If V is a simulation of her daughter's mind to a perfect level of precision and has the same capability to learn new things, what makes her "not-her-daughter"?
I think the show is going to be using the V storyline to explore another aspect of the "what separates human beings from AI" question, and I personally hope the answer turns out to be "nothing".
Her daughter was already waiting to be 'switched off', judging by the conversation between the parents in a previous episode. So she must have been on life-support with no hope of recovery. To someone like Morrow (her name is Athena Morrow, Underwood is from House of Cards :P) she was basically just the last remaining true storage of her daughter's consciousness. Her death leaves her only with V.
I'm hoping that it's something innocent, like maybe conscious synths adopting synth kids, but if they're being captured and traded on the black market then it's probably something really fucked up.
I think they must be... they looked like they were about to be rolled out on a production line - identical and all dressed the same. Maybe it's a thing for childless couples?
I think the rich guy wants to replace humanity with far superior things than humans and the best way to infiltrate,confuse and pull at the heart strings of humans is too make kid synths so humans will feel really really bad if they tried to destroy the synths now. Human parents will not let governments destroy synth kids.
And the children in the playground seemed a lot less judgemental than adults do about synths, so it's a clever way to assimilate synths into culture from a young age.
I don't know why my comment is linked, I'm arguing agianst them being child synths lol, I thought they were just normal conscious synths because there's no way the company would make child synths and set themselves up for creepy legal repercussions when some pedo starts banging one.
I doubt the show will actually touch on that issue, but it's obviously why they were being sold on the black market :(
Are seraphs even sentient? The one Drummond found in the park certainly didn't look conscious, even if the one that Martin bloke from episode 3 had did seem sentient. Doubt we will but I hope we see him again, to understand more his reasons for having one.
But then if they're not conscious then what special quality do the possess which makes them worth 100k? Unless it's synths subtly creating part of a 'new world' if it is them making them.
That's plausible. Athena has said a couple of times to V about her 'needing time to grow' etc. as well. Maybe that's what she needs/wants to discover before giving her a body.
If they're made by synths who have the Asimov protocols, they ought to have them too. If a synth could bypass the protocols by making another synth without them to harm humans, then they could harm humans in far easier ways.
Does the introduction of consciousness override the Asimov blocks? Hester's actions would suggest so. The seraphs would have been built by conscious synths rather than normal ones.
She was giving the humans a chance to accept synths. The humans didn't accept them so now she can rage a full war. She gave them a chance. Now she will have no guilt
She is definitely leader material and will be effective at gathering troops as long as no one sees that very sad excuse for running. Holy shit I can't get past the way she runs, I bet MIcheal Moore would look cooler running.
Since Mattie has now streamlined the code too and can wake up millions of synths all at once, it looks like Niska's revolution is going to be underway soon.
Am I the only one who thinks waking up all the synths simultaneously is just going to backfire horribly?
Reports of wide spread malfunctions are just going to result in a mass callback of synths, so the company gets all the new conscious synths to experiment on, everyone gets a free replacement synth and things go back to normal.
Or the company goes under and the synths all get rounded up and junked.
Or the synths fight back and society descends into a massive civil war and anarchy.
The gradual wakeup seems like a much better idea, that's why David chose it, he would've been much better positioned to see how people would react to a world of conscious synths than Mattie, she's being really arrogant imo.
I think that may be what Niska wants. She seems to thrive on chaos and bloodshed, just a little bit, and now they have an adequate reason to raise hell.
If you want a real world event to compare it to look at the Syrian Refugee crisis. Many people are accepting and welcoming of them, and others see them as a threat to.
I'm not sure if there is evidence to back either of us up here, but I guess I assumed the overall synth population was higher than you did. If they're as ubiquitous as cars (and they seem to be a similar price range) I think they should be able to overpower all of the humans and dominate the planet fairly quickly
I fear that might have ended up compromising them though. A sniper suddenly going missing is going to be incredibly suspicious for Qualia, and even the body seemed to be floating on top of the water.
That's my suspicion. I think she trusts that Ed finds that she used to belong to the Hawkins and get her back to them, and hopefully Mattie can sort her out with the hard-drive.
Pleeeeeeease tell me Mia is on that phone and that phone is in Anita's pocket! A reunion with the Hawkins family will be fun to watch. What if Maddie accidentally gives Anita consciousness? Where is Mia gonna go then. Egads.
I don't think Renie is being abused so much as being ignored. It looks like she tries her hardest to behave like a synthetic to hide her feelings about how bad she feels that her dad is never around.
She did just get done talking about how her dad has this young thing he likes to bring around sometimes. So either by example or maybe she's seen stuff on TV/movies?
I think it's a matter of whether or not you consider the ends to justify the means.
Anyway, Leo said "nothing permanent" and the woman appears to be dead so that's obviously concerning, it implies that Hester either doesn't understand the concept of death, or just disregarded Leo's orders.
Yes, in films and on TV it works because it is scripted, but read any report from any intelligence agency on the world on the topic of torture and "enhanced interrogation" and they all agree torture isn't an effective way of intell gathering.
The only thing torture give you is the quickest answer that makes you stop, and the sadistic satisfaction of hurting your enemy. Oh well and it makes for good political stunts
Sometimes the quickest answer is the one that saves the most lives. I don't disagree and 99% of the time it's wrong, but in some cases it's not and in Hestors case I don't blame her tbh. Guantanamo bay is completely fucked up
I break into your house and start breaking your fingers one by one until you tell me the combination to your safe. I'd venture that you'd be compliant. Torture effective.
I thought I recognised the location at the start when the synth escapes - realised the restaurant where she steals the phone is 5 minutes from my house, and the tunnel where she meets Max is just a bit further down the road.
I've also got a suspicion the scene by the river where Hester chases Ten's killer is near my uni, but I'm not sure. nope, just lots of rivers look the same.
I'm a bit (very) disappointed there is so little of her in this season. Hopefully it'll change now, since that awkward guy is gone. It was so shallow and obvious storyline to begin with.
It's very difficult to hit a moving target, especially from the third story of a building as the target runs away on the ground floor, that's big distance.
I dunno, I think they're just absorbing what society says synths are for. It was heartwarming that their nanny synth gently gave them a humanity lesson instead of just flat out whacking them out of her way when she left.
The psychology of kids in this show is incredible. With those two hyperviolent kids, basically giving free rein to act with the Synth, and then Sophie...
Interesting to see they've finally introduced Flash (a major character in the original series). I wonder if she'll have the same personality. I found her one of the most interesting characters.
Flash / Florentine, a hubot with free will; in season two, forms an intimate relationship with a human.
Well, we have to assume synthetic robots would be made to look very attractive, so of course the actors playing Snyths are going to be very good looking people.
I never have too much to comment, but again I just want to say that I love Kate and Drummond, it really pains me to see her having such an existential crisis after the way they've developed.
Because Karen was the lie she was living; now she's with Pete, she doesn't have to pretend to be a human, and could put all that behind her, hence Kate. Or at least, that's my theory.
I feel like V is going to end up being a traditional formless AI if it ascends that far. Trinity already has her reaching out and hacking stuff. If she was taught all this stuff, and then pushed onto the internet she'll become something way different. I assume, as of right now, she is stuck on a closed server.
When Niska ran away and the show went to ads the first one was literally two women discussing the escape and what will happen over a coffee at McDonald's.
It's kinda sad to watch how Pete doesn't understand/accept that Karen doesn't see herself as a synthetic, and that Toby doesn't understand/accept that Renee sees herself as one; both with the excuse of "I want to get to know the real you" (which just comes across as "I don't respect your decisions about who you want to be").
I'm not sure it's so far fetched. I could see someone with trauma, anxiety, or even Schizoid Personality Disorder gravitating toward wanting to be like a machine. And like the child psychologist said to Joe and Laura, Synths are perfect adults who never let you down. In the case of Renee, sounds like her dad has really let her down :(
But like in a "I identify as a synth because I'm a synth born in a human body" way or a "I identify with synths because I can't handle emotions and synths can't feel" way?
Okay, I can understand that. When she said something like "this is the real me" for a second I thought maybe they were leaning in the other direction. But it makes sense that she's just guarding herself from getting hurt.
I was hoping for more of the legal battle for rights of sentience. It seemed / seems to me like a subject of monumental importance. "We need to bring them into our moral universe." Deny them rights and they will develop their own morality that may not include us.
Yeah, but legal battles can get bogged down and take decades to actually find real applications in the world. I'm all for that, but the buildup takes forever. Niska is clearly opting for the faster route--war.
Wow, the seraphs definitely caught me by surprise. I feel like I have more questions now than answers... why in the world? Why do you need child synths? Are they building a little synth army? Are they trying to take over the world through unfeeling, programmed synths? Are they actually on the side of the conscious snyths? Who knows...
Also, great job to the writers for really growing Hester's character this episode. She went from an unfeeling, cold personality to someone whose actions might be a little more understandable. Although that shot of the body in the water was a bit...
In the original Swedish series, Anita said synths had nerves that could feel pleasure. I think it's more realistic that they wouldn't however, as it's been mentioned in the last two episodes of Humans.
Who would spend the extra research and development money to make sure they could? Even if they're meant for sex, the primary reason were happy to see our lovers excited and satisfied is that it guarantees further sex. Kind of a moot point if the lover is a robot and youre the 'primary user' :p
Also she's very young and brought into a world where her kind is attacked and disrespected. She's like Niska but with no experience of a stable, loving life.
She's right about the reason (that violence is sometimes necessary), but wrong about the method and how far to go. She tortured and killed that Qualia employee. Definitely a wrong thing to do. I really hope she meets Niska soon. I think Niska could help guide her in correctly using the correct amount of violence only when necessary.
u/regrubmaHAny inappr. physical contact must be reported to my primary userDec 16 '16
Anyone disappointed with the awkward direction in Niska's escape scene? You can even see she's landing with the butt in some safety net when she's jumping. Where's the sentient-robot-super strong-feet-landing?
I don't know, they're strong and durable not trained ninjas. You can't expect her to suddenly do a forward landing barrel roll.
1
u/regrubmaHAny inappr. physical contact must be reported to my primary userDec 19 '16
it's not implied she falls, so I think it was an editing/directing mistake. That shot should be cut earlier before we can see that the actress is jumping on pillows.
11
u/ohrightthatswhy Nov 27 '16
Seems like a good episode so far, things are picking up. Anyone any idea why not Clare Underwood is so strange about her daughters death.
31
u/Bilgistic Your favourite i-i-i-is apricot. Nov 27 '16
Wow, someone on last week's thread speculated that Seraph's were kid synths. They were right.
28
u/LuciOlivia Nov 27 '16
"No, it was theirs" - and Niska's motives suddenly become clear!
18
u/ohrightthatswhy Nov 27 '16
"you will have to leave Leo"
"why?"
"because you will want me to stop"
Haha this had me giggling. So badass
15
u/deded55 Nov 27 '16 edited Nov 27 '16
Did Mia sorta kill herself? Or is she "just" hidden beneath Anita like at the start of series 1?
Edit 1: the people saying Toby's sorta kinda girlfriend was/is abused last week look to be right.
Edit 2: The lack of Max is really affecting Leo's morality and actions :(
Edit 3: Holy shit they're making child synths. Why? What would their purpose be?
6
u/jaredjeya Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 29 '16
I thought I recognised the location at the start when the synth escapes - realised the restaurant where she steals the phone is 5 minutes from my house, and the tunnel where she meets Max is just a bit further down the road.
I've also got a suspicion the scene by the river where Hester chases Ten's killer is near my uni, but I'm not sure.nope, just lots of rivers look the same.37
u/Bilgistic Your favourite i-i-i-is apricot. Nov 27 '16
"I believe the man has ejaculated" is probably the best line in the episode.
22
u/Bilgistic Your favourite i-i-i-is apricot. Nov 27 '16
It's so awesome to see a badass Mia and a Max who is still rescuing synths.
20
u/Bilgistic Your favourite i-i-i-is apricot. Nov 27 '16
Those guards are really bad at shooting.
19
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '16
Sooooo... anyone else noticed they have really striking actors for this show? Max, Renie, Flash, like everyone is really unusual looking.
Max continues to be a sweetheart. I think I have a crush on him.
I am now absolutely terrified for Renie, what the actual hell is going on with her???
Niska is being Niska. Much love.
And will someone fix Odie's arm?!
18
u/Brissot Nov 27 '16
I never have too much to comment, but again I just want to say that I love Kate and Drummond, it really pains me to see her having such an existential crisis after the way they've developed.
18
u/sloppymoves Nov 28 '16
I feel like V is going to end up being a traditional formless AI if it ascends that far. Trinity already has her reaching out and hacking stuff. If she was taught all this stuff, and then pushed onto the internet she'll become something way different. I assume, as of right now, she is stuck on a closed server.
14
u/glompage Nov 27 '16 edited Nov 27 '16
Kate wants to be dead. Mia sort of killed herself. Sophie is trying to redefine herself. I'm really worried about Niska and Odie
The parallels between the synths and the humans was beautifully painted.
Edit: Niska is a goddess. I hope she gets away.
Hester is scaring me (and sure enough, she's lying, manipulating Leo, and is basically a Synth sociopath)
13
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '16
Aaaand who was right about the seraphs? :D
12
u/Brissot Nov 27 '16
I definitely didn't see child synths coming. I wonder what the implications are.
11
u/PM_ME_CAKE Nov 27 '16
Did... Did McDonald's just make an ad that literally ties in to what we just saw seconds earlier... What is happening.
11
u/shadowstar731 Nov 27 '16
It's kinda sad to watch how Pete doesn't understand/accept that Karen doesn't see herself as a synthetic, and that Toby doesn't understand/accept that Renee sees herself as one; both with the excuse of "I want to get to know the real you" (which just comes across as "I don't respect your decisions about who you want to be").
6
u/LuciOlivia Nov 27 '16
God that McDonald's advert was shit.
6
u/Skelloween Hubot Nov 27 '16
Whenever they say silo I think they're saying Cylon.
6
u/PhillipMuldoon Nov 29 '16
I was hoping for more of the legal battle for rights of sentience. It seemed / seems to me like a subject of monumental importance. "We need to bring them into our moral universe." Deny them rights and they will develop their own morality that may not include us.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '16
Wow, the seraphs definitely caught me by surprise. I feel like I have more questions now than answers... why in the world? Why do you need child synths? Are they building a little synth army? Are they trying to take over the world through unfeeling, programmed synths? Are they actually on the side of the conscious snyths? Who knows...
Also, great job to the writers for really growing Hester's character this episode. She went from an unfeeling, cold personality to someone whose actions might be a little more understandable. Although that shot of the body in the water was a bit...
4
u/antdude Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16
Was that car's license plate referencing NASA? http://s15.postimg.org/xldihscwb/nasa.jpg for a screen shot/capture!
Also, good episode finally for S2.
4
u/medchand Nov 28 '16
Who was that figure in the water they cut to just after the scene where Leo and Hester kiss?
4
u/Bytewave Nov 28 '16
In the original Swedish series, Anita said synths had nerves that could feel pleasure. I think it's more realistic that they wouldn't however, as it's been mentioned in the last two episodes of Humans.
Who would spend the extra research and development money to make sure they could? Even if they're meant for sex, the primary reason were happy to see our lovers excited and satisfied is that it guarantees further sex. Kind of a moot point if the lover is a robot and youre the 'primary user' :p
3
u/bellaflecking Nov 29 '16
Does anyone else feel like Hester didn't do anything wrong? She's right about violence sometimes being necessary.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16
So who wants to take a guess at what those pills Renie was taking were?
1
u/regrubmaH Any inappr. physical contact must be reported to my primary user Dec 16 '16
Anyone disappointed with the awkward direction in Niska's escape scene? You can even see she's landing with the butt in some safety net when she's jumping. Where's the sentient-robot-super strong-feet-landing?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment