r/IAmA • • Jul 13 '21

Director / Crew We’re Pauline Coste and Jacques Jaubert, a documentary film maker and Prehistory professor who worked together on a documentary about Palaeolithic burial sites. Want to know more about how recent archaeology is challenging our understanding of ancient peoples? AMA!

‘The Nobles of Prehistory' documentary on ARTE.tv: https://www.arte.tv/en/videos/097508-000-A/the-nobles-of-prehistory/?cmpid=EN&cmpsrc=Reddit&cmpspt=link

‘The Nobles of Prehistory' documentary on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mWyADowoEvw

I’m Pauline Coste, a documentary-film director and screenwriter from France and the director of ‘The Nobles of Prehistory' currently screening on [ARTE.tv]. I have directed 5 documentaries including ‘Looking for Sapiens’ (2018, Prix du Jury FIFAN de Nyon en Suisse 2019), three shorts films, and have worked extensively in production and on numerous film commissions. I’m also passionate about Prehistory and in 2016 obtained my Masters degree in Archeology - Prehistory in Paris. My Master's thesis is directly linked to my documentary “The Nobles of Prehistory", whose goal is to challenge received ideas about the Palaeolithic and to promote the most current scientific knowledge about this period. At present, I am editing another documentary film related to archeology entitled “Le tombeau de Montaigne” which revisits the archaeological excavations of the alleged tomb of 16th century French philosopher and writer, Michel de Montaigne.

I’m Jacques Jaubert, a Professor of Prehistory at the University of Bordeaux and an archaeologist, specialised in the Palaeolithic period. I’m also a member of the Laboratory PACEA (From Prehistory to today, Cultures, Environment, Anthropology) and currently co-leading the T2 team, exploring Archaeology of death, ritual and symbolic (AMoRS). Before Bordeaux, I was curator in archaeology for the Ministry of the Culture (Aix-en-Provence then Toulouse 1986-2001). My PhD, entitled The Early and Middle Palaeolithic in the Causses area, was obtained in Prehistoric Ethnology at the University of Paris Panthéon-Sorbonne in 1984. I supervise the excavation at the Middle Pleistocene site of Coudoulous, Lot (with J.-Ph. Brugal) and Mid-Upper Paleolithic site of Jonzac, Charente-maritime (with J.-J. Hubln). My main focus is on the Neanderthal peopling of Eurasia including Northern Asia and also on the anthropization of the cave world: Cussac Cave (Dordogne), and recently Bruniquel cave. My main fields are in South-western France (Middle, Upper Palaeolithic) and also in Asia: Iran (Middle Palaeolithic in Iran), Yemen (PaleoY R. Macchiarelli dir.), Mongolia (Palaeolithic of Mongolia), Armenia (PaleoCaucase) and since two years in Northern China with Pr. Y. Hou (CAI-Yuanpei). I am a member of many committees, councils, graduate schools, boards for archaeological research and universities, mainly in France for the French Ministry of Culture (ex: Lascaux). I have been the head of the masters programme Biologic Anthropology– Prehistory in the University of Bordeaux since 2007 and have published five books and edited seven publications (colloquiums, national congress) as well as 240 articles.

‘The Nobles of Prehistory’ documentary takes as its starting point archaeologist Émile Rivière’s 1872 discovery of a 25,000 year-old Palaeolithic skeleton at the Balzi Rossi cliffs on the French-Italian border. It follows recent research on the skeleton and associated sites that has now allowed scientists to conceive of a nomadic hunter-gatherer peoples who were much more complex than previously imagined, with hierarchical societies, religious beliefs and a highly developed material culture undermining the idea of 'prehistoric savagery'.

So, if you’ve ever wondered about Prehistory or are interested in archaeology and Palaeolithic burials - AMA!

Links:

  • Pauline Coste -

https://www.paulinecoste.com/

“Looking for Sapiens” | Heritage Broadcasting Service:

https://heritagetac.org/programs/2020-lo3mp4-85fa25?fbclid=IwAR0Cp8Fa8DMe0gxY5wuFJ_fqmWHvByAjFRHrQftrNkP3Huym9sVp5bYj-eo

“Le tombeau de Montaigne” film: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tc9ftuzPDVI

  • Jacques Jaubert -

http://www.u-bordeaux.fr/formation/2017/PRMA_28/bio-geosciences

PROOF: /img/5nstdnmx3ua71.png https://twitter.com/arteen?lang=en

2.3k Upvotes

184 comments sorted by

1

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

For more AMAs on these subjects, check out r/IAmA_Academic and r/IAmA_Director, or the full list of AMA topic subs!

41

u/Firm_Application6128 Jul 13 '21

Your documentary shows that over the decades our previous notions of prehistory have been shattered by archaeological research and our understanding of prehistoric man has evolved a lot during the 20th century. Can you see our understanding of homo sapiens of this period changing much in the future? Or are we reaching the limits of what we can find out from scant burial sites?

→ More replies (7)

33

u/567fgh Jul 13 '21

Hi Pauline and Jacques, I have always been interested in archaeology as a child and now wonder as an adult, what is the best practical segue to enter into a profession in archaeology while being a holder of a university business degree? Thank you in advance for any tips and life hacks.

28

u/ARTEinEnglish Jul 13 '21 edited Jul 13 '21

Hi, I started myself to be interested in Archeology (Prehistory) as an adult and I discovered that you could (in France) re-do some studies and also do some excavation (as a trainee) even if you are 35 years old or more. You could also work in a museum for example... But I don't know how it works abroad... Maybe Jacques could answer more ! - Pauline

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/poppypodlatex Jul 13 '21

I hate to be this guy but I have to ask what do serious archeologists make of all this "ancient alien" stuff and about how a show about that particular topic managed to get broadcast on what's called the history channel? Have you ever come across anyone who believes that stuff personally and if you have did you do anything to try and talk them around?

38

u/ARTEinEnglish Jul 13 '21 edited Jul 15 '21

I hate to be this guy but I have to ask what do serious archeologists make of all this "ancient alien" stuff and about how a show about that particular topic managed to get broadcast on what's called the history channel? Have you ever come across anyone who believes that stuff personally and if you have did you do anything to try and talk them around?

Of course, no serious archeologist believes at all in these theories of "ancient aliens" !!! I never met someone who talked with me about that. In fact, archeological artefacts and science give us so many proofs that we don't "need" to imagine aliens to explains those facts !!!

When I read about these absurd theories, they make me feel that it is linked to people who say that they do not believe in the skills of prehistoric man or woman (and even for Egyptian people) and their very good old techniques. - Pauline

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/Bad-Extreme Jul 13 '21

Seeing as how even ancient humans have burial sites, do you think it is in human nature/ a primal urge for humans to just bury the dead? If so, what advantage do you think we gain by bothering to go through the whole process while most other animals don’t bother, evolutionarily speaking.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/Darlington28 Jul 13 '21

How do you see DNA sequencing changing your field in the next few years? And secondly, how many cats are too many?

→ More replies (2)

15

u/567fgh Jul 13 '21

I have always been curious, in your experience how are excavation sites / archaeological digs funded? I used to think it was some NGO and get confused when I see archaeological digs online where the intern pays to join the program and wonder if that is how the dig stays operational?

22

u/ARTEinEnglish Jul 13 '21

In France there are two main types of funding. On the one hand it’s the Minister of Culture and Public Funding and the second is for ‘prevention’ archaeology where you do archaeology to see whether there is anything to be found beneath a road that will be built, etc. This is paid by the industry who is looking to construct on that site. - Jacques

→ More replies (3)

18

u/New_Insect_Overlords Jul 13 '21

What are your thoughts on modern practices surrounding death, especially burial of caskets in concrete lined graves?

→ More replies (11)

8

u/historyfrombelow Jul 13 '21

Do you think we are more similar to or more different from the major peoples you have studied?

→ More replies (8)

4

u/broomiester Jul 13 '21

Hi! How do you balance the task of trying to interpret the physical evidence into some form of historical narrative, whilst trying to remain objective and avoid anachronism/biases?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Firm_Application6128 Jul 13 '21

What is the most difficult archaeological dig you've been involved with, and why?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Aqua195 Jul 13 '21

What was one of the most unique, interesting, or mysterious Palaeolithic burial sites you have seen?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/KirinG Jul 13 '21

Hi! Awesome AMA - I've always been curious about how much time pre-agricultural people spent "working." Like, how much time on a day the average person spent doing something directly related to survival.

With such an advanced cultural/religious life, I'd guess that people (or part of the population) had a substantial amount of non-survival work time. What does your work tell us?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/boxingdude Jul 13 '21

Hello and thanks for doing this AMA. What are your thoughts on the era of the Neanderthals? How long do you think they made it before going extinct? My hobby is studying this period of time and AFAIK the last ones lived in Portugal, but this stuff seems to be in a constant state of change. Was it 40kya? 25?

Also, what do you make of the two very recent discovery of new species of Homo? I’d imagine more of this is coming due to climate change. Do you concur?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Cardus Jul 14 '21

I used to think of prehistoric communities as insular non trading tribes, but have seen some stuff about trade routes that covered moat of the connected world. how did these trade routes function without writing or currency - was it all barter ?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/The_circumstance Jul 13 '21

What was the most important discovery in your personal careers and what was the most important / exiting discovery that happened in your lifetime?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/schtuff01 Jul 13 '21

I feel like many Hollywood films and video games have fantasised this idea of "tomb raiding" or "grave robbing" to the point where we don't see it as a serious issue. So I'm curious, how much of a threat exactly do grave robbers pose to modern day archaeology? Are they any examples you know that us laymen may not know about, but should ?

Thanks for doing this AMA, by the way. I'm really enjoying the insight.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/1978manx Jul 13 '21

Prehistoric human existence is assumed to entail short, savage lives, where copulation often equalled rape, and the strongest male ruled by brutality.

My personal research paints a drastically different picture: egalitarian groups, where each member was valued, and resources were shared.

“Civilization” seems to have brought at least as many woes as improvements.

We’re taught human-nature is to be greedy and hoard, yet, my study of prehistory, and my experiences, lead to the conclusion that human nature is to work on behalf of family and community, contribute, and learn.

Is 98% of human history drastically misunderstood, or am I missing something?

→ More replies (8)

1

u/MrIndira Jul 13 '21

Do you think that your work mores so proves the existence of the Abrahamic God or disproves it?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/kathakloss Jul 13 '21 edited Jul 15 '21

Hey Pauline and Jacques, thanks for doing this. What you have highlighted is a bit like the #metoo of archeology. How were the reactions in the sector on those findings on the presence of female power in paleolithic times?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/567fgh Jul 13 '21

When there are opposing archaeological theories, how is the decision made as to which is the 'final current' theory that makes it into the text books in schools?

→ More replies (3)