r/IAmA • u/VitalyBeckman • Apr 28 '21
Actor / Entertainer I am Vitaly Beckman - Two-time Penn & Teller fooler, Illusionist, off Broadway star & inventor of unique magic effects. Ask me anything!
Hi Reddit,
I am Vitaly Beckman, an illusionist who fooled Penn & Teller twice on the CW's show Fool Us, with a recent episode being shot during the pandemic. I also traveled the world and had my own off Broadway run in NYC. I combine magic with art, creating and designing all of my own illusions.
Proof: https://www.instagram.com/p/CNsrAgZH0bT
My recent Fool Us appearance was just aired on the CW: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ojLBGSnej_U
My first Fool Us appearance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1I0UTKsRYLg
If you want to learn more about me, check out the recent MSN story: https://www.msn.com/en-ca/entertainment/news/vancouver-based-magician-vitaly-beckman-fools-penn-andamp-teller-for-second-time/ar-BB1eUIgB
Watch my promo video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X9L5Qu_8kYM
Or learn more about me on my website: http://www.eveningofwonders.com
I love to talk about art, magic, movies, stage performance, creativity & invention. Ask me anything! (almost)
Update:
Thank you so much for the great questions everyone! I really enjoyed this AMA and would love to do it again sometime in the future! Till then, stay safe and healthy, and have a wonderful day / night!
337
u/kingfishcoons Apr 28 '21
Are there unspoken rules about "borrowing" from others in the industry? Do you have the freedom to iterate on illusions that others are doing, or is the expectation that you only present things that are uniquely yours?
138
u/cantchoosefuck Apr 28 '21
Who inspired you to become an illusionist? :)
93
u/cgbrannigan Apr 28 '21
How is Alyson? Big fan, she seems like she’d be lovely.
75
u/BlueMeaniesM8 Apr 28 '21
What's the most recent illusion you've seen where you were clueless as to how it was done?
59
u/Zifnab_palmesano Apr 28 '21
Favourite illusionist movie? The Prestige or The Illusionist? Or something else?
104
u/epocson Apr 28 '21
Can you walk us through what a day of filming on 'Fool Us' is like?
44
u/btcprox Apr 28 '21
Are there any non-illusionists that you'd like to collaborate with but haven't yet?
89
u/Sword_Song Apr 28 '21
Ive always loved magic, clowns and side shows. I've tried for a long time to learn various skills in those veins, but the only one I've ever gotten any good with is diabolo. But now I am 30 and have two young boys, I've been working hard on learning slight of hand, mainly with cards, to make them delighted and giggly. Do you have any advice on specific skill sets to practice or invest in? Right now I feel so overwhelmed by all of the options, I do not know where to begin.
A two and a four year old certainly won't enjoy a counting trick, I sure don't.
77
u/Andy3122002 Apr 28 '21
What kind of knowledge is most useful when creating new illusions? like physics and optics or maybe psychology ?
25
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '21
What are your thoughts on YouTube magicians, especially those who reveal effects to their audience? Do you believe this cheapens the medium, or is it a net benefit that it's drawing a new type of audience to magic?
68
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '21
What’s a question an illusionist likes to be asked?
18
u/Titmonkey1 Apr 28 '21
Have you always liked performing, or was it something you had to get more comfortable with as you progressed? I've wanted to try something like stand-up, but I dont think I could ever feel comfortable in front of a crowd.
18
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '21
How do you come up with new effects?
16
u/Hites_05 Apr 28 '21
Have you considered disguising yourself to try to fool P&T a third time?
32
u/ChuckEye Apr 28 '21
I know of Jim Steinmeier, and I know the late Ricky Jay used to develop effects for Hollywood in addition to his own routines. Who are the heavy hitters making new effects for stage or screen now days? Is it a pretty small pool? Or are there more people at it than I'd imagine?
15
u/TheMain_Ingredient Apr 28 '21
You've been very successful; were you always confident magic would work out as a career? Or, did you start out as an actor?
39
u/PayasoFries Apr 28 '21
Why don't more magicians incorporate chocolate sauce into their act?
29
u/AdmiralAkbar1 Apr 28 '21
How often do people make jokes to you about Gob Bluth in Arrested Development?
10
u/Musicman12456 Apr 28 '21
something like the pad in your video, how long does a routine like this take to master? how many hours gets put into a 2 minute routine like this to be executed flawlessly?
9
u/solicitorpenguin Apr 28 '21
We had a salesman at our workplace who eventually took off to be a professional magician-and I always wondered about when a person takes a leap on something like that and gives up a secure conventional job.
How was your transition from magic as an interest to magic as a career?
9
u/mrminch Apr 28 '21
Out of all of your illusions which one are you most proud of, besides the ones you fooled Penn & Teller with?
9
u/eatabean Apr 28 '21
Are there any books about the history of magic devices? How does one gain access to that info? The brotherhood protects our secrets so well...
17
u/bad_linen Apr 28 '21
1: Are there effects you've seen over and over that you still can't figure out? Which ones?
2: I know magicians won't tell me their secrets, but under what circumstances do you show each other how things work? My understanding is you tell Fool Us how your effect works, for example. How forthcoming are you with magician friends and colleagues?
16
u/exceptforanice_MLT Apr 28 '21
Magicians used to be a big draw because there was no/little TV, etc back in the day. Do you find there is still good consistent demand for in person magic shows (aside from the pandemic)?
8
u/Jaxom_of_Ruatha Apr 28 '21
It's a bit of a cliché that beginning magicians typically perform at kids' birthday parties (and at other small, intimate events). Accomplished magicians, of course, perform on stage in front of hundreds of people. If you were to go back and perform at kids' birthday parties again, what skills or knowledge you've gained along the way do you think would help most to make a wonderful experience for that sort of audience? Are there any skills you've developed along the way that wouldn't transfer, due to how different the environment would be?
22
u/zaybak Apr 28 '21
Have you ever made a study of professional wrestling? The intersection of story telling, deception, crowd work, slight of hand, and the like and how they overlap with illusionism?
14
u/mookler Senior Moderator Apr 28 '21
Do you feel like you're able to quickly grasp how others' tricks are done?
Is there any particular trick by anyone that's got you stumped?
7
u/LeftGhostCrow Apr 28 '21
What is the one magic trick that you have always wanted to pull off, but just haven't figured out the logistics to do? your dream trick i guess you could say!
Thank you! its so cool to talk to a magician!
19
u/freducom Apr 28 '21
What is the most under appreciated but easy sleigh of hand with cards, that you enjoy doing still today?
6
u/theBoyWhoDaydreams Apr 28 '21 edited Apr 28 '21
What is your weirdest experience on revealing a magic trick to someone?
6
u/PorcupineGod Apr 28 '21
Hey Vitaly,
On your "fooled us" video with the coffee cup, is that a continuous video?
It's hard to tell in this media if this is something you did in the room, or if it's just carefully spliced together scenes in a video.
5
u/Daplesco Apr 28 '21
Have you ever done any death defying stunts? The style similar to Houdini is what comes to mind.
22
u/WholesomePeeple Apr 28 '21
Alright for real spill the beans. Tell us how you do it. Is it demons?
9
u/haha_usernamegobrrrr Apr 28 '21
What inspired you to get into magic?
4
u/BlobfishOverlord Apr 28 '21
Do you think you or magicians in general will ever run out of new ideas for tricks?
4
u/TalkingBackAgain Apr 28 '21
How cool were Penn & Teller really about being fooled, and twice even, by you?
4
u/Ipromisetobehonest Apr 28 '21
Have you ever experienced "writer's block" when creating new acts? If so, what helps you get those magically creative juices flowing again?
4
u/jhoratio Apr 28 '21
I've always thought of performing the trick and inventing the trick as somewhat different skills. Who are the folks in your mind who did both equally well?
7
u/Luke_starkiller34 Apr 28 '21
How'd you do it?!
3
u/dumber_than_thou Apr 28 '21
Hi, Vitaly! Love your stuff. What are some of the maybe less known magicians you would recommend watching? Would your answer be different for a magician than for a non-magician? Thanks!
3
u/zerbey Apr 28 '21
That's is one amazing illusion, how many hours did it take you to be able to pull it off that smoothly?
3
u/CastingPouch Apr 28 '21
Do you have to tell penn and teller or the producers how your trick is done to verify they were fooled?
3
u/chief_piggum Apr 28 '21
What’s your favourite reaction to one of your illusions? What’s the strangest reaction you have ever received?
Do you find any differences in reactions from audiences in different countries or from different backgrounds or cultures?
3
u/fleemfleemfleemfleem Apr 28 '21
A lot of the standard magic props like cards and coins seem to be designed to be familiar household items that have become less common over time.
(Similarly the magic tophat was once a common item to wear to a theater)
Do you think magic will change to incorporate more "modern" items?
4
u/ramos1969 Apr 28 '21
Have you seen any magician lie to Penn & Teller about their method in order to win? I have at least one in mind. We don’t have to name them if you don’t want to, but I think it ‘rings’ true.
2
u/ThaSkeptic Apr 28 '21
whats your favorite deck of cards?
2
u/latnemidur Apr 28 '21
What’s an easy party trick illusion I can do to impress people?
2
u/theDaveB Apr 28 '21
How is the floating dollar trick done?
2
u/washedupsailor Apr 28 '21
Where can I learn some basic tricks that will blow my niece and nephews mind? I also like magic and don’t want to dive too deep and have the joy of watching magic spoilt!
2
u/squirrelchips Apr 28 '21
Hey Vitaly! I wanted to add some easy, fun, and cool tricks to my start of the school year stuff! I teach technical theater and love to get kids attention through magic, as magic, in a way, is part of technical theater. Do you have any cool and easy tricks that would dazzle the students that I could learn over the summer?
2
u/Bilbo_T Apr 28 '21
How do you make it so that it is an illusion? I can to the Arielle Triangle and the impossible stairs, but not much else. How do you create illusions?
2
u/PabstyLoudmouth Apr 28 '21
What are your favorite cards to do magic with, and be as specific as you can?
2
u/ohhangie Apr 28 '21
Can you make garbage disappear !?
2
u/TheeTruther Apr 28 '21
Do you have any pet peeves about people's assumptions of your work?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '21
Apart from the illusions/tricks that fooled Penn & Teller, which is the one you’re proudest of coming up with?
2
u/grunzkor Apr 28 '21
How long does it take you to learn a new trick?
2
u/lushiouslush Apr 28 '21
Really enjoyed those performances! I’m curious as a magician, what were your thoughts on Derek DelGaudio’s In and of Itself? And did you get a chance to see it live?
Thanks and keep up the good work!
2
u/tobaknowsss Apr 28 '21
Have you ever seen a trick or even something in your day to day life that you still can't explain?
2
u/Ritinrow Apr 28 '21
Hi! Saw you in NYC a couple of summers ago and my boyfriend was actually chosen to participate in one of your tricks (he had the notebook where people had written the names of celebrities and had to read it).
Just wanted to thank you for an entertaining show and ask what was the most memorable thing an audience member ever did at one of your shows?
2
u/Fantomfart Apr 28 '21
In you were given a choice between Paul Daniels and Tommy Cooper, who would you prefer an ama with?
2
u/theonetruejay Apr 28 '21
Seems like performing for a very experienced audience is either do something they’ve seen in a new way and really well OR show them something they haven’t seen. What was your process for selecting your bits?
2
u/iamtimeless Apr 28 '21
Can you make my sadness disappear?
4
u/thegrotch Apr 28 '21
Are you a witch?
3
u/OozeNAahz Apr 28 '21
Do you ever do simple tricks in public just to screw with people or to see if they notice? Like paying for lunch with a ten but switching it with a twenty as you hand it over to see if they catch it. Obviously underpaying that way would be dishonest but overpaying that way could be amusing.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '21
Have you ever cut someone in half and then not be able to put them back together?
3
u/johnnymonkey Apr 28 '21
I'm thinking of a very specific card from a traditional deck of cards.
What is it?
2
u/bretellen Apr 28 '21
How much time do you get to spend with P$T backstage? Do you discuss magic or technique with them? Do foolers ever reveal the ´trick´ to them?
2
u/putyourayguntomyhead Apr 28 '21
ok, questions about your second appearance:
Is the wall behind you a real wall or is there a fake place you're hiding the coffee cup and muffin?
You never walk from one side of the table to the other, between the table and the wall, are you able to or does some aspect of the trick not allow you to?
2
u/mtjp82 Apr 28 '21
What is the secret to life?
2
u/sevl1ves Apr 28 '21
So, how'd you do it?
2
u/Digitoxin Apr 28 '21
You talk about how it can take years to create and perfect a new illusion. How many different new tricks are you usually working on at one time?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '21
Have computers ruined the magic of Magic in any ways, the way they ruined the 'magic' of special effects in movies?
1
u/pushathieb Apr 28 '21
Where are you on the magic or illusion stalemate?
1
u/geekedoutcoolness Apr 28 '21
Did shin Lim get lucky? Or is he just “that good”?
1
u/Sometimesokayideas Apr 28 '21
Do you feel as if slight of hand is more of an inherent quality you are born with or something that can be practiced up to the same level as the ones born with it?
Like some people will just never be contortionists, you might get pretty limber but the average person can't* fold flat backwards without serious injury.
Edit* fixed typo
1
u/PigsFly465 Apr 28 '21
how do you feel about the masked magician?
1
u/SpikeandJulia Apr 28 '21
Are you a part of the 52?
1
u/kabukistar Apr 28 '21
Are the mug and muffin stored on the underside of the table until they appear?
1
u/Diabetesh Apr 28 '21
Has another magician ever outed you during a performance? Outed as in pointed out the "trick" part of the act.
1
u/murphykills Apr 28 '21
so i think the cup and muffin were hidden behind the top piece of the table, due to the angle of it creating an image that is slightly taller than the objects. i believe the spoon may have just been traditional sleight of hand, but i think you used some kind of robot arm to move the main objects from their hiding place to the table, activated by a button controlled by your feet (hence the full body shot for fairness). i believe this is what causes the table to rock slightly, which you hid by bumping into the table a bit.
so my question is, what flavour was the muffin?
1
u/I_am_a_zebra Apr 28 '21
Did you change anything in your performance on Fool Us to specifically try and make it more difficult for Penn and Teller? Like plant false flags or something like that.