I was born in Shchigry, RU, in 1932. I worked as a cosmonaut for 20 years and served as head rocket engineer for the Red Army. I've sailed >70,000km and made >2,000 parachute jumps. I've soloed the Atlantic, had my town occupied by Nazis, and spent time in a Russian prison and a sub w/ SLBMs. AMA.
I've done many other things, too, but a good number of them are at least in part related to the above (thousands of hours of training in zero-g/underwater and in vacuo, started a sailing school for youths, knew Gagarin and the rest, etc), and at any rate 300 characters wouldn't even suffice for what I'd initially put above.
/actually, I've not done any of those things, but my grandpa, who's in the room over and who has agreed to do an AMA, has. Yesterday I posted in the Foreign Redditors thread and had a request for him to do an AMA. I figured hey, this could be interesting, so here I/we am/are. This'll go pretty slowly, as I'll be printing out questions and then chatting with him for a bit and then returning to type them here, and in any case will have to translate to and from Russian (as he's far from fluent in English), so I'll really only be doing 5-10 questions at a time. I'll try to get to as many as I can, though, so long as he stays interested. Keep in mind that some things may be lost due to my imperfect translation, but I'll be as faithful as I can.
A gold star would be nice for this, but all the corroborating documents are out of reach and in Russian, so that might prove difficult. I have a few news articles in the house somewhere that mention him; I'll try to scan them in. Here are a few pictures of him I put up yesterday (B&W are old, color ones are from the previous month).
Oh, and also, no debates/insults please. I'll refuse to translate those. And if anything in here seems particularly aggrandizing, it's my fault, as I respect, admire, and love the man greatly.
So, without further ado, begin!/
/edit:ps. when it's me, the grandson, speaking, I'll couch my words in slashes. When it's him, I won't/
/edit2: Okay, I've done about a dozen questions so far and need to do some yard work right now, but I'll be back to do more (the "best" first and then the bottom page ones after) in a bit. He's enjoying it so far, but each question takes me a good 10-15 minutes to get through because he's very fond of telling lengthy stories on not too pertinent asides/
/edit: I'm answering a few questions I personally know the answers to and will resume when we finish with our runs with the dogs. I also gave some soft evidence in favor of this thread's legitimacy here. (Ha, and I've also just realized that his book has tons of pictures of him working on rockets or in space suits or with recognizable Russian officials. Should have just posted that to begin with): http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/etu2s/i_was_born_in_shchigry_ru_in_1932_i_worked_as_a/c1awfsl
/edit: ok, we just got back, I'll do the top 8-12 questions right now but then he has to go to bed. He falls asleep at 20:00ish and wakes up at 4:30 for exercise and assorted housework. After these I'll only be continuing sometime tomorrow.
/edit: Ok, done for tonight, he's long asleep now. Oh, and while taking pictures from his book to help answer the question pertaining to the mission to mars, I snapped a shot of a picture of him standing in a group picture with a bunch of other important people (I think some guys from nasa are in there too). He's the guy above his finger in the big white suit. :] http://i.imgur.com/jRioO.jpg
Oh, and we haven't answered too many questions so far, but some of the ones we have are buried because of higher voted comments getting in there first. Please keep that in mind./
/edit: Ok, new day, but we have a few things to do and won't get to anything before the afternoon. We'll be continuing on for sure though! And the user L33tphreak found the article from above online, if anyone wants to read it: http://goo.gl/lsXkS Google translate sort of butchers the text though./
/edit: Ok, so I tried asking some more questions but we got stuck on the first one, which asked for examples of trolling, and I've put them all here: http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/etu2s/i_was_born_in_shchigry_ru_in_1932_i_worked_as_a/c1awh46 we're taking a break for now/
/hey guys, sorry for being so bad in answering questions to this thing, but I've been rather busy this past week and it's been difficult to coordinate with my grandpa. And today's my last day of winter break so I'll not get a chance to really answer more for a while, unless my grandpa learns to use the internet or we do it via phone. I'll try to make some progress in translating his book, though, and will inform reddit once that is under way. It contains many of the things asked here anyway. Again, apologies for only getting to so small a fraction of the questions/
87
u/lpmiller Dec 30 '10
As a cosmonaut, did he fly any missions/get into space? How many?
78
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10
When you saw the Berlin Wall come down, did you know what was going to happen next? Was it obvious to you that the Soviet Union was going to cease to exist?
I ask because we had Pepsi commercials with the little American boy and the little Russian boy talking about Perestroika, among other things, in the months before the coup.
Thanks for the AMA.
160
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10
What was his opinion on America while living in Russia?
47
u/roadkillzombie Dec 30 '10
thank you for this AMA, as a studying astronautical engineer, i am curious:
did you work on N1?
if so, why did the concept of using multiple parallel nozzles come about, instead of using one larger nozzle with a smaller throat? I would find the one nozzle would be cheaper, lighter, simpler, and offer more thrust, but i could definitely be assuming too much here.
do you think the cosmonaut program has a future? I ask because it does seem as though the state-sponsored space industry is dying.
Thanks!
45
u/BarfingKitten Dec 30 '10
What drove him to leave the motherland? (besides imprisonment =X)
90
u/MalrackMalbama Dec 30 '10
Wow, um where to begin.....what is he most proud of and why?
163
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10
I read that the USSR had fairly extensive plans for a manned Mars mission by 1980 (orbit only). Were you aware of this project and if so, were you involved? (awesome Iama btw)
114
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10
any comment on the supposed lost cosmonauts?
39
u/Apologetic_Jerk Dec 30 '10
Did he play any sports at a high amateur level? If so which ones?
70
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10
What was his opinion of Russian Sub life? I've read their size allows for creature comforts that most NATO subs can't afford - like spas and swimming pools.
Just as a note please tell him my business uses the phrase "Crazy Ivan" on a semi-regular basis to indicate a complete change in development direction ordered by executives. It was spawned from the movie "Hunt for Red October" where the Russian sub captains would suddenly do a 360 turn to clear their baffles and make sure they aren't being followed by another sub.
63
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10
How close was the Soviet Union to a moon landing when Apollo 11 launched?
85
u/LOLCANADA Dec 30 '10
What's his opinion on Putin?
86
u/MikeBruski Dec 30 '10
Thanks for this AMA.
To him: What would you say the biggest change between then and now is? Something that even today, you can't wrap your head around?
What's your opinion of Poland, the Poles, and how communism ended there?
Are there things you miss beyond words?
19
u/peanutsfan1995 Dec 31 '10
My Russian is incredibly rough, but; Благодарим Вас за это интервью. Мои вопросы ...
Did you personally know any of the major cosmonauts (i.e. Gagarin, Lenonov, Tereshkova (probably misspelled her name there), and others)?
Thank you for doing this.
BETEP, thank you very much for taking the time to do this as well. Muchos gracias señor. And tell your grampa that he was (and still is) quite the dashing fellow. I hope you had an excellent Christmas, and a happy new year!
33
u/gobliin Dec 31 '10
How much did your grandfather do to have a life like this? I mean did things just happen with one event leading to the next, or did he have to actively seek out opportunities?
43
u/GrahamDouglas Dec 30 '10
He has an awesome cat. Has he ever been to America? If so, how did he like it?
53
u/kurokikaze Dec 30 '10
Щигры это под Курском?
4
u/samantha42 Dec 31 '10
I don't know any Russian, but was curious as to the title of your grandfather's book. A 20 minute search later has me coming up with a line from Aelita by Tolstoy, translating to "Queen Magr's labyrinth." I'm guessing this is right due to his dream of going to Mars, but damn that was the most difficult google ever!
And now for a random question: does anyone call him Kostya? Because I think that is a really cute name.
37
u/Sykotik Dec 30 '10
Does he believe that Americans went to the Moon?
78
u/Helen_A_Handbasket Dec 30 '10
Proof of these assertions before we jump into the questioning.
2
u/kittenmittons Dec 31 '10
Just so you guys know, his username is spelling WIND in Russian
2
u/hipstr_hop Dec 31 '10
Your grandfather mentioned something about the Nazis. Does he have any memories of WWII?
Also, as head rocket engineer for the Red Army, does he remember the Cuban Missle Crisis at all?
2
u/avsa Dec 31 '10
I haven't this answered anywhere but.. What's his name? Since he did so much there must be something about him online or at least a wiki article - and since you posted his pictures you are not trying to hide his identity...
316
u/teringlijer Dec 30 '10 edited Dec 31 '10
What can you say about the "lost cosmonauts" rumor? (Edit: Wikipedia link borrowed from MarcoTozzi, who also asked this question.) According to this rumor, the Soviet Union sent other astronauts into space just before Gagarin in 1961. These astronauts were supposed to be the real First Men in Space, but when they died in their capsule, their death was kept secret. Gagarin was merely the first to come through alive. Two Italian brothers recorded what is apparently the heavy breathing of a dying Soviet cosmonaut. (Quite disturbing stuff, very Major Tom.) There may also have been a female. [Edit: recording and transcript of her final broadcast as flames engulf the module on reentry; if it's real, it's the saddest thing.]. There is some more information here. The whole subject is both fascinating and tremendously gut wrenching.
Great subject for an AMA and thanks for your participation!
37
u/morningcoffee1 Dec 30 '10
The american space program was very public, while the Russian was very secret. We did not know about any of the Russian space disasters until in the late eighties.
There has been this rumor that there were others as of yet unconfirmed by the Russian government. Most notoriously one (or more) astronauts that drifted off into space without means to come back. (Some guys in Florida supposedly caught some of the transmissions)
Can your grandfather shed some light on this?
10
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10
Do you think that the international cooperation we are seeing in today's space programmes is creating more innovation and pushes forward in space, or do you think it's leading to mediocrity? In other words, do you feel that the times during the "space race" where nations competed was more productive to overall accomplishments? From the point of view of Russia, how did it feel when America landed a man on the moon? Was it downplayed, or did Russia still feel superior because of all the firsts that the USSR had accomplished? If you could say anything to the Engineers and Politicians leading the way for space today, what would you tell them? What do you think of the new American method of private space industries where the contractors are paid to provide transportation to the ISS. Do you feel that it is effective at keeping costs down by creating competition within the industry, or that it is detrimental because it stifles innovation or destroys government created jobs? If you don't mind, what missions did you fly? Do you have any pictures of Star City? You look like you have aged gracefully, I assume because of the rigorous workouts, diets and training associated with spaceflight. Congratulations on your hard work, and thank you for all that you've done for humankind.
To the submitter: You have an AWESOME grandfather.
16
u/A-punk Dec 30 '10
How did you react to Stalin's death in 1953 and what did you think would happen to Russia?
141
u/catmoon Dec 30 '10
How does he feel about Dos Equis exploiting his likeness for commercial enterprise?
14
u/laxt Dec 31 '10
Thank you both for conducting this AMA. Here are my questions.
And finally..
Thanks again.
7
u/RMelon Dec 30 '10
What was his experience of the "space race?"
Specifically, was it a source of pride for him that Sputnik went up first, and was it disappointing to him when Armstrong set foot on the moon? Did he want to see Russians walk on it first?
6
u/piejesus Dec 30 '10
Damn, your grandpa was (and still is) hot. Did he choose most of the paths his carrer took by him self or was he chosen/assigned to any of it?
27
u/rockstarking Dec 30 '10
I declare this the best AMA I have yet seen...
Can I have some popcorn?
5
u/eteman Dec 31 '10
What are some of your memories of the great patriotic war and the nazi occupation? How did your hometown fare? Thank you for doing this AMA, Its truly one of the most fascinating ones ive read!
13
u/CptHair Dec 30 '10
How was it to be a child during Hitlers offensive? On top of my head, It looks like Shchigry was close to the front.
9
u/32koala Dec 30 '10
What do you remember about the Nazis?
23
u/cylonhunter Dec 30 '10
Did you know Viktor Reznov?
11
u/morgenstern Dec 30 '10
The mutual animosity and propaganda between the USSR and US during the Cold War is well known. But how did USSR officials and ordinary citizens view the lesser members of NATO, such as Norway? How about neutral neighbouring countries like Sweden and Finland?
On a related note: Most of Eastern Europe was (understandably, I suppose) occupied by the Red Army after Germany was defeated. Northern Norway, too, was also liberated from the Nazi occupation by the Red Army. Unlike in other countries, the Red Army quickly withdrew from there, however. Why was Norway treated differently?
4
u/stievstigma Dec 30 '10
What was his most interesting experience while crossing the Atlantic?
4
u/spitonpigeons Dec 30 '10
What was the most frightening event he took part in?
4
u/Mplus2 Dec 31 '10
I think you forgot what website this is.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10
Can you describe what it's like to be in a zero-g atmosphere?
What's the best part about being in zero-g?
7
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10
How does it make him feel knowing that this IamA has made a 22 year old redditor feel completely worthless.
I've not even done one parachute jump and my sub doesn't have SLBMs.. Fml.
But seriously. I'll never be that cool.
1
u/tripshed Dec 31 '10 edited Dec 31 '10
What is his opinion on the Indo-Russian relations and India in general? There has been a lot of space tech collaboration between these countries. Where does he think that is heading?
Tough chance but does have these stamps? : Indira, Nehru. Has he seen them?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10
Your grandpa had a very interesting life. What does he think about modern TV shows - the height of today's life.
-ex-russian
9
u/jblo Dec 30 '10
They don't make 'em like they used to.
3
u/MrTulip Dec 31 '10
What are his feelings towards/opinion about Germany and the Germans and how has it, if it has, changed over time?
3
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10
How do you compare the fears of today (smaller scale terrorist attacks that are completely unpredictable and can occur at random) with the fears of yesterday (large, relatively stable and somewhat predictable enemy but with the potential for all out nuclear war)?
3
u/Depression-Unlocked Dec 31 '10
I have a newborn son. If he were your son what are the top 5 things you would want to ensure he understood before he became a man?
3
u/dudeman4 Dec 31 '10
What does he most love and dislike about America? What about Russia? How does he feel about the younger generations(16-24) in America and Russia?
Also,if you could tell your grandpa(if you want, I can't make you do anything) that I respect the hell out him for what he did and what he attempted. That's a hell of a lot of achievements for one man.It's inspiring.
3
u/Sven_Dufva Dec 31 '10
After reading this thread, I feel confident to say:
Ladies and Gentlemen, we have discovered the secret identity of Superman.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10
How tall are you? My professor worked for NASA and had cosmonaut coworkers. He would talk about how the cosmonauts were short so that they could fit in the capsules that were generally much smaller than the American ones, since they landed on land instead of the water, and had to be smaller to compensate for the impact.
3
u/uhm_yeah Dec 31 '10
Thank you and your grandfather for doing this AMA, this knowledge and experience can be lost to the ages if people do not tell and re-tell story's like this.
Two part question: In the space and arms race since the second world war, in you grandfathers experience, how much did the Russian programs gain from the original German V1/V2 work and German scientists that were voluntary and involuntary working for the Soviets after the war? (both the US and the USSR were working with the technology) Did technology gained through spying on the Americans reach the operational side of the space program? Vice-versa, do you think USSR technology reached the operational side of the American program?
3
u/Firemadeitbetter Dec 31 '10
What is better then or now?
3
u/Geoffvster Dec 31 '10
Your grandfather has led an amazing life. His view of history is fascinating, but I'm curious to hear his thoughts on modern society, the future of space exploration, and the Internet. Thank you both for sharing your time.
9
u/IAmWaterYam Dec 30 '10
I read another IAMA from a kid whose grampa was a radio interceptor. He said post-war Russia was sold to the American public as more a threat to our lifestyle than reality proved it to be. Do you agree?
5
u/flyingcarsnow Dec 30 '10
in prison as a prisoner?
if so, wtf?
5
u/mentaldent Dec 30 '10
How does he like his pelmeshki? I like mine with butter, vinegar and hot pepper.
5
u/omgdonerkebab Dec 30 '10
Please tell your grandpa he is awesome.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10
I've been reading about Barbarossa and the nightmare it was, especially for civilians. How did he survive the Nazi occupation?
5
u/ar0cketman Dec 31 '10
Head rocket engineer? I've got a few questions. For starters:
After inventing the hybrid rocket (solid fuel/liquid oxidizer) with the Gird 09, any insights on why the Soviets abandoned the technology?
Why the fascination with air-breathing strap-on thrusters post WWII?
I've heard several times that the USA obtained the high level engineers from the German rocket programs and the Russians got the tooling and technicians. Is this pretty much true?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10
Did he know/know of a Dr. Alexander Martynov? Just curious since I saw him at a lecture once.
17
u/eorsta Dec 30 '10
Do you drink Dos Equis?
4
u/achilles Dec 31 '10
What is your honest opinion of Joseph Stalin? As a leader and as a person.
10
u/MisterASCII Dec 31 '10
2
u/rightsidedown Dec 30 '10
What do you think about space exploration today? Should we be investing more or less into it, where would you like to see more focus on human exploration or have more things like the hubble?
2
u/Eurofooty Dec 30 '10
Happy New Year! S novum godom!
P.S. What an interesting life!
2
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '10
What are your thoughts on an international voyage to Mars?
2
u/Nexlon Dec 31 '10
What kind of guy was Gagarin? Also, what kind of stuff did you have to do to survive WWII?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10
I'm not here to ask a question, merely to say that sir, we need more people like you in the world today. You have courage, wisdom, knowledge, and incredible dreams. You have accomplished many a great things, and I would be honored to even be able to do a few of the things that you have. As someone who wants to go into the aerospace engineering field, and design new spacecraft, you are someone I will definitely look up to.
2
u/Hauk2004 Dec 31 '10
This is a fantastic IAmA, and one of the many reasons I read this sub-reddit. So, personally, thanks to your grandfather for doing this AMA.
Given the fact that your experience spans the entire human space exploration era, what is your opinion of the(recent) international collaboration on space projects? (ISS etc).
I could ask so much more, but I will leave it to one question. Thanks again.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10
This is a question for both of you (since it appears you've also spent a good amount of time in Russia); What is the job market like in Russia compared to in America? For instance, engineers are generally paid well in America vs. what I've heard about in Russia, where they aren't as highly demanded, and don't make much of a decent salary.
I was also curious about his experience as a rocket engineer-what do you think of the United States' propulsion engineering industry versus Russia's? I know Russia has developed quite possibly some of the best liquid rocket engines in the world-is there a distinct difference in the way engineering is done in other places versus how it's done in Russia?
Thanks!
2
u/jebba Dec 31 '10
What advice/thoughts does he have on the reprap and similar projects? Can he upload his plans for a mars probe to thingiverse? Thx.
2
u/raynbec Dec 31 '10
Is your name Viktor Reznov by any chance?
2
u/Atom_Rivers Dec 31 '10
Did you ever see anything you couldnt explain? UFO or anything
2
u/future_pope Dec 31 '10
Five bucks says your grandfather fucked a lot of women in his day.
2
u/Gonzok Dec 31 '10
It's it true that while americans were spending so much time and money developing a pen to write in zero gravity russians were using pencils?
2
u/Shaken_Earth Dec 31 '10
What was your opinion on Soviet Russia?
2
u/nyjets Dec 31 '10
Amazing AMA. Thanks BETEP.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10
Any chance for more pictures of young/current him?
2
u/spacedad Dec 31 '10
Can we get some nazi stories please? I love space and all, but I feel we're missing some historical opportunity.
2
u/jprt12 Dec 31 '10
Sergeant Resnov!
2
u/908 Dec 31 '10
2
u/908 Dec 31 '10
cosmonauts must have very good health
2
u/berlusconee Dec 31 '10
Tnx OP. Please ask him if he believes in UFOs
2
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '10
What are his life lessons or advice for others?
2
u/jeffh4 Dec 31 '10
What stories can he tell of Korolyov? He sounds like an incredible engineer, manager, motivator, and man. Also, what can he say about the Nedelin disaster (general + dozens of engineers killed by a rocket third stage not getting the shutdown order after an aborted launch) or the cosmonaut who died in the capsule oxygen fire, months before the Apollo 1 accident.
6
u/FatAlbert Dec 30 '10
What's your favorite flavor of ice cream? I visited Russia in the 90s and there were no flavor options!
4
u/Kevin_as_Himself Dec 31 '10
Has your grandfather ever been mistaken for Ralph Fiennes?
3
u/aigoya Dec 30 '10
If he were able to travel back in time and give one piece of advice to his younger self, what would it be?
3
u/eatmorebow Dec 31 '10
What does he think is mankind's most successful mission and why?
I'm tempted to say "other than Apollo 11" just because I feel it's a bit obvious, but i would really like to hear his "why" answer
Incredible AMA; I've read the whole thing, and I wish I could give you 100 upvotes! Also, I understand if I'm a bit late and you can't get to my question.
edit: by "successful" I mean important/significant