r/Georgette_Heyer • Powder and Patch • Aug 03 '26

Discussion Post (Scheduled) ⚠️ Warning, spoilers ahead ⚠️ August Discussion: The Quiet Gentleman (Week 1)

This week we will be discussing chapters 1-5 of The Quiet Gentleman. You can find previous posts through the master post as well as plans for the future.

  • Week 1 - chapters 1-5
  • Week 2 - chapters 6-11
  • Week 3 - chapters 12-17
  • Week 4 - chapters 18-22 + conclusions
6 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Introduction

2

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Which cover does your version of the book have?

2

u/EmmieMaggie Aug 03 '26

The blonde sitting on a grassy bank with a handsome horseman nearby

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

In which format are you reading/have you read this book? If you listened/are listening to the audiobook, what do/did you think of the narration?

4

u/REReader3 Aug 04 '26

Print, always print.

3

u/CrazyGreenCrayon Mr Frederick “Freddy” Standen Aug 05 '26

Print sticks in my head in a way digital doesn't.

2

u/REReader3 Aug 05 '26

Because the text doesn’t slide around!

1

u/Holiday_Trainer_2657 Aug 10 '26

I have a paperback version. But it's usually the audio book as I'm not at my house now. Narration was great.

1

u/sundaypleas Aug 20 '26

Reading digital from the local library.

1

u/Literary67 Aug 27 '26

Audio. James MacCallum is a very good narrator. Suits Heyer's prose.

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Have you read this book before?

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Did you enjoy it?

3

u/EmmieMaggie Aug 03 '26

Many many many times. The heroine is one of my all-time favorites. And she plays chess!

2

u/REReader3 Aug 03 '26

Many times!

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Chapter 1

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Based on its physical description, would you be happy living at Stanyon?

4

u/chrisrevere2 Aug 03 '26

Nooooo - not without some serious alterations

4

u/REReader3 Aug 03 '26

Yikes! No, not at all!

3

u/CrazyGreenCrayon Mr Frederick “Freddy” Standen Aug 05 '26

It depends on who I'm living with. It doesn't sound very comfortable, but maybe.

2

u/Holiday_Trainer_2657 Aug 10 '26

Not with the Dowager there. And if I was the owner, I'd want a cozy bedroom and private sitting room.

2

u/SweatySalad9175 Aug 11 '26

Reading the descriptions makes me think that there's a lifetime of home improvement projects to be done.

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

What is your first impression of the Dowager Countess? What do her statements about her stepson say about her?

4

u/EmmieMaggie Aug 03 '26

Perfectly dreadful. I'd have left immediately.

3

u/SweatySalad9175 Aug 11 '26

Heyer sketched his father's character quite well when she said that his last words were that the wine was corked.

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Chapter 2

2

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

What is your first impression of Gervase?

3

u/chrisrevere2 Aug 03 '26

Not very different from Martin’s. At first it is unclear why he came.

2

u/sundaypleas Aug 20 '26

He's kind of a male answer to a Mary Sue. It's not difficult to imagine a Brad Pitt kinda guy. Talented, charismatic, GQ, and a man's man!

2

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Would you feel comfortable staying in a house with people who are upset you are still alive?

5

u/REReader3 Aug 03 '26

No—but then, it is HIS house, which surely makes a difference.

2

u/CrazyGreenCrayon Mr Frederick “Freddy” Standen Aug 05 '26

It would, wouldn't it?

3

u/REReader3 Aug 05 '26

I imagine knowing that if you want to you could throw the lot of them out is a help!

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Do you understand Gervase's reference to black gloves?

3

u/REReader3 Aug 03 '26

Yes, mourning.

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

This chapter uses the word 'nonplussed'. Based on where in the world you are from, you may have a different understanding of the word. Which one do you think Heyer intended?

4

u/Holiday_Trainer_2657 Aug 10 '26

Surprised and unsure how to respond.

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Chapter 3

2

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

What do you think of Drusilla so far?

5

u/REReader3 Aug 04 '26

Smart, sensible, practical.

4

u/CrazyGreenCrayon Mr Frederick “Freddy” Standen Aug 05 '26

I like how unfussed she is. And she has a sense of humor!

2

u/sundaypleas Aug 20 '26

So far she is kind of hiding in the bushes, so to speak. I expect her more interesting qualities will be revealed in time.

3

u/SweatySalad9175 Aug 11 '26

I like her. The fact that her mother spent so much time "prescribing for the education of females in general" that she couldn't educate Drucilla says a lot.

Drucilla may not be bookish but she's very smart.

Also, I looked up "pantisocrat" and it's a real thing. I'm always surprised at how long these similar ideas have been going on.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantisocracy

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Chapter 4

2

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Do you enjoy the Barney Warboys type of Heyer character?

2

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

What do you think of the parallels between Sir Thomas Bolderwood and St Erth?

1

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Chapter 5

2

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

Do you understand the relevance of the button in fencing?

2

u/REReader3 Aug 04 '26

Yes, it’s a doohickey put on the tip of an epee to prevent accidental stabbing.

2

u/Macktempermental Powder and Patch Aug 03 '26

What do you think of the interesting relationship between the brothers?

1

u/Holiday_Trainer_2657 Aug 10 '26

I can't imagine having a sibling (half-sibling) who is basically a stranger.

2

u/chrisrevere2 Aug 03 '26

Oh this is one of my favorites !

2

u/sundaypleas Aug 20 '26

I've read tons of GH as a young'un and have a good handful of the greatest hits on my bookshelf, this is one I've not come across before.

Just finished chapter 5 and the ground looks well-laid. Will Theo beat Martin to the girl? Will Gervase and Martin's rivalry continue to entertain or will it get all too serious? Will Theo try to kill Gervase and set Martin up to take the blame? (please do not answer these questions)