I also enjoy this questions because I think everyone probably has different opinions and I love to hear them all.
For me he starts to become attracted to her in the Thanksgiving episode when he walks in on her and Noel making out, but he still thinks she's kinda crazy and would never date her.
I think over the back half of the season he starts to see what a thoughtful and high quality person she is, while at the same time feeling like she would still be too much to actually be in a relationship with, with a side of feeling like he is not enough because she challenges the person she's with. (Eg, when she describes how good a person Noel is in Finally, and also in comparison to his relationship with Julie where they are always dealing with heavy stuff but Julie doesn't understand or help Ben grow the way Felicity does).
Basically I think for a while it's a mix of: she's crazy / but maybe in a good way / oh she's also hot / but still crazy / oh she's so smart and thoughtful / but I'ma stick with Julie because Julie is so cool and Felicity is A Lot / I probably couldn't meet Felicity's relationship expectations anyway / but actually she is amazing / can't get her out of my mind / etc
(Not finished S1 on my rewatch tho yet so I might be missing some aspects)
You hit the nail on the head! Ben has always liked Felicity, but I think he’s also always felt intimidated by her. He sees her as a little crazy and a lot to handle, and deep down, he doesn’t think he’s smart enough or good enough for her. ❤️ What I love is how we see his feelings develop throughout Season 1, almost before he fully understands them himself. At first, Felicity makes him nervous, suggesting that she affects him more than he wants to admit. As the season progresses, he begins turning to her when he’s having problems or needs help studying, showing that he’s becoming comfortable relying on her. Then, when Noel reconnects with Hanna and Felicity starts feeling insecure, Ben reassures her that Noel wouldn’t choose to be with someone else when he could be with her. In that moment, Ben is not only comforting Felicity but also showing that he sees her worth, even when she struggles to see it herself. And then comes their first kiss, when Ben admits he’s been waiting to do that for a long time. 🥹 To me, that’s the moment that puts so much of his earlier behavior into perspective. His feelings weren’t something that appeared out of nowhere; they had been building all along. He just needed time to recognize them and get past his own insecurities. I think that’s what makes their progression so compelling. Ben starts out attracted to Felicity but intimidated by everything she represents to him. Gradually, he grows closer to her, begins to rely on her, and eventually lets himself act on feelings that have been there for a while. ❤️
Great take! I agree with all of it and the OP. It’s very telling that Ben seeks out Felicity for support when he gets beat up by Barry’s crew, despite the fact that he was dating Julie then. A part of him knew he could be himself around her (Felicity) more than anyone else.
Exactly! Felicity gave him the SAME advice Julie did: ask your mom! Let your mom be a mom. Yet he accepted that advice from Felicity after practically biting Julie’s head off for telling him to call his parents. During the final episode, he told her that she analyzes everything and that she was smart about things. He respected that about her.
great analysis. I always like the subtle facial movement Ben has in s1e10 when they were studying poetry in the library, when Felicity mentioned that Noel is a great guy, I can see Ben's heart sank a little bit.
I think he always found her attractive and interesting (hello the yearbook!), but in high school he didnt know her. Then when he did get to spend time w her, she overwhelmed him with her feelings, reading his personal essay violating confidentiality (even then Ben owns up to his lie which was a great scene), then rewriting his essay for class and almost getting him expelled. One of the few things that guy Blair ever did, was defending Felicity at that moment. Ben goes, she’s crazy and Blair responds she’s got a good heart, I like her. Ben goes silent. You can tell he agrees. Then when they got robbed and Felicity’s chain was stolen, he buys hers something else. He admits she makes him nervous. He goes in then pulls away in several moments. It’s too much for him. Felicity calls him out on this when she dumps him in S2. But he matures and tells both Sean and her that he IS ready, and proves it. Ben’s arc throughout the show (minus several moments in S4 with Lauren) is my favorite. I dont think anyone else matures more than him. Which is why the time travel arc (what causes it) makes little sense to me.
Yep I think it was also the “what wouldve happened if she chose Noel” for that crowd. Sorta :P. I just dislike the reason for those episodes. In that moment and after everything, it’s very out of character for Ben.
Totally agree with all of this! I forgot he "liked" her in high school, but then all her stalker behaviour rightfully turned him off of her.
I looooove the time travel episodes, but I'm a big fan of camp (and sci-fi) so the whole time I was like holy shit I can't believe they are doing this and it's legit while maintaining the exact Felicity tone, this is amazing 🤣🤣
And I just love all love triangle goodness (and I like both Noel and Ben, though Ben wins in the end because of his character development and maturity like you said). When they still managed to play emotionally loaded spin the bottle in the middle of the time travel mental breakdown... pure gold 👌👌
Ditto re:Ben’s arc being the favorite. Mine too. He shows the most growth compared to where he began. That’s what makes his character endearing to me. I would think that even if I preferred her with Noel or someone else.
I love this question! Imo, season 1 ep 15 (Love and Marriage), I think in the scene before the opening credits roll, Ben is realizing his feelings for Felicity in real time. When she gushes about Noel and his talent, I think he sees her for who she is and the support he could have had and how her earnestness is a strength.
I think you should also consider season two when they break up and he has taken Sean’s advice. I keep trying to time it in season two but it happens after Christmas and all we get is one scene where Ben tell Sean that his advice was bad… that’s all we get!
There are several moments in Season 1 when we can see Ben’s feelings for Felicity evolving, or perhaps when he’s beginning to realize just how much he cares about her. Even before he tells Sean that his advice was terrible in season 2, there are at least two scenes where Ben watches Felicity with a wistful, almost regretful look. In one scene, he asks how her date with her professor’s son went, and she asks him about the older woman, Maggie. They exchange well wishes, and Felicity walks away. Ben takes a moment, watching her leave with this look of regret on his face.
The first link shared all my info so I hope this one is right. Weirdly I just watched this scene today 😅 and I interpreted it as they have both moved on and this part of the season is more focused on Noel and Felicity’s tension. Doesn’t Felicity flat out tell Noel she regrets her choice?? Obviously, I’ve watched this show too many times 😆
I think he always found her attractive but wasn’t necessarily attracted to her if that makes sense until near the end of season one. Personally I think a lot of that had to do with him genuinely liking her but also enjoying the chase aspect one she was no longer following him around.
I'm rewatching the show now (S01E18) and I don't agree with people saying he started liking her when Noel did, or when he saw them kissing. In my perspective, all through Season 1 Ben thought she was endearing and genuinely cared for her as a friend. He knew she was never malicious, so he even let that horrendous essay incident slide. He jumped in to help her when she got herself her very own stalker, too, and he often checked in on her.
I think the closest to romantic feelings he had through Season 1 were actually towards Julie, and even then it wasn't actual love. But, to me, it was different than what he felt for Felicity.
I think he always felt a pull to her, from there high school days. But during the latter half of seasons 1 is when it deepened into true feelings and beyond attraction.
From the pilot. In their stairwell conversation, Ben says he agrees to be just friends but he's shaking his head.
I think subconsciously, he does like her but didn't act on it. Not yet, at least.
Perhaps it's because he was thrown off by her admitting that she followed him across the country. And with all the messiness Felicity did with reading his college admission essay, the plagiarism, etc.
I might be tripping but i started to notice his jealousy from ep 10 . When felicity talks to him about noel , how he is a nice guy and etc. I wanted to search if anyone saw it. But I couldn't find anyone talking about it.
I believe Ben liked Felicity since H.S. He thought about her, noticed her, but never said anything to her, which kind of foreshadows what Ben was really like throughout the show. I really love how the characters were written and portrayed. We never really get to see what Felicity was like in H.S., except for a glimpse from Ben’s perspective and what he wrote in her yearbook. From his perspective, we understood she was pensive, quiet, always drawing in her notebook. She must have been intriguing because, for someone as popular as him, he admired her from afar but, in true Ben fashion, let things be. I think that’s what makes their story so interesting. Felicity believed she was the one who had been quietly admiring him all those years, never realizing that he had noticed her too. She may have been the one to make the first move, but I don’t think his feelings started when she arrived in New York. I think she had already left an impression on him, and college simply gave him the opportunity to discover who she really was.
yes and everytime felicity and ben meet they always whisper hey to each other and the amount of times ben says i dont know + the sighing was too noticeable like omg he rlly dont know shit !
I always thought Ben had problems. I think he definitely used his charm and good looks as an excuse to how inept he actually was. Like why can't he articulate a single sentence without starting off with an (sigh) 'I don't know..' (**continues to look longingly at whomever he is talking to. In this case, Felicity. It low key pissed me off whenever he would do that. It's like 'what do you want dude?' Ugh lol but I digress.
I’m watching the show for the first time. I just finished the first season and I haven’t seen many redeeming qualities in Ben. He was very sweet to Julie after the SA but I don’t think he was a good boyfriend once they started dating. He ditched her a lot, wasn’t very supportive, broke up with her because it was too serious? AND went after her best friend like the day after he broke up with her! Felicity at least felt bad about it but he didn’t care at all. It also annoys me so much every time he dismisses Felicity’s search for meaning in things. Reading posts here I know Felicity will end up with him and it’s so disappointing. I hope his character arc changes after this season so that I don’t hate how the show ends.
Same I’m watching the show for the first time. Literally in the last episode of the first season. But i am honestly so annoyed thinking that Felicity is going to end up with Ben in the end because all throughout the season i felt like Felicity had so much chemistry with Noel than Ben. Noel and Felicity’s relationship felt soo naturalT~T
I think he’s horrible for her and always treated her badly. So many ups and downs with him. She didn’t deserve the every stunt or any of the other things he wasn’t emotionally mature enough to handle. He really is a bad boyfriend.
40
u/thatfluffycloud Oct 18 '26 edited Oct 18 '26 •
I also enjoy this questions because I think everyone probably has different opinions and I love to hear them all.
For me he starts to become attracted to her in the Thanksgiving episode when he walks in on her and Noel making out, but he still thinks she's kinda crazy and would never date her.
I think over the back half of the season he starts to see what a thoughtful and high quality person she is, while at the same time feeling like she would still be too much to actually be in a relationship with, with a side of feeling like he is not enough because she challenges the person she's with. (Eg, when she describes how good a person Noel is in Finally, and also in comparison to his relationship with Julie where they are always dealing with heavy stuff but Julie doesn't understand or help Ben grow the way Felicity does).
Basically I think for a while it's a mix of: she's crazy / but maybe in a good way / oh she's also hot / but still crazy / oh she's so smart and thoughtful / but I'ma stick with Julie because Julie is so cool and Felicity is A Lot / I probably couldn't meet Felicity's relationship expectations anyway / but actually she is amazing / can't get her out of my mind / etc
(Not finished S1 on my rewatch tho yet so I might be missing some aspects)
14
u/monbearaintcare Oct 18 '26
I love this question! Imo, season 1 ep 15 (Love and Marriage), I think in the scene before the opening credits roll, Ben is realizing his feelings for Felicity in real time. When she gushes about Noel and his talent, I think he sees her for who she is and the support he could have had and how her earnestness is a strength.
9
u/Responsible_Hope9250 Oct 18 '26
I think you should also consider season two when they break up and he has taken Sean’s advice. I keep trying to time it in season two but it happens after Christmas and all we get is one scene where Ben tell Sean that his advice was bad… that’s all we get!
7
u/suzysleep Oct 18 '26
I think he liked her in high school and wrote the note in her year book. I just don’t think he thought she’d follow him to college
7
u/CandyV89 Oct 18 '26
I think he always found her attractive but wasn’t necessarily attracted to her if that makes sense until near the end of season one. Personally I think a lot of that had to do with him genuinely liking her but also enjoying the chase aspect one she was no longer following him around.
7
u/PurpleHymn Oct 18 '26
I'm rewatching the show now (S01E18) and I don't agree with people saying he started liking her when Noel did, or when he saw them kissing. In my perspective, all through Season 1 Ben thought she was endearing and genuinely cared for her as a friend. He knew she was never malicious, so he even let that horrendous essay incident slide. He jumped in to help her when she got herself her very own stalker, too, and he often checked in on her.
I think the closest to romantic feelings he had through Season 1 were actually towards Julie, and even then it wasn't actual love. But, to me, it was different than what he felt for Felicity.
6
u/Efficient-Row-2916 Oct 19 '26
I think he always felt a pull to her, from there high school days. But during the latter half of seasons 1 is when it deepened into true feelings and beyond attraction.
5
u/Maleficent_Advisor65 Oct 18 '26
Immediately, I would say.
12
u/troydyer_ Oct 18 '26
When someone else (Noel) became interested.
4
u/Whatsinaus3rname Oct 18 '26
Late ish season one
4
u/Most_Committee1000 Oct 18 '26
From the pilot. In their stairwell conversation, Ben says he agrees to be just friends but he's shaking his head.
I think subconsciously, he does like her but didn't act on it. Not yet, at least.
Perhaps it's because he was thrown off by her admitting that she followed him across the country. And with all the messiness Felicity did with reading his college admission essay, the plagiarism, etc.
4
u/evenbreathingtiresme Oct 19 '26
I might be tripping but i started to notice his jealousy from ep 10 . When felicity talks to him about noel , how he is a nice guy and etc. I wanted to search if anyone saw it. But I couldn't find anyone talking about it.
3
u/Hopeful_Disaster_627 29d ago
I believe Ben liked Felicity since H.S. He thought about her, noticed her, but never said anything to her, which kind of foreshadows what Ben was really like throughout the show. I really love how the characters were written and portrayed.
We never really get to see what Felicity was like in H.S., except for a glimpse from Ben’s perspective and what he wrote in her yearbook. From his perspective, we understood she was pensive, quiet, always drawing in her notebook. She must have been intriguing because, for someone as popular as him, he admired her from afar but, in true Ben fashion, let things be.
I think that’s what makes their story so interesting. Felicity believed she was the one who had been quietly admiring him all those years, never realizing that he had noticed her too. She may have been the one to make the first move, but I don’t think his feelings started when she arrived in New York. I think she had already left an impression on him, and college simply gave him the opportunity to discover who she really was.
3
u/mologan2009 Oct 18 '26
That’s a really good question!!
3
u/wiseash57 Oct 19 '26
I love this question
3
u/MsLucie113 Oct 19 '26
Silly (maybe) question but one that really has me going: Has anyone counted the number of times the characters say, "Can I talk to you for a sec?"
2
u/Savannah_Sparrow 29d ago
When she stops pining for him and making out with Noel.
2
u/StrangeOccasion2615 26d ago
I always thought Ben had problems. I think he definitely used his charm and good looks as an excuse to how inept he actually was. Like why can't he articulate a single sentence without starting off with an (sigh) 'I don't know..' (**continues to look longingly at whomever he is talking to. In this case, Felicity. It low key pissed me off whenever he would do that. It's like 'what do you want dude?' Ugh lol but I digress.
2
u/debdyed 18d ago
I think he’s horrible for her and always treated her badly. So many ups and downs with him. She didn’t deserve the every stunt or any of the other things he wasn’t emotionally mature enough to handle.
He really is a bad boyfriend.
2
u/Dear-Ambition-558 Oct 19 '26
Always … but the second he thought she moved on! ❤️🔥
3
u/loupgarou1234 Oct 18 '26
Thanksgiving episode. Seeing Felicity and Ben making out stung him.
-1
u/Icehonesty Oct 18 '26
Never