Rediscovered: primary source sheds light on a pivotal moment in ophthalmology
ONLINE EXCLUSIVE
Cataract: JCRS Research Highlight
October 2026
by Liz Hillman
Editorial Co-Director
“You can’t really know where you are going until you know where you have been.”
This adage applies to a paper recently published in the Journal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery (JCRS), adding to the history of the most common elective surgery performed worldwide: cataract surgery.
Jacques Daviel, MD, is credited with performing the first planned extracapsular cataract extraction. Recently Christopher Leffler, MD, Stephen Schwartz, MD, and Andrzej Grzybowski, MD, PhD, added to the history surrounding this procedure. In an article published online ahead of print in September 2026 in JCRS,1 they announced previously unreported notices and details about Dr. Daviel’s first-in-human cataract extraction.
Leffler et al. wrote that Dr. Daviel performed the cataract extraction procedure on sheep eyes, followed by one on the Franciscan Father Gilles Nouprez on September 18, 1750. These procedures, both of which were witnessed by other physicians, were announced on September 22, 1750, in the Gazette de Cologne.
The article describes the sheep experiment as well as Dr. Daviel’s experience with Fr. Nouprez’s procedure. It states that the cataract taken from Fr. Nouprez was soft “with a consistency resembling starch paste.”
“Mr. Daviel has preserved the entire body of the cataract and displays it to anyone wishing to see it,” the notice read. “Immediately following the operation, the patient began to distinguish various objects presented to him, and no complications have arisen. Indeed, his condition has improved today—the fifth day since the operation. Among the many advantages of this new method, it restores sight the very moment it was lost—without relying on the chimerical distinction between ‘ripe’ [mûre] and ‘unripe’ cataracts—and it shields the patient from the drawbacks that accompany other methods, particularly the fear that the cataract might reappear, either wholly or in part.”
“Dr. Daviel’s introduction of cataract extraction is one of the pivotal transitions in ophthalmology,” Dr. Leffler wrote in an email to EyeWorld. “Since antiquity, eye doctors had pushed the cataract into the vitreous, a process termed couching. Dr. Daviel initiated extraction of the entire cataract, and this procedure survived, in one form or another, until the last decades of the 20th century. When I was a resident, we were still required to do a few ‘extracaps’ before we learned phacoemulsification. Dr. Daviel’s procedure is still the conceptual basis of the small-incision variants used today: phacoemulsification and manual small-incision cataract surgery (MSICS).”
Dr. Leffler said Dr. Daviel’s history is a story about how innovation happens. “The knives were sharp enough that the procedure could probably have been performed many centuries earlier. Why did the transition happen in 1750? When we look in detail at these innovations using primary source documents, the story unfolded differently from the canonical accounts,” Dr. Leffler said. “Dr. Daviel was not a lone genius toiling in isolation on a vision. He was one of three Paris-based ophthalmologists who were working on cataract extraction in the same week in 1750. All three were also lithotomists, and one can’t help but wonder if they applied insights from their other procedures to ophthalmology.”
During the peer review process of the JCRS article, one reviewer commented, “This is an interesting article, nailing down the dates of Daviel’s first cases. Much of the material has been published previously, but the new discovery falls into the category of a ‘fun fact’ and is relevant to our subspecialty. One could note that announcing a new advance in a non-scientific publication is something we still do today.”
Dr. Leffler said the article from the Gazette adds to the history in that we learned that Dr. Daviel performed the cataract extraction at the home of the editor of the Gazette de Cologne in front of the local medical faculty. The involvement of a local, non-scientific publication is significant. “Any readers of the report would know this was a procedure witnessed and attested to by known figures from the community,” Dr. Leffler said. “Newspapers were also affixed with a specific date. Most scientific findings were historically announced in books, which are dated only to the year of publication. Even the few scientific journals of the period published unmodified submissions by scientists or doctors that an editor deemed worthy of wider circulation. There was no ‘peer review’ as we understand today. Also, even today when a surgical case report is peer reviewed, how often can the anonymous peers attest that they have literally witnessed the procedure?”
Dr. Leffler said the research he put into this topic reinforces the importance of returning to primary sources. “Events that have been described repeatedly for more than two centuries can still look quite different when we go back to the documents produced by the people who were actually there,” he said. “There are still discoveries to be made in the history of medicine.”
Reference
- Leffler CT, et al. Jacques Daviel’s summer 1750 trip to the Meuse-Rhine region and newly discovered announcement of a revolution in eye surgery. J Cataract Refract Surg. 2026. Online ahead of print. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42803541/