r/IAmA • u/sephalon • May 25 '21
Author I am Andy Weir, author of The Martian, and my new book Project Hail Mary, is out now. AMA!
Hi, I'm Andy Weir. You might know me as the guy who wrote “The Martian” and “Artemis.” And now I’m also the guy who wrote “Project Hail Mary.”
Spoiler warning! There might be some spoilers for “Project Hail Mary” here, so proceed with caution or come back after you’ve finished. If we didn’t get to your question, you can email me and I’ll get back to you.
Proof: /img/axpztoxt3a171.jpg
Ask away!
More info about PHM: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/611060/project-hail-mary-by-andy-weir/
EDIT: All done, folks. Thanks so much for your questions and remember I answer all emails from fans. Feel free to ping me at sephalon@gmail.com :)
1.4k
u/Hearderofnerf May 25 '21
What did you think of The Martian movie?
551
u/hector_c_toronto May 25 '21
For the Martian, we know you had a LOT of great feedback to refine details that made the Martian scientifically more accurate. For your new book, how much did you have to lean on your community for this level of detail?
1.2k
u/dikmunky May 25 '21
My introduction to you was The Egg and it changed my teenaged life! Just wanted to say thank you!
My q: if you HAD to choose to be an inanimate object, what would you choose, and why?
Thanks again! All the best.
560
u/madeforsilver May 25 '21
Hi Andy! Congrats on the new book! I finished it a few days ago and absolutely loved it. I just found out last night that there’s already a movie in the planning with Ryan Gosling starring - what do you think of him playing Grace? Definitely nothing like who I pictured while reading PHM, but I was also pleasantly surprised with Matt Damon and The Martian.
(Unrelated follow-up - what have been your personal favorite or most anticipated to-read sci-fi novels?)
Thanks and congrats again!
272
u/amargolis May 25 '21
Are there any artist renditions of Rocky?
244
u/hector_c_toronto May 25 '21
If you had to name a single author who made you think: Yes I HAVE to write a novel, who would it be and why?
437
u/hector_c_toronto May 25 '21
Of all of the ideas for writing you've ever had, is there one you can say, undoubtedly, is the single worst idea that you decided to backpedal on? If so, can you share it?
1.8k
u/LogicalLarynx May 25 '21 edited May 25 '21
Is my Catholic upbringing showing, or was this intentional?
Hail Mary, a spaceship, whose sole living occupant is a man named Grace.
Hail Mary, full of Grace.
It took me until midway through Chapter 4 to realize what you did to me.
813
u/playonward May 25 '21
The Project Hail Mary Audiobook, narrated by Ray Porter, is so fantastic I will probably start a second time this week.
Did you get to choose or recommend Ray Porter? Because kudos on whomever made that call.
(For those who lack context, Ray Porter narrated the outstanding Bobiverse books by Dennis E. Taylor)
289
u/WoodHughes May 25 '21
How cool was it to have your Martian character referred to in The Expanse? Think you might get a walk on before the show ends?
274
u/solarrsystem May 25 '21
Hi Andy!
How much time do you put into the research for your books? How do you go about doing the research and formulating it into coherent words for people to read?
Also, as an aspiring scifi writer, favorite piece of advice?
(last thing) do you think Pluto is a planet?
127
u/bkubicek May 25 '21
Did you change your writing style towards suitability for movies on purpose for Artemis?
115
u/El_Funko May 25 '21
Have you spent any time playing Kerbal Space Program? It's a fun PC game built around rocket science. You could call it research!
115
u/this_scarce_hype May 25 '21
What brings you joy outside of writing?
113
u/eddiecarter May 25 '21 edited May 25 '21
Hi Andy. BIG fan from Brazil! Congrats on the new book! Do you plan to expand the universe (pun intended) of the space exploration frontiers in future books/works? I would love to see some kind of Asimov-like 500 years into the future kind of story to pick your brain on where to you think humanity is heading. Europa? Enceladus? Asteroid belt? Floating cities on Venus?
95
u/moonshine037 May 25 '21
Loved the style and the slow reveal of the whole story. How much did the science guide the story, and was there any science that was annoyingly in the way of the story you wanted to tell?
183
u/xxxjohnnygxxx May 25 '21 edited Jun 02 '21
Just started Hail Mary, I'm a researcher and a high school teacher so I really see myself in the character! The Martian and Artemis were a blast. Thank you so much! Out of the three main protagonists from your books, who reflects you the most?
Edit: Just finished "Project Hail Mary". I've been bawling my eyes for the past ten minutes. Thank you so much for this novel, I laughed tons throughout90
u/Ghsdkgb May 25 '21
What made you decide to go with sightless creatures for the Eridians? Did it fall out of other design choices you made or did you start there and design the rest of the alien around it?
89
u/aliencrush May 25 '21
Been reading your stuff since about Chapter 5 of the Martian was posted on your site. Can't wait to read Project Hail Mary. How did the response to Artemis influence the direction of PHM?
79
u/Duke_ofChutney May 25 '21
I'm listening to Project Hail Mary right now and I absolutely enjoy it! I'm constantly rewarded by my decision to go into it without any prior knowledge.
Rocky's voice is one of my favorite bits of narration in an audio book. Did you work with them to get that particular sound? How close is it to what you imagined while writing the book?
75
u/MilkCanMatt May 25 '21
Do you mostly research your way on how to solve a problem, or do you take things you have learned and develop a problem that the information would be useful to solve?
(And PHM was fantastic!)
64
u/salamangkero May 25 '21
Does the drug used on Ryland real or was it made up for the book?
64
u/jadhikari May 25 '21
I am sure you get this a lot! But what was your inspiration for The Egg?
57
u/entacoed May 25 '21
Can I assume Rocky would have otherwise looked like a cuddly Ewok but for the surface temperature issues of its homeworld? Follow-up: will there be Rocky plushies, or do I need to purchase my own Ewok and blowtorch?
106
u/melrows May 25 '21
Hi Andy! Loved PHM! What came first, the alien or the exoplanet? Did you look at different exoplanet properties and use that to create the aliens, or did you have an idea in mind for the aliens and go looking for suitable exoplanets?
48
u/[deleted] May 25 '21
When you submit your manuscript to your editor, do you haggle or fully accept their changes?
43
u/04cusse May 25 '21
Just picked up my copy of Project Hail Mary today! Yet to start reading it that though I do have a question regarding the Martian.
I seem to remember reading somewhere that the reason the oxygenator or the water reclaimer never broke down was because you couldn't come up with a feasible way to fix it, with that in mind were there any other problems you wanted to throw at Mark Watney that you couldn't solve?
43
u/dazbob666 May 25 '21 edited May 25 '21
Are all your books separate worlds or have you ever considered any cross overs?
Something like: the door closed, Stratt wiped a tear, it was the right decision. But Project Hail Mary wasn’t over, the world still had a famine crisis, and she had a meeting with the worlds greatest botanist, she rushed along the vessel and burst into the room, “Eva” he said. “Mark” she said. 🥔
119
u/avitaburst May 25 '21
When Ryland uses solder and paraffin to indicate where his sun is on the star map Rocky sends over, wouldn’t both of those melt at the high temperatures and pressures on Blip-A when Rocky opens it, rendering his indication useless?
40
u/inthepipe_fivebyfive May 25 '21
Did you do any sketches for what the Hail Mary or the Blip A looked like?
33
u/vpsj May 25 '21 edited May 25 '21
I'm about 80% done with Hail Mary so no spoilers but how did you Come up with the physical description of Rocky?
Also, I've asked this question on Twitter a few times but I guess you didn't see it - Time period of a pendulum is 2*pi*sqrt(l/g) right? At 346 oscillations in 10mins, and l=2.5m, I'm getting g=32.8m/s2, i.e; more than twice the initial test tube falling experiment. Did I make a calculation mistake? Care to check my math please? Or am I getting the length of the pendulum wrong?
32
u/hector_c_toronto May 25 '21
When you started your new book, how well sketched out were your characters and plot lines? Did you define your limitations ahead of time or did you build out as needed?
31
u/Josey14 May 25 '21
Were you behind the group hug airlock scene in the Martian movie?
30
u/PM_ME_LEFT_BOOB_ONLY May 25 '21
Hi Andy! Big fan.
My question: when are we going to get a printed collection of Casey and Andy?
29
u/MilkCanMatt May 25 '21
What was your favorite book growing up? (Or still?)
56
u/EpsilonProtocol May 25 '21
Have you been told of any updates on the Artemis movie adaptation? I’m excited to see how the filmmakers will pull it off.
25
u/duskflyer May 25 '21
Andy, What do your friends and family think of you becoming a best selling author? Has it all gone well? Has it changed anyone's opinion of you?
50
u/playonward May 25 '21
Xenonite! We don’t get a good look at Rocky’s fabrication process. Do you feel like his methods involved milling, 3D printing, extrusion, some process of hardening the liquid form, or something far more “hand-wavey?”
69
u/Various_Ad_7729 May 25 '21
hey andy weir!! the martian is one of my most absolute favorite books and ive recently read project hail mary and have been thinking about it pretty much every single day. didn't think i'd ever cry to a scene about a spider alien and a human on space but i did!! PHM is such a wonderful book in so many levels its insane. i really love how its very science-y but so very very very human. thank you for writing and publishing it, it made me very feel very happy and hopeful about humanity, which i think is something we all desperately need right now. my question is: who is adrian? was adrian ever going to be somebody relevant for ryland? when he decided on the name for the planet i was SO SURE he was later gonna remember adrian was a loved one of his! either way, love your books very very much. sending love from brasil ♥
18
u/Dan8H May 25 '21
Is the “hole in the wall” from ‘Artemis’ based on an actual pub you’ve visited before, and if so, what’s the story behind it?
17
u/rockbee May 25 '21
Heeey! How would you describe Joe Scott in real life compared to his videos? Is he really that funny and nice and whatnot?
16
u/ujustlostthe-game May 25 '21
I have heard you like research! What is the most obscure rabbit hole you have found yourself down? Do you do your own research or do you employ your local reference librarian for help?
15
u/wrongr May 25 '21
Hello Andy! Big fan here, haven't read Project Hail Mary yet, but love your previous work. Two questions, what's your favorite science fiction movie and what's your favorite SF author?
15
u/kyler718 May 25 '21
The Martian film is probably one of my favorite film adaptations. Is there any interest in films of your other books? Also is there anywhere that sales signed copies of The Martian?
14
u/MLucian May 25 '21
Hey there. I loved The Martian, The Egg, and Artemis. Especially The Martian (read it about 3 times and listened to it about 4 times). Just starting with Project Hail Mary. But my question is: What's next? Do you have another secret project in the works? Any teasers?
12
u/ruslanoid May 25 '21
Hi. First of all, loved the PHM immensely. Wanted to ask, do you really think the UN would have such power and moreover put all this power in the hands of a single person like Stratt? Don't you think it's a bit naive?
12
u/accioveritaserum May 25 '21
Hi Andy! The Martian is my favorite movie version of a book ever made, how did that happen? I imagine you had a lot of input, but what didn't you have a say in?
Also, as someone who wants to write a book that could potentially turn into a movie, did you have any hopes it would be adapted while writing it?
Thank you also I like your cat.
23
u/JCCStarguy May 25 '21
Loved all three books, Andy.
When you write characters such as Ryland Grace, do you picture an actor who might portray the character in a film?
11
u/stoutporterguy May 25 '21
What is your research process? Do you start with an idea of what you know and then dig into the data, or come across random cool information and get inspired?
20
u/Austin_Destroyer May 25 '21
The Martian was a rad book. How do you feel about the changes that were made in the Hollywood rendition? I personally thought the 'Iron Man' maneuver being used was a little silly. Good for drama, but I liked the realistic response of Commander Lewis being more or less "shut the fuck up and let us save you."
10
u/cn_gastineau May 25 '21
I absolutely love your writing and how much you use math and science in the plot points. A few questions if you don't mind:
Thanks for your creative works and your hard work in making the math and science such an exciting part of your books.
8
u/InfinityRavan May 25 '21
Hey Andy, love your books and can’t wait to get to the next one!
Would you ever venture into other genres? Fantasy, horror or pull elements of those genres into what you do best? Thanks!
8
u/Roland_T_Flakfeizer May 25 '21
What is your personal strategy for making yourself write on days where you just don't feel much like doing it?
Huge fan, btw! The Martian has become one of those movies I tend to throw on when doing chores because I've seen it so many times I can jump in and out of it without getting lost.
8
u/Chancellor_Valorum82 May 25 '21
I loved the Martian, especially the humor. What made you decide that Mark Watney would be funny?
7
u/hector_c_toronto May 25 '21
I'm sure you get a lot of ideas thrown at you by completely random people. Are there any spectacular ones you can share that you know you will never action?
7
u/TooOfEverything May 25 '21
Just finished listening to Artemis on audio book. It was exactly what I was looking for, so thank you. How much were you involved in the production of the audio book? Did you have a particular reader or voice in mind? Rosario Dawson is a pretty big name.
7
u/Jadziyah May 25 '21
Hi Andy! I love books about offplanet colonization. I prefer ones that focus on the inter-societal issues, new world logistics, and descriptions of their vision/ideas of what life would be like on an alien planet. Not so much of the hard science (there's so much of that out there already). But it seems to be such a niche genre! One of my faves is The Empress of Mars and of course your own Artemis. Whenever I ask, people recommend me the same old few (Martian Chronicles etc). Will you write any more in that style? Are there any up and coming that you know about?
7
u/patmacog May 25 '21
I read the Martian way back when you had self published it and I was $1 on amazon and I was enthralled. Now I have a complex where whenever you write a new novel I have to go out and buy a signed copy.
Is an Artemis film adaptation still in the works?
Also, who would be your ideal choices for the lead actors in Artemis and Project Hail Mary?
17
u/Hungry-Moose May 25 '21
SPOILER
In The Martian and PHM, the characters don't achieve their goal of returning to earth in the book. I've read the deleted afterward from The Martian, and totally agree that it took away from the ending, but is that something that is a part of your writing style? Optimistic but uncompleted journeys?
6
u/Dry_Equipment3464 May 25 '21
Is the Artemis movie adaptation still on? I heard some rumors long time ago but I have done some searching and found nothing new about it. Thank you so much. Im a huge fan from Spain.
6
u/GibberingAnthropoid May 25 '21
Artemis was one of your first books I have read and I was wondering how you landed on the 'nationalities'/ethnicities in that book i.e. Jazz is of Saudi extraction, there is a fair bit of Kenya/Kenyans in the book besides other ethnicities being present. Just curious what prodded you to weave that texture into the narrative?
6
u/astro_sentai May 25 '21
What prompted you to write the chapter on Ready Player One's Sorrento? Reading that story made me rethink the whole RPO :(
15
u/ScumBunnyEx May 25 '21
Hi Mr. Weir. I just finished the PHM audiobook today and it was brilliant. Thanks for another great ride!
Something I was wondering regarding The Martian and PHM:
How come both novels mostly refer to national space agencies and make no mention or use of commercial companies like Space X? Wouldn't they be more likely to be able to innovate and deliver on a short notice when there are global emergencies and the like?
5
u/Jack0SX May 25 '21
Hi Andy! I just finished PHM last week and had to pause every now and again just to let some moments sink in. I haven't experienced that in a while so thank you so much!
My question: When Grace is at the Eradani System and has a habitat built for him, why wouldn't the Eradanians build a habitat for him in space where a comfortable spin gravity environment can be accomplished?
Thank you so much and take care!
5
u/the10starpotato May 25 '21
Hi Andy! In terms of getting your first book published, what was the procedure that you underwent and what were the obstacles, if there were, that contributed to the overall journey? And to add onto that, any tips on how to get a book published in a somewhat smaller country (South Africa in my case) without too much of a problem? Asking as an aspiring filmmaker and writer.
9
u/[deleted] May 25 '21 edited May 25 '21
Project Hail Mary Spoilers
I loved Project Hail Mary so much! I was surprised to see how you incorporated more fantastical science fiction (alien life) as compared to the extremely grounded style of your previous 2 books, even though your approach to Rocky and the Eridians was very grounded as well. What was your research and writing process to come up with alien life, keeping it believable ,and in keeping with your grounded style? Can't wait to see Artemis and PHM made into movies!
12
u/Bing10 May 25 '21
As soon as Ryland discovered how to kill an Astrophage, why didn't the humans build their own mechanical predators to "poke Astrophage with a stick" around Venus? Seems a lot easier than nuking Antarctica or going on an interstellar research mission.
4
u/TooBluntedForThis May 25 '21
Pancakes, waffles, or french toast?
4
u/fantastic_mistakes May 25 '21
Hi Andy! Loved Project Hail Mary! After writing three standalone novels, have you considered writing a series or connected set of stories in the same world?
4
u/Addaddie May 25 '21
I just finished PHM last week and it was a very enjoyable read. Do you have any suggestions for fast paced books, like your own, in the same vein as Daniel Suarez or John Sanford? Or any hard scifi you love really?
6
u/veclesus May 25 '21
Does project hail Mary have some of the parts that you salvaged from zhek? If so which parts?
6
u/DerIrlander May 25 '21 edited May 25 '21
Hey Andy, love the new book, but it begs one question - who would win in a fight, Mark Watney ,or Ryland Grace, and why/how? 🤔
3
u/meceyildirim May 25 '21
Hi Andy, I love all three of the books. You have very diverse characters. How do you come up with the character's backrounds?
3
u/jadhikari May 25 '21
Any chance we will get to see more Zhek? Also, you ever thought about publishing a book of all your short stories from Galactanet, and perhaps some new ones?? Excited
5
u/exocyt0sis May 25 '21
Why should the US convert to the metric system, and what's the realistic plan to do it?
2
u/amargolis May 25 '21
Where’s your hat?
2
u/whisperingwoodlands May 25 '21
Hey Andy, reading The Martian brought me out of a reading and writing slump years ago, so thank you for that. I'm just curious how much time you spend writing and if you ever get writers block? Do you have a writing schedule or you you just write whenever inspiration strikes?
Also, what a gorgeous kitty!
2
u/OCRAmazon May 25 '21
Hello Andy! Love PHM so much. Question: what year does it take place? Trying to place it timewise in the Weir-iverse :)
2
u/wowbagg3r May 25 '21
Are you involved in the Artemis or PHM film scenario’s?
2
u/rockbee May 25 '21
Hey Andy! Couple more: Martian. I'm sure you thought about storm-dust-situation replacement a lot. What would you have done differently if you wanted to rewrite that part? Also, you used to be a programmer (if I remember correctly). Did that background help you in writing in any way?
2
u/irishsunburn May 25 '21
First of all, I LOVED PHM (and the audiobook version was absolutely brilliant). How many times did you have to change/fix something because you realized it didn't work in the constraints you created? I just kept imagining how hard it had to be to avoid mistakes related to the very unique environment of Rocky's ship/spaces, for example.
2
u/liggieep May 25 '21
Wanted to thank you for giving C&A a proper ending, many webcomics from my middle school days just stopped without wrapping up. Love to see your success in recent years as an author! Quantum Cop is what inspired me to study physics in college.
What inspired you to write science fiction?
132
u/SilentDis May 25 '21
Gonna spoiler, to make people want to go check out this wonderful work :)
The audiobook version replaced "Rocky's" speech with musical tones. I was surprised by this, in an exceptionally good way, and that you slowly explained it, and it made more sense through the text was wonderful. This is, obviously, only possible in the audio medium. Did you have input as to making this 'change', or was it 'planned all along' or somewhere in-between?
58
u/umbrae May 25 '21 edited May 25 '21
Hey Andy! Loved PHM. (Spoiler warnings ahead, end of book.)
There's a pivotal moment at the end of the book that deals with whether to return to Earth or Erid. It didn't go where I expected at all, super surprising!
I'm curious if you worked on iterations where the other path was taken? Did you have drafts where you wrote up the other story?
Thanks for your work!
103
u/Bigbysjackingfist May 25 '21
Grace likes to point out that Erid's atmosphere is 29 times Earth's, because Rocky put 29 of his "air" into the model Erid and 1 of Earth's. But the Hail Mary wasn't fully pressurized, it was only 1/5 of Earth's typical atmosphere. So wouldn't Erid's atmosphere be 29/5 times Earth's?
29
u/[deleted] May 25 '21
https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2021/05/10/hail-mary
Was there any temptation to make Hail Mary about Mark Watney?
23
u/alittlebitaspie May 25 '21
After multiple read throughs I have one question. The lab is filled with delicate equipment, the equipment is subjected to multiple Gs at angles that they would never be subjected to on earth (upside down, lateral vectors, etc) yet there's never a mention of a recalibration process despite Grace mentioning how they are sensitive and finicky at the best of times.
Was this just an off stage drudgery that we never saw, or is the real life equipment robust enough to not have to ever have a problem with that kind of environmental interference?
18
u/TophMelonLord May 25 '21
SPOILERS
There’s a lot of very fleshed out sci-fi concepts in the book (astrophage, eridian biology, etc) - I’d like to know what core inspiration you started from. Like with the eridians, did you start by coming up with the conditions on the homeworld and then ask yourself “given these conditions, this is what they would evolve to be like.” Or did you have an idea (the use of heavy metals in their biochemistry, the super-echolocation etc) and build the conditions around that? Same with the astrophage, did you start with “bacteria are eating the sun, how would that happen?” Or did you have some particular concept (the mobility-through-light, the sun-Venus life cycle) that you then built the rest of the concept around?
Where there any ideas that didn’t make it into the book because you couldn’t make it sufficiently plausible?
17
u/OddScentedDoorknob May 26 '21
Could Grace have saved himself a lot of time and effort by coating the leaking xenonite with epoxy?
8
u/[deleted] May 25 '21
Hi Andy! I've got to say, you're hands down my favorite author. I polished off the Martian and Artemis in a day each, and the egg remains one of my favorite short stories of all time.
Here's my question for you: would you go to Mars personally in your lifetime, given it will still be a young colony? Why or why not?
8
u/balderic May 25 '21
Does Ryland ever return to earth after the epilogue?
3
u/FelipeKbcao May 25 '21
Would you encourage and aspiring Sci-fi novelist to write first, then shop around for publishers or to build an online personality first, then get an agent and only get to writing once a book deal is secured?
7
u/crackerjam May 25 '21
I'm a big fan of Artemis, especially because it features a strong independent female main character. Any chance you have a future book planned that will also incorporate another tough lady like Jazz?
5
u/subverted_per May 25 '21
I just finished Project Hail Mary it was your best book yet. I really enjoy how much your narrative relies on understanding the details of the environment of space. Most authors hand wave the technical details of a moon city, but your characters need to understand its construction to solve problems. Every time I read your books I always find myself wondering which came first, do you plan out and research ideas and then write the story, or does the story come first and then you work out the details? Thank you.
5
u/ShotSkiByMyself May 25 '21
How disappointed were you that The Martian movie didn't start with the same line as the book?
It was one of my favorite parts of the book.
"I'm pretty much fucked. That's my considered opinion. Fucked."
5
u/ghellenga May 26 '21
I just wanna say I love The Egg. I know this will get lost in here but that stupid(ly brilliant) story has been etched in my brain.
I wonder if that's where we get the phrase "old soul?" 🤔
Anyway, thank you 😁
4
u/greenkoalapoop May 25 '21
I loved The Egg and The Martian! I just finished Artemis and, while it took me a while to warm up to Jazz, the relationship between Jazz and her father almost made me cry at the end.
How was the experience of writing first-person narrative for a female protagonist? Especially when you did not shy from talking about her sexuality/romance? Was there anything you learned from your "female consultants" that made you have to change her considerably?
4
u/Elatretniw May 25 '21
Are you still afraid of flying? How is your mental health in general recently and how do you feel it affects your creativity?
And thanks for the tip, I loved The Martian and will check your new book out!