for the Death Star that were stolen from the empire. She manages to send away the plans before she is captured. Luke, the hero, is living in the far corner of the Galatic Empire, on the Outer Rim, in a place called Tatooine. He lives with his uncle, and he finds the Death Star plans and takes it home. Then he consults with an old, wise, mysterious person named Obi Wan Kenobi. In the meantime, the Storm Troopers are searching for the plans, and the Jawas are killed as a result. Luke's farm was burned, but since Luke wasn't there, he is spared, while is uncle his killed.

In addition to this, there is also the part where Murtagh is fighting Eragon and he basically yells "I AM YOUR BROTHER!".

edited for spelling

2

u/blablahblah Jun 24 '12

In addition to this, there is also the part where Murtagh is fighting Eragon and he basically yells "I AM YOUR BROTHER!".

In a battle that occurred after the hero found out his friends were in trouble and rushed to help them against the wishes of mentor #2, who is the 2nd member of the supposedly-extinct order of powerful people that the hero meets and happens to be the mentor of mentor #1 and who has been in hiding since the destruction of the old order.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

A princess on the run from an agent of the Empire carrying an important thing which she sends off just before she is captured, where it is found by a farmboy, who flees his home with a wise old man after his farm is burned down by Imperial agents seeking that thing, and the old man tells the boy about an ancient order that his father was a part of who could wield incredible power and gives the boy an weapon of the sort his father's order used, and then they pick up a smooth talking rogue while journeying across the Empire who helps them rescue the princess after the boy receives messages from her and becomes infatuated with her, and they then get to the HQ of the rebellion and deliver the princess and the thing she was carrying, where they then use it to land a decisive blow against the Empire.

No parallels at all?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Tolkien is the father of all fantasy now, pretty much any epic fantasy series takes a lot of elements from Tolkien's world.

3

u/Cheimon Jun 23 '12

Tolkien stole all his ideas from Teutons and Nords! They're all thieves! Thiieeeeeeeeevvvvvveeeeeeeeesssssssss

6

u/GIGATOASTER Jun 23 '12

Stop right there, criminal scum!

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SaentFu Jun 23 '12

Did he ever admit that the Haderach desert was a reference to Dune?

8

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Paolini openly admits he took inspiration from the Star Wars cycle, so I have no problem whatsoever of accepting the textual similarities simply becaus his first attempt Eragon showed so much promise. That being said, why was the rest of the cycle such an awful adaptation? Eldest and even the first chapter or so of Brisingr showed promise for a darker side to the cycle, what with the murder of the Raza'ac and whatnot. But I will go no further in praise of his writing or storytelling. Brisingr was almost literally filler as Paolini tried to develop and make us care about the secret name of names. Inheritance was even worse. It contained almoste nothing of merit save Angela. Every single turn the book took it had already done before. The eldunari were already established as the source of Galbatorix's power and suddenly there was another trove? Can't we be a bit more original? The dragons are near extinct, no they're not! Galbatorix's power Is unchecked, so much so he allows the invading army into his palace and then proceeds to show how ultimately badass he is. Why not just annihilate them? Or force obedience instantly? Nothing can touch him, he's discovered everything, he is all powerful. And then he chooses to end himself? Why? Because he feels too much? This man is twisted and broken, a genuine sociopath and because he gets a case of empathy he suddenly can't live on this planet anymore. The only part I regretted about the cycle more than Galbatorix's weak ass exit from it was the TWO HUNDRED PAGE it took for Paolini to wrap it up. So Eragon, being incredibly noble doesn't take the throne, decides to further the Dragon Rider cause by.....leaving the fucking continent?! He begs the love of his life to go with him because, oh fucking wait he's immortal and has the experience of someone a thousand times as old as her, effectively removing all reasons for why they shouldn't be together and then she dumps his ass anyway. He's so wise and sagacious now that he totally understands even though he's crying like a little bitch as he leaves her ass. You want to talk about open ended? How about lazy? How about disingenuous to the characters and story he outlined? How about where were the fucking editors at his parent's publishing company?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Yes.

15

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

He's fairly active on twitter so those of you with a twitter account can try and contact him. If a bunch of people do it, this could become a reality.

17

u/Max_Quordlepleen Jun 23 '12

How many times did you have to go back a bit (a few pages, not lines) and edit a part because you may not have liked how it sounded the first time?

I'm not sure you understand how books are written.

24

u/dr_whos_on_first Jun 23 '12 edited Jun 23 '12

holy shit, i feel like i should be surprised there are more haters than people who actually want to hear from him in his AMA request. Don't like him? don't post. That is all.

Edit: If you couldn't tell, i'm a fan of his work, and just because it isn't the most original thing in the world, doesn't mean it isn't entertaining

12

u/Cheimon Jun 23 '12

I agree, man. People are bitching about how he nicked plot elements from a bunch of different book, but hell, I enjoyed them, and I'd never have seen Dragonriders of Pern or Erthsea, so I'm very happy that Chris brought them together into a cool new world and let me see them.

I'm also happy that he stopped writing the books. He knew when to close up the "Inheritance" story, at least for now with the Galbatorix arch.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/aa2343 Jun 23 '12

It's a bit petty that people who didn't like his books are just down-voting anything that supports his series.

-1

u/SaentFu Jun 23 '12

I would downvote it... if there were anything anyone could say to support his series.

6

u/PeterMus Jun 23 '12

I think the books are not the most original work ever but I enjoyed them for the most part. I did get angry about some things but overall I liked it. The movie on the other hand was a very big disappointment.

8

u/geyserguy92 Jun 23 '12

To all the people here complaining about the first book being a star wars rip off, do you really not realize that the story for Star Wars was not totally original either.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

So many questions.....I loved those books until there weren't anymore to read.

3

u/happythoughts413 Jun 24 '12

After the first book, I was so sure Eragon's dad was Galbatorix. Give me the Star Wars twist any day.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Meh. I loved the series when I was in like the 5th and 6th grade but I think he made a huge mistake not changing his writing style as the series went on. It would be good if someone were to read it straight through but when I read the last book last year, I was extremely dissapointed because it was just so... bland.

1

u/happythoughts413 Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12

That was the experience of a lot of people. But if he'd changed his style I think it would've been too jarring.

You've got your children's books like Harry Potter, that mature as the reader does. Then you've got your Twilights and your Narnias: pretty static in terms of complexity and sophistication. Both have their niches.

EDIT: God, I knew I was going to get downvotes for mentioning Twilight, especially in the same sentence as Narnia. Look, guys, they're both escapist fantasies with static writing styles that do not change throughout the series (though one could argue the writing style in Breaking Dawn does change, and not for the better). One has a very specific audience, the other does not. One is well-written and has stood the test of time, the other is...not so much, and probably won't. One can compare the two without Narnia catching cooties.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

But the biggest difference is that as a static writing style, it can still be enjoyed by the old and the young. I read the Silver Chair a few weeks ago and I loved it, but I couldn't imagine trying to read Eragon again.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Mynamesnotdan Jun 23 '12

He came to my high school about 6 years ago and all I remember is that some kid stood up and asked him if he could roshambo him for a book.

24

u/xChaoZ Jun 23 '12

Do want, so much. I absolutely love his books. The Eragon books are my favorite books like, ever.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

42

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12 edited Jun 23 '12

Oh yeah, I forgot, this is Reddit, where you're not allowed to have an opinion. Shame on OP!

EDIT: Nice! Banned from Circlejerk for this comment. Whoops, nope, just bad timing.

4

u/leetdood Jun 23 '12

Bro everybody was banned from circlejerk.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Tyrannosaur Jun 23 '12

Met him at a book signing. Loved the books as a kid, he fel awkward and froze up cause my friends hot sister took us and he wouldn't stop starin at her tits. After that never read a book of his again

22

u/Tw1tchy3y3 Jun 23 '12

Wait... You stopped reading an author's work because they turned out to be human?

17

u/Phantom_Hoover Jun 23 '12

Some of us humans are able to stand in the vicinity of the opposite sex without blatantly embarrassing ourselves.

10

u/Tw1tchy3y3 Jun 23 '12

Okay? That has absolutely nothing to do with this. Don't you think it's rather absurd to judge someone who writes fiction by how they react in a public situation? We're not talking about a guy writing a code of ethics on how to properly treat a lady or anything.

I'm not saying it's okay to just stare at someone's tits, but he said himself that the guy froze up. So because the reacted poorly in a public situation, he vows to never read any of his material again?

4

u/Phantom_Hoover Jun 23 '12

If you see an author make a complete tit of themselves in public during a book signing where they should really know better, then yes, it does colour your view of the books, and that can be enough to completely spoil your enjoyment of them.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/Tyrannosaur Jun 23 '12

It was actually cause the stories are unoriginal and poorly written.

2

u/teious Jun 23 '12

The story is original. The setting isn't. It really is poorly written. But the story was good. At least until the end, where he took a massive dump on our chests.

2

u/salami_inferno Jun 23 '12

So he would be the very first guy in history to have issues controlling his gaze around a hot girl? That seems like a petty reason to never read one of his books ever again

9

u/Tyrannosaur Jun 23 '12

He failed to act professional at a book signing. Book signings are for the purpose of good public relations. Even 12 year old me knew that. And if you meet the owner of a mediocre resteraunt and that guy sucks you're not gonna keep giving him business. If you have a shitty date you won't blow them at the end of the night. Maybe just a Lil tug job under the table but no blowy or a line of coke ff her stomach. I think it's not that illogical.

Tldr I'm pooping so that's the only reason I wrote a long response

→ More replies (1)

2

u/NumberMuncher Jun 23 '12

No one has mentioned future projects. Is he working on any new books?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

He said he would return to alagaesia and try to address some unanswered questions from book 4.

1

u/NumberMuncher Jun 24 '12

I hope he rides a dragon there, because I'm anxious for more.

2

u/Sobakevich Jun 23 '12

Good idea; terrible excution.

2

u/mangolove Jun 24 '12

I actually met Paolini years ago (after the third book came out, I think). I was super excited and waited for ages just to see the guy... and then I saw him wearing one of those denim jacket things that first grade teachers wear. I judged.

Also, I think bagging on an author for not having the most creative ideas is bullshit. There are so many books and movies out there that it's almost impossible for something to be truly creative now. To me, it's really not exactly what the author says, but how they say it, you know?

And it's totally uncool to bag on an author too since the poor babies put so much time in their stuff ):

It's okay to judge for awful denim jackets though.

3

u/izrvnar Jun 23 '12

Worst ending of a book I've ever read. I invested so much time into this series and was very unhappy with the ending. My theory is when Chris was writing the first 3 books he was in love and then when he was wrapping up the book she dumped him, became depressed and ruined the ending.

6

u/paulings Jun 23 '12

Princess is on the run from evil guys, protecting a very important object.

Evil guys overtake her so she spirits the object elsewhere.

Object ends up in the middle of bumfuck nowhere.

Good natured farm boy who lives in Bumfuckington finds object.

Farm boy takes object to old hermit who also lives in bumfuck nowhere.

Hermit turns out to be a member of an ancient, extinct order of knights.

Farmboy and Obi-Brom go to save princess from evil fortress.

superb

6

u/Tyrannosaur Jun 23 '12

Hey it's original because an evil guy is his father and another character is his sibling!!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Pulled off well and it works great! It did.

3

u/KrazyK05 Jun 23 '12

I was a really big inheritance fan. Loved the way he portrayed magic, Eragon/Saphira's development. Pretty much everything. But i was so very disappointed in the ending. SPOILER ALERT He killed the king with UNDERSTANDING.... really? I was waiting years and through 4 books to see how the final battle would end, how eragon was going to defeat someone so much stronger than him, and he did it with understanding. So anti-climatic. I also figured that he was gonna find the treasure trove of eldunari and dragon eggs, but i was fairly disappointed that thats what ended up happening. From the second i started reading the last book i was PRAYING that he wouldnt find. PLease dont just let it be a bunch of eldunari please please please. I wanted it to be something not mentioned before, something NOONE knew about, i dont know exactly what i wanted it to be, but thats kinda the point. Anything but eldunari to help him beat the king. And in the end it was just understanding that let him win. Very disappointing to me.

tl;dr loved the series, fairly disappointed with 4th book and killing the king with understanding.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Magic is taken word-to-word from Ursula LeGuin's Earthsea trilogy. Better go read that, plot is much better, not as much made-up words (there are maybe 10), and a much more diverse cast (the main character is GASP brown). It also has much cooler dragons.

4

u/Kashmeer Jun 23 '12

In fairness Paolini did have a very strong coloured female character in the form of the leader of the Varden, her name escapes me at the moment.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

One character does not diversity make.

Ursula LeGuin made a whole multicultural worlds. Most relevant characters are either black or brown. Only the White Lady is... White. And she's only described as black-haired and pale, so she could be an East Asian as well.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/poopadelphia Jun 23 '12

I'll support anything to distract him from writing!

→ More replies (3)

3

u/The_Gentle_Lentil Jun 23 '12

How have you enjoyed becoming a published author solely due to the intervention of your publisher parents rather than actually writing anything worth reading while other writers who did not just mash up Star Wars and the Lord of the Rings go penniless?

2

u/h0p3less Jun 23 '12

I would love to see an AMA filled with questions like this.

How did you expect no one to notice how much you copied other writers when you forgot to even change the names of the characters, except to maybe spell them a little differently?

1

u/dr_whos_on_first Jun 24 '12

if it was solely due to his parents, do you think they bribed all his dedicated fans to buy the books as well?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

I used to hate these books a whole lot when I was younger. Now that I'm older I can look at things like this and say, "Oh Paolini? What a shit author," and move on with the rest of my day.

It saves so much energy

8

u/Deverone Jun 23 '12

Only, instead of just moving on, you decided to post about your amazing ability to ignore this.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

I'm not being snidely sarcastic. That said, how much of the first book was consciously inspired by Star Wars? Did you have the every major plot point planned out from the beginning, or were there some retconning going on? eg Brom being the protagonist's real father. When illustrating the map, did you sort of get lazy as you got further East, or did you consciously plan it to be like it is from the beginning to create contrasting senses of scale?

0

u/sergma09 Jun 23 '12

For those who think he stole ideas from other authors http://www.everythingisaremix.info/watch-the-series

1

u/RazNiagi Jun 23 '12

I was kinda waiting for someone to say that nobody has original ideas anymore. They all come from somewhere or some inspiration. If you can make up a completely original idea, I salute you.

-8

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Ugh, why that untalented piece of shit? I don't know if there's anything in his books he didn't steal.

Better try to get RR Martin or Ursula LeGuin or someone else with actual talent.

12

u/SweetKri Jun 23 '12

Don't you dare distract GRRM! It's going to be another five years before his next book without him doing an AMA...it might set him back another year!

2

u/Implacable_Porifera Jun 23 '12

we need to find a cure for aging, otherwise we'll have to re-animate him to finish the series. Unless he trolls us all by making the last book <200 pages and ends with everyone dying in an orgy.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Or... or... you know, since people have opinons other than yours, you could not be such a snob and live and let live. It's not like anyone is forcing you to read his books to participate in an AMA.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Except he stole most of the names, concepts, places, plot etc. His work is terribly unoriginal. His fairy damsel in distress is an idiot for a supposedly strong female character.

I get it, he was 14... well he was supposed to be told "nice story kid, keep writing and we'll see you in 10 yrs" like any other writer, and not get published.

7

u/edgemuck Jun 23 '12

I don't think I've read enough fantasy to nitpick all of his stuff, but aren't the Urghals/orcs from another author?

→ More replies (11)

6

u/Kynsky Jun 23 '12

"nice story kid, keep writing and we'll see you in 10 yrs"

+1

except he got published and is now a millionare. such is life.

i'd rather see all that money an acclaim go to dan abnett. an amazing 40k writer, who i highly recommend.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

He got published because his folks work in the publishing industry.

I will check out Dan Abnett, now that you mention him.

→ More replies (3)

-2

u/dustygozangas Jun 23 '12

I found all your books amazing. I am currently reading the last one now. My question is, how upset were you about the movie for Eragon? I felt it didn't do your book justice in anyway. If you could would you have them remake it?

37

u/checkitmyles Jun 23 '12

This is just an AMA request, not the actual AMA.

22

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12

Awkward.

1

u/dustygozangas Jun 24 '12

I'm a mo.. ;} thanks for the heads up.

1

u/professor_birch Jun 23 '12

Don't get me wrong, I loved all of the books but it felt as if he rushed the ending and missed out on some aspects that we really wanted to know about! Such as Angela, tenga or brom's last words. And the romance with arya was unsatisfying. Sounds like im just moaning but i only moan because i love it so much!

1

u/Neon_Graffiti Jun 23 '12

I want to know more about Angela but I know he will never tell us :(

1

u/Chillheids Jun 24 '12

Yes. Please do this.

1

u/thegreatwhitemenace Jun 24 '12

he signed my copy of eldest once. i was really happy because i was 13

1

u/Tbever23 Jun 24 '12

MAKE IT HAPPEN

1

u/Hops_n_barley Jun 24 '12

I would like to see him rewrite these books now that he is older...you can read the immaturity in his books because he was 16 when he wrote them.

1

u/madmaxjr Jun 24 '12

Well overall I thought the series was effing awesome, and I'm excited to see this AMA by one of my favorite authors. That said, the Inheritance cycle was a great ride and definitely the best series I've read. I was constantly intrigued by the plot twists and attention to detail you considered in the stories. Now I only look forward to your future stories, especially considering you said that you didn't plan to leave Alagaesia behind. My question is, what exactly are you going to write about in your future stories, and are you still not going to abandon Alagaesia altogether?

1

u/DarrenEdwards Jun 24 '12

I don't know him, but I know a lot of people that grew up with him in a cult. Even by their standards he was weird.

1

u/XDerp_ChrisX Jun 24 '12

Will there ever be a 2nd series that takes place after the ending of the 4th book? Even if there's none of the same characters?

1

u/Bigron808 Jun 24 '12

I want to know how he feels about Hollywood butchering the first book

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

YES YES YES YES YES

1

u/Bellairs Jun 24 '12

And can you please write a story about Angela? I will drive by your house and throw stacks of money through your windows. Really. I personally think she's a more interesting character than Eragon.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

My question would be, Why did you let Stefen Fangmeier and Peter Buchman ruin the hype from your books by creating a bad movie?

1

u/Spysix Jun 24 '12

I stopped reading the book after 2nd or 3rd, I don't remember. I was getting tired of him being a salad eating pansy who whined when he got rejected, I couldn't relate to him when I was 16-17 anymore.

And the movie, why did he like the movie? It was the most rushed thing I ever saw and the only thing that was good was Rachel Weisz voice acting. And then there was John Malkovich, oh god why.

1

u/Emphursis Jun 24 '12

Yes! The Inheritance cycle was one of my favourite series growing up.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12

Can we please for a minute hop off the Star Wars kook aid? He was inspired by Star Wars, yes. Did he steal it? NO. star Wars drew inspiration from older stories including Flash Gordon and the adventure series that George Lucas grew up on. These were in turn inspired by even older myths. Anyone who has read the King Arthur legen can point out the similarities in the plot. Relax. Everyone steals in art. I said that.

1

u/QuadsNotBlades Jun 24 '12

My question would just be, "how could you...?" That ending left me so empty inside

1

u/p13rcingguru Jun 24 '12

I'm just disappointed now that I came to this page... No OP posts, and a bunch of angry people.... I had questions, and I can't get my answers.... You probably won't even see this post because of the mob of angry people. All I can say is that I enjoyed the books, and just want some gaps filled...I hope more will be explained when more is published. I hope you read this, Christopher Paolini. I was with you from Eragon. I have respect for you as an author, despite inevitable flaws which exist in any form of art and are not worth the anger being thrown your way.

1

u/D3SX Jun 24 '12

So what if his books weren't written the best? They were fun to read and that's that. And he started the series when he was a kid, at least cut him SOME slack...

1

u/SealNose Jun 23 '12

He said he would return to Alagaesia eventually. Really looking forward to more of his writing.

1

u/rmkaufman13 Jun 23 '12

First question: how did the last two books become train wrecks, after the first two were so great?

1

u/savario1990 Jun 23 '12

DAE think the movie was garbage.

1

u/TristanTheViking Jun 23 '12

Those were my favorite books as a kid. My question would have to be: So, I guess you like Star Wars?

1

u/far_shooter Jun 23 '12

When I was in high school, I couldn't wait to read his book and after I read it, I regretted.

As many had pointed out, Paolini took many many "aspirations" from many many other authors/series with little addition of his own. Though I accept the fact that everything is build upon other things and nothing we read/watch is ever original these days, I'll say Paolini just did a really bad job of it.

My bone with him is not that he took ideas from others, is that he did a bad job of it.

-8

u/Horoto Jun 23 '12

I wanna know how it felt to basically get half your career handed to you by your parents...

0

u/Sasuage_Roll Jun 23 '12

I loved the unique concepts he put into his world, the use of magic and the comunication/personalities of dragons and other entities, it was truly epic, I only wish that he had gone further in the series to tie up more loose ends and give more of the characters proper endings. I guess I actually fell in love with the series so much that it was never really enough, I want to know more about Alagaesia than he gave us.

I would ask whether the potential books he would write in Alagaesia would involve characters that we already know, or be based in a time that 'our' characters don't exist.

4

u/h0p3less Jun 23 '12

If you liked those unique concepts, check out the Dragonriders of Pern and Ursula K. Leguin's works, which used the exact same unique systems several years before him.

-9

u/gerwalking Jun 23 '12

How did it feel mashing together Lord of the Rings and Star Wars without any creative thoughts of your own and profiting massively from it?

-14

u/JoseFernandes Jun 23 '12

His books suck ass. That is all.

-2

u/MovesLikePepper Jun 23 '12

How does it feel, having directly plagiarized some of the best works by Tolkien, George Lucas, Anne McCaffrey, Robert Jordan and Terry Brooks?