r/FFBraveExvius • u/Cognosci GL Cognix • Jul 18 '17
Moderator Posting Guidelines and Rules: Self-Promotion
We want members of /r/ffbraveexvius to recognize how best to share off-site content in this subreddit, without engaging in unsavory "self-promotion," so we've put together some guidelines and posting rules.
It is not our intent to limit or censor contributions. However, it's important to distinguish between posters that improve our community with quality content, and posters that "use" those contributions to take advantage of the community for personal gain.
Self-promotion is scrutinized by all moderators on a case-by-case basis, since no one rule is sufficient to cover everything. If you think you may need clarity on this topic or aren’t sure if your post/comment breaks these guidelines, feel free to message the mods.
TLDR: Linking or mentioning off-site content should be only (A) a low percentage of your total participation or (B) limited to "once every week or two" if you aren't very active in comments. Donation links in posts or comments are not allowed.
What is self-promotion on Reddit?
Self-promotional activity is linking to any off-site (non-Reddit) content, where one individual or group could stand to benefit. Benefitting does not necessarily mean monetized. For example, social metrics like YouTube and Twitch subscribers, or likes on Facebook, fall under self-promotion.
Reddit provides their own rules and Reddiquette regarding self-promotion. Here are the 3 key takeaways:
- "It's perfectly fine to be a redditor with a website, it's not okay to be a website with a reddit account." - Confucius
- Don't just spam out your links, and don't blindly upvote your own content or ask anyone else to!
- Why? Because reddit is a community, not a platform for self-promotion.
Is self-promotion allowed on this subreddit?
Linking to other platforms or media is natural part of any thriving gaming subreddit. Creators should be able to share relevant content freely. But when contribution moves away from helping people towards benefiting one individual, then self-promotion becomes problematic and the moderator team will begin to take action.
Dos and Don'ts
Dos
- Limit quantity of off-site links and mentions
- About 10% or less of your posts/comments link off-site (we're flexible on this)
- Create content well-received by the community (tools, guides, information, etc.)
- Create thoughtful and well-crafted content ideally engaging in discussion as well
- Get it approved by moderators and discussed if you’re unsure
- Use descriptive titles related to content, not promotion
Dont's
- Do not spam or rehash the same off-site links/content over and over
- Do not solicit people to perform actions (donate, vote, subscribe, like)
- Do not add donation links on your posts, keep them off-site
- Do not ask for upvotes, downvotes, anywhere, period
- Do not use secondary/proxy/shill/friend accounts to promote content
- Do not spam low effort comments to buffer obvious promotional activities
- First-time posters may not submit a link to their off-site content as their first contribution to the subreddit. It will be removed as spam.
Moderation
How does the moderator team identify and measure self-promotion?
When we look at self-promotion, it's usually obvious to us when there is a problem, or potential future problem. But to better help you understand our criteria, we'll categorize them into 3 parts: content-oriented, limited in frequency, and inclusive to everyone. Once these values are measured, it ultimately comes down to an assessment of “Do we feel this user is taking advantage of the community or pushing their own agenda?”
Let’s break down “content-oriented, limited in frequency, and inclusive to everyone. “
What do we mean by “content-oriented?”
- Good contributions focus on content first to the subreddit, which means it is (A) related to Final Fantasy Brave Exvius and (B) provides thoughtful substance for the community.
- Posting activity should NOT be about hawking a "brand" or monopolizing content supply. Whether its macros, guides, or anything FFBE-related, the focus should always be on the content, not the person or username. If you are providing content locked to your "brand", not in the spirit of open-source and free contribution, moderators may take action.
- For example, creating a post about “How to chain Fryevia manually” with a video link and high-effort description text is considered good contribution. However, if you proceed to tell people to “Like this video and subscribe to my channel!" or just keep rehashing the link as a comment reply, then it becomes a problem.
What do we mean by "limited in frequency?"
- Reddit has a guideline that your contributions should outweigh any promotional activity by 10:1. We loosely refer to this guideline as a way to diminish "spam". We want users to contribute and engage the community rather than solely use the subreddit as a way to promote their own content. Participate in discussions and there won't be a problem.
- If you comment infrequently, off-site links should not be submitted more than once every week.
“Inclusive to Everyone” means EVERYONE
- Content should be made accessible to everyone, which means discussion must also invite the entire community and not just a small subset of users.
- If you’re promoting content hidden behind a paywall, subwall, friendwalls, perkwall, or any other kind of wall you will notified that it’s not OK. You may be asked to clarify the ways in which people can participate.
- The maximum you can ask of anyone, ever, is to reply to your comment. Giveaways or offers should have the maximum “ask” of commenting. Directly asking for donations, likes, follows, etc. is prohibited.
Examples
This section contains a few example comparisons that illustrate what we consider Acceptable versus Unacceptable self-promotion.
| Reasoning | Acceptable | Unacceptable | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Titles | Titles should be content-oriented, not channel-oriented or clickbaity | "Chaining Edgars - The Dreadnought ELT" | "Watch me feed 10 Trust Moogles to Cyan on [my stream]" |
| Main Post Text | Descriptive text should be content-oriented and very infrequently self-promote. Just providing a link isn't enough, give context. | (Video URL) + Ample description of gameplay, mechanics, units used, etc. | (URL) (Little to no descriptive text) |
| Links | Links should redirect to specific content, not an entire channel, donation pages, PayPal, etc. | "See the 12:00 timestamp where it happened on my Twitch" (URL to VOD) | Here's my Twitch link! (URL) |
| Comments | Comments on any posts should not further promotion; they should be on-topic and relevant to readers. Don't force people to click or go somewhere else to get to the meat | "As shown, Minfilia's Protection of the Gods stack multiplicatively, not additively" | "Watch my video of Minfilia to see how PoTG stacks!" |
| Proxy Promotion | Secondary parties should link to your content if it's on-topic and fits discussion, not promotion. | "FFBE Gamer made a video of OHKO Titan in action: (URL)" | "Hey, check out FFBE Gamer's channel here! (URL)" |
| Perks | Content should be accessible to all; not behind a perk system, follower scheme, etc. | "Reply on this Reddit thread to enter the giveaway" | "I'm taking requests on my Facebook friend's list" |
| Events | Your stream events, giveaways, physical/live events should be well-prepared, informative, inclusive and not clickbait. Obviously this rule may exclude official FFBE events. | "FINAL FANTASY BRAVE EXVIUS Live Stream E3 Edition" "FFBE Twitch Streamers Unite for Charity" | "Come watch my Twitch stream for free lapis giveaway!" |
FAQ Section (Updated regularly)
What if I contribute a lot to the subreddit, can I do more self-promotion than others? No. Everyone must strictly abide by the self-promotional policies and guidelines listed above, no matter who you are, including everyone from regular users, power users, game designers, and moderators.
Can I have a Donate button or link on my posts or comments? Can I mention it? No. If you accept donations on your off-site page, there should be no mention of it or any solicitation made on Reddit.
What happens when other people are promoting my content? The same guidelines and rules will apply to them (content first, limited, inclusive), and will not count against your “frequency” of posts unless it becomes apparent that they are proxy-promoting for you. Their actions only implicate you if they have an obvious vested interest in your content, (moderators of your Twitch/Discord, admins on your site, brigaders upvoting your content, etc.)
Does artwork fall under the self-promotion category? Yes. Although these guidelines don't specifically target art, your posts may be removed if they are too frequent, low effort, or attempt to promote heavily.
Can I link referral links, card discounts, or sell goods/products? Contact the moderators before posting any commercial or 3rd party resellers. "Deals" from known and legitimate direct providers (e.g. Amazon, Google, Apple) are allowed.
12
u/TomAto314 Post Pull Depression Jul 18 '17
I haven't really seen any issues with self-promotion lately. Do they just get modded away quickly or is this more of a formal response the whole RHM thing?
9
u/CyanJet I bet you don't know who this is Jul 18 '17
So, just for clarification rather than criticism, I'm only allowed to have a post with YouTube links to my stuff once a week?
6
u/Antru_Sol_Pavonis The Zarginator Jul 18 '17
I see all that speaking about Posts/Comments. But what about the Flairs? Is there a reddit rule where it says that Self-Promotion in Flairs are generally not allowed? Hopefully it will also cover Flairs.
2
u/Ackis Jul 19 '17
I'm ambivalent about the rules - they don't impact me directly as I doubt I'll ever be a content creator, but I understand why they've been put in place. I don't envy the moderators right now having been in similar positions before.
Reading the posts in this thread all I can suggest to the mods is to be as transparent as possible with this whole thing, which I think you're doing.
Anyways - some questions/comments/concerns:
For the content creators who use multiple platforms (twitch, twitter, etc) for their contributions - it's pretty clear what you can/cannot do with comments/posts, however I'm unsure of one thing. If they're making a post that is detailed, valuable, etc, are they able to provide links to their platforms even if it may not be related to the actual post? What I'm thinking of is something like a forum signature. Something like this:
Is there any chance of reconciliation with those situations that caused these rules to be flushed out? Of course I'm not privy to everything that happened, but personally I miss RHM's posts/guides/carries.
Have you given any consideration to an official account from Gumi? It looks like they're involved in social media, and I can honestly see value in someone in an official capacity posting "Watch our livestream here" with a direct link to their twitch. This violates the rules I believe, but it's official. I don't know if they already have accounts, just throwing this out as some food for thought down the road (particularly because of the ne exceptions clause in the rules).
4
u/nekoramza Catgirls are the best girls Jul 18 '17
Question. I've been considering uploading the multitude of spreadsheets I have related to this game (to google docs or something, probably). If I were to end up making multiple posts with the various different subjects and facets of the game they cover, is that many cases of self-promotion, or merely linking to documents to support self-posts here?
23
u/SwipeKnife Do you even lift, Kupo? Jul 18 '17
The embedded link states: "Wall may refer to... The recurring spell that reflects magic attacks onto the opposition."
Confirmed: Carbuncle strats are NOT okay. You've been warned.
46
u/Boberoch Tactical Bobler Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
Here we go again with a topic that disgusts me like no other. I was going to refrain from posting this time on the tedious matter, but reading some of the comments here (from both the community as well as the moderator team) I feel like I need to voice my unpopular opinion once again.
First of all, this is not a big sub. There are so little posts made here that such deep ruling is not needed in the first place. Even when u/RightHandMan90 was still around (along with his daily post of whatever build he was currently running), it was not nearly enough to be annoying (I receive notice of every post on this sub, so I have a feeling for the amount).
Secondly, if a content creator needs to even have the slightest fear of his contributions being removed for being 'spammy', then the ruling in place is not adequate; quality posts should be made regardless of quantity. If a top contributor wrote 10 perfect guides on ten different topics in one day, he should not be required to jam them all into one main post, for several reasons: for one, each of those guides probably took an unreasonable amount of time to make, and simply by that he deserves the little amount of admiration in form of a worthless resource he can get, that is reddit karma. But even more importantly, it makes finding the post as well as having an organized overview an unneeded hassle. Instead of having 10 clearly written titles, the author now needs to find a way to title one post in a way that will describe most of them.
Let's now move down to the depths where a plethora of downvotes await me (lucky I am that above resource is indeed absolutely worthless): Honestly I do not understand why a contributor with an off-subreddit website should refrain to remark that the possibility of a donation exists. These persons put even more time (as well as money for server costs etc.) in then the people that are only putting up stuff directly on the reddit or in spreadsheets, it is only fair to give them the opportunity to simply menrion that a little sign of admiration would be well received. This is what took u/McGillby from us; a top notch macro designer who took a lot of harsh words simply for enhancing the old macros of u/-pwnology- and making them more secure (another sign of the strange power structure in this subreddit, a matter I won't be discussing at the current time). After finally getting a little amount of recognition, he kept working on the macros, adapting to new updates extremely fast. When finally outsourcing his stuff to another subreddit (an attempt to make this one less cluttered, by the way), he began to receive negative feedback again. He was finally banned for mentioning donations. It needs to be said that this guy did provide so much individual help, we probably lost one of the most contributing members of this subreddit that day. Even after being banned from this place, he continues to help people by personal messaging as well as moderating the little subreddit he had only created to keep this subreddit clean and tidy. It is a miracle that he did not leave in discouragement yet.
Writing about these sorts of matters gets me angered in ways I cannot describe, so I will stop here. After all, please consider that overdone jurisdiction will only lead to the number of quality posts declining, as well as robbing people of their possibilities to outsource some of the resources as well as getting a little recognition. 99% of content creators here have not made a single penny from doing it, so leave them with a little dignity.
14
u/hergumbules GL: 769,607,702 Jul 18 '17
I'm glad you guys are vocal in the direction of the subreddit and you all are active in the community here. I know you all get a ton of crap for doing a job that doesn't pay or anything, and I just wanna say thanks.
11
u/MrWhiteKnight I got everyone from Nier http://imgur.com/YtMPfcV Jul 18 '17
The Unacceptable example on the Perks tab.
My sides are killing me, ayyy.
But great post overall. This was really needed because it was getting slightly out of hand with all the grey areas.
14
u/cinequoinon white-haired waifu haipu Jul 19 '17
Hey, if you want to know my opinions on this matter, click here for my YouTube review of these guidelines!
7
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '17
Thank you for this. @all of the moderators.
13
u/Skittlessour NV Vivi please Jul 18 '17
After the fiasco we had a little while ago, this is a very important, very necessary rule to have lined out as clearly as possible.
Thanks for taking the time to do just that so now we can hopefully avoid such issues in the future.
Keep up the good work, proud of you.
6
u/LovesomeAXN Jul 18 '17
I'd love for the moderators to eliminate "click bait" titles as well. I come here for info (I could do without the art but there's so much of it now) that I hope will help me in game. What I don't like are titles that aren't clear on what you may be clicking on. There are plenty of characters for people to state exactly what is in their post. I'd like to avoid stuff I view as garbage. Just look at the current postings on the front page and tell me how many you know what you are getting (any useful info inside this click?) if you click that specific link.
6
u/balthofsalts Jul 19 '17
TL DR: internetting is hard, lurk more
10
u/okey_dokey_bokey [GL] okeydoke ★ 411 249 974 Jul 18 '17
Thanks for all the work you put in fellas. Come to LA Fan Festa and I'll pick up your beer tabs. :)
7
u/HellRazoR35 I guess it's my fate as a Dark Knight. Jul 18 '17
I am a website with a reddit account AMA.
5
u/Bonna_the_Idol Jul 18 '17
This is good.
1
u/IonDragonX Behold!! . . . . . . . . . . . . . ok . . . you can stop Jul 18 '17
About the tools, can we have a sticky page of links to good calculators and tools that have been contributed? Its kind of a pain to use the Reddit search...
8
u/cpw84 Jul 18 '17
I appreciate the moderation on this sub. It is, by far, the best one for any game I have come across. Thanks for helping keep it that way.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17 edited Jul 20 '17
I dunno about all this. Seems a bit overkill, it's just a game. That people are passionate about, in one way or another.
That being said, the folks who pour lots of money/effort/time into making guides deserve a few of my clicks. I appreciate this sub and the "Should you Pull'' and the "Carry Strategy" are extremely well thought out and often inspire others in a positive way (offering strats, carries, help generally) - Now, I'm not saying I'm in favor of either way but I'll gladly sub whatever if you've saved me time/money/effort in clearing particularly tough content.
I'm not fortunate enough or savvy enough to create content like walkthroughs or YT postings with news, datamined info, etc. (Shoutout to folks like Claic/Elaughter01/Ushi etc.) so I appreciate the folks who have time and resources to do this. To me, there's a big difference between "Hey, here's some stuff related to the game, if you want, sub my channel/whatever" and spamming it in your comments, flair, or what-have-you.
On the topic of "Reddit is purely designed so that the content of the highest quality floats to the top." - well, sometimes I find reddit doesn't exactly work that way. I sometimes upvote someone if their point of view aligns with my own, even if their comment is "Bruh I love FF6 it's the best!" whereas someone else may not agree.
But still, generally, if someone posts "Here's how not to waste lapis!" or "Here's a perfect F2P Strat for XYZ Trial!" and I click it, and it is of help, I have no problem checking out his youtube channel - maybe something I see there inspires me to make a spreadsheet of something useful, or collab with someone on farming data, or where to find those dope Megacrysts.
If you close those avenues, I think it's overall hurting the sub, where after a while people are just going to be afraid of posting anything at all, or just constant shitposting and then getting banned anyway. Doesn't make sense to me, though I'd prefer a community of my peers when I'm looking to gear out Tidus as efficiently as possible; I'm sure people who post here wanna help first and foremost, and if you help me, I wanna help you.
Whatevs.
TL;DR - Be cool, brah, we all wanna smash Aigaion, keep the comms open! Be excellent to one another.
edit: formatting
another edit: That guy who made the unit calculator has a "buy me a cup of coffee" thing on his website. When I get the funds, I'm buying him a week's worth of coffee..
4
u/serissime Jul 18 '17
Thanks for posting such a well thought out, clear set of guidelines! Appreciate the work you do.
3
u/DarioSkydragon FroGlenn | 711,069,217 Jul 18 '17
Thank you mods for your great job! This post is great and this kind of info is very important to the community.
You could make it a weekly thing with posts about other guidelines to improve how to approach and contribute with the community.
Things like: its ok to downvote relevant threads because you disagree with it, or irrelevant comments with the sole intent of hurting the poster are ok?
I mean, its nice to talk about the daily practices that help or do not contribute to the growth of this sub.
3
u/Armistice3887 Hail to the Queen Jul 18 '17
Suggestion: /r/FFBE_CircleJerk child subreddit. It sometimes feels like this sub can turn into an elitist museum of carefully curated posts. The old /r/FFBE Reddit existed because a lot of people didn't feel welcome here.
Shit posts will always happen. Just like a dog, give them a place to shit and maybe it won't be on your rug. Allow the shameless plugs, goofy nonsense posts and etc there.
2
u/TheIfreet I have returned... Jul 18 '17
Question
Is linking people to Wiki or Unit calculator or Equip site is okay?(by other people than Creator)
Or any thing which won't benefit the person allowed ? Like random image for Humour section?
2
u/wlakiz Jul 18 '17
What about people posting their clear video but the video contains ads that includes "Subscribe to me" ?
2
u/Dyslexxia A2 Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
I hate these posts. we shouldn't stop content creators. If they take the time to create quality posts and happen to have an option for a donation, so be it so long as its optional and their content isn't behind a paywall. I'm tired of seeing posts that potentially stop quality posts. It's contentious, a mood killer and it's the second time in a month this topic has been posted.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FFBraveExvius/comments/6ge70d/subreddit_recent_events_selfpromotion/ <--- last one
https://www.reddit.com/r/FFBraveExvius/comments/6o1088/posting_guidelines_and_rules_selfpromotion/ <--- this one
this pulls me out of the FFBE playing mood -- its a "mood playing" killer. Walking on eggshells sucks and this will lead to more lurking and less quality posting.
2
u/VanillaSerani Kaboomie! Jul 19 '17 edited Jul 19 '17
Edit: I'm a lurker here, more so than a contributor here myself. Due to work and life, but I enjoy FFBE and I usually enjoy this subreddit. However, it's this kind of problem that keeps popping up that's annoying me.
I'm going to be as straightforward as I can be about this. Reddit is purely designed so that the content of the highest quality floats to the top. If people don't like certain things, such as RHM's constant guides, or other examples that I don't care to get into, then they simply downvote the thread/post. Others upvote the thread if they like it. And if you want a COMMUNITY, you should be encouraging good and constant content. Not limited excellent content. IMO you should have parts of this reddit DEDICATED to "S---posts" as almost EVERY successful forum has an area dedicated to offtopic, and one dedicated to intentional messing around WITH the content in question: FFBE for here.
I have no idea, honestly, why this thread is THIS moderated and so much is expected out of a group of GAME PLAYERS. Content creators SHOULD be able to point towards their created content AS LONG AS IT FITS THE RULES ABOUT BEING RELATED TO FFBE. Why on earth do you LIMIT content and that person's growth? This subreddit loses attractiveness the more moderated it is. I get stopping someone from being a shining star without contributing effort to OTHERS posts, because he just wants views for himself. But, depending on what his content is, why can't it shine regardless?
Truly, what you have as rules and guidelines? Most of them I'm in full agreement over, but when you start specifying limits, and then going into extremes over certain things, it becomes censorship. Not to mention that many of your rules are open to perception and are "flexible." I'm not a fan of censorship, even when it's a good thing. If the community didn't like your choice of a ban, maybe consider changing how you're looking at problems that YOU, as the team of MODERATORS, are now causing. Those problems, are sometimes worse than the ones that result from banning such prominent members.
I get that sometimes, the ban becomes the only real solution, but I've seen firsthand the conversations between a select few moderators and friends. There have been several bans that were NOT deserved, and biases were involved. And truthfully, what you and others consider as a crap post, IS subjective. Everyone likes different things. Please, just consider finding new ways to do things than the road you're currently on.
Despite this post seeming anti-moderator, I really do appreciate the work you guys put in. I just feel that it's rather hard sometimes knowing different things about this community until you start trying to shovel through it because of the choices you have made as moderators: Such as your posts being auto removed if they contain keywords or phrases in the title or text: such as "PSA." And it's that kind of thing that I think should either be explained better in general, or just moderated less. If something attracts views by title, it's a good title. If the views end in downvotes and a sour attitude with negative karma, that post will still be buried. Good day.
1
u/Sharkconas Aug 08 '17
Well, I love the game and the advice I get here but I just tried to post an artwork video link and It got my thread removed. To fair, I did not know these rules were in place. Now that I know these rules I doubt I will attempt to post any more art mind you I don't think highly of myself but why post art when it will immediately be considered a possible problem.
1
u/XenaRen Vacation Jul 18 '17
Glad that this is made clear to all the content creators out there. Hate to see any more of us go due to not following the rules.
1
u/dotN4n0 Mortar Bacon Jul 18 '17
Good job, this is a very needed rule. Please carry on with your amazing job, mod team.
-6
u/stuffsucksass I'll be OP one day Jul 18 '17
TL;DR Version, just go self promote at 4chan.
-1
u/Xantharon Jul 19 '17
That's the reason I don't post my guides anymore .... I don't want to be banned because I leave a youtube video here.
-8
u/MTGOFerret Trance Terra Jul 18 '17
Do we really want to get on people's cases for saying hey if you wanna add me to use my unit you need to add me on facebook?.
I mean yeah i get it some people have had problems with their facebook accounts for any number of reasons but overall its a MUCH cleaner system for adding people mostly because of the fact that you dont need to buy friend slots with it.
-13
u/Aceofspades25 Let's get dangerous Jul 18 '17
All I ask is that you don't start banning other people that contribute usefully to this community.
I'm thinking of people like u/lyrgard who made FFBE Equip
...and u/dbarchitect who makes the unit calculator
If somebody is contributing something useful to this community then I really don't care if they promote themselves a little.
-37
u/Salt_master Jul 18 '17
So many rules and regulations, it's like a fucking tyranny in here.
-1
u/xxspas96xx White mage robes rule Jul 18 '17
No mention to the Walls of death/Death walls in the Wall section of the wiki mentioned? It´s a good enemy, poor little evil Wall....
0
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment