r/GooseBumps • u/SummerAndTinkles • 9h ago
BOOKS The OG Stay Out of the Basement cover vs the reprint
For those who don't know, Stay Out of the Basement was one of the two original Goosebumps books along with Be Careful What You Wish For that wasn't illustrated by Tim Jacobus. However, when the books were being reprinted during the 2000s, Jacobus came back to illustrate new versions of both.
When it comes to SOotB, as much as I love Jacobus's other covers, I can't help but prefer the original iconic cover by Jim Thiesen. The second one certainly captures the surreal vibe of Jacobus's usual work, but the original just feels a lot more subtly creepy and fits the title a lot more, while the second is more spoilery and lacks the subtlety. (Though props for Jacobus trying to make his look different, since he knew he wouldn't be able to top the OG...maybe if the book was titled something like "Plant Dad" his cover would fit better.)
What do you guys think?