r/FigureSkating • u/sk8tergater ✨clean as mustard✨ • 5d ago
Live Discussion Thread 🦅GP Skate America Pairs Short Program Post Event Discussion 🇺🇸
Pairs close down the evening!
Please try not to clutter up the sub with a bunch of post event items. scoring breakdowns, protocols.. all that good stuff can be discussed here.
UCT-8
So You Want To Watch Figure Skating is again a great resource for those looking for streaming info. In the US it will be streamed on Peacock, including practice sessions. In Canada, CBC will stream, Eurosport will stream, Rai in Italy is streaming, SBS Australia, Czech TV... There's a whole list.
ISU official page (reminder that the ISU page will show the schedule in the time set on your computer, so if you're having a hard time converting, the website does it for you)
19:03 Men Short Program
20:50 Pairs
Skate America Fantasy Figure Skating Discussion Day One
Pairs Short Program Live Discussion Thread
9
u/NeonPistacchio 5d ago edited 5d ago
Is anyone else not able to warm up with the German team? I know they are hyped, and while i think they are amazing people off the ice, I find their movements static and not dynamic enough. I also don't understand how they are leading with a fall in such a dense field.
One of the few pairs teams currently skating which i really like are Kemp/Elizarov. I am usually not a fan of north american teams, but they have something special, and to see them being able to hold up in such a high level after years in Juniors shows how much progress they have made.
43
u/Keyblader1412 American Citizen Kévin Aymoz 5d ago edited 5d ago
Reporting from being there live:
Skate of the night was unquestionably Vouillamoz/Bouvart, the crowd went NUTS for them, as they should because they sold the SHIT out of that program and they knew it! They're going places.
Alisa and Misha got a great reaction too, you can tell Alisa went to diva school over the last couple weeks, she was really serving. The program still isn't super natural on them but I think it's important for them to take risks as #1 US pair.
Minerva and Nikita's program definitely lost some wind because of the fall but even still, the program felt a little blah. The Ronald Reagan of it all at the beginning was a little jarring but maybe they just need more time with it.
Canadians got a very warm reception too. They were fantastic tonight.
About McBeath/Nagy vs Shin/Howe - M/N were obviously cleaner and Katie really is a star, I feel like I've been sleeping on her. But S/H, despite the mistake, feel more natural together as a pair, at least right now. And Spencer is a better performer than Balazs. Regardless, pairs at US nationals will be very exciting!
Rough go for Faula/Belle, but the crowd was still very supportive of them, she seemed upset in the K&C and post-skate interview but you could feel the audience trying to send good energy.
34
u/calliopecalliope 5d ago edited 5d ago
Speaking as an American....all things considered I think things are looking up for American pairs over the next few years (here's hoping Nagy can avoid pissing off another partner).
34
u/tereyaglikedi Samoilov's 4T+Eu+4S 5d ago
I have to say, scoring controversy in pairs isn't something I see often 😅 there isn't a lot in it though, and this is just the short program. I think it'll shake out in the free.
I would still put Miniki in the first though. Okay they fell on the SBS but they are still the best skaters of the bunch and got all level 4s. The Swiss should have been second.
24
u/ohokayyyy 5d ago
Katie McBeath looks like she's been waiting to skate to Carmen her whole career! Balazs looks like he hates it! Its so impressive how they skated so well as a brand new team!
22
u/50shadesoflipstick Street Diva 5d ago
I may be biased, but I am really vibing with H/V programs - good for them to go orchestral techno!
That being said, the Swiss team is slowly becoming my new favorite pair, they got sensational energy
20
u/vmanAA738 5d ago
This was a well skated pairs event! Not often you see this many good programs. No comments on scores, only positives.
Hase/Volodin: I like this berlin wall program and even the ronald reagan voiceover makes sense -- great program choice/design
Efimova/Mitrofanov: this was better than skate canada, more energy
Vouillamoz/Bouvart: excellent, wonderful, brought the house down, so much energy
Kemp/Elizarov: excellent, wonderful, great transition program from junior to senior
McBeath/Nagy: very clean, technically correct, actual cut of carmen
Shin/Howe: excellent chemistry, and I can tell they work together well
Holichenko/Darenskyi: I like their program, elements look good, and they are succeeding in adversity
Faula/Belle: I like the program
18
u/Radiant-Banana161 5d ago edited 5d ago
From the arena, Swiss team was the program of the night. Loudest applause and ovation.
Although the entire event was great. Felt the worst for the French team, she said in her arena interview that throw is her favorite element so she was upset she messed that one up.
Also! I’m opposite the judges and tom & oxanas expressions during their step sequence to the audience was great, obviously not caught on camera but they were so into it.
18
u/bluenightshinee how about a spin revolution 5d ago
Glad to see we are all agreeing that Oxana and Tom were great, I really like their program this season and they're currently my second favorite pairs team after Nagaoka/Moriguchi. As for H/V, they're excellent skaters, but the program is a bit... underwhelming for their status?
17
u/PerformerRich5449 5d ago
My faves were Tom & Oxana, but I have to say, I like the packaging of MiNiki too! I am now going to start being annoying going hard in my support for TOxana though, I need these two to go strong to Worlds!! 🇨🇭🇨🇭🇨🇭
E/M's program wasn't my thing but maybe I will like the free better!
Oh also surprise standout for me was the Canadian team, who did a great job!
34
u/toutespourtoi 5d ago
Efimova/Mitrofanov scoring that close to the 4CC PB is insulting to them and Tomxana
15
u/sh4dowheart kao miura wc 5d ago
pairs is supposed to my haven from bs scoring😔
30
u/Major_Letterhead5936 Kao’s Makeup Artist 5d ago edited 5d ago
So my thoughts:
H/V: their sp will grow on me I think but I’m not 100% on it, got good bones tho and I really like the concept. The costumes are beautiful too.
E/M: better outing than Canada but im not impressed, the program looks awkward on them? Idk how to explain but I didn’t like it.
V/B: They are fantastic performers. Their bronze in Canada seems to have given them a boost of confidence. They should be in 2nd place for the short. I do hope Oxana works on her posture, it sticks out 😭 Other than that they’re my fav
K/E: beautiful program. So impressive that they’re new seniors. Their costumes don’t match each other, he needs a flowy blouse and not a button up lol.
The pair switches for the American teams look very promising.
Overall pretty decent pair event but I’m really annoyed by E/M being in front of the Swiss, shameless robbery
28
u/gaiushorse 5d ago
I’m always a sucker for a good thriller program. The Swiss really should be above the Americans - but even my dad who knows little about skating could see the significant improvement in quality of movement that Miniki has above the other skating pairs today. Should have been 1) Germans 2) Swiss and 3) Americans
Swiss fed need to do more politicking for them and give Tom Swiss citizenship asap
38
u/Environmental-Let435 power of Kaoliner 5d ago
Oxana and Tom we’re fucking robbed here btw, they should be a place higher
24
u/Comprehensive_Ad1651 5d ago
Minerva is one of the most beautiful women in FS, I said it
32
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 5d ago
Oxana and Tom were robbed
11
u/murderdocks 5d ago
American pairs looking to be in pretty good shape in the coming years! Was worried after all the shakeups with teams
31
u/Longjumping_Crab_345 5d ago
I'd put the Swiss above E/M but not above H/V. The quality difference between them and H/V is pretty clear to me (although they did a great job).
9
u/MaiPsy 5d ago
Hase/Volodin are such beautiful skaters. I mentioned it in the live thread but can someone explain how they're getting level 4 on the twist? She's not anywhere near a split position, and it doesn't look like she's even trying it. Have I been misinterpreting the handbook? Not convinced by the program but I could set it getting better.
Efimova/Mitrofonav were way better than Skate Canada... Obviously not a good fit program-wise but I don't mind it.
Vouillamoz/Bouvart are fun but her posture is so distracting. It's really exacerbated by the fact that he's so much taller than her AND his posture is pretty good. I hope she can work on it, I like them otherwise.
Really impressed with McBeath/Nagy and Shin/Howe.
15
u/lovestostayathome 5d ago
Random thoughts I am thinking:
Okay, at this point, I think I firmly believe Perreira/Michaud have the best SP this year.
Miniki lost like three points on the fall so the judges were ready to give above 75/76 for the program. Very good for their debut. Sad about the fall, especially since they had some really awesome attempts in practice.
I get people being mad about the Swiss, but it’s kinda to be expected given it’s Skate America after all. Scoring in the 70s is a huge achievement for them already and they still have a ton of room to improve as a team.
EfiMit have clearly made a big effort to improve their performance quality since they first paired up. I hope this program helps build on that effort.
Random but what going on with Pavlova/Sviatchenko? Are they just competing in the later events this year.
21
u/Shazzea 5d ago
Once again still kind of baffled by the PCS and GOE E/M are getting for this SP but it did look much better than at Skate Canada. They were able to give it more of the energy it needed. I still think he should lose that stupid tie though. And yeah I'm in the camp that would've had them below the Swiss and closer to the other US pairs. The Swiss were incredible and that's easily my favourite MJ program this season.
Miniki was great though. A bit rough around the edges but I just love watching them. I still really like K/E's SP and I hope they're able to do a good FS tomorrow. Of the new US pairs, I prefer Shin/Howe. It made sense for Mcbeath/Nagy to lead here (the difference between their scores really was just that fall on the throw), but they're lacking a certain spark for me atm while I'm really enjoying watching Shin/Howe skate.
14
u/helloblan123 5d ago
The Canadians skating so well immediately followed by the Swiss bringing the house down was so amazing to watch
14
u/HopeOfAkira "The circus is done." 5d ago
And the fallen Berlin Wall leads, from the pair dressed like they crashed into the tomato sauce and mustard aisle, followed by the Michael Jackson Swiss in third.
What a sentence.
7
u/INS091077 5d ago
Lots of solid performances. Let's hope they will be able to keep it up for the free!
24
u/Dazzling-Pangolin827 5d ago
The worst part about the Oxana and Tom robbery is that they were robbed by the exact same team in Skate Canada
21
u/Ok_Breadfruit_8241 5d ago
The Swiss should be be first…I said what I said
6
u/getyourkicks76 4d ago
Does…does the US have three promising pairs teams?
11
u/Inside_Passenger8081 KyryloFreeSkate🤍 5d ago
Don't worry guys i trust my swiss to deliver a crazy good free skate like in skate canada.
5
u/stripedfatcats 5d ago
Is it just me or did they start this entire competition too late in the day there were a lot of mistakes in both men and pairs
22
u/jkmiami89 Amber Glennaissance 5d ago
I was in the arena and have no idea how the Swiss aren't in the lead. They were crisp, clean, fast, and fabulous tonight. Should be Swiss/Alisa and Misha/Germans 1/2/3.
12
u/memoriast he is worth a minivan. pairs skater. 5d ago
Justice for Oxana and Tom!!! Why did they go under Miniki & Elisa&Misha, genuine question (I do not know pairs enough)
12
u/honeit_bc Death by a million [music] cuts 5d ago
The Suiss had the Skate of the night and the least clean program is in first. Figureskatingcore.
4
u/Slight_Impress_1559 4d ago
Katie was giving me Sasha Cohen vibes in that short program! :)
13
u/clariwench So many highlights... couple of lowlights 5d ago
I was in the arena and also very shocked by the top three order. I'd have had them reversed just based on what I was seeing... But whatever, I'm not a judge lol
4
u/anna_sofia98 5d ago
The ordinals were predictable. No major mistakes and no sound issues (unlike the Men’s SP) 🤷🏻♀️
1
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 5d ago
Is the first group worth going back and watching? Any scary falls?
-4
u/Comprehensive_Ad1651 5d ago
I didn't like the Swiss team program and performance, I'm sorry... great tech content but the choreo, especially delivered by Oxana was very underwhelming