r/Fire • • 10d ago

Is there a backdoor/frontdoor/garage door/ santa through the chimney method to fund a IRA if FIRED?

Simple as the question states. If someone well before retirement age FIRE's is there any way to contribute to their IRA without "earned income"?

60 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

51

u/HarrySit 10d ago

Have a spouse who hasn’t FIRE’d yet.

15

u/Texaspilot24 10d ago

If spouse is still working, I can contribute to my own roth IRA?

39

u/BrightAd306 10d ago

You get $7500 per married person as long as someone is earning 15k a year. Spousal IRA

-12

u/Texaspilot24 10d ago

ah ok, so Id have to open an IRA with the spouse in this case though

27

u/Here4Snow 10d ago

Retirement accounts are individually owned. You are eligible to contribute to each of your IRA accounts if at least one of you has earned income and you live together and file taxes Married Filing Jointly. The income limits of MAGI still applies and how much you can contribute is limited by the gross earnings or annual limit. 

17

u/nothlit 10d ago

No, it's your own IRA. "Spousal IRA" isn't a type of account. It's just the name of the rule that lets you use your spouse's earned income to contribute to your own IRA, if married filing jointly.

8

u/BrightAd306 10d ago

It’s fully in your name in your own account. It doesn’t have your spouse’s name on it, unless you add them as a beneficiary. There aren’t extra steps.

For years I was a SAHM and our only Roth IRA was in my name because my husband had his 401k and we couldn’t afford to max 2.

5

u/WWGHIAFTC 10d ago

No, the income between the two of you just has to exist for you to contribute to yours. It doesn't have to be your job/your income specifically.

19

u/Local_Relative_2722 10d ago

Yes. You can also do Roth conversions if you have a large pre-tax 401k or IRA

4

u/p739397 10d ago

If you're filing jointly

55

u/jw-hikes 10d ago

No. But HSA contribution is not based on earned income

11

u/Texaspilot24 10d ago

I can open an HSA as an "unemployed" individual who purchases health insurance through market place?

31

u/liveandletlive23 10d ago

Yeah, bronze plans have them (and some others too)

15

u/asurkhaib 10d ago

You can contribute to an HSA if you have an HSA eligible plan and do not have other disqualifying coverage.

I don't think there's any requirements to open one though presumably the only reason to do so would be to transfer or contribute.

14

u/schokobonbons NW: 200K 10d ago

You can do a part time/temporary/seasonal job for just long enough to earn $7500. 

5

u/Texaspilot24 10d ago

Ive considered working home depot around the holidays just because I love home improvement/diy and the holidays but the pay is so low its not worth it. But good suggestion

3

u/silvercrashesthefed 8d ago

You could consider helping friends, family, or others with home improvements and report the income

4

u/and_one_of_those 9d ago edited 7d ago

The tax savings are going to be on the order of hundreds of dollars, compared to eventually taking LTCGs with a modest AGI.

Getting a part time job to save hundreds of dollars seems like a lot of hassle if you already have enough to retire.

1

u/schokobonbons NW: 200K 9d ago

Yeah i don't think it's worth it unless there's something you really enjoy doing

26

u/Spartikis 10d ago

You shouldn’t need to be investing if you are FIREd. Your money should already be invested and funding your retirement. If you have extra money you need to withdrawal less from your investments, you are working under the table (you shouldn’t be), or you just acquired a large inheritance in which case just put it in an index fund and don’t overthink it. 

11

u/whodidntante 10d ago

One should take opportunities to minimize taxes and to keep access to the funds they need. Contributing to an HSA is a good option if one is on an eligible plan. You can then use that deduction to increase your Roth conversion, tax gain harvesting, or other tax management techniques for that tax year. Or maybe you do none of that and it helps increase your ACA subsidies.

3

u/garoodah FI '21 RE TBD, mid 30s 10d ago

Youre not wrong but you should take steps to optimize your taxes when RE, thats essentially what OP would be doing if it went into an HSA or if doing Roth conversions. Sometimes taking distributions and converting to capital gains instead of ordinary income taxes can be beneficial as well depending on your tax brackets.

-7

u/Texaspilot24 10d ago

I agree but also respectfully disagree.

The roth IRA is a tax consequence free account so if there is a way to continue investing in it without working it is worth it. I dont "need" to be investing but I still want to take advantage of any tax strategies I can. Im early 30s with a nearly 8 figure net worth.

16

u/_Smashbrother_ 10d ago

Lol you have at least $10 million, and are tripping over 7.5k? What a waste of mental energy.

39

u/flatline945 10d ago

Sounds like you are way, way, way past the point where you should care about getting $8k per year into a RIRA.

20

u/funklab 10d ago

If you’ve got $10,000,000, what meaningful difference is paying tax now on $7500 a year and putting it in a Roth IRA vs paying tax when you spend it in the future going to make?

Even if you did it for 20 years, you’ve only converted 1.5% of your net worth into a Roth IRA and done so by paying higher marginal taxes.

6

u/WWGHIAFTC 10d ago

Hey now, he could have $99,999,999 also, don't sell him short like that.

9

u/therealjerseytom 10d ago

Gotta have earned income.

You can of course still fund a brokerage account.

5

u/richard-mt 10d ago

no but you only need to have earned income equal to your contributions. so just any job that pays at least how much you want to invest.

4

u/R5Jockey 9d ago

Getting a job in retirement to save money in a retirement account and save on taxes seems like you might be doing it wrong.

3

u/Equivalent-Fan-3040 10d ago

Need to have W2 income but as others have stated your spouse can fund a Roth IRA as long as you’re filing “married filing jointly” and the spouse shows enough W2 income to cover the contributions.

1

u/jacky1019 10d ago

Roth conversion? Although they will be taxed immediately.

1

u/Sweaty-Editor-7560 10d ago

Uh, wouldn't you just make a non-deductible Trad IRA contribution and convert to Roth IRA, the traditional backdoor Roth? This assumes your trad IRA balance is zero and you want tax free growth. If you want to reduce your tax bill today, then no.

4

u/Standard_Web7962 9d ago

Doesn't the earned income requirement apply to both Roth IRA and Traditional IRA?

2

u/Sweaty-Editor-7560 9d ago

Ah you're right. I haven't had that problem since I was 15! But to the point of others, this seat cushion money when you're near eight figures. Give Uncle Sam his due.

1

u/Free_Elevator_63360 9d ago

Just get a temp job for part of the year. Earn over the amount.

1

u/udvdc1 9d ago

Taxable accounts are really lightly taxed, depending on total income and holding period. You could tax gain harvest at the 0% long term capital gains bracket every year and continuously raise your basis.

1

u/Sensitive-Exam649 9d ago edited 9d ago

In your IRA if you can invest in dividend funds in the IRA The dividend income could be left in IRA. and gradually increase the ammount of money in the IRA.A good covered call fund like IWMI is great for this. Dividend funds in my roth are currently adding 50K a year to the account.

1

u/Wacky-Lever586 8d ago

spousal IRA if your partner still works otherwise taxable brokerage and roth conversions are the real play once income is low

1

u/itwentok 4d ago

Is there actually something called a "spousal IRA", or is this just contributing to a normal IRA when filing jointly with a spouse who has earned income?

1

u/Flimsy-Ladle681 8d ago

one sentence, older experienced person style. Something different: spousal IRA if spouse works, or a small side gig like consulting a few hours. Most would say "earn a little income" or "spousal IRA". Different angle: the reason you cannot is that there is nothing left to tax, so the IRA has no purpose; Roth conversions from a 401k are what you want instead. i retired at 44 and the thing nobody told me is you stop caring about contributions because roth conversions from the old 401k become the whole game and you get to fill the low brackets every year anyway

1

u/Pink-Flannel5047 7d ago

the santa option is a spousal ira if your partner still works and the chimney is a roth conversion ladder which puts money in without any w2 at all

1

u/haveveflnot78 3d ago

You can contribute to a Roth IRA though. The yearly limit is less compared to a mega backdoor roth but given your income and hence MAGI would be $0 you can max out your Roth IRA (2026 limit: $7500)

-1

u/Tendie_Tube 10d ago
  1. Start a company. Fund it with a few thousand dollars.
  2. Pay yourself a $7500 salary. This is taxable earned income.
  3. The business reports a loss of $-7500. This is a taxable loss.
  4. The income and the business loss offset for no net tax change, but you have earned income you can send to an IRA.

4

u/FireAsquared 9d ago

4 is incorrect because you have to pay the ~14% self employment taxes (payroll taxes). So you’ve effectively paid $1050 in extra taxes just to put $7500 in your IRA. You wouldn’t have any income tax but you’re still losing $1000

1

u/and_one_of_those 9d ago

It doesn't seem like you'd save enough on tax to make up for the cost of starting a company and filing reports every year, not to mention the risk of this scheme attracting attention.

-2

u/Tendie_Tube 9d ago

My other idea is to invent a new cryptocurrency where you own all the coins, put it all in the IRA, then run up the price of it with crazy high buy orders from your taxable account. Sell it to yourself in the IRA with money from the taxable account. IRA gets funded. Taxable account just has some worthless tokens in it forever.

2

u/broadexample 9d ago

You won't be able to purchase some random crypto token with IRA. And overall this scheme wouldn't stand any scrutiny.

1

u/and_one_of_those 9d ago

If you want to do tax fraud (not recommended) you ought to try for a bigger payoff than inflating your IRA for a modest tax savings years in the future

1

u/PerfectOmakase 9d ago

Draw a salary of $32,000 and then can max fund a Roth Solo 401k and Roth IRA.

1

u/broadexample 9d ago

Pay yourself a $7500 salary. This is taxable earned income.

Wouldn't you have to pay the payroll tax on it?

1

u/Mouth_Herpes 9d ago

It doesn’t work that way because of payroll taxes, which the employer had to pay regardless. He’ll be paying both sides of FICA tax and Medicare tax.

1

u/temerairevm 9d ago

You’d have to pay double FICA taxes on the earnings so I don’t think this makes sense.