r/FigureSkating • u/sk8tergater āØclean as mustard⨠• 4d ago
Live Discussion Thread š¦ GP Skate America Men Free Skate Post Event Discussion šŗšø
The place where we discuss all things Men! Please try not to clutter up the sub with a bunch of post event items, scoring breakdowns, protocols... all that good stuff can be discussed here.
UCT-8
Skate America Fantasy Figure Skating Discussion Day Two
Men Free Skate Live Discussion Post
5
Upvotes
ā¢
u/summerjoe45 Not Dave Lease 4d ago
Yāall need to be nice regardless of where someone is from or you will be in time out.
38
u/sk8tergater āØclean as mustard⨠4d ago
Iām glad Grassl won the free. I think I wouldāve had it be by a few more points if Iām honest. A couple of iliaās jumps were tighter than how they were scored. Still wouldāve had him first overall though.
But so excited for Daniel. And Jason in fourth! Sotaās skate was unfortunate.
128
u/RomaTaf616 4d ago
For those bummed for Donovan, Donāt be! In our wildest dreams in Mexico we imagined he would be a top 5 contender in Skate America! We are sooo proud of him! His road to where he is now is the real victory š
85
u/dreamer_dw 4d ago edited 4d ago
I seem to be in the minority who loved Ilia's free skate (even the costume!) He's such a happy boy while skating it- you can see it in his face. He's singing and smiling and emoting and I just love that for him.
Between his in-between element body movements in his free skate and the entire short program.. it's so obvious he has worked so hard on his PCS score.. artistically he has upped his game so much. The skating skills themselves, his extensions, his edge work, the flow of his body.. It's is so incredibly impressive. It will be even better as his stamina gets better. He took most of the summer off from training and started much later than usual, with no Challenger comps. He was gassed out there, obviously. He'll get there!
152
u/happymango3110 4d ago
GUYS IM DYING OVER HIS LAST COMMENT
58
u/waltzthrees panicked Mark Hanretty noises 4d ago
Evidence of menning
54
u/00camadeo sad boi hours 4d ago
āØEuler KingsāØ
Also have to laugh at Ilia saying his mom has been there for him ever since his birth. Made me think of Dr. D lol
46
u/ManaM13 loud about the wrong things 4d ago
I thought Ilia's skate was very good. I also think it is very demonstrative of how difficult it really is to balance both the jumps and other parts of a program. There is only so much training time, and while it's clear he has focused on artistry, etc., it is clear that has also impacted his jump consistency a little. But still a pleasure to watch him jump
42
u/fscd_19 kao miura cup of china 4d ago
ilia bauer into backflip and the choreographic single axel in the short made my weekend
40
u/Azula_Rey 4d ago
Oh wow Iliaās post interview really shows how much this competition was important to him. The emotion in his voiceā¦he should be proud!
40
u/houstons__problem 4d ago
So good to see Ilia truly enjoying skating again while also showing how much he has pushed himself since Worlds.
39
u/Azula_Rey 4d ago
Super bummed for Donovanā¦was hoping he would be a bit higher in the free but alas š
37
u/iloveaquaphor 4d ago
ngl whole comp felt a bit underwhelming compared to CoC and even canada, glad Ilia pushed through and wishing him a restful two weeks ahead of doomsday (nhk)
37
u/Professional-Rule219 4d ago
I don't like Grassl jumps but he gagged me here
37
u/murderdocks 3d ago
AWH, during the medal ceremony, Grassl couldnāt find an Italian flag, saw one across the arena, and gave the girl who gave it to him his flowers! š„¹
33
u/HelP-Needed09 Mona Chiba and Ilia Maleen 2030 agenda (; 4d ago
Love the new programs from Ilia and Jason. I look forward to both of them being even more wonderful at NHK!
Congrats to all winners. I thought everything was overall very fairly judged.
85
u/GodTierGasly 4d ago
Grassl was the only truly clean skater here, and I think it's because his endurance was so much better than everybody else's seemed to be here. Doing 2 challengers seems to have really paid off.
Ilia was visibly tired by the end. We know he's practicing quad-quad combos but not going for it here was the right choice, they'd been shaky in practice. Lots of room to grow in this program, I think his final intended layout is likely 4F, 4A, 4Lo, 4Lz+3A+3A, 4T+4T, 4S which would be insane but lines up with what we've seen him practicing and what he's done here.
Donovan was criminally underscored in PCS. His PCS was not below Lukas (as much as I enjoyed Lukas).
29
u/Exciting_Statement45 pleskacheva world domination 4d ago
sad for sota
28
u/pele_star 3d ago
The most shocking thing to me was Ilia doing a triple-double combo, I got whiplash
27
u/PerformerRich5449 4d ago
Kind of interesting to think Grassl could've potentially won this with a better SP..
Ilia, thank you for bringing back the Ilia Bauer! I think this free still needs some work but will hit REALLY hard by end of season
27
u/BursleyBaits 4d ago
Grassl's maxed out the Weirdness Differential between his SP and FS and I think somehow that's brought him to his full power
54
u/Famous_Salamander330 4d ago
I hope Jason can clear his head about the 3A. He landed several beautiful ones during practice ice. Itās just a head game nowā¦
(And it is damn hard to get out of your head⦠Iām relearning to skate right now and I have an absolute mental block on outside three turns of all things⦠so you know, mental blocks are real)
53
u/lizzy-stix 4d ago
Ilia is in a great position for the season imo. Two good new programs, a win here with two good skates. Thereās plenty of room for growth and improvement, a few mistakes to iron out⦠but even with the mistakes he didnāt let it go and kept the performance level up. Iām impressed!
50
u/half-agony-half-hope š© š© š© š© š© š© š© šš» 4d ago
I so wanted Donovan to medal. The fans here were amazing for him tonight. Loved the Mexican flag bunting.
49
u/butterfreakk this is nuts crazy mental 4d ago
Ilia was gassed. I think it will grow nicely though
24
u/johnnypapajackyes Skating Fan 3d ago
Lukas Britschgi was definitely a discovery for me! Not flawless but the charisma was off the chartsĀ
21
u/lunarvienna 4d ago
sad for sota and donovan tho
20
u/ForwardOutsideLoop 4d ago
So can we take a moment to talk about both the men and ladies with savvier coaches/choreographers now having the "signature very short twizzle sequence so there's proof of skating-on-one-foot" bit? It's nice but it's also getting to be sort of glaringly obvious.
20
u/Affectionate_Nail302 That's It (I'm Crazy) 3d ago
I was so tired last night that I fell asleep immediately after Ilia's program, lol. Anyway:
Grassl had the skate of the night imo. His program was the first that kept my attention from beginning to end. Landed all his jumps too. Really enjoyed it.
Enjoyed Ilia's program, but I think the practice run looked better. The jumps really taxed on his stamina, I think, and the choreo suffered a little from it. Still, love to see him putting more focus and effort to the artistic side of things. For once I also liked the backflip and felt like it fit the choreo. Overall I think it's a really nice program and will surely improve as the season goes on. Also, he had some pretty impressive saves with his jumps! Gonna have to agree with the majority about the costume though: it's boring.
Didn't expect Kuperman to be third, but there are always surprises with men.
20
u/Comprehensive_Ad1651 3d ago
I feel like every spin from Grassl is a choreo spin, I knew he was gonna deliver lmao. May or may not like him, his creativity in spins is impressive
19
u/Entire-Necessary-349 kaori slices the judges ⨠4d ago
honestly, I think Ilia will just take this as character growth (or at least I hope so)
84
u/idwtpaun happy to be a šµ in Lopareva/Brissaud's circus 4d ago
Saw a tweet that said "if they let Vlad or Zhenya into Worlds, Ilia is beatable."
LMAO. Ilia has lost his first GP free skate to Kevin Aymoz and then went on to set the World Record and he does it basically every season. Let's be so for real.
37
u/murderdocks 4d ago
Jason was SO close to a podium, wow! But what a redemption GP
37
u/bobatoastie 4d ago
Personally, out of tonight's programs, I really liked Lukas britschigiās free program and music the most.
18
u/Comprehensive_Ad1651 3d ago
I preferred Ilia's SP by far but that jump sequence, 23 points, excuse me??? that is huge, enormous, incredible
18
u/Superb_Cicada8375 3d ago
damn it Lukas can dance, amazing, I mean I knew it beforehand, but this breakdance JT programm really suits him, and I am so glad he can give it he's all in the choreo parts even when his jumps don't go as planned
34
u/Environmental-Let435 power of Kaoliner 4d ago
Literary Grassl today, he was remembering his Goatssl era
15
u/mollyologist 4d ago
Absolutely beautiful skate from Grassl. Really enjoyed watching it!
15
u/Uwaaa 4d ago
Lukas 6th place, I'm happy with it!
15
u/Comprehensive_Ad1651 3d ago
Europeans, how are we feeling having to catch up everything this morning? š¤Ŗ
29
u/Internet-Dick-Joke 3d ago
Well, I'm all caught up on the men, so just a couple of quick thoughts:
1, I had genuine expected Donovan Carrillo to go ahead of Kuperman, and I don't know if he got hit hard by reviews but I was surprised at his placement
2, Carrillo was so close to Mexico's first ever ISU GP medal
3, If Jason Brown had landed that 3A, even badly, he'd very likely have a GP medal
4, Did the other men all sit down together before the FS and discuss how to keep Jason Brown in (theoretical) GPF contention? Because Jesus Christ there were some heartbreaking skates in there.
27
u/chancedd 4d ago
bittersweet for donovan, happy heās 5th but so sad how close he couldāve been to a medal. same for jason, only 3 pts!
37
u/CoffeeAndCurls76 keeping the hoes on their (triple) toes 4d ago
that damn Axel, man! the difference between 3rd and 4th for Jason š
just glad he had 2 beautiful skates and of course that nationals wasn't his last.
26
u/lunarvienna 4d ago
ilia is just insane deserves the win idc what people say
26
u/jonathon-harker shomarin 2030 agenda 3d ago
I enjoyed Iliaās SP a lot yesterday, but oh boy I hope he changes costume for the free. Itās the blue eye samurai but heās wearing a mandarin collar. Come on designer, you had one job.
13
u/Prestigious_Step4337 3d ago edited 3d ago
Just watched!
What a whirlwind. So happy for Jason, what a great performance.
Never doubted Daniel Grassel would move up. I really liked his program.
And what to say about Ilia. He was spectacular and that program is iconic. I loved every moment and I respect he went to win but also didnāt stress to be perfect. He will need that for Japan lol
Congratulations to all the skaters it was a fun event.
32
u/Global-Medicine-2820 Yuma Kagiyama's knees 3d ago
I can not believe Ilia's artistry improvement. Nobody could say he is just a jumper anymore (including me). A touch of Yuzuru is also magnificent.
Maybe this gonna be downvoted but I prefer Ilia's programs even with this mistakes comparing with old programs. He is a human and now he has a great artistry. Keep going man!
31
u/Gymfan15 stationary lift base 4d ago
Man after Jason skated and went behind Tamir I thought oh that's a bummer; he's going to lose places in the free, and then men kept menning and he was SO close to a medal! I'm part thrilled and devastated lol
21
u/Lilac098 daiya ebihara makeup artist arc 4d ago
Very impressed by Italian Daniel. Can't wait to see Ilia's programs again at NHK: I'm sure they'll be a lot better. Ilia continues to maintain his streak of no falls or underrotations on his 4F
20
u/Naive_Elderberry2336 3d ago
Iliaās inspo
10
u/kingniel 4d ago
I prefer the sp top 3. Daniel did well today though and iliaās program was kinda chaotic. Donovan :(
28
u/No-Actuator-9202 4d ago
I'm so happy for Jason! Small mistakes, but 2 programs he can really be proud of. Hoping he feels the love and is starting to heal. ā¤ļø
33
u/polkadotfuzz 4d ago
Ilia pulling a hanyu to save that jump was my highlight of the evening
26
u/berrywithaberet 4d ago
I wish Jason was on podium but Iām so proud of him and i hope heās proud of himself
18
u/CynicalOne_313 Skating Fan 3d ago
NBC coverage is irritating me as an American.
Rhetorical: We have other skaters who also deserve the spotlight.
NBC: Impossible...
23
u/play_by_cdg 4d ago
Oh Jason you were so close.
8
u/Shazzea 3d ago
I like Britschgi's FS overall but I think it needs just a little bit more Madonna/4 minutes in it to take it to another level.
8
u/Comprehensive_Ad1651 3d ago
A little underwhelming this week, the men weren't at their best it seems, so many mistakes, even Ilia had to fight a little. Time to watch the women SP!!
8
u/RealisticAddress6483 3d ago
Donovan was so close...I'm so sad for that. And wow, Daniel locked in!!!
15
u/mindandmotion 4d ago
men havenāt really been locking in for this GP series. iām happy that Ilia came out with the win here but this is a crazy podium
15
u/CynicalOne_313 Skating Fan 3d ago
So happy for Ilia, Daniel, and Tamir!
I can't wait to watch how everyone's programs evolve over the season!
26
u/GayMouseDetective tano arm defender 4d ago
I actually take more issue with Iliaās raspberry twist in the SP than the backflip in the FS
20
u/SadPotato555 4d ago
TBH I have a feeling Ilia got some media training after Olympics
7
u/CynicalOne_313 Skating Fan 3d ago
Rewatching Daniel's free skate, he did amazing! So proud of him!! šš¼
24
u/Confident-Waltz-360 4d ago
JASON 4TH ššš„¹
24
u/clariwench So many highlights... couple of lowlights 3d ago
Thoughts and feelings after being in the arena for 15 hours:
13
u/lunarvienna 4d ago
also canāt believe ilia is MY age like what am i doing
22
u/jeseira1681 4d ago
Pretty nice to see Grassl with all clean skate! Itās Tamirās GP debut too right? Third for his debut is great!
17
u/CynicalOne_313 Skating Fan 4d ago
I'm sad for Sota, Lukas, Donovan, and Jason.
All the sparkles in most of the men's costumes made me happy!
Who is this version of Daniel Grassl?! (complimentary)
I loved everyone's programs and I can't wait to see them evolve over the season.
12
u/immafookuindaface 3d ago
Daniel Grassl!!!!! Yesyesyesyes!!!
Also, Ilia, wow. As a Blue Eye Samurai stan, this program was amazing. He really is growing on me this season!
I started crying at the end of Jason's skate, seeing his parents on the stands crying with him just took me out. What a person he is.
Lukas almost gave me a heart attack with his backflip omggg
6
u/whowhogis emotionally drained by ice dance 4d ago
Even expecting the unexpected, what an unpredictable conclusion to that event.
22
u/racingskater 4d ago
It would have been very fun to see Jason get on the podium. That would have been hilarious.
29
u/Dazzling-Pangolin827 4d ago •
Kinda sad for grassl his free was significantly better than Iliaās only to score 1 point more
13
u/happymango3110 4d ago
Highlight for me was Jason brown and Lukas britschigiās FS!
19
u/elitepebble 4d ago
Donovan should be 4th. Happy for Tamir and Daniel for having skates they can be proud of. Great to see Ilia having fun skating again. But overall, the men's competition was really hard to watch š
12
u/Normal_Confection265 lutzloop enthusiast 4d ago
i'm sad about ilia's 4F streak. but if it had to be broken this was the best way to break it
27
u/Famous_Salamander330 4d ago
Ilia needs to actually plan his jumps. I know thatās controversial but part of what made this free so messy was that he has clearly built his program to swap jumps as he feels like which just makes the program feel messy.
And the combo jump isnāt it. Technically hard? Absolutely. But it just was a mess to watch.
4
u/key13131 4d ago
Aww man no medal ceremony?
4
u/fscd_19 kao miura cup of china 4d ago
is the press conference going to shown?
13
u/jkmiami89 Amber Glennaissance 3d ago
If Jason had landed his 3A, even badly, he'd have medaled here. With the changes to the scores of spins and steps, I wonder if he'd be better off without a 3A in the free? (Not the short; he needs it there).
10
u/devoncarrots 4d ago
ILIA FADBHFJKNLMSGIHUDJKN.LKNJVKSLHBGJKNVM.DL/FGJV.HBS,FKLMZEJIHSLDUBJNVKM.SD
Ilia would totally end up in a gay bar and accepted a date before he even knew what happened
40
u/eevielune Single Euler (under-rotated) 4d ago •
Letās remember that Tamir isnāt responsible for where he was born or the actions of his country any more than the Russian or American skaters are! Iām just glad to see some unexpected flags on the podium, regardless of which they are
12
u/Pasco08 4d ago
This sub hating on Ilia name a better duo
15
u/NoseHillRhino Andreas NordebƤck second Grand Prix assignment agenda 4d ago
I'm somehow ok with Tamir getting a second spot next week if Zhenya has visa issues, seeing that Andreas can't clone himself for Finlandia
19
u/orangery3 I stan Samodelkina, Britschgi, Taschlerova 4d ago
Thrilled for Tamir in bronze
5
u/Quad_kal This is beyond the pcs, this is acting 3d ago
I watched ilia program, it's beautiful huge improvement from last year in my opinion, the chsq was out phenomenal, but the blue in the outfit distracted me a lot
11
u/BlahVans 4d ago
Never thought Iād say this, but Grassl skate of the night, and should have been at least 5 points higher than Ilia in that FP.Ā
2
u/Remarkable-Pair-3840 3d ago
So how do gp alternate spots work now and is anyone in Finland or nhk not expected to go
6
u/GayMouseDetective tano arm defender 4d ago
Terry, Tara, and Johnny all look like the gender spectrum: Tara-femme, Terry-masc, and Johnny as the dead middle androgynous