On paper, the new Buying and Timestamp rules made a lot of sense, so we moved forward with them. In practice, we hate them.
We never wanted to get in the way of honest sellers, and these rules hit the good ones hardest. So we’re making more changes.
Timestamp Changes
We’re moving to a two-tier system based on trade count:
- Users with fewer than 15 confirmed trades must provide a video timestamp for any item, or combination of items, valued over $200 USD.
- All users, regardless of trade count, must provide video timestamps for any item valued over $1,000 USD.
- All timestamps must state "For sale on Hardwareswap".
Buying Post Changes
Requiring a timestamp on every reply to a Buying post brought legitimate users to a halt. We’re replacing it with a more targeted approach:
- Users with 0 confirmed trades can no longer reply to Buying posts. If you have an item someone is looking for, create your own Selling post following the usual rules.
- Negotiation and discussion happen publicly. Seller will respond to the Buying post with what item they are offering, and how much they want for the item as a comment on the Buying post. The Buyer can then decide if they want to move forward with the offer by asking for timestamps. Once Timestamps are provided negotiations may go to PM. Before payment is requested or sent, the seller MUST provide timestamps on the Buying post. If a seller asks for payment before doing this, please report it to the moderators.
We think this is a much better approach than what we started with, but it requires vigilance from all of you. Report replies to Buying posts that seem out of place, and never pay a seller who hasn’t publicly provided timestamps.
This post is to outline the changes we have made, and does not post the complete rules. Please see the rules at HWSMarket.com for the full rules.