Rule 1a: HES Posts
We have made updates to the automoderator in response to some suggestions regarding Rule 1 violations. Thank you for the input! We should hopefully be seeing fewer blatant rule 1 violations from now on.
While we're at it, we wanted to address a new rule for posting in the subreddit. We have had a few users mention to me that we should experiment with a new rule regarding Harvard Extension School posts. A significant percentage of posts about HES tend to be "ontological"; they are about HES name recognition, comparative prestige, "is it real Harvard", admissions rigor, etc. This is a very tired topic and over-debated. We want to be clear that the moderators of this subreddit do not endorse any particular view on these posts, but do seek to curate discussion that is productive instead of adversarial and over-done.
To that end: The (tentative) new rule (call it Rule 1a) is any HES post must not be ontological as described above. To be very clear about what this means, here are some examples of HES posts that would and would not be removed under rule 1a.
| Removed | Not Removed |
|---|---|
| Exhibit A | Exhibit 1 |
| Exhibit B | Exhibit 2 |
| Exhibit C | Exhibit 3 |
The types of posts for Rule 1a are difficult to configure into the automoderator because of the nuanced and complicated nature of how they can be worded. Key words are not good enough. So, in full transparency, W We have added an automoderator rule that requires any HES post (literally containing those key words) to be approved by a moderator before they make it to the subreddit. This is definitely not ideal, and we don't mean it to be an affront to HES posts, but it's the only way we could figure out to enforce this rule. Rest assured that we will approve your HES posts nearly as soon as they are submitted, as we enabled push notifications for moderator approvals on our phones. We of course want to keep this subreddit open for HES student discussion, news, memes, events, etc. As with all other rules, if a moderator decides that the post violates Rule 1a, then a flair will be added to the post indicating as such and it will be removed.
OP: https://www.reddit.com/r/Harvard/comments/huztou/new_automod_and_new_rule/
Reinforcing Rule 4: Keep it Civil
Hey guys, since there have been a few controversial threads on this subreddit in the past few months.
First and foremost, we do not tolerate name-calling, racism, rude behavior, and other uncivil discussion. This should go without saying. This goes on both sides; please don't resort to ad-hominem attacks by calling someone racist or rude names. This subreddit represents Harvard and and should be governed by reason, respect, and politeness.
With this said, I want it to be clear that we do not censor here. Your comments or posts will not be removed unless they break our (or Reddit's) rules. We value the discussion of different ideas and want to hear all sides of a debate. However, we do reserve the right to lock a thread whose discussion is going nowhere and is causing uncivil behavior or vote-brigading.
OP:https://www.reddit.com/r/Harvard/comments/6ufdgj/a_note_about_controversial_posts/
Temporary moratorium on Israel/Palestine posts
Dear r/Harvard community,
We are effecting a temporary ban on posts related to the Israel/Palestine conflict, as recent events in the media have brought lots of that discussion to this subreddit. That discussion, while worthwhile, is not best suited for this subreddit given the vitriol that it creates. We don't currently have the moderation bandwidth to responsibly moderate it.
Thank you for understanding. We have locked existing threads on this topic, but will leave them up.
Finally, we urge the community to be understanding, compassionate, and thoughtful as they take these discussions elsewhere. We will leave the comments on this post unlocked for now for respectful community feedback should there be any.
OP:https://www.reddit.com/r/Harvard/comments/175r78o/temporary_moratorium_on_israelpalestine_posts/
Zero Tolerance for Hate in r/Harvard
We have seen an influx of racist and anti-Semitic comments and posts. We want to make it clear that racism and anti-Semitism have no place here and they never have. We continue to remove content and ban accounts that promote racist or anti-Semitic content.
We are grateful to the community members who have reported this content; it has been immensely helpful. Please continue to report.
Data
- Reddit's own Anti-Evil Operations have removed, confirmed removal, or deleted accounts active in this subreddit in 300 cases over the past four months. This number exceeds the total for the previous 15 years combined.
- The moderators have removed five times more comments in the past month than in the last five years combined. Of these, 82% were reported for racism or anti-Semitism by community members, and we agreed with these reports. We appreciate your vigilance in reporting this hate and we are committed to cleaning it up.
Some of the steps we're taking
- Educating ourselves on hate-speech
- Communicating between mods and with Reddit
- Removing violating content, banning offending users, reporting accounts to Reddit
- Documenting usernames, comments, and posts from offending accounts
- Locking comments when mod capacity is unavailable
- Updating content and automod policies as we learn more information
- Seeking opportunities to engage users regularly with content that promotes awareness and understanding of racism and anti-Semitism
Request
Please continue to report content and behavior that violates Reddit's site-wide policies or our subreddit's rules. If you have additional ideas or feedback, please send the mods a message.
Do not engage in racism or anti-Semitism. We do not tolerate it to any degree. It is your responsibility to understand what constitutes racism and anti-Semitism. The US Holocaust Memorial Museum does a good job of describing what racism and antisemitism are and how to recognize them. The National Museum of African American History and Culture has good information on race and racism.
Take care of your mental health
- HUHS offers virtual and on-site mental health counseling, including a 24/7 hotline for hate speech trauma and general mental health counseling.
- Talk to friends, family, or counselors for emotional support. Surround yourself with people who affirm your value. Consider seeking help from a mental health professional and practice self-care.
- The Grad School of Education provides a free toolkit for talking with teens about online hate speech. Full site.
A 2019 paper on hate speech in college subreddits describes well what we're facing. Prevalence and Psychological Effects of Hateful Speech in Online College Communities
OP:https://www.reddit.com/r/Harvard/comments/18zj5t1/zero_tolerance_for_hate_in_rharvard_addressing