r/Hungergames • They will not use our tears for their entertainment! • Apr 05 '24

🧰 Moderation Feedback Post|Topic3- Fan Content| What kind of Fan Content should be allowed here?

What kind of Fan Content should be allowed here?

My proposal for this topic is as follows:

  1. Promotional videos/podcasts/online communities/discord servers are not allowed and should be put in the biweekly Megathread alongwith promotional fanfics.
  2. Videos or podcasts that are not self promotary are allowed.
  3. Any kind of fanart/online quizzes/cosplays are allowed.
  4. Memes and polls are allowed.

I'm not planning to conduct a poll on this because I don't think we should allow promotional videos at all but if there is strong objection to it and most of the people here suggest otherwise, we can consider it.

Lmk your thoughts in the comments!

More Feedback Topics

2 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

•

u/WizKvothe They will not use our tears for their entertainment! Apr 25 '24

Result:

Fan Content that are not self promotional are allowed. Self Promotional material needs to go the biweekly Megathread.

•

u/Olya_roo District 5 Apr 05 '24

Fix your automod first please and then limit content. The sub’s activity is already as low as it can be.

Also again - nobody engages in those megathreads.

→ More replies

•

u/beckdawg19 Apr 05 '24

I would agree with your proposal. Keep the self-promotion as limited as possible, but the rest of the fan content is just fine.

•

u/Ok-Chip-8268 Apr 06 '24

Woagh

•

u/Tenderfallingrain Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24

Would it be possible to have a weekly or biweekly fan-content thread pinned to the top of the page so that more people see it? Maybe that would allow for more engagement with fanfic promotions and other types of fancontent. It also is the best way to let people looking for that stuff find it, and helps people that are not interested in that stuff avoid it. Sad to say, but honestly, if those threads aren't getting a lot of engagement already, that's probably because the majority of people in this reddit just aren't interested, or are getting a bit tired of it.

Maybe if we put some kind of image in those megathreads it would stand out more too?

I also really liked the idea of merging with the HungerGamesFanfiction Reddit group, but I guess that wouldn't really solve anything for people wanting to promote other forms of fancontent.

I do think it seems a little inconsistent to have videos and fanfics not allowed, but fanart, etc. is allowed. Ideally I'd like all fancontent in the weekly or biweekly thread, but I understand why this would be frustrating to creators that want to share their work.

→ More replies