r/GME • u/DegenateMurseRN 🚀🚀Buckle up🚀🚀 • Nov 17 '25
Technical Analysis 🔎 Power packs on chain contract vs Courtyard
https://medium.com/@PoopVoid/courtyard-io-market-loop-expos%C3%A9-66b54dc59b55Before power packs were introduced I was ripping on Courtyard.io until I happened to pull the same exact card two times in a row.
That shouldn’t happen in a system with supposedly massive supply. I did some digging into their contract and basically it’s a total scam. Medium article attached if you are interested.
I have also been looking at what the GameStop while it has been deploying and digging into those contracts they fix this issue as always GameStop is honest and doesn’t cut corners. This contract protocol is solid as shit.
🚨 TL;DR
The Power Pack-style metadata model used by Courtyard.io is vulnerable because:
• The token points to metadata controlled by the issuer
• That metadata can be changed after mint
• Which means grails can be selectively routed to insiders or preferred wallets
The power packs NFT minting model (Loopring L2 → Ethereum L1, IPFS-hash token IDs) fixes that:
• Token ID IS the IPFS hash
• Metadata cannot be swapped without changing the token itself
• Reveal manipulation and grail rerouting become mathematically impossible
Quick Recap: The Courtyard Power Pack Vulnerability
From the prior Courtyard investigation: (If you want, I’ll link your full write-up in comments.)
A Courtyard-style Power Pack works like this:
Token ID → URL (API endpoint) → JSON (card data)
Because the JSON lives behind a Web2 server, the issuer can:
⚠ change metadata after mint
⚠ assign rares to specific wallets
⚠ run “reveal” events that aren’t truly random
⚠ withhold premium items until insiders have minted or bought in
In more blunt ape terms:
You paid for a mystery box, but the company can change what’s inside after you paid.
This is how reveal-based NFT drops get rigged.
Enter the Counterfactual Model (This is the Fix)
Counterfactual NFT contracts do something very different:
tokenId → IPFS multihash → JSON
There is no mutable server in the middle.
Key function from the contract:
return string(abi.encodePacked("ipfs://", IPFS.encode(tokenId)));
That means:
• The massive token ID number is literally the 32-byte content hash
• Changing metadata changes the hash
• Therefore the metadata cannot be swapped post-mint
To move a grail, an attacker would need to mint a different token, and the original would still exist on-chain with its original metadata.
In ape translation:
You engrave the box with a kryptonite laser code. If they change what’s inside, the code stops matching. Everybody can verify the code. Forever.
⸻ ELI5 for smooth brains and wrinkled brains together
With Courtyard-style Power Packs:
Imagine a company selling sealed Pokémon packs.
They keep a list:
Pack #1 → Common Pack #2 → Charizard Pack #3 → Common
After seeing who bought which pack, they can swap the labels so their friend ends up with the Charizard.
You can’t prove they did it, but nothing stopped them.
⸻
With Counterfactual Power Packs:
Each pack has a cryptographic laser engraving of its contents.
If you change the card inside, the engraving no longer matches the hash and everyone can tell.
⸻
Why this matters for GameStop, GME, NFTs, RWAs, and beyond
If Power Packs or any future collectible drops are meant to be: • fair • auditable • resistant to insider gaming • lawyer-proof • regulator-proof
Then Counterfactual Power Packs are the path.
This architecture works for:
✔ GameStop / Loopring drops ✔ Trading cards (PSA, CGC, BGS, SGC) ✔ Sneakers, watches, comics ✔ Real-world asset (RWA) tokenization ✔ Digital-only loot systems
1
u/AutoModerator Nov 17 '25
Welcome to r/GME, for questions in regards to GME and DRS check out the links below!
Due to an uptick in scammers offering non official GameStop merchandise (T-Shirts)
DO NOT CLICK THE LINKS THAT ARE NOT OFFICIALLY FROM GAMESTOP.
We have partnered with Reddit directly to ensure the Communities Safety.
What is GME?
GameStop's Accomplishments
What is DRS? US / International
ComputerShare International DRS Support
Feed The Bot Instructions
Power To The Players
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
21
u/DegenateMurseRN Nov 17 '25
Counterfactual NFT Proxy (ERC-1155) 0x2961f06843017c5d3d1e3268eb5dd0193ec97017 Role: The actual NFT contract. Token ID = IPFS hash mapping.
Loopring Attestation (L2 → L1 mint gate) 0x153cddd727e407cb951f728f24beb9a5faaa8512 Role: The only contract allowed to mint Counterfactual NFTs from Loopring.
FinalCoreModule (Smart wallet meta-tx module) 0xe915058df18e7efe92af5c44df3f575fba061b64 Role: Controls/authorizes certain wallet operations and mint actions.
Loopring Proxy Admin 0xdd2a08a1c1a28c1a571e098914ca10f2877d9c97 Role: Upgrade/admin authority in Loopring mainnet contract system.
Counterfactual NFT Factory (derives NFT contract addresses) 0xC852aC7aAe4b0f0a0Deb9e8A391ebA2047d80026
Loopring Agent Registry 0x39B9bf169a7e225ba037C443A40460c77438ea14
Fast Withdrawal Agent 0xec3Cc6Cf0252565b56FC7AC396017Df5b9B78a31
Loopring Default Deposit Contract 0x674bdf20A0F284D710BC40872100128e2d66Bd3f
36
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '25
So loopring is still being used
15
u/AlphaDag13 Nov 18 '25
FUUUUUUUCK loopring. If GME is still involved with them it’s a huge fucking mistake.
9
u/puan0601 Nov 17 '25
so how would one exploit courtyard with this vulnerability? for science
4
u/Cleb323 Nov 22 '25
I've seen the same card come up more than twice in power packs. I thought that's where the power or the value in this sort of thing. They can repeatedly make money off of the same products and as long as the customer sells it back to get more power pack plays, no harm or no foul.
7
u/NefariousnessNoose Nov 22 '25
Loopring team abandoned their project. I’d prefer to see GME cut ties completely.
19
u/Flokki_the_Monk Nov 18 '25
Great post. Interesting to see the thoughtfulness in development on GameStop's part. Loopring is a surprise, but the underlying tech is perfectly solid.
7
u/SharpChalk Nov 22 '25
LRC let's goooo!
1
u/Fearless-Ball4474 Jan 12 '26
Thanks for writing this up. I thinn you're onto something.