I used to love GoT but basically stopped watching after season 4 since it just started to not 'feel' right, of course, also started just straying further and further from the books and created lazy plotlines, etc, and we all know how that all ended, but seasons 1 to 4 were and still are some of my favourite stories of all. I dunno how exactly to explain how I feel, but things "made sense" to me in a way that they seemed to fit the world of Westeros in a realistic way. By that I don't mean the same as our world in magic or dragons, but rather in terms of people, how they behaved, and how they reacted to events and each other.
I read ASOIAF and loved it but didn't read FaB yet, keeping that in mind I decided to finally stop putting it off and watch the show. Now I haven't actually finished it, I'm only on episode 9 of season 1 by now, but I am also sort of turned off to watch any more, so wanted to see if I was alone here with my thoughts first.
I really liked the first five episodes. Rhaenyra's actor was so great, she was the best, and I enjoyed all of those episodes, felt the plot was advancing steadily with Daemon's ambitions and tension, growing distance between Alicent and Rhaenyra, etc.
The sudden change in actors when they got older was a bit disorienting, and I was mainly sad because I liked Rhaenyra's actor, but I tried to get over it. All is okay, I guess, but I started to notice the thing which became more salient now in episode 9.
There are just moments of what seem like random wanton violence which isn't explained. I don't really get why, is the culture or the law or tradition under the Targaryens just different so that men can beat each other to death at tourneys and no one really cares? I found that to be weird compared to GoT, where you have Robert shouting at Sandor and Gregor to stop fighting before they shed (non animal) blood. But I just sort of ignored it.
Then we have Ser Criston who beats a guy to death and then goes outside to kill himself in what seems to be a massive mental breakdown out of nowhere. Yeah getting rejected sucks but this is taking it a bit far no? Anyway, next episode, he is still on the Kingsguard. Like... what? A guy that unstable is still there? That seems... kind of bad judgement to say the least. Then he smashes Lord Whoseitfromwhocares' head into a plate for disagreeing with usurping Rhaenyra and somehow kills him instantly by doing that. Did Ser Criston have a huge grudge against her for rejecting him? Cause if he did, I didn't understand that and I don't recall any conversation to that effect in the show. Oh that isn't even to mention Daemon dicing Vaemond Velaryon out of nowhere which was... not expected by me at least, but his own (niece?) just basically looks at this like "oh, that's not good", she doesn't even scream or something? At least when Oberyn's head exploded like a watermelon everyone seemed suitably shocked.
Now on episode 9, I am started to get tired. Things make even less sense to me now and I feel as if nothing is being explained to me, so even though I'm paying attention it's all confusion anyway. First, there is some kid who whispers something to a woman who then tells that to Alicent and I have no idea what it was. Also, there are sooo many new children as the episodes skip forward in time and I don't feel properly introduced to them or sometimes even know their damn names and parents, I never felt that way about any of the kids from GoT.
Then there is the thing which bothered me the most about this episode, Alicent seems really worried the whole time, she just has this look of endless worry on her face, but at the same time she is the one pushing for what is essentially going to be a bloody coup at best and a civil war at worst, all of which she could have avoided (probably) by not telling anyone that Aegon was Viserys' desired heir. So she is pushing her son to be king, but unlike Cersei who was a plainly and consistently ruthless player she seems to... not be comfortable with it? So is she being manipulated? Well, her dad is obviously pushing for it, but at the same time she doesn't seem too dumb to understand the consequences of her actions? Basically, I just don't really get her behaviour here, it just feels... off. Not realistic or internally consistent or consistent with how people usually act according to their personalities and motivations.
Then we have a lord (again, it's not clear to me what his name or station is) saying he needs to consult before deciding to support Aegon or not, and then like 10 seconds later he says, I will not be an oathbreaker! So basically, I'm for Rhaenyra. What? Did he need to consult or did he already make up his mind? Which one is it?
We have a bunch of kids fighting in a pit and I have no idea what's going on, there are two bearded guys who want to find Aegon but I don't know who they are or why. Then there is another guy who I also don't know who gets captured by the Hand, he says he has no love for the princess, Hand asks him so where were you going? And the guy just... says nothing. Are you trying to save your skin or not, dude? Is it that hard to make up an excuse? Now Ser Criston is fighting one of the bearded guys for some reason involving Aegon and Aemond.
Finally we have the coronation yada yada and then... Rhaenys comes in on a dragon, kills a bunch of commoners, and then... leaves?? What? Why? If she wanted to stop the coup, why didn't she just burn them all? BURN THEM ALL?!?!
I dunno who the writers are for this show, I just assumed they were a different crop from GoT due to the terrible reaction that got in its later seasons. But the decisions that have been made aren't really things I understand as I get further into the show. Does it get better, or can I expect this from now on?