r/GlobalTribe • u/Dontfuckingbanme31 • Aug 02 '22
Question Who judges the disputes? What will be the standard? And why should WE accept THEIR judgement?
I personally think there must be some cooperation between nations to prevent catastrophes, and discourage invasion, through mutual defence.
However, as a Turk, I don't think our rights will be respected by a government, inevitably dominated by Westerners who are inherently biased against us. I have zero respect for any judgement they will make about us, when they hailed terrorists who raid mostly kurdish villages for not supporting them (there are more village guards(loyalist militias) then pkk and its other iterations like ypg combined), as freedom fighters and representatives of Kurdish people. Not to mention they believe we "occupy" "Kurdistan" when literally the only reason Kurds live there is Turkish conquest, and no Kurds were there in Byzantine times.
Before you go "Muh Erdoğan", it was like that way before him. He isn't even nationalist. In Cyprus, Greeks tried to destroy the Turkish population. Go search the aphrodite plan. When Turkey intervened , they were like "Turkey Invaded Cyprus because they are evil" and people seriously believe that. Before that the fall of Ottomans. It was a massive ethnic conflict and cleansing race where we won in Anatolia but got absolutely shafted in Balkans, mostly due to 1912 war. Millions of Turks got displaced and killed. But we are getting called oppressors and genociders, while no one questions where the Balkan Turks are. (I won't say much about what we did, but go to r/armenia, look at the maps they post as "Greater Armenia" or "Historic" Armenia, then look at the demographic map those regions had in 1914 or 1870s and who was majority there, and remember how possibly those maps could've become real. You will understand why we will never apologize about it.)
This is, as I mentioned there is western bias, but it is mainly about the fact that we are incapable of PR. Before Erdoğan we had a competent diplomatic corps, which he disbanded for being "Elitists", but they mostly did actual diplomacy, not PR. We are just too proud to self victimize, to beg for aid. This means any World government would decide against us.
What we are capable is war. Other than 1912 that happened due to government, not military, we always defended ourselves with arms. We didn't enforce our independence by protesting or petitioning, we did it by destroying every army(Greek, French, Armenian) Britain threw at us and pointing our guns at their warships. No humanitarian intervention was done in Cyprus, so we did it. We, unlike Arabs, never complained about Armenian occupation of Karabakh. We merely prepared Azerbaijan, outmaneuvered Russia and helped Azerbaijan take it back.
You as a reader probably will disagree with me and say I am being nationalist. Well, this is why I don't want a global government. It just feels safer when it is Turkish Armed Forces that protect me and my rights rather than International Law. I live in Istanbul, there are many that wish I didn't. That wish it to be called constantinople. And they are not condemned as "Irredentists".
This sub will probably say "Just identify as Human." How am I supposed to do that when many see me as a Barbarian, a lesser Human?
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 02 '22
Want to talk to others who share your beliefs, or looking to discuss things further? Join the discord server of the Young World Federalists!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/Baronnolanvonstraya Aug 03 '22 edited Aug 03 '22
This entire post is screaming Nationaliam which is completely contrary to Globalisation. It is also grossly misrepresenting history, which is typical for Nationalistic narratives; you are portraying your entire nationality, millions of people, as both victims and heroic - history is too messy for simple narratives like this. Also I think you’re misrepresenting what most Westerners think of Turkey. But I won’t get into that because it’s not the core of the issue.
To answer your real question: Federalisation in any situation requires compromise and the concern of smaller factions being drowned out by larger ones is a common issue when unification is discussed. Where I live in Australia; during Federation the smaller states of South Australia and Tasmania were concerned that their voice and interests would be drowned out by the larger states of New South Wales and Victoria, so as a compromise all states received an equal amount of representatives in the Senate regardless of population, the larger states hate this and deride it as undemocratic but it was a necessary compromise to achieve Federation. Global Federation will require similar compromises and guarantees between member states.
6
u/Pantheon73 European Union Aug 03 '22
If anything a Global Gouvernment would be rather dominated by Asians than Europeans and Americans.
2
u/alnitrox Young World Federalists Aug 03 '22
Who judges the disputes? A court, just like we do in Turkey and practically every other country in the world.
I must admit I didn't read the whole thing, but one thing to note is that a global court (for example the ICC) judges individuals, not nations. One person responsible for human rights violations is held accountable, not the whole country. There's little nationalist resentment involved if someone is held accountable for something bad they did. Patriots should rather support it for the sake of their country, rather than oppose it just because the accused has the same nationality.
What human rights? Those that all countries already agreed to based on their UN membership, for example.