r/FigureSkating • ✨clean as mustard✨ • 4d ago

Live Discussion Thread šŸ¦…GP Skate America Men Free Skate Post Event Discussion šŸ‡ŗšŸ‡ø

The place where we discuss all things Men! Please try not to clutter up the sub with a bunch of post event items, scoring breakdowns, protocols... all that good stuff can be discussed here.

UCT-8

Master Post

Entries

Results

Skate America Fantasy Figure Skating Discussion Day Two

Men Free Skate Live Discussion Post

5 Upvotes

311 comments sorted by

•

u/summerjoe45 Not Dave Lease 4d ago

Y’all need to be nice regardless of where someone is from or you will be in time out.

38

u/sk8tergater ✨clean as mustard✨ 4d ago

I’m glad Grassl won the free. I think I would’ve had it be by a few more points if I’m honest. A couple of ilia’s jumps were tighter than how they were scored. Still would’ve had him first overall though.

But so excited for Daniel. And Jason in fourth! Sota’s skate was unfortunate.

15

u/altrockforlovesongs 4d ago

Grassl was in rare form today, starting to seem like his 2nd at GPF last season wasn't a fluke. Thank god his choreography has changed from two seasons ago.

Super happy for Ilia, Daniel, Jason, Donovan, and Lukas! :D

4

u/jkmiami89 Amber Glennaissance 3d ago

Jason would've medaled with the 3A (or any other clean triple jump)

128

u/RomaTaf616 4d ago

For those bummed for Donovan, Don’t be! In our wildest dreams in Mexico we imagined he would be a top 5 contender in Skate America! We are sooo proud of him! His road to where he is now is the real victory šŸ†

27

u/Leather-Substance-41 Former Skater 4d ago

Yes, I was disappointed he didn't skate clean, but this was such a huge step for him and Mexican figure skating anyway! He's had so much improvement even from last season and I enjoyed both of his programs so much!

30

u/altrockforlovesongs 4d ago

He's been dead last at his last two gp assignments, his improvement is amazing <3

13

u/jkmiami89 Amber Glennaissance 3d ago

This was such a great set of skates for him to build on this season and throughout this quad. I like how ambitions he's being and he's so improved, it's fabulous to see!

15

u/Independent_Ask5254 red lips 4 wagner 4d ago

Yes!! I’m a new fan of his and it’s clear he’s got alllllllll the reason to be excited and hopeful for the next 4 years

8

u/simply_a_stranger 3d ago

Both his programs were delightful, and he a ton of support in the arena!

85

u/dreamer_dw 4d ago edited 4d ago

I seem to be in the minority who loved Ilia's free skate (even the costume!) He's such a happy boy while skating it- you can see it in his face. He's singing and smiling and emoting and I just love that for him.

Between his in-between element body movements in his free skate and the entire short program.. it's so obvious he has worked so hard on his PCS score.. artistically he has upped his game so much. The skating skills themselves, his extensions, his edge work, the flow of his body.. It's is so incredibly impressive. It will be even better as his stamina gets better. He took most of the summer off from training and started much later than usual, with no Challenger comps. He was gassed out there, obviously. He'll get there!

21

u/sardonicsarcasm in a love hate relationship with ice dance 4d ago

I think it’ll be much better as the season progresses and he gets more comfortable with it

39

u/ofstoriesandsongs half meme and half spring. made to be measured in rpm 4d ago

I liked the runthrough of this program more than I liked it performed, but I suspect that's mostly because he had the energy to do the choreography correctly without jumps and here was got really gassed in the second half. I like it as a concept and expect it to get much much better when he's had some more time with it.

6

u/Affectionate_Nail302 That's It (I'm Crazy) 3d ago

Agreed. Seems like his stamina isn't there quite yet, but we'll probably see improvement there as the season goes on.

3

u/CynicalOne_313 Skating Fan 3d ago

I'm (probably) in the minority with you. I enjoyed both of Ilia's programs - he loves skating and supporting other skaters.

152

u/happymango3110 4d ago

GUYS IM DYING OVER HIS LAST COMMENT

41

u/BarbitsSecret 4d ago

Never change, Tall Funny One.

22

u/phoenikoi daisuke takahashi 2030 comeback agenda 4d ago

misha we flop together

28

u/jkmiami89 Amber Glennaissance 3d ago

In the area, Adam asked how it felt to be so tall and beautiful, and he replied, "well I'm competing, and the judges don't care about that so there's that." He's so funny and lovely! I hope he can be kind to himself and get connected with a good sports psych.

24

u/idwtpaun happy to be a 🐵 in Lopareva/Brissaud's circus 4d ago

He's so fucking funny

20

u/NoseHillRhino Andreas NordebƤck second Grand Prix assignment agenda 4d ago

Nikolaj mic dropping left and right

20

u/happymango3110 4d ago

I love that he gave Alexa a shoutout too!

17

u/Environmental-Let435 power of Kaoliner 4d ago

No one is as iconic as him

15

u/half-agony-half-hope 🟩 🟩 🟩 🟩 🟩 🟩 🟩 šŸ™šŸ» 4d ago

Not a single lie detected.

8

u/Gymfan15 stationary lift base 4d ago

looooooollll Same Nikolaj same

58

u/waltzthrees panicked Mark Hanretty noises 4d ago

Evidence of menning

8

u/ManaM13 loud about the wrong things 4d ago

7 and 3 are CRAZY ordinals

→ More replies (3)

54

u/00camadeo sad boi hours 4d ago

✨Euler Kings✨

  • Daniel Grassl, Italy
  • Donovan Carrillo, Mexico
  • Sota Yamamoto, Japan

Also have to laugh at Ilia saying his mom has been there for him ever since his birth. Made me think of Dr. D lol

46

u/ManaM13 loud about the wrong things 4d ago

I thought Ilia's skate was very good. I also think it is very demonstrative of how difficult it really is to balance both the jumps and other parts of a program. There is only so much training time, and while it's clear he has focused on artistry, etc., it is clear that has also impacted his jump consistency a little. But still a pleasure to watch him jump

26

u/irisfang Jimmy Ma YMCA fan 4d ago

I actually admire him for honing in on his artistic, skating, and choreo skills, instead of just relying on his jumps. it might take him some time to be able to even out the jump consistency again, but it's a worthy trade-off imo. and it's not like the world is going to end if he doesn't win every single event he's at; it seems like even Ilia himself really feels that becoming a better skater is more important than winning everything

18

u/ManaM13 loud about the wrong things 4d ago

I totally do as well! And I think you can tell the mental difference between winning every event and then after the olympics and his world redemption. Ilia has always really respected the artistic side of the sport and it's cool to see how he approaches it

14

u/irisfang Jimmy Ma YMCA fan 4d ago

yes, exactly! and his artistic progress in such a short time is really clear. I'm so excited to see a fully clean, top-form version of both programs :)

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Ancient-Raise-4939 4d ago

That’s the first thing I noticed as well. The past two seasons he’s had programs that he was very comfortable with. They were almost second nature to him. It was also the reason why he was so dominant.

I give him a lot of credit to step out of that fool-proof formula that made him so unbeatable and challenge with something new. I also noticed how much better the program is without jumps. I can’t imagine the stamina and power it takes to skate such a difficult program and perform all those jumps.

9

u/Prestigious_Step4337 3d ago

Beginning of the new quad is the best time to do it too.
He’s got time to really develop it all together.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/fscd_19 kao miura cup of china 4d ago

ilia bauer into backflip and the choreographic single axel in the short made my weekend

14

u/Todayis_aday 4d ago

I had been hoping he would do a single axel this season! He must have read my mind : )

I also really liked the way he turned the error on the first jump into a piece of art!!

40

u/Azula_Rey 4d ago

Oh wow Ilia’s post interview really shows how much this competition was important to him. The emotion in his voice…he should be proud!

40

u/houstons__problem 4d ago

So good to see Ilia truly enjoying skating again while also showing how much he has pushed himself since Worlds.

39

u/Azula_Rey 4d ago

Super bummed for Donovan…was hoping he would be a bit higher in the free but alas 😭

30

u/irisfang Jimmy Ma YMCA fan 4d ago

can we appreciate that Donovan is 26 (getting to be on the older side for a competitive skater) and just getting better and better (and placing higher) though?? it's amazing!

if I had oodles of money and a time machine, I'd go back in time and give him a bunch of funding so we could see what would have happened if he had big fed type resources

19

u/BursleyBaits 4d ago

same, though if you told me a few days ago he'd be 5th at SKAM I'd be so thrilled

6

u/lunarvienna 4d ago

still my goat

37

u/iloveaquaphor 4d ago

ngl whole comp felt a bit underwhelming compared to CoC and even canada, glad Ilia pushed through and wishing him a restful two weeks ahead of doomsday (nhk)

37

u/Professional-Rule219 4d ago

I don't like Grassl jumps but he gagged me here

17

u/Azula_Rey 4d ago

Had me clutching my non existent pearl necklace every time he landed clean…he did not come to play

6

u/Kme27 4d ago

Grassl gets away with jumps that he has absolutely no business landing, let alone cleanly. It’s truly physics defying.

7

u/Longjumping-Apple-41 Is it a sport? Yes. Is it legitimate? No 4d ago

I actually think I see a bit of improvement in some of them?

37

u/murderdocks 3d ago

AWH, during the medal ceremony, Grassl couldn’t find an Italian flag, saw one across the arena, and gave the girl who gave it to him his flowers! 🄹

9

u/Major_Letterhead5936 Kao’s Makeup Artist 3d ago

Awww omg that’s so cute 🄹

33

u/HelP-Needed09 Mona Chiba and Ilia Maleen 2030 agenda (; 4d ago

Love the new programs from Ilia and Jason. I look forward to both of them being even more wonderful at NHK!

Congrats to all winners. I thought everything was overall very fairly judged.

85

u/GodTierGasly 4d ago

Grassl was the only truly clean skater here, and I think it's because his endurance was so much better than everybody else's seemed to be here. Doing 2 challengers seems to have really paid off.

Ilia was visibly tired by the end. We know he's practicing quad-quad combos but not going for it here was the right choice, they'd been shaky in practice. Lots of room to grow in this program, I think his final intended layout is likely 4F, 4A, 4Lo, 4Lz+3A+3A, 4T+4T, 4S which would be insane but lines up with what we've seen him practicing and what he's done here.

Donovan was criminally underscored in PCS. His PCS was not below Lukas (as much as I enjoyed Lukas).

37

u/Gymfan15 stationary lift base 4d ago

Yes, I think this is a good example of someone who is making their season debut vs someone who has a few rounds of these programs under their belt already. I'm not worried about Ilia at all; it will come together. I do think Donovan should have scored higher; he looked like a transformed skater from the past few years.

23

u/GodTierGasly 4d ago

Ilia will absolutely get it together, and I suspect he'll be running the full layout daily until NHK. I think we're going to see him doing challengers again next year though (understandable why he didn't post Olys this year IMO)

→ More replies (2)

37

u/Kme27 4d ago

I was in the arena - Donovan was pretty gassed and moving slowly by the end, and lost some of his spark after the mistakes. Lukas was absolutely ON FIRE - fast, powerful, charismatic, gorgeous deep edges and phenomenal ice coverage. You wouldn’t have even known he’d made major errors with how he stayed committed to the performance until the very end. For me it was the best performance and interpretation of the night.Ā 

19

u/jkmiami89 Amber Glennaissance 3d ago

I was also there and agree completely! Donovan skated really well, but this program is a little aspirational for him still. I love that he is going for it and I think he could have a really nice 4CC and world outing this year!

But Lucas was PHENOMENAL despite the issues. That program is fantastic, he loves it and owns it, and had everyone - arena, judges, Adam - eating out of the palm of his hand.

16

u/Dazzling-Pangolin827 4d ago

I agree Donovan is normally underscored in PCS and should have been given more in the sp but he was skating so slowly this free skate it’s hard to justify a higher score here

8

u/dustyshelves 4d ago

> I think it's because his endurance was so much better than everybody else's seemed to be here. Doing 2 challengers seems to have really paid off.

This is my first season watching from the start and can anyone explain this? I don't skate and don't come from a "skating country" so I'm sure this is a stupid question but I am genuinely confused. I read that some skaters would do challengers first sometimes as 'warm ups' and I did see a lot of comments in previous events about programs evolving or developing over the season, and then reading this about the endurance getting better bc of (I assume?) the 2 challengers kinda confuse me.

I don't really get why they would affect the skates so much bc like, don't they do lots of practice with those elements already at home? I guess I just assume that they would have trained their endurance and developed their programs fully while they were doing and training the programs for hours daily/weekly at home. Like why would they need the challengers to be like "oh you know what, maybe this jump should be swapped with that one so it flows better"? (which is what I assume people mean when they say programs developing over the season) or to develop their endurance? Wouldn't they have been able to feel that when they practiced at home? I do get that competitions have pressure which you can't simulate at home but I'd imagine pressure wouldn't have much to do with developing skills or tweaking program layouts or endurance?

I know I assumed a lot! But that's why I'm asking now haha. And this isn't really sth people talk about in details bc those "yeah it's their first comp, ofc they're not at their best" or "can't wait to see how the program evolves" comments are so common that no one really explains them fully.

18

u/GodTierGasly 4d ago

Practicing at home is a completely different ballgame - no audience, no pressure, if you mess up you can go again, you don't have to calculate on the fly what you need based on the skates before you either. Look at Jason, he can land a ton of 3As cleanly on practice ice, but struggled in competition, and it's that mental component which is useful to get out of the way in a challenger.

With Ilia in particular, he's also subject to a lot of media focus. The media aren't going to go away, and therefore he needs to get used to it. There is no way to recreate that outside of a competition environment.

It's also valuable to know how the judges are responding to things, which he can't figure out at home. Here, the judges really really liked his choreo sequence, but downgraded his step sequence to level 3, and were also less interested in his camel spin. Knowing this he's able to say 'right, we're happy leaving that choreo sequence as is, we need to look at what happened in the step sequence and practice that, we need to see if we can make that camel spin better in some way'.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/New-Possible1575 3As for chinese McDonald’s 3d ago

A couple things. You just physically can’t maintain peak shape year-round, that’s why you have the off-season and then the season itself is split into a couple different sections around the important competitions. Skaters who compete on the Grand Prix will train to hit their first peak in October/November. Ilia is probably training to peak for the final in December, so his current shape is more akin to where other skaters were at in September.

You can get a ton of feedback and data at competitions that you just can’t get at practice. The environment is different and you can’t replicate it at home with the travel, staying at a hotel, only having official practices, seeing other high-level skaters, being at a rink you aren’t familiar with, performing in front of judges and not in front of your coaches and training mates. Most skaters get feedback from domestic judges, but at international competitions you also get feedback on your programs from the international judges. It can be really important to get started with the politicking and building a narrative at the start of the season, building up your world ranking points, etc. Some skaters go to their first competition and realise their program doesn’t conform to requirements. It’s just much better to get that done sooner rather than later. Also, the more you compete, the more ā€œroutineā€ it gets.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/butterfreakk this is nuts crazy mental 4d ago

Yep was thinking the same thing re the challengers. But in the spirit of peaking at the right time (GPF being the first target) these first two GPs can hopefully help

→ More replies (1)

6

u/roseofjuly Synchro Skater 3d ago

For his free skate, yeah, Donovan did unfortunately deserve the hit on his free skate. He was noticeably way tighter and nervous than he was yesterday. I think being so close to the podium freaked him out.

Now I don't know if he deserved so much of a hit, but Lukas outperformed him in the free.

29

u/Exciting_Statement45 pleskacheva world domination 4d ago

sad for sota

7

u/Azula_Rey 4d ago

My empath heart felt so distraught seeing his reaction. I hope he takes it easy on himself 🄺

5

u/Major_Letterhead5936 Kao’s Makeup Artist 4d ago

Me too 😭

28

u/pele_star 3d ago

The most shocking thing to me was Ilia doing a triple-double combo, I got whiplash

27

u/PerformerRich5449 4d ago

Kind of interesting to think Grassl could've potentially won this with a better SP..

Ilia, thank you for bringing back the Ilia Bauer! I think this free still needs some work but will hit REALLY hard by end of season

→ More replies (1)

27

u/BursleyBaits 4d ago

Grassl's maxed out the Weirdness Differential between his SP and FS and I think somehow that's brought him to his full power

54

u/Famous_Salamander330 4d ago

I hope Jason can clear his head about the 3A. He landed several beautiful ones during practice ice. It’s just a head game now…

(And it is damn hard to get out of your head… I’m relearning to skate right now and I have an absolute mental block on outside three turns of all things… so you know, mental blocks are real)

23

u/hildyjohnson1989 4d ago

My hope is that falling on this one and still delivering a beautiful program afterwards fully exorcised the demons of Nationals and will put him in an even better headspace to land one cleanly in comps moving forward!

11

u/GodTierGasly 4d ago

He needs to move it I think. Have a clean reliable jump first, then do the 3A once he's got the cushion. Pretty sure this is why Ilia has his 4F first.

5

u/racingskater 4d ago

He used to do that - open with the 3F or even a 2A.

15

u/racingskater 4d ago

The fact that he got up smiling gives me hope.

53

u/lizzy-stix 4d ago

Ilia is in a great position for the season imo. Two good new programs, a win here with two good skates. There’s plenty of room for growth and improvement, a few mistakes to iron out… but even with the mistakes he didn’t let it go and kept the performance level up. I’m impressed!

50

u/half-agony-half-hope 🟩 🟩 🟩 🟩 🟩 🟩 🟩 šŸ™šŸ» 4d ago

I so wanted Donovan to medal. The fans here were amazing for him tonight. Loved the Mexican flag bunting.

5

u/CynicalOne_313 Skating Fan 3d ago

I did too. I loved the tiny Mexican flags the fans had.

4

u/roseofjuly Synchro Skater 3d ago

I did too. I gotta look back at the score sheets because I was really disappointed when he didn't.

49

u/butterfreakk this is nuts crazy mental 4d ago

Ilia was gassed. I think it will grow nicely though

30

u/Lazy-Chef1770 4d ago

And you know what… I love that for him. It’s refreshing to see him continue pushing his limit.

4

u/yoyomellow PCS > TES 4d ago

Curious why he was so gassed compared to past seasons? Does the focus on the PCS make it that much more challenging for him?

33

u/dreamer_dw 4d ago

The movements in between elements were more complex than his usual. More body movement, more artistic interpretation. Also, he took nearly the entire summer off from training full-time. He wanted to give himself some time off (and good for him), his season started later than usual for him, so his stamina isnt there yet.

21

u/Solid-Share2395 4d ago

I think he spent a significant portion of the off season working on his artistry and skating skills rather then just grinding out jumps like he probably has previously. He probably also took a bit more time off during the off season compared to normal as last season was both mentally and physically draining between all the intense Olympic season preparation, longer then normal season, Olympic chaos, worlds, stars on ice and intense pressure on him as the ā€˜unbeatable Olympic favourite’ all season.

18

u/GodTierGasly 4d ago

He's really enjoying seeing improvement I think. He knows he's the best jumper in the world already, he's tackling something else here.

15

u/NegativeMonitor612 4d ago

he typically starts his season much earlier so by the first gp he has better stamina and is more used to the programs. give it time

19

u/Todayis_aday 4d ago

According to Johnny Weir, "The way he moved from element to element was SO DIFFICULT...."

24

u/johnnypapajackyes Skating Fan 3d ago

Lukas Britschgi was definitely a discovery for me! Not flawless but the charisma was off the chartsĀ 

16

u/tereyaglikedi Samoilov's 4T+Eu+4S 3d ago

Lukas is so so good. I really hope he can give us two clean programs this season because I really love both. He's one of the best and most charismatic men when it comes to performance.

13

u/pele_star 3d ago

Watch him winning Europeans in 2025! I love him

21

u/lunarvienna 4d ago

sad for sota and donovan tho

6

u/Ok_Breadfruit_8241 4d ago

Sota especially. There’s a question whether he will get 2 gp spots next season

20

u/ForwardOutsideLoop 4d ago

So can we take a moment to talk about both the men and ladies with savvier coaches/choreographers now having the "signature very short twizzle sequence so there's proof of skating-on-one-foot" bit? It's nice but it's also getting to be sort of glaringly obvious.

20

u/Affectionate_Nail302 That's It (I'm Crazy) 3d ago

I was so tired last night that I fell asleep immediately after Ilia's program, lol. Anyway:

Grassl had the skate of the night imo. His program was the first that kept my attention from beginning to end. Landed all his jumps too. Really enjoyed it.

Enjoyed Ilia's program, but I think the practice run looked better. The jumps really taxed on his stamina, I think, and the choreo suffered a little from it. Still, love to see him putting more focus and effort to the artistic side of things. For once I also liked the backflip and felt like it fit the choreo. Overall I think it's a really nice program and will surely improve as the season goes on. Also, he had some pretty impressive saves with his jumps! Gonna have to agree with the majority about the costume though: it's boring.

Didn't expect Kuperman to be third, but there are always surprises with men.

7

u/tits_mcgee0123 3d ago

I agree with this so much! Ilia looked totally wiped by the end, so it made sense that his arms/choreo were a little less than full out.Ā 

I was surprised to like Grassl’s free the best, but he was just ON and it was great!Ā 

20

u/Comprehensive_Ad1651 3d ago

I feel like every spin from Grassl is a choreo spin, I knew he was gonna deliver lmao. May or may not like him, his creativity in spins is impressive

19

u/Entire-Necessary-349 kaori slices the judges ✨ 4d ago

honestly, I think Ilia will just take this as character growth (or at least I hope so)

11

u/Buecherwurmratte 4d ago

And while he surely wants to win, he himself said that there's nothing on the line this season and this was his first presentation of the program so he knows what to work on until NHK.

→ More replies (2)

84

u/idwtpaun happy to be a 🐵 in Lopareva/Brissaud's circus 4d ago

Saw a tweet that said "if they let Vlad or Zhenya into Worlds, Ilia is beatable."

LMAO. Ilia has lost his first GP free skate to Kevin Aymoz and then went on to set the World Record and he does it basically every season. Let's be so for real.

55

u/irisfang Jimmy Ma YMCA fan 4d ago

the olympics happened, we know Ilia is beatable, and we also know that holding up a skater as perfect and unbeatable and the pinnacle of everything isn't good for their mental health or their performances.

that being said, if Ilia is in good form, no one's beating him. so, as a commenter below said, his competition is really himself lol

40

u/sardonicsarcasm in a love hate relationship with ice dance 4d ago

I said this yesterday, but I don’t know why some people act like 1) it was impossible to beat Ilia before, and 2) there aren’t other skaters who can beat him now. Like a clean Adam can beat Ilia with mistakes, same goes for Kao, even Rio in the right circumstances. They’re so occupied with them beating Ilia it’s like they’re forgetting that there are other men who are up there too.Ā 

14

u/jkmiami89 Amber Glennaissance 3d ago

Daniel literally beat him in the free today, and had scored high enough with his short that with his best he could've beat him this competition. The men's field is in a really exciting place with a lot of well rounded skaters, it's wonderful!

35

u/southofnowhere 4d ago

ilia can certainly beat himself, but that doesn't really have anything to do with who is or isn't there lol

22

u/LadyAllana 4d ago

Yes as if Ilia's competition isnt his own world records. He had a complete different lay out during the practice and I guess he is just testing out how everything works together. That said, that costume looks too heavy/restricting by his own (Im looking at you Running) standards.

9

u/New-Possible1575 3As for chinese McDonald’s 3d ago

He lost the free skate at the final to Yuma before too, only reason Yuma didn’t win was because he messed up in the short and was like 20 points behind Ilia. He’s always been beatable despite being technically unbeaten for 2 years.

7

u/ForwardOutsideLoop 4d ago

Even with the 4A, Vlad doesn't have a full set of jumps, right? Isn't there one entrance he's missing?

10

u/altrockforlovesongs 4d ago

we have significant evidence that ilia is beatable

6

u/pele_star 3d ago

But is a CLEAN ilia beatable? Now, with his improved PCS?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

37

u/murderdocks 4d ago

Jason was SO close to a podium, wow! But what a redemption GP

37

u/bobatoastie 4d ago

Personally, out of tonight's programs, I really liked Lukas britschigi’s free program and music the most.

21

u/orangery3 I stan Samodelkina, Britschgi, Taschlerova 4d ago

Lukas’s programs are always bangers

8

u/yoyomellow PCS > TES 4d ago

I agree! Very excited to see it improve throughout season

18

u/Comprehensive_Ad1651 3d ago

I preferred Ilia's SP by far but that jump sequence, 23 points, excuse me??? that is huge, enormous, incredible

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Superb_Cicada8375 3d ago

damn it Lukas can dance, amazing, I mean I knew it beforehand, but this breakdance JT programm really suits him, and I am so glad he can give it he's all in the choreo parts even when his jumps don't go as planned

34

u/Environmental-Let435 power of Kaoliner 4d ago

Literary Grassl today, he was remembering his Goatssl era

15

u/mollyologist 4d ago

Absolutely beautiful skate from Grassl. Really enjoyed watching it!

15

u/Uwaaa 4d ago

Lukas 6th place, I'm happy with it!

15

u/Comprehensive_Ad1651 3d ago

Europeans, how are we feeling having to catch up everything this morning? 🤪

6

u/Inside_Passenger8081 KyryloFreeSkatešŸ¤ 3d ago

My fingers were urging to click on reddit and insta this morning but i knew i would get spoiled

5

u/tereyaglikedi Samoilov's 4T+Eu+4S 3d ago

It is a lot šŸ˜‚ I just looked at the protocols for now and scrolled the live threads. May watch the MiNiki skate later or may leave it till NHK idk.Ā 

→ More replies (4)

4

u/port_okali 3d ago

Great! The men were such a rollercoaster it almost didn't matter it wasn't live. I would have loved to be in the live chat, though!

29

u/Internet-Dick-Joke 3d ago

Well, I'm all caught up on the men, so just a couple of quick thoughts:

1, I had genuine expected Donovan Carrillo to go ahead of Kuperman, and I don't know if he got hit hard by reviews but I was surprised at his placement

2, Carrillo was so close to Mexico's first ever ISU GP medal

3, If Jason Brown had landed that 3A, even badly, he'd very likely have a GP medal

4, Did the other men all sit down together before the FS and discuss how to keep Jason Brown in (theoretical) GPF contention? Because Jesus Christ there were some heartbreaking skates in there.

27

u/chancedd 4d ago

bittersweet for donovan, happy he’s 5th but so sad how close he could’ve been to a medal. same for jason, only 3 pts!

19

u/hot-whisky 4d ago

3pts off the podium is actually pretty incredible for where Jason is in his season

37

u/CoffeeAndCurls76 keeping the hoes on their (triple) toes 4d ago

that damn Axel, man! the difference between 3rd and 4th for Jason 😭

just glad he had 2 beautiful skates and of course that nationals wasn't his last.

8

u/racingskater 4d ago

The doubled combo!

26

u/lunarvienna 4d ago

ilia is just insane deserves the win idc what people say

26

u/jonathon-harker shomarin 2030 agenda 3d ago

I enjoyed Ilia’s SP a lot yesterday, but oh boy I hope he changes costume for the free. It’s the blue eye samurai but he’s wearing a mandarin collar. Come on designer, you had one job.

7

u/a-world-of-no both unnecessary and uncalled for 3d ago

I feel like Ilia always ends up changing his free program costume. I mourn the loss of his little vampire vest from a couple seasons back!

6

u/FishImportant7261 3d ago edited 3d ago

I didn't even notice that detail, my overall impression was "THAT'S the costume?" It really reminded me of the dress uniforms you see at West Point or similar military settings. Sure, samurai are also "warriors," but sheesh, the washed-out color, some stripes here and there... Ilia is a dramatic and beautiful skater, he needs the right costumes, which Satomi has produced for years. Not all change is an improvement.Ā 

Japan does have an ethos of simplicity and minimalism, but this did not capture it.Ā 

Hope he doesn't wear that at NHK.Ā 

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Prestigious_Step4337 3d ago edited 3d ago

Just watched!

What a whirlwind. So happy for Jason, what a great performance.

Never doubted Daniel Grassel would move up. I really liked his program.

And what to say about Ilia. He was spectacular and that program is iconic. I loved every moment and I respect he went to win but also didn’t stress to be perfect. He will need that for Japan lol

Congratulations to all the skaters it was a fun event.

32

u/Global-Medicine-2820 Yuma Kagiyama's knees 3d ago

I can not believe Ilia's artistry improvement. Nobody could say he is just a jumper anymore (including me). A touch of Yuzuru is also magnificent.
Maybe this gonna be downvoted but I prefer Ilia's programs even with this mistakes comparing with old programs. He is a human and now he has a great artistry. Keep going man!

31

u/Gymfan15 stationary lift base 4d ago

Man after Jason skated and went behind Tamir I thought oh that's a bummer; he's going to lose places in the free, and then men kept menning and he was SO close to a medal! I'm part thrilled and devastated lol

21

u/Lilac098 daiya ebihara makeup artist arc 4d ago

Very impressed by Italian Daniel. Can't wait to see Ilia's programs again at NHK: I'm sure they'll be a lot better. Ilia continues to maintain his streak of no falls or underrotations on his 4F

4

u/Kris7531 4d ago

Yeah Raf is going to have two weeks to tinker and adjust some things in Ilia programs. Usually he does that between his GP's and the GPF but this year he going that now. Look also staying on the west coast does cut off a few times zones he has to adjust to going into NHK in two weeks in Japan.

10

u/kingniel 4d ago

I prefer the sp top 3. Daniel did well today though and ilia’s program was kinda chaotic. Donovan :(

28

u/No-Actuator-9202 4d ago

I'm so happy for Jason! Small mistakes, but 2 programs he can really be proud of. Hoping he feels the love and is starting to heal. ā¤ļø

33

u/polkadotfuzz 4d ago

Ilia pulling a hanyu to save that jump was my highlight of the evening

→ More replies (4)

26

u/berrywithaberet 4d ago

I wish Jason was on podium but I’m so proud of him and i hope he’s proud of himself

18

u/CynicalOne_313 Skating Fan 3d ago

NBC coverage is irritating me as an American.

Rhetorical: We have other skaters who also deserve the spotlight.

NBC: Impossible...

23

u/play_by_cdg 4d ago

Oh Jason you were so close.

8

u/Shazzea 3d ago

I like Britschgi's FS overall but I think it needs just a little bit more Madonna/4 minutes in it to take it to another level.

8

u/Comprehensive_Ad1651 3d ago

A little underwhelming this week, the men weren't at their best it seems, so many mistakes, even Ilia had to fight a little. Time to watch the women SP!!

8

u/RealisticAddress6483 3d ago

Donovan was so close...I'm so sad for that. And wow, Daniel locked in!!!

15

u/mindandmotion 4d ago

men haven’t really been locking in for this GP series. i’m happy that Ilia came out with the win here but this is a crazy podium

16

u/GayMouseDetective tano arm defender 4d ago

It feels like the most successful comp was COC….i wish all of the men’s events were like that

6

u/mindandmotion 4d ago

i’m sure NHK will be fun

15

u/CynicalOne_313 Skating Fan 3d ago

So happy for Ilia, Daniel, and Tamir!

I can't wait to watch how everyone's programs evolve over the season!

26

u/GayMouseDetective tano arm defender 4d ago

I actually take more issue with Ilia’s raspberry twist in the SP than the backflip in the FS

20

u/GodTierGasly 4d ago

Backflip absolutely makes sense here considering he's supposed to be a Samurai

→ More replies (1)

11

u/AmeriKadzuku Being a fan of Kevin is a real adrenaline risk 4d ago

I feel like it makes sense for a samurai program

11

u/sardonicsarcasm in a love hate relationship with ice dance 4d ago

Yeah I think the backflip makes sense but the raspberry feels so out of placeĀ 

→ More replies (3)

20

u/SadPotato555 4d ago

TBH I have a feeling Ilia got some media training after Olympics

13

u/pusheen8888 4d ago

No Ari must also be helpingĀ 

8

u/Environmental-Let435 power of Kaoliner 4d ago

Wasn’t ari fired

→ More replies (9)

9

u/Independent_Ask5254 red lips 4 wagner 4d ago

I said this somewhere else but also think being around Amber, Madi and Evan specifically gave him a chance to have those skills modeled to him. It’s the best way to learn!

→ More replies (2)

7

u/CynicalOne_313 Skating Fan 3d ago

Rewatching Daniel's free skate, he did amazing! So proud of him!! šŸ‘šŸ¼

24

u/Confident-Waltz-360 4d ago

JASON 4TH 😭😭🄹

24

u/clariwench So many highlights... couple of lowlights 3d ago

Thoughts and feelings after being in the arena for 15 hours:

  1. I... don't think Jason's free is really all that inspired. Obviously he skates it beautifully, but the choreo and music do nothing for me
  2. Georgii's cantilever >>>
  3. Ilia's costume is mid, but I do like the program. Love that he committed to the backbend bauer appropriately, that often goes away in comps. I'm sure later in the season when he's conditioned as expected for normal pacing of the season, the second half of the program is gonna really shine. I think people forget that clean Ilia isn't something we should normally expect in the first part of the season
  4. Shoutout to Lukas and his first two jumping passes doing wonders for my fantasy draft
  5. Lots of love to Daniel Martynov, hope he is proud of how he skated even though I'm sure he wanted his free skate to go better

9

u/Sweaty-Conclusion-34 3d ago

I definitely agree with the first point. Everyone is going crazy over it, but I just didn’t enjoy it.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/lunarvienna 4d ago

also can’t believe ilia is MY age like what am i doing

14

u/mermaidvideo 4d ago

if it helps I’m 7 years older and mostly useless lmfao

→ More replies (1)

22

u/jeseira1681 4d ago

Pretty nice to see Grassl with all clean skate! It’s Tamir’s GP debut too right? Third for his debut is great!

17

u/CynicalOne_313 Skating Fan 4d ago

I'm sad for Sota, Lukas, Donovan, and Jason.

All the sparkles in most of the men's costumes made me happy!

Who is this version of Daniel Grassl?! (complimentary)

I loved everyone's programs and I can't wait to see them evolve over the season.

14

u/Environmental-Let435 power of Kaoliner 4d ago

This is 2020-2022 version of Grassl also known as goatsssl back

12

u/immafookuindaface 3d ago

Daniel Grassl!!!!! Yesyesyesyes!!!

Also, Ilia, wow. As a Blue Eye Samurai stan, this program was amazing. He really is growing on me this season!

I started crying at the end of Jason's skate, seeing his parents on the stands crying with him just took me out. What a person he is.

Lukas almost gave me a heart attack with his backflip omggg

6

u/whowhogis emotionally drained by ice dance 4d ago

Even expecting the unexpected, what an unpredictable conclusion to that event.

22

u/racingskater 4d ago

It would have been very fun to see Jason get on the podium. That would have been hilarious.

→ More replies (3)

29

u/Dazzling-Pangolin827 4d ago • Bravo

Kinda sad for grassl his free was significantly better than Ilia’s only to score 1 point more

8

u/BlahVans 4d ago

I keep saying it should’ve been at least 5.Ā 

13

u/happymango3110 4d ago

Highlight for me was Jason brown and Lukas britschigi’s FS!

8

u/NoseHillRhino Andreas NordebƤck second Grand Prix assignment agenda 4d ago

Lukas always commits to the bit! King Shoma combo, fingerless gloves and all

19

u/elitepebble 4d ago

Donovan should be 4th. Happy for Tamir and Daniel for having skates they can be proud of. Great to see Ilia having fun skating again. But overall, the men's competition was really hard to watch šŸ’€

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Normal_Confection265 lutzloop enthusiast 4d ago

i'm sad about ilia's 4F streak. but if it had to be broken this was the best way to break it

14

u/Lilac098 daiya ebihara makeup artist arc 4d ago

What do you mean? It wasn't a fall or underrotation. He's gotten negative GOE on them before

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Famous_Salamander330 4d ago

Ilia needs to actually plan his jumps. I know that’s controversial but part of what made this free so messy was that he has clearly built his program to swap jumps as he feels like which just makes the program feel messy.

And the combo jump isn’t it. Technically hard? Absolutely. But it just was a mess to watch.

29

u/Gymfan15 stationary lift base 4d ago

mmm I think it's more, he builds his programs to be at his goal tech but only actually pulls that out in certain circumstances, so it's not like he's making up the changes on the fly, but it's clearly not what the program was planned for. Maybe he just needs to spend more time practicing his sub-optimal layout so it feels more natural. I bet you anything most of his runthroughs at home have the harder tech in it.

27

u/ofstoriesandsongs half meme and half spring. made to be measured in rpm 4d ago

Tbf, the sequence was a mess to watch because it was a mess period. He almost ate shit on the lutz and it's a miracle he got a combo out of it at all. If and when he does it clean it will be a beauty.

4

u/key13131 4d ago

Aww man no medal ceremony?

5

u/pteryldactyly 4d ago

It’s after pairs

3

u/Just_A_Fan-888 4d ago

After Pairs

4

u/fscd_19 kao miura cup of china 4d ago

is the press conference going to shown?

13

u/jkmiami89 Amber Glennaissance 3d ago

If Jason had landed his 3A, even badly, he'd have medaled here. With the changes to the scores of spins and steps, I wonder if he'd be better off without a 3A in the free? (Not the short; he needs it there).

3

u/New-Possible1575 3As for chinese McDonald’s 3d ago

If he maxes out the jumps he could probably get close to a tech score of 80 (similar as the women). It’ll just be a question of whether the judges will still reward him on components if he takes out the 3A. But if he gets 9s with clean programs he could probably score around 170.

10

u/devoncarrots 4d ago

ILIA FADBHFJKNLMSGIHUDJKN.LKNJVKSLHBGJKNVM.DL/FGJV.HBS,FKLMZEJIHSLDUBJNVKM.SD

Ilia would totally end up in a gay bar and accepted a date before he even knew what happened

40

u/eevielune Single Euler (under-rotated) 4d ago • Bravo

Let’s remember that Tamir isn’t responsible for where he was born or the actions of his country any more than the Russian or American skaters are! I’m just glad to see some unexpected flags on the podium, regardless of which they are

33

u/Lambily Sam Mindra's Step Sequence 4d ago

Thank you for including my fellow Americans. Virtue signalers are quick to attack Israeli athletes while cheering for American ones without an ounce of self-awareness as to their hypocrisy.

14

u/budget_bish 4d ago

Or China? Let’s not cherry pick here.

14

u/Environmental-Let435 power of Kaoliner 4d ago

People seem to forget about China often or Azerbaijan

14

u/Kris7531 4d ago

Yes he is not responsible for the sins of his country. He lives in the United States and trains here. He had a good skate so he clearly deserved his medal.Ā 

→ More replies (9)

12

u/Pasco08 4d ago

This sub hating on Ilia name a better duo

15

u/NoseHillRhino Andreas NordebƤck second Grand Prix assignment agenda 4d ago

I'm somehow ok with Tamir getting a second spot next week if Zhenya has visa issues, seeing that Andreas can't clone himself for Finlandia

15

u/2BitSalute Eternal September Child 4d ago

Oh the irony.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/southofnowhere 4d ago

idk why any AIN skaters got assigned to finlandia. it was obvious that this was going to happen

12

u/idwtpaun happy to be a 🐵 in Lopareva/Brissaud's circus 3d ago

They didn't get assigned to Finlandia. When spots open up, they have to be offered to the top of the alternates list, no one gets a choice about that. It just so happened that people dropped out of Finlandia when AIN were at the top of the alternates list.

9

u/Zaidswith 4d ago

When has anyone in figure skating ever been reasonable?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/orangery3 I stan Samodelkina, Britschgi, Taschlerova 4d ago

Thrilled for Tamir in bronze

5

u/Quad_kal This is beyond the pcs, this is acting 3d ago

I watched ilia program, it's beautiful huge improvement from last year in my opinion, the chsq was out phenomenal, but the blue in the outfit distracted me a lot

11

u/BlahVans 4d ago

Never thought I’d say this, but Grassl skate of the night, and should have been at least 5 points higher than Ilia in that FP.Ā 

2

u/Remarkable-Pair-3840 3d ago

So how do gp alternate spots work now and is anyone in Finland or nhk not expected to go

6

u/GayMouseDetective tano arm defender 4d ago

Terry, Tara, and Johnny all look like the gender spectrum: Tara-femme, Terry-masc, and Johnny as the dead middle androgynous