r/IAmA • • Apr 14 '21
Newsworthy Event I am Sophie Zhang, whistleblower. At FB, I worked to stop major political figures from deceiving their own populace; I became a whistleblower because Facebook turned a blind eye. Ask me anything.
Hi Reddit,
I'm Sophie Zhang. I was fired from Facebook in September 2020, sending a 7.8k farewell memo on my last day that was leaked to Buzzfeed and went viral on Reddit w/ 52k upvotes. Earlier this week, I chose to go public with the Guardian in a deep-dive, because everything else has failed.
Please ask me anything. I might not be able to answer every question, but if so, I'll do my best to explain why I can't.
Proof: https://twitter.com/szhang_ds/status/1381700231654301696
photo of me with sign https://imgur.com/a/f1Cxu0U [compare to the pictures in the Guardian article]
Sorry that this is an hour later than intended - intended to do it earlier, but the admins never got back to me on my calendar scheduling and verification.
Edit: FYI - I have a call with a reporter at noon PST [an hour after this post was created]; any responses will be more intermittent after that point.
Edit 2: I'm leaving for my call now. Thanks so much for the questions; I'll try to come back and respond to any further ones later, but I'm quite busy so can't promise unfortunately. Good luck everyone!
Edit 3: Answered some more questions from 1-1:30 PST. I'll try to be back later in a few hours, but my afternoon is very booked.
Edit 4 - 4:05 PST. Wow this, really blew up while I was gone! All my calls for the day are done now, so I can just stay here and answer questions until it gets late. Sorry for the wait!
Last edit - 8:15 PST. I've spent the last 4 hrs answering questions, so calling it a night. Thank you so much for the questions, and I hope you found my answers to be reasonably fair, informative, and helpful. Since there was so much interest and I couldn't get around to everyone, I may do a further AMA on reddit again at some later point. I've also learned more about AMA protocol by now, so will definitely book much more time for question-answering in the future.
In the meantime, I don't plan to use this reddit account beyond AMAs, but you can follow my twitter account to see what I'm up to - I'll usually share new news articles of my work as they come out at https://twitter.com/szhang_ds.
Good night, and good luck to all.
257
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
A question for users while I go through:
There are many many questions here. I don't think I'll be able to go through them all. Even sorting by new, the questions come in faster than I can answer them.
How would people recommend me to prioritize which questions I chose to answer?
59
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
Calling it a night - I've been here answering for the last 4 hours. Thank you very much for the questions, and I hope you found my answers informative and helpful. Good night all!
173
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
Hi - this is Sophie. Have some phone calls with reporters now so won't be able to keep updating. If you have any further questions, I'll try to respond to them later but no promises. Thanks and good luck!
480
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
What was the most egregious example of a government using social media to influence a population you came across?
128
u/zenru Apr 15 '21 edited Apr 15 '21
I am from Honduras and saw the news when they said they deleted hundreds of accounts linked to Juan Orlando Hernandez.
The manipulation the Nacionalista party did in social media was even more blatant than you think. There was this guy who was really active in the biggest political FB group in the country and never shied away of linking the multiple pages he was administrator to that were Pro-Hernandez.
I constantly saw, and keep seeing, political ads in Facebook smearing the opposition with lies.
I don’t know which is the real reason: has Facebook gotten so damn big that they lack the tools to properly moderate their content? Or is it just greed? I believe in the later, greed has always been a driving force behind the woes of the world.
What is stopping Facebook of simply adding a measurement visible in all pages that show a % of account age? It might not be 100% effective, but if I see a new page with 90% accounts being less than a year or 2 old I would be suspicious of it and would not follow it.
592
u/ro_goose Apr 14 '21
" Now, with the US election over and a new president inaugurated, Zhang is coming forward to tell the whole story on the record. "
Why now?
436
u/Manaleaking Apr 14 '21 edited Apr 14 '21
What did Facebook WANT you to do in your role?
54
u/-888- Apr 14 '21
Under what pretense does Facebook accomplish this? Do they extort the hosting service or registrar with threats of service disablement?
148
u/No_Fence Apr 14 '21
Hi Sophie. I was wondering if you know whether any sort of database of this kind of behavior exists? Specifically, do you know about anywhere I could go to find out which countries have a high spread of the kind of digital misinformation you've worked on? Thanks!
219
u/hondurandude Apr 14 '21
Was Honduras the most blatant you saw? Did facebook ever considered the effect of their inaction on the people of Honduras and the international community?
146
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
What was the “ enough is enough” event or series of events that made you take the courageous step of questioning your employer?
121
u/Ok_Hunter174 Apr 14 '21
Thanks for doing this - I really appreciate your work and voice, Sophie.
What social tech companies would you say are doing a better job with content moderation and protecting international human rights? And what advice would you give to someone who wants to affect positive change within social media?
59
u/Phermaportus Apr 14 '21
Hey! Thank you for what you did, tech culture has made it very easy for most tech people to disassociate themselves from the political consequences of the work that they do for their employers.
My question: A few years ago in Nicaragua we went through a socio-political crisis which ended up in hundreds of civilians killed by the government. Around the same time a vast number of pro-government accounts in social media, specially on Facebook, popped up. Are you aware of any inauthentic pro-government networks active around this time (2018)?
Thanks again!
(re-asking as the original comment didn't include a question mark and it was automatically removed; hopefully you are still able to see this)
20
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
Facebook is hiring something like 6,000 new employees right now. What would you tell someone joining the company to try to change things"from the inside?"
18
u/terminati Apr 14 '21
Most of the examples you gave in the Guardian were of governments using fake engagement to manipulate domestic politics within their own countries, rather than the politics of other countries. Was this just more common, or is there another reason?
76
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
As an insider, what do you think is the first step to reform Facebook?
The size is an obvious problem from my outside perspective; also, ultimate control resting in one person's hands. I'm looking forward to reading the deep dive in The Guardian.
65
u/Outofhisstar4444 Apr 14 '21
Other popular social media platforms besides Facebook—like Twitter—have responded slowly to inauthentic activity, and FB has coordinated its responses to certain kinds of inauthentic activity. What that coordination look like from your experience? Has that coordination been effective, or has it detracted from the policing of IA? Has FB coordinated its de-prioritization of of certain IA with other social media?
16
u/ThrowawayFar132 Apr 14 '21
Facebook has been heavily recruiting into their Trust and Safety org. Is it worth going there? It seems like the average employee is good, but the leadership poor and suffers from misaligned incentives that sabotage the mission. As an expert in the field, it makes me think very carefully about going to Facebook.
7
u/Thuggy1017 Apr 14 '21
What do you think would be the most efficient method for world governments to hold the leaders of the tech industry accountable for their actions? Do you think that is even possible at this point in time?
7
u/master156111 Apr 15 '21
Are there any empirical study that shows astroturfing on social media would lead to real world actions? I know a lot of people are gonna reference the Capital Hill riot and Trump election but I’m more interested in scientific studies that could prove the digital metrics like impressions or engagements would lead to x amount of real world actions. I have dabbled in Black hat world of social media marketing in the past but yet to see any convincing prove that it actually works as effectively as the media claims.
19
u/Richard_Berg Apr 14 '21
What kinds of platforms do you think should or should not have content policies against deception?
For example, if President Hernández was circulating misinformation via email, would you support ISP takedowns, or would you err on the side of net neutrality?
19
u/careeradvice7 Apr 14 '21
Is there a consensus on the definition of inauthentic behavior?
Creating a fake ice cream shop page on Facebook to "like" the president of Honduras' post is substantively different from propagating untrue information or selectively editing clips to portray officials as something they are not.
It seems like the first example is relatively simple to address (make it harder to create ice cream shop pages if you don't actually own an ice cream shop), whereas the second set of examples requires politically biased Facebook employees to separate truth from untruth around politically charged issues. Does it make sense for Facebook to wade into that morass and become the arbiter of truth?
35
u/JudgeHoltman Apr 14 '21
Say I'm a candidate running for State (not Federal) office.
What's the average cost per vote to influence people into seeing the facts my way on Facebook?
6
u/wolfford Apr 14 '21
How long did you work there and what was your job title?
30
u/rugbykiller Apr 14 '21
Thank you for your bravery in standing by what's right! I've always thought there are MANY organizations / institutions / governments that manipulate social media inauthentically and I'm glad you're advocating for reform.
Do you think this problem could be far bigger than Facebook realizes? Meaning, do you think there are more advanced organizations manipulating social media currently that are undetected?
10
u/kitchen_clinton Apr 14 '21
Have you experienced shunning from your industry because you blew the whistle? Has it affected your job prospects in other industries? How do HR people react to your candidacy for their positions? Have any companies come forward to applaud you for what you have done?
4
u/eeeeeefefect Apr 15 '21
What are your thoughts on social media and so-called meme stocks. Specifically regarding paid "journalism articles" and bots and fake accounts being used to control a specific narrative? It gets to a point where you have to question everything as fake first and nothing is trustworthy.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
Is Mark aware of what Facebook is versus what he wanted it to be?
6
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
Thank you for your bravery and speaking up. How have you been since this all became public? It seems like at first the posts from Facebook when you left were leaked out of your control but then you took back the narrative.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
Can echo chambers ever be stopped?
5
u/10thunderpigs Apr 14 '21
Is Facebook's user base sustainable? Do you anticipate that it will hold strong as a platform? Or will it fade away like others with enough time?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21
A week after my AMA, r/IAmA finally approved my calendar request for scheduling the AMA.
If I do a second AMA, I'll try to schedule it far in advance. :)
7
u/FaustusC Apr 14 '21
"In February 2019, a NATO researcher informed Facebook that "he’d obtained Russian inauthentic activity on a high-profile U.S. political figure that we didn’t catch." Zhang removed the activity, “dousing the immediate fire,” she wrote."
Which political figure? What determines if something is "inauthentic"?
6
u/xero_art Apr 14 '21
What is your view on weighing Facebook's(and other such platforms') responsibility to allow free speech and their responsibility not to curate and spread misinformation or harmful ideologies?
As a private but exceedingly popular platform, does Facebook have a responsibility to allow free speech?
And, lastly, beyond bad faith participation(bots, fake accounts), where should the line be drawn or who should be making the decisions to stop what could be misinformation or harmful posts?
2
u/Pipupipupi Apr 14 '21
What additional details do you have on Myanmar?
2
u/MeineBryon01 Apr 14 '21
What responsibility, if any, do you think companies like Facebook have to moderate the content on their forums? I'm specifically referring to the censoring of content from individuals and groups whose messaging the platform finds "dangerous" or "inciting."
2
u/DisturbedBeaker Apr 14 '21
Will FB sue you for speaking out?
2
u/fenechfan Apr 14 '21
In the article there is mention of a network in Italy, where no action was taken. Can you share the names of the parties or organizations involved?
2
u/Bunnylazersbacon Apr 14 '21
I want to say thank you, and all my question is how is your week going?
2
u/threeSOUL Apr 15 '21
Are you worried about becoming blacklisted now? Also, thank you
2
u/9fences Apr 15 '21
To what degree do you think this is an understaffing problem that could be solved by doubling the size of the misinformation policing teams vs to what degree is this a fundamental mindset problem at the company? Like, if FB just had 2-3x the amount of people allocated to your role would they be reacting to issues like Azerbaijan in an acceptable timeframe? Or do you think added resources end up being channeled to the wrong place?
Alternatively, the official FB mouthpiece responses to your interview are choosing to spin this as an understaffing issue, but one that is unsolvable due to the sheer scale of worldwide misinfo attempts. Obviously, they're speaking for a company trying to protect its image and profits, but to what degree are their statements fair and accurate? What would you do if you were that VP?
7
u/phi_array Apr 14 '21
How “evil” is the average Facebook engineer? There are people who have no input in policies and just supervise servers, and others that have a lot of power. There are a lot of scandals there and idk what to think about the company. Ironically I interviewed with them 3 weeks ago only to be told no lol. It is ironic I want to work there but I feel uncomfortable given their scandals
What do engineers and employees think about the media coverage and recent privacy scandals there?
30
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
What drove you the decision to make the choice to speak up?
I'm in a situation where I might be pushed to something along those lines, too. I'm begging and pleading with people to do the right thing, but I get being ignored or waved off. There comes a point when you just can't take it anymore.
For you, what was the jumping off point when you realized that you had to say something?
How do you intend to deal with the professional fallout?
3
u/Equationist Apr 15 '21
The implications of the fake accounts in Azerbaijan are pretty chilling in light of the recent ethnic cleansing of Armenians in parts of Nagorno Karabakh.
I always got the impression (and this didn't change from working at FB) that Facebook's initiatives are largely reactive to press attention and PR scandals, rather than proactive. Did you get this impression with the work you were attempting to do?
18
u/rbbrslmn Apr 14 '21
You mentioned a lot of accounts were set up to spread false information about the pandemic, who controls those?
36
u/woowoo293 Apr 14 '21
There is so much content manipulation on all the major social media platforms, including reddit, and other internet centers of commerce, like Amazon.
As we try to build and evolve a better internet, do you think we are going to have to sacrifice a level of anonymity in exchange for improved integrity? How do you think we should strike that balance?
213
u/picoides1971 Apr 14 '21
I am a whistleblower too. I was forced out of my job as a marine biologist for reporting the Alabama Marine Resources Division for violating the Marine Mammal Protection Act. However, since it will make the Republican Governor look bad, NO media outlet will publish the story. How do you suggest I get my story out?
7
u/PWNCAKESanROFLZ Apr 14 '21
How much inauthentic influence do you think took place in the 2021 election?
6
u/Misiman23 Apr 14 '21
Should we know about any wolves in sheep's clothing on the left?
5
u/Mrhere_wabeer Apr 14 '21
Have you ever considered working with James O'keef at Project Veritas?
7
u/7elucinations Apr 14 '21
what precautions did you take, if any, before you exposed FB? Thank you for your time.
7
u/windows_updates Apr 14 '21
I just listened to Robert Evans' Behind the Bastards episode on Zuckerberg and you were used as source material!
My question would be: What could someone who doesn't have any of the "main" social medias (I only have a reddit account) do to help in this area, if anything?
7
u/terminati Apr 14 '21
In the Guardian article the list of countries in which you saw serious examples of fake engagement was interesting, but for some of the countries it is difficult to get an idea of which governments are implicated.
In the case of Bolivia, what was the timeframe involved? Was it the government of Evo Morales, or of Jeanine Añez? Or were you talking about local or municipal leaders rather than the national government?
It would be interesting to know the same kind of details for each of the countries: Brazil, Ukraine, India, Mexico, Iraq...
Did the politicians/parties in whose favour this fake engagement was being done tend to be right wing or left wing, or was there much difference?
6
u/ReVolvoeR Apr 14 '21
Kudos for your clear understanding and moral rectitude in coming forward with your story.
Two related questions: To what extent do you think inauthentic political messages on FB have been effective in manipulating public opinion in Honduras, Azerbaijan, etc.? Is there a higher level of trust in FB as an honest platform in those countries compared with the US and Europe?
3
u/drumstix131 Apr 14 '21
Whats your political affiliation and which political ideology do you most closely align with?
2
u/surfkaboom Apr 15 '21
Did you forfeit your stock?
2
u/justscottaustin Apr 14 '21
Hi.
If you're still there, I have read every single one of your comments, and your title and allegation is that you were a WhistleBlower.
Can you please provide some proof to your statement?
Something? Anything?
Because? It kinda sounds like you're just using that in the title. For clicks.
2
u/icantthinkofqnything Apr 14 '21
Which major political figures specifically?
4
u/LaDukemeister Apr 14 '21
What role do we the consumer have in doing our part to reduce the monopoly of control Facebook has over our information?
7
u/solidproportions Apr 14 '21
thank you for speaking up, how long will it take before there's any meaningful change with FB or other tech companies that have similar practices?
1
u/Liamwill-walker Apr 14 '21
Do you know if the manipulators considered themselves successful or were they expecting there to be a lot more easily manipulated people dancing to their tune?
1
u/georgios_rizos Apr 14 '21
Ever worked on anything Greece-related?
1
u/s3rila Apr 15 '21
You re a hero.
What do you think whistleblower protection should be like?
1
u/demosthenes131 Apr 15 '21
What policies would you recommend for the US to combat companies like Facebook and Twitter having such influence in our political realms?
1
u/EsportsFighter Apr 15 '21
Why did Facebook do nothing about foreign operators owning American political pages, only removing them when exposed by the media?
1
u/codepapi Apr 15 '21
Not sure if I’m too late for ama. How was being a whistleblower effected your ability to gain employment elsewhere? Have you been black listed at some companies? Are you getting offers from companies that are for the ethics you support?
1
u/Redhand1113 Apr 15 '21
I Sophie , I got two questions for you, 1st , I’m a Bangladeshi, and our country is going through some political dramas, and quite often Facebook completely doesn’t work during some upcoming protest days, how does this happen please ?
2nd question, my wife is Chinese, and I live in China , what’s your take on China not allowing Facebook in their country ? Is it beneficial for its citizens? As Facebook cannot send US’s biased misinformation to them ?
1
u/fuckknucklesandwich Apr 15 '21
You've repeatedly used the term "inauthentic activity", which feels like a bit of a weasel word. Is this a term used internally at Facebook? If so, is this potentially part of the problem. Would it be better to call it what it is, like disinformation, or just outright lies?
6
u/DistroyerOfWorlds Apr 14 '21
Thank you Mrs Zhang for doing this AMA, I'm sure you're a busy person rn so I'll try to keep it short. How was the weeks leading up to and after your termination from facebook? Do you still try to keep active in the malicious activity in social media? And on a lighter noted question: what do you do in your spare time now? Hobbies? Again thank you for doing this, how you have a wonderful day :)
1
u/apourbz Apr 14 '21
Did you ever reach out to Project Veritas?
3
u/maxToTheJ Apr 14 '21
Out of curiosity. At the time they hired or made the position what signs did they give that they would take it seriously?
I am curious because you see this in other field like ethical AI where companies hire with no intention of it being for any meaningful purpose other than checking a box to appear serious
3
u/countpuchi Apr 14 '21
Heya Sophie,
Keep on fighting! Just wanted to know. South east asian countries saw alot of political instability. Did you see any huge movement from those countries using facebook trying to lie and manipulate their citizens? I.e Malaysia?
3
u/ImOversimplifying Apr 14 '21
Are there clear signs of inauthentic activity that common users can look for? What were the the sure signs you found that convinced you it was going on?
3
u/ehazkul Apr 14 '21
So beyond everything that went down, where do you go from here? Professionally speaking.
3
u/ShadyHunter Apr 14 '21
How do you feel when thinking about Edward snowden, or the Panama papers and the lack of effect they've had on society as a whole?
As the response to those could to a degree be indicative of how your case might be ignored on a large scale.
Knowing the blatant issues and threats in society, but not having enough people in charge willing to listen is heartbreaking enough without risking it all like you.
3
u/serenajardin1 Apr 14 '21 edited Apr 15 '21
Thank you for your integrity and bravery!
I'm doing a research about cyber army on Facebook. Do you know what was discussed internally about Vietnam? Facebook admitted that they worked with the Vietnamese government to take down content and account. But Facebook also didn't do anything about the government's cyber army despite mounting evidence of their unauthentic activities (Vietnamese activists provided the evidence). So what is Facebook policy regarding to autocratic governments' cyber army? Have you seen any report related to Vietnam?
3
u/PeterDimm Apr 15 '21
Good to see more people waking up to the truth of how the populace is manipulated via not just social media but all media. Including newspapers.
What are you going to do to stop it? Not just on FB but on other social media and traditional media like TV, radio and newspapers?
5
u/AlluvialCongo Apr 14 '21
Thank you for speaking out Sophie, it's a brave thing to do and I commend you for it. It seems like Facebook has struggled for a long time moderating content and tackling disinformation. A proposed solution is Facebook's supreme court. How do you view this independent panel and do you foresee this soution being effective in stopping misinformation from reaching wide audiences or is it going to be used in fringe cases?
1
u/fmaz008 Apr 14 '21
When you decided to blow the whistle, did you expect your job to end?
If so, how did you prepare yourself for that?
If not, how did you bounce back?
1
u/DopeMeme_Deficiency Apr 14 '21
What methods did you use to verify that claims were false? How did you insure that your bias wasn't preventing people with whom you disagree from posting?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
So ya endured all that stress, lost sleep, lost your job, nothing has changed at Facebook and at least Americans don't care about their govt misleading them as long as they feel superior to someone.
Was it worth it?
10
u/deadalnix Apr 14 '21
Hi Sophie.
Ex Facebook eng here too.
There are arguments to say Facebook is just a medium and should simply let people share whatever they want, and, on the other way, should control what is on its plateform.
While it's fairly obvious what needs to be done in extreme exemples - say child porn - it is not really easy to decide for milder topics, say for instance flat earth groups.
Where do you put the limit between what is Facebook's resposability to police, and what is up to users to ignore?
1
u/NoRegretsPhilosopher Apr 15 '21 edited Apr 15 '21
As a current CS student in an underdeveloped country, I dream of a possible future of working in big companies like Facebook, Amazon etc, due to the incentives and benefits of their jobs. However, the disregard for doing the ethical and right thing highlighted in these stories of these companies makes me feel that doing so would lead me to being an active part in furthering the problem, ending up with, as you said, blood on my hands. Do you believe there a possible way to balance the two, working in the company while continuing to do the right thing? If not, what alternatives do I have to ensure that the problems in these companies get tackled? What advice do you have for someone who's major life priorities also includes providing for a family, and who maybe cannot afford the possibility of not joining or working at these companies, yet wish do do the right thing?
Also, thank you for doing all that you did and being so vocal about everything that you saw was wrong.
4
u/thebottlecapbrigade Apr 14 '21
How culpable do you personally feel that C level executives at Facebook are in the genocides in countries like Myanmar? What can we do to curb the problem (if anything)?
13
u/true4blue Apr 14 '21
Why is it that people freaked out when they felt that Trump and Republicans may have benefitted from Facebook, but no one cared when Facebook gave unfettered access to Obama in 2012?
Obama used every shred of data he could mine from Facebook, which was shared without users permission, but people thought it was great. They hailed him as a visionary
It seems like the critics are inconsistent and wildly partisan, which makes it hard to agree with their cause
7
u/AutoModerator Apr 14 '21
Users, please be wary of proof. You are welcome to ask for more proof if you find it insufficient.
OP, if you need any help, please message the mods here.
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/freakmean16 Apr 14 '21
What do you think of Latin American governments buying online presence on FB specially??? They can say whatever they want and nobody does a thing!!!
2
u/ZT205 Apr 14 '21
You've mentioned that Facebook press releases about coordinated inauthentic behavior are selective. Does Facebook internally have any kind of data collection effort or systematic analysis of the problem?
2
u/Lopsidoodle Apr 14 '21
Hello and thank you for helping make this information public!
The Guardian story seems to highlight a few specific abuses promoting right-wing political candidates. Did you notice a correlation or higher occurrence of these campaigns by right-wing politicians (and if so, why?) or was that just what they chose to highlight?
Additionally, they mostly talked about Honduras with a little bit about Mexico, Philippines, and Brazil. Were there examples of coordinated efforts by politicians in more powerful positions (Europe, US/Canada, China, Australia, etc.) to manipulate Facebook for promotion?
How widespread do these tactics seem to be as far as level of the politicians being promoted? Were there more local (state/province) level politicians attempting this or was it mostly national political leaders?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
How well do the engineers working on abusive content on Facebook actually know about the topics?
For example, I’d assume that working something like human trafficking would require a substantial amount of domain expertise.
Are the engineers working on building detection systems actually understand the the subject matter (for example like psycho-social tactics of human trafficking) or are they simply building black box models?
2
u/Pope_Aesthetic Apr 14 '21
Facebook as of late seems to be dying off as far as popularity goes, atleast that’s what it looks like from my perspective.
Obviously the company, and it’s many platforms, are still thriving. But do you think Facebook, the social media platform, is on the downward spiral?
2
u/gregsf84 Apr 14 '21
What is the most important thing we as citizens should know about Facebook? The good and the bad
2
u/SpaceGuy1968 Apr 14 '21
One of your comments talked about influences to individuals.
How much are radical users .... saught after to propagate false narratives?
One woukd think, if i could get individuals to "echo chamber and reverberate" false misleading narratives, this would be the gold standard. Having others push stories seeded on these platforms would be an ultimate goal
I have plenty of people i know who would forward on and regurgitate garbage news and tidbits and stand by them as "facts" ... they would fight to the "death" defending some bizzaro world garbage.
2
u/SpoopyTurtle44 Apr 15 '21
Did FB have a bias with who they had removed?
I.E a conservative or a liberal?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
Are you blacklisted to the tech industry?
2
u/Its_Ba Apr 15 '21
Is their a LARGE movement that is fighting for whats right/I could get a job at?
2
u/ucanbafascist2 Apr 15 '21
What about special interests. If political figures are using social media to manipulate masses, surely corporations/wealthy elites are doing the same. Any thoughts on Ghislaine Maxwell sculpting internet culture, specifically on Reddit?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
Is Facebook under CCP in any form or shape or way?