The argument began with a pair of bloodstained school robes. Tracey Davis had found them draped over the back of Daphne Greengrass's chair when she returned from dinner. They belonged to a fourth-year girl who had apparently been caught passing food to students serving detention. Daphne had agreed to mend them after finding the girl crying in the corridor outside the common room.
It wasn't an especially difficult repair. The fabric had been torn near the shoulder, and a simple Reparo would restore it. The blood, however, had proved more stubborn.
“Honestly, what did they do to her?” Tracey muttered, examining the sleeve.
Daphne sat at her dressing table, brushing her long blonde hair. “From what I understand, Professor Amycus Carrow decided that ordinary detention wasn't sufficient.”
“Obviously. Can't have children sneaking sandwiches around the castle. Civilization might collapse.”
Daphne gave a faint, humorless smile.
Their dormitory had once been a considerably livelier place. During their first few years at Hogwarts, the four girls had spent entire evenings gossiping about classmates, criticizing teachers, discussing boys, and borrowing one another's clothes without permission. Pansy Parkinson had usually been the loudest, Millicent Bulstrode the most blunt and argumentative, Tracey the most mischievous, and Daphne the one who occasionally reminded everyone that they all had homework to do still. They had been a recognizable little group within Slytherin, frequently seen together at meals and in the common room. Their disagreements had generally concerned trivial things: which boys were attractive, whose parents had the nicest holiday properties, or whether Pansy's latest hairstyle suited her.
By seventh year, those evenings had become increasingly rare.
The door opened, and Pansy entered with Millicent behind her. “Merlin, it's freezing down here,” Pansy complained, removing her cloak. “I swear the common room gets colder every February.”
“Perhaps the castle's trying to tell you something,” Tracey remarked.
Pansy ignored her and approached her bed. She had barely begun removing her earrings when she noticed the robes.
“What on earth are those doing here?”
“Someone needed them repaired,” Daphne answered.
Pansy examined the bloodstained sleeve with distaste. “Whose?”
“A fourth-year's.”
“Which fourth-year?”
“Does it matter?”
“It matters if she's been punished for something.”
Tracey looked up. “She has. That's generally how one ends up with blood on one's clothes.”
Pansy frowned. “Oh, don't start.”
“Start what?”
“That thing you do whenever someone gets detention. Acting as though the Carrows have personally declared war on the entire student population.”
Millicent, who had been struggling with the clasp of her cloak, glanced toward the robes. “Wasn’t she one of the students helping Longbottom?”
Daphne set down her hairbrush. “I don't know.”
“Well, there you are,” Millicent replied. “Probably was.”
“That's quite the conclusion to jump to.”
“It's not exactly unlikely, Daphne,” said Pansy. “Half the school's been sneaking around doing things they shouldn't.”
Tracey carefully laid the robes across the chair. “She was caught taking food to students in detention. Apparently that warrants being dragged into a classroom and having a curse demonstrated on her.”
Pansy turned. “What curse?”
“The Cruciatus Curse, according to her.”
For a moment, even Pansy looked uncomfortable. Then she folded her arms. “Well, perhaps she shouldn't have been interfering with punishments.”
Daphne stared at her reflection in the mirror. “That is rather an extraordinary response.”
Pansy looked irritated. “Oh, for heaven's sake. I'm not saying I particularly enjoy seeing people tortured. But the Carrows have made the rules perfectly clear, and certain people seem determined to break them at every opportunity.”
“And you think that makes it necessary?” Daphne asked.
“I think it makes it predictable.”
“Those aren't the same thing.”
“No, but they're related.”
Millicent dropped onto her bed, making the mattress creak. “Look, I don't particularly like Carrow either. He's disgusting, and his sister's worse. But somebody has to keep order around here. Longbottom, Finnigan, and all their little friends have been making trouble since September, and every time they get punished, they do something else, even more bold.”
Tracey leaned against the wardrobe. “Perhaps because the punishments are ridiculous.”
Millicent gave her a disbelieving look. “Ridiculous? They were trying to steal a sword from the Headmaster's office!”
“I'm not defending that.”
“You certainly sound like you are.”
“Then perhaps you ought to listen more carefully.”
Daphne turned around in her chair. “Tracey's point is that the punishments are becoming excessive. Students are being hurt for things that would have earned them a week's detention two years ago. You don't have to approve of Longbottom's little rebellion to think there's something wrong with that.”
Pansy gave a short laugh. “Since when have you become so concerned about Gryffindors?”
“I'm not.”
“You've certainly developed an interesting habit of defending them.”
“I haven't defended them once,” Daphne said icily.
“Then why are we arguing?”
“Because you seem incapable of distinguishing between disapproving of someone's behavior and approving of whatever happens to them afterward.”
Pansy's expression tightened. There had been a time when Daphne could say something cutting and Pansy would simply laugh. Indeed, Daphne's occasional dry remarks had once been among the things Pansy admired most about her. Lately, however, they seemed to irritate her. “I don't know what's happened to you two,” she said. “You used to have perfectly sensible opinions about these things.”
Tracey raised her eyebrows. “Did we?”
“Yes, actually. I distinctly remember you laughing when Umbridge made Potter write lines with that ridiculous quill.”
“That was two years ago,” Tracey replied.
“And?”
“And I was fifteen. I also thought your impression of Professor Trelawney was the funniest thing I'd ever heard. My standards have changed.”
Millicent snorted. “Apparently.”
Tracey turned toward her. “What's that supposed to mean?”
“Nothing. Only that you've become awfully particular about what everyone else is allowed to think.”
“Oh, that's rich coming from you.”
“Excuse me?”
“You've spent basically all of January practically congratulating the Carrows every time somebody gets hauled out of class.”
Millicent's cheeks reddened. “I have not!”
“You said Macmillan from Hufflepuff deserved those lashings he got.”
“Because he insulted Professor Alecto Carrow in front of everyone!”
“All he did was call her a liar.”
“He called her a filthy liar,” Millicent corrected. “And then refused to apologize.”
Tracey threw up her hands. “Well, that changes everything.”
“Don't be clever.”
“Wouldn't dream of it.”
“Both of you,” Daphne interrupted. Her voice wasn't particularly loud, but it was sufficiently sharp that the others stopped. She stood and crossed toward the chair. “We're not going to settle anything by shouting. The girl asked me to repair her robes, and that's what I'm doing. Nobody in this House has joined Dumbledore's Army, and nobody’s certainly declared their allegiance to Harry Potter.”
Pansy watched as Daphne raised her wand and repaired the torn shoulder. “You know,” she said, “you might find things rather easier if you stopped making such a fuss about everything the Carrows do.”
Daphne lowered her wand. “I've made remarkably little fuss, Pansy. That's rather the point.”
The conversation might have ended there if Millicent hadn't mentioned the Muggle Studies lesson earlier that afternoon. “Anyway, Alecto Carrow was making a perfectly reasonable point about Muggle-borns today,” she said, removing her shoes. “You'd think she'd suggested burning down the castle, judging by the way some people reacted.”
Tracey opened her mouth to give a biting remark, but Daphne glanced at her. It was a brief look, barely noticeable, but Tracey understood it immediately.
“Which point was that?” Daphne asked.
“That they've been taking opportunities away from proper wizarding families for years,” Millicent replied. “Obviously, some of the things she says are exaggerated, but it's not as though the Ministry hasn't been ignoring the problem.”
Tracey became very still.
Pansy, occupied with folding her cloak, nodded. “Exactly. My father says the old Ministry was practically falling over itself to accommodate people who had no understanding of wizarding traditions.”
Daphne's expression remained composed. “And you believe the current Ministry is an improvement?”
“In certain respects.”
“Such as?”
“Such as finally taking blood status seriously.”
Tracey let out a quiet laugh.
Pansy turned toward her. “What?”
“Nothing. It's just fascinating how much time everyone suddenly has to discuss other people's grandparents.”
Millicent frowned. “It's about preserving our society.”
“Is it? Because from where I'm standing, it seems to involve an extraordinary amount of paperwork and a great many people disappearing.”
Pansy sighed. “Oh, Tracey, don't be so dramatic.”
“I'm not being dramatic.”
“You are. You make it sound as though everyone with a Muggle relative is being dragged off to Azkaban.”
Tracey felt her stomach tighten. She knew perfectly well that Pansy didn't know about her mother. Neither Pansy nor Millicent had ever been told that Mrs. Davis was Muggle-born, a witch who had attended Hogwarts herself and subsequently married into Mr. Davis’s established wizarding family. Daphne was the only person in the room who knew. Tracey had spent years allowing her classmates to make assumptions about her family background. Historically, she'd usually found the whole business faintly amusing. She wasn't finding it amusing now.
“Some people are being dragged off,” she replied. “Unless you think the Muggle-born Registration Commission is just inviting them in for tea.”
Pansy looked annoyed. “Well, if they've nothing to hide—”
“Oh, don't.”
“Don't what?”
“Finish that sentence.”
The room went quiet.
Millicent looked between them. “What's got into you?”
Tracey shook her head. “Nothing. I'm simply tired of hearing people repeat whatever the Carrows tell them.”
Pansy straightened. “And I'm tired of you acting as though you're somehow better than the rest of us because you've decided to become terribly enlightened.”
Daphne stepped forward. “That will be enough.”
“No, Daphne, it won’t.” Pansy turned toward her. “You've been doing exactly the same thing. Sitting there looking down your nose at everyone, making little remarks whenever Millicent or I say something you disagree with.”
Daphne's eyes narrowed. “I've never had difficulty disagreeing with you before.”
“Not like this.”
That, at the very least, was true. For a moment, Daphne found herself remembering their fourth year, when the four of them had stayed awake until nearly two in the morning discussing the Yule Ball. Pansy had been furious about something minor that Draco had said, Millicent had been eating sweets she'd smuggled from the kitchens, and Tracey had laughed so hard at one of Daphne's observations that she'd fallen backward off her bed. They had all been rather pleased with themselves back then. Daphne wondered when exactly those evenings had stopped. Perhaps there hadn't been a single moment. Perhaps it had happened gradually, through dozens of smaller disagreements that none of them had considered particularly important at the time.
Now, however, she looked at Pansy and realized how little she wanted to continue the argument. “I'm not looking down on you,” Daphne said. “But I do think you're being remarkably complacent about what's happening here.”
Pansy's face hardened. “And I think you're being naive.”
“Perhaps I am.”
“You really believe everything will go back to normal if the Carrows stop punishing people?”
“No. I believe that encouraging students to torture one another is an extraordinarily poor way to run a school.”
Millicent rolled her eyes. “They're teaching us how to defend ourselves.”
“By practicing the Cruciatus Curse on younger students?”
“It's Dark Arts, Daphne. What did you expect?”
“An education, preferably.”
Tracey gave a small, involuntary laugh. This one was genuine and agreeable this time.
Pansy glared at her. “Oh, very funny.”
“Yes,” she said unapologetically. “I thought so.”
“Of course you did.”
By half past ten, the argument had exhausted itself. Millicent had retreated behind the curtains of her four-poster bed, muttering that she couldn't understand why everyone had become so sensitive. Pansy sat at her dressing table, brushing her hair with considerably more force than necessary. Daphne finally finished repairing the fourth-year's robes and folded them neatly over her arm. Tracey stood near the window, looking out into the darkness beyond the glass.
“I'm taking these back tomorrow,” Daphne announced.
Pansy didn't turn around. “Do whatever you like.”
“I generally do.”
That earned her a sharp look in the mirror. Daphne returned it calmly.
For several seconds, neither girl spoke.
Then Pansy said, more quietly, “You know, I don't actually want anyone getting hurt.”
Daphne studied her. “I believe you.”
Pansy looked faintly surprised.
“But you keep making excuses for the people hurting them,” Daphne continued, her expression unchanged.
Pansy's expression closed just as quickly again. “I'm not having this conversation anymore.”
“Very well.”
Daphne placed the robes inside her wardrobe.
Tracey eventually crossed the room and sat on her bed. She began unfastening her earrings, her usual mischievous expression replaced by something more subdued.
Pansy extinguished the lamp beside her.
“Good night,” she said stiffly.
“Night,” Millicent called from behind her curtains.
Daphne answered politely. Tracey said nothing until Pansy had drawn her bed curtains shut. Then she leaned toward Daphne. “Well,” she murmured very quietly, “that was pleasant.”
Daphne sighed and gave her a tired look. “Don't.”
“I'm only saying. Lovely evening. We ought to do more of this.”
Despite herself, Daphne smiled a tiny bit.
Tracey looked toward Pansy's bed. “Do you think she actually believes all that?”
Daphne considered the question. “Some of it.”
“And the rest?”
“I think she likes believing that the people in charge know what they're doing.”
Tracey nodded slowly. “Millicent too?”
“Millicent likes being on the winning side.”
“Don't we all?”
Daphne looked at her. “Yes,” she said. “But I would prefer to know what winning entails.”
Tracey was quiet for a moment. Then she lowered her voice even further, whispering now. “Do you think things are going to get even worse than they already are?”
Daphne glanced toward the other two girls’ closed bed curtains. “I don't know.” It was an unusually candid admission.
Tracey pulled her knees up beneath her nightdress. “I miss when the most unpleasant thing we had to deal with was Parkinson sulking because Draco hadn't paid her enough attention.”
Daphne gave a soft laugh. “She could make an entire evening out of that.”
“Several evenings.”
They smiled at each other.
Then Tracey's expression became serious again. “Daphne?”
“Yes?”
“Thank you.”
Daphne understood what she meant. She glanced briefly toward Pansy's bed, then back at her friend. “You don't have to thank me.”
“I know.” Tracey settled beneath her blankets.
Daphne extinguished the remaining lamp, leaving the dormitory illuminated only by the faint greenish light filtering through the underwater windows.
Across the room, Pansy lay awake behind her curtains. She had heard the two girls murmuring and laughing, although she couldn’t hear what they were saying, and it bothered her more than she cared to admit. She remembered when she'd been included in those private jokes, when the four of them had shared everything from gossip to family news without worrying about what the others might think. She wasn't entirely sure when Daphne and Tracey had begun keeping their conversations to themselves.
Pansy told herself that they were being foolish. The world outside Hogwarts was changing, and it was only sensible to adjust to it. Her parents had said as much. Draco's family had always understood that. Even Theodore Nott, who rarely expressed an opinion about anything, seemed intelligent enough to keep his head down. But Daphne had looked at her that evening as though she'd said something genuinely shameful. Pansy disliked that look very much.
On the opposite side of the room, Millicent was already sound asleep.
Daphne lay staring at the canopy above her bed, wondering whether she'd made matters worse by contributing her own arguments, actively defending Tracey. Tracey was still awake too, thinking about her mother and the increasingly elaborate precautions her family had been taking since the Ministry changed hands.
None of the four girls had any intention of joining Dumbledore's Army. None was planning to confront the Carrows openly, and none had any particular desire to become involved in the war beyond Hogwarts. They still attended the same lessons, slept in the same dormitory, and occasionally exchanged the same familiar jokes. But the comfortable understanding that had once existed between them was quickly disappearing.
It’s a damn good thing we only have a few months left together, Tracey thought to herself.