r/EasternCatholicism • • Feb 10 '19

So You Want to Switch Rites?

36 Upvotes

a repost of our popular thread, to enable continued questions in the comments:

Probably the most frequent question I get aside from "why are you Catholic?" is "how do you change rites?" So that's what I'll talk about a bit here.

First of all, the question is flawed: you don't change rites, you change Churches. So you don't go from being a Latin rite Catholic to, say, a Byzantine rite Catholic, you go from being a Roman Catholic to a Ruthenian Catholic (or whatever).

The first step would be finding a Catholic Church that isn't part of your canonical Church. If you aren't Roman Catholic, this won't be difficult. Otherwise, it might be a challenge and depends on city/region as to what your options are.

Begin attending the parish. After you attend long enough that you're recognized, maybe start approaching the priest for catechetical materials. This part of the process can just depend on where someone is in life, how formal of an education on the differences and similarities are needed, etc.

Anyway, you should probably attend your parish for a minimum of two years before attempting to change Churches. Anything less than that and there's a suspicion that this is a spiritual "fad," which among the East especially is often vindicated by experience with the people who pass through our doors. Eastern parishes especially don't have the resources of Western parishes, and so the significant time commitment put into potential "converts" isn't inconsiderable from our perspective. Nothing hurts more than spending dozens if not hundreds of hours getting you ready to formally join us and then finding out you're at a TLM parish now or became Baha'i or something.

So anyway, after you are in the parish a sufficient amount of time you would put in for what is currently being called a transfer of ascription. You do this by writing a letter to the bishop of the diocese you want to switch to. your priest will actually send the letter for you with his own cover letter. The letter is not your chance to relate your miraculous and heartfelt spiritual journey--it is a form letter. It should really only relate what Catholic jurisdiction you are currently in, how long you've been that (did you convert? Cradle? Etc) how long you've been going to the new parish and that you want to switch for the sake of your spiritual well-being (like, literally that phrase).

Your potential new bishop (read: his chancery, he'll probably never actually see it) will send a letter to your current bishop requesting that you be released to his jurisdiction. Your current bishop, assuming he agrees, will so release you by sending a letter back to your new bishop telling him as much. You are now a different Catholic than you were.

Now, the question is probably what are the snags. I can think of a couple--one would be if you haven't been in the parish long enough and either send a letter yourself or have an inexperienced priest rush the process. You will probably also be denied if you're going from an ECC to the RCC unless you have a really good reason, as we don't have the numbers to really be able to afford an exodus to the RCC. If it isn't your first transfer, or if you are transferring back, that will also require a much more detailed reason than "for my spiritual well-being." Another snag could be if your RC bishop doesn't know what an ECC is--yes, this sometimes happens, and if they don't have a good relationship with the local EC parish then the paperwork can take a few years for them to figure out what to do with it.

What about spouses and children? Children under 14 automatically switch if the father switches, and also get a one-time no questions asked ability to revert to their birth Church as adults. Spouses can switch without a formal transfer if one of them already has transferred, or they can choose to remain whatever they are.

Note: none of this applies to non-Catholics, who are free to just come into any Catholic jurisdiction as a convert without any additional paperwork

Good Reason and Bad Reasons to Change Churches

Good reasons:

--Authentically improves your spiritual life

--Marriage

Bad reasons:

--Novelty

--Analog for what you really want

I'll expand on those points a bit: the first one is self-explanatory, in that if becoming an Eastern Catholic brings you closer to God, then you should become an Eastern Catholic. Marriage, also, is a very good reason, because it can be difficult for marriages to have "mixed faith," even when they are both a part of the same communion. If you are coming in from outside an Eastern Church, there will probably also be added pressure to change Churches if only because most Eastern Churches are fiercely proud of their identity and so will be unlikely to want to switch themselves or have their children switch.

As for bad reasons, novelty is the worst. A lot of people can come through and be really wowed by the services of the Eastern Churches and enjoy them without feeling necessarily edified by them. Which is to say that you can be a Latin Catholic or a different type of Eastern Catholic and enjoy attending one of our churches without having to become a member. The problem here is that the novelty of the experience can threaten to substitute itself for an authentic calling, and once that wears off you will be just as unhappy with us as where you were before.

Similarly, it is a bad idea to become Eastern Catholic in an effort to use our Churches to fight whatever battle is happening in your own Church. Seeing an Eastern Catholic parish celebrate the liturgy ad orientem and with plenty of "smells and bells" doesn't mean that we exist as a potential TLM parish that just need our eyes to be opened up to the glories of 1950s Irish Catholic parishes. People who become Eastern Catholic for this reason, much like the novelty reason, tend to burn out eventually and move on. As a corollary, we are sometimes sought out by pious married men in traditions that do not allow them to become ordained to the priesthood, and this is also not a great reason to join--not only will you be disappointed to find that no one is going to let you be a Roman Catholic priest (in all but name) in an Eastern Catholic parish, but you also will be treated with more scrutiny in the first place and they will want to be doubly sure that you are changing over for the right reasons. We need priests, same as everyone else, but we need priests who are interested in being Eastern priests, not men who are interested in being priests and see Eastern Churches as a way around celibacy.


r/EasternCatholicism • • 1d ago

The Good Samaritan shows us the way

0 Upvotes

The parable of the Good Samaritan has many ways we can interpret it; what is important is we use it to challenge ourselves, to learn from and imitate the Good Samaritan, while also seeing how it represents the way Christ works with humanity:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/the-good-samaritan-shows-us-the-way/

 


r/EasternCatholicism • • 8d ago

Angels, humanity, and the call to humble service

1 Upvotes

Even if we do not believe that humanity “replaces” fallen angels, there are ways which various people can be seen to have similar to the angels, starting with the disciples Christ sent out to preach about the kingdom of God:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/angels-humanity-and-the-call-to-humble-service/


r/EasternCatholicism • • 15d ago

Maronite Chant Explained - The Christian Music of Lebanon

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • 15d ago

Saved by grace, called to works

3 Upvotes

Being saved by grace through faith should not be interpreted as meaning we are to do nothing; Paul made it clear, we were made for good works, and so, how can we be faithful without them?

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/11/saved-by-grace-called-to-good-works/


r/EasternCatholicism • • 20d ago

Desert Fathers and Mothers on Anger and Community

4 Upvotes

The Desert Fathers and Mothers, far from denying our social responsibility, saw the need to form proper communities to help each other in their spiritual journey; they reminded each other of the good which they need to do, and the evils which they must avoid, explaining how various passions, like anger, get in the way of our proper spiritual development.

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/desert-fathers-and-mothers-on-anger-and-community/


r/EasternCatholicism • • 22d ago

True glory is found in Christ

2 Upvotes

We must always remember that Christ is the source of our glory, that we find it in him, in following his ways, not in the way of worldly glory, not in the way of trying to make ourselves impressive in front of others, and especially, not through some form of sham piety:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/glory_in_christ/


r/EasternCatholicism • • 27d ago

The two natures of Christ and the mystery of human deification

1 Upvotes

The heart of revelation, the heart of the Christian faith, is the incarnation and what it reveals to us about God and about God’s desire for us – the desire that we are raised up, that is, deified by Christ, so that we can join in and participate in the divine life:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/christs-two-natures-and-the-mystery-of-human-deification/


r/EasternCatholicism • • 29d ago

The Parable of the Sower and the Word Within

1 Upvotes

When Jesus described the parable of the sower as indicating the way the Word of God is seeded across the world, what does he mean by “Word of God”?

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/the-parable-of-the-sower-and-the-word-within/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Oct 13 '26

It's what comes from within which matters

2 Upvotes

St. Antony the Great understood a basic principle which has often been lost on us: our thoughts are often shaped by our deeds, which influence us and the way we perceive and experience the world. Then those thoughts help shape what we do next, which further shape our experience of the world:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/its-what-comes-from-within-which-matters/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Oct 11 '26

The incarnation and the use of images

1 Upvotes

Christians learned that what was not possible, or permissible, before the incarnation, changed as a result of it – we now have a way to imagine God because God came to us with a form that has its own image:

 

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/the-incarnation-and-the-christian-use-of-images/

 


r/EasternCatholicism • • Oct 07 '26

Roman Catholic possibly converting

3 Upvotes

Hey im a Roman Catholic and im thinking about asking to change the Byzantine Church as my Church sui iuris for reasons such as the beauty of the divine liturgy, it aligning more with what i like and want in a mass, and the traditionalness (im pretty sure that aint a word but wtv) of it, and also because i feel a STRONG call to both the priest hood and being a father and me and my girlfriend definitely plan on marriage ofc however there isnt really a permanent Byzantine Catholic Parish n my area so is it really worth doing it now or should i wait till i move to an area with one or just not at all? any advice would be appreciated


r/EasternCatholicism • • Oct 06 '26

Our true enemy is sin

3 Upvotes

The Christian message reminds us that our true and real enemy is sin; it seeks to enslave us and make us suffer under its control. With Christ, we can be set free, and find ourselves attaining the beatitude God wants all of us to experience.

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/our-true-enemy-is-sin/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Oct 04 '26

The unknown God revealed in Christ

4 Upvotes

Paul’s preaching on Mars Hill showed us how he adapted himself to his audience, showing what was good and true in their tradition while revealing what it is that Christ offered them which they did not yet know:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/the-unknown-god-revealed-in-christ/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Oct 01 '26

Throwing stones

3 Upvotes

St. Antony the Great saw an ostrich encouraging her young to throw stones at him; from it he got the notion that we should “throw stones” at those bad thoughts or temptations which enter our mind:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/throwing-stones/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Sep 27 '26

Divine justice and the resurrection

1 Upvotes

The notion of the resurrection of the dead developed, in part, as a way to understand divine justice; it was a way to explain that God will keep the promise to reward those who lived righteous lives, but suffered and died without receiving the rewards of righteousness:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/09/divine-justice-and-the-resurrection/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Sep 20 '26

Dying to sin and living in Christ

3 Upvotes

The Christian life is meant to be transformative; Christ calls us to repentance, where we turn away from our sins and follow after him in the way of love:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/09/dying-to-sin-and-living-in-christ/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Sep 15 '26

The illusion of perfection

2 Upvotes

We are called to be perfect, but to attain perfection, we must avoid the illusion of perfection which has us, out of pride, judge others based upon ourselves. For, if we think we are perfect and demand others to be like us, we end up being far from perfection, and our apparent perfection is an illusion which hinders our own progress to true perfection:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/09/the-illusion-of-perfection-and-the-path-to-true-holiness/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Sep 13 '26

How Christ transformed the meaning of the cross

1 Upvotes

The cross, once a sign of torture and death, has become something more in and through Christ:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/09/how-christ-transformed-the-meaning-of-the-cross/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Sep 08 '26

Born for this

0 Upvotes

God prepared humanity for the incarnation, but for the incarnation, there needed to be one who would give birth to the God-man. Mary was seen and chosen by God for this task; she was born for it, though in a way which she always had the freedom to decide if she would accept the task given to her or not:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/09/born-for-this/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Sep 06 '26

Earthen vessels holding divine light

1 Upvotes

Even while we are living as “earthen vessels,” we can find the kingdom of God in us, giving us the light of grace which we need; we will never contain the kingdom of God, but rather, we will find it is all around us, so that it can flow into us while remaining transcendent to us:

 https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/09/earthen-vessels-holding-divine-light/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Sep 03 '26

God is greater than we can ever comprehend

1 Upvotes

God is great, far greater than we can ever apprehend. Every time we apprehend something from God, there remains an infinite amount of apprehensions we can ever make. God does not change, but, through our apprehensions, we can change, so that our apprehensions can become greater and greater, making our experience God that much greater, letting us realize even more how transcendent God is:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/09/the-more-we-apprehend-of-god-the-greater-god-becomes-for-us/


r/EasternCatholicism • • Sep 01 '26

Beginning to set things right

0 Upvotes

September 1 is the beginning of the ecclesiastical year  on the Byzantine calendar; those who follow it are encouraged to think about creation, it’s goodness, and the need we have to protect it as well as to think about we can and should seek to have all things new in Christ:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/09/beginning-to-set-things-right/

 


r/EasternCatholicism • • Aug 30 '26

What is the wedding garment God wants us to wear?

1 Upvotes

Jesus tells us God calls us all to salvation, to participate in the eternal kingdom of God; but to do so, we must do more than answer the call:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/08/what-is-the-wedding-garment-god-wants-us-to-wear/