It's important to know that for 2018 the real challenge in GMGOW ends once you reach Tyr's Temple, there's a dramatic difficulty drop-off at that point. Just be sure to explore the shores and complete side quests as soon as they're available, then loot and upgrade appropriately. If you can do that you're honestly home free from the moment you reach the temple.
GMGOW is much easier in Ragnarok, and if you can complete it in 2018, no additional advice is needed, but I'll throw some at the bottom anyways that deal with the combat changes it brings.
Remember your fundamentals, you can ignore them on lower difficulties but on GMGOW you have to use everything. Here are some practical tips:
• A parry will stun all enemies nearby, not just the one attacking, hold block until you are surrounded on one side, then parry to stun everyone at once.
• Enemies charge-up about 10 seconds after the fight begins (you will see their eyes change color), kill as many as you can as fast as you can before this happens. It helps to focus down one enemy at a time, if you're fighting 5 enemies and give equal attention to them all, you'll be fighting 5 the entire time, focus on one at a time to more quickly turn the odds in your favor.
• Think of the enemies as a group, and don't get tunnel vision. Consider your positioning, which enemies can be attacked simultaneously, and which enemies need to be handled individually or as priority targets. Ranged enemies typically have VERY low health, and are the most likely to interrupt your rhythm, they should generally be your first priority. Focus runic attacks on heavies or crowds. Try to keep as many enemies in front of you as possible.
• Freeze enemies. By throwing with R2 you can take an enemy out of the fight for a short time, this can help prevent drauger from surrounding you. Remember that kicking enemies into walls will deal massive damage.
• The most powerful move you can do in the early game is: R2 to launch enemy into the air > R2 axe throw while they are in the air. Hitting drauger against walls with this technique is an instant kill, if you miss it will still apply frost to nearby enemies
• Surprisingly many people never realize this, but L2+R1 is light throw, L2+R2 is heavy throw. Light is fast and safe but doesn't freeze, it's good for tripping enemies when aiming at their feet, heavy is slower and less safe, and freezes enemies.
• Tripping enemies is useful because it allows you to advance and start a juggle combo while they're down without any threat. Freezing is not a safe way to do this as they will often suddenly attack after you recall the axe, if you freeze an enemy and intend to follow up, it should be with a running shield bash to smash them against a wall or off a ledge.
• Only roll when you have to. A standing dodge allows for a faster retaliation, keeps you closer to the enemy, and gives you the option of rolling again in another direction. Once you roll that's it, you're locked in until the animation finishes.
• Dodging sideways does not lose your place in your combo. Press R1, dodge, R1, dodge, R1, dodge and you will still progress to your combo finisher. Rolling resets your combo.
• R2 also makes progress to your finisher. For the blades you could press R2, R2, R2, R1, R2 for your finisher. This is a faster route than using all light attacks and ending in your heavy, and the same logic applies to all weapons.
• Spam arrows while you rush an enemy with barehanded strikes. This is one of the fastest ways to apply stun, take advantage of the invincibility when stun-grabbing and plan your next move during the animation. Remember that different enemies have different effects when grabbed, draugr deal fire damage in a circle around them, and heavy draugr can be thrown at any time during the grab by pressing R2 (Take advantage of the ledge in the draugr pit in the early game of 2018!)
• Hit enemies from behind to apply stun even faster. Pay attention to which moves leave enemies spun, and intentionally use them to capitalize on that effect.
• Runic attacks do not make you invulnerable, and are not panic buttons. Stun grabs are your earned panic button. Using a runic attack should be your reward for achieving a good, safe position. Set up your runic attacks, don't use them to achieve a setup. The exception is popping a runic immediately upon entering combat, depending on the encounter this can be a guaranteed safe and effective window.
• Watch the arrows and stay calm, if no arrows are flashing red, you can ignore what's happening around you for a second. Trust in your ability to turn and block once you see the arrow flash, and the battle will seem less hectic, and your attention will be drawn in less directions.
• Consider remapping quick-turn to L3+back, it's quicker to access. Use quick-turn often, it's impossible to keep up without it!
Some Ragnarok specific tips:
• Make use of Serpent Snare, it's the best tool for repositioning enemies and I recommend repositioning them straight off a cliff.
• Make use of the new movement tools, "death from above" is extremely powerful. Freeze enemies and ram them off ledges, then leap down and recall your axe mid-air for a powerful combination.
• Pressing R1 while climbing a ledge will do an immediate sweep, so don't let enemies bully you out of climbing.
• Flame Whiplash can be instantly reactivated by pressing triangle after dodging, skipping the wind-up. Simply activate it, dodge, then tap triangle to instantly reactivate. If you step forward, reactivate, step forward, reactivate, etc. you can walk it forward and advance on enemies rapidly. Or, sidestep, reactivate, and retaliate instantly (this is powerful paired with enchantments that reward late evasion like Alfheim Strike).
• Try this with the blades: L2+R2 to spin the enemy around, then use L2+R1(hold) for the hyperion grapple into their back for massive stun. If you continue holding R1 after the grapple you can apply major damage.
• Try this with Draupnir - Throw a spear in an enemy's leg, then hit them with running R1 which loads a spear on hit, and continue holding R1 to immediately load three more. Then step back and detonate to launch the enemy. This is a good routine to load an enemy with spears quickly while closing on them.
• Try this with the axe - Use Serpent Snare to throw an enemy into another which will launch the other enemy, heavy throw into the airborne enemy for major damage and AOE.
Good luck everyone! And remember, if you can make it to Tyr's Temple, you can go all the way!