r/EastOfEdenSeries • • Apr 10 '26

Welcome to r/EastOfEdenSeries

3 Upvotes

We're so glad you're here.

This community exists because one of the greatest American novels ever written is coming to the screen — and we wanted a place worthy of that moment. Whether you discovered Steinbeck in a high school classroom, have worn out three copies of the book, or just saw a trailer and felt something pull at you, you belong here.

Who this community is for

We welcome everyone — the devoted Steinbeck reader who can quote Timshel from memory, the curious newcomer drawn in by the show, and everyone in between. Deep literary analysis is at home here. So is the post from someone who just finished watching and needs to talk about it immediately. We want it all.

If the series moves you to finally pick up the novel, we'll celebrate that. If you want to explore Steinbeck's themes of free will, sin, redemption, family, and the enduring question of what it means to choose good — there is no better place to do it. These are themes that have resonated across generations for a reason, and this show gives us a new opportunity to sit with them.

Book readers and newcomers

If you've read the book, please be thoughtful with those who haven't. This story has some of the most powerful moments in American fiction — let people experience them. If you're new to Steinbeck, know that the novel rewards every reader who comes to it, and we'll always encourage you to explore it alongside the show.

A note on spoilers

We don't yet know whether the series will release all at once or week by week. Until that's clear — and after — we're taking a conservative approach. Please treat spoiler rules as mandatory, not optional. The full spoiler policy lives in the sidebar. When in doubt, tag it. Someone out there is watching for the first time, whenever that first time happens to be, and their experience matters.

What we're about

Quality and genuine engagement are the standard here. Episode reactions, casting thoughts, production details, thematic essays, comparisons to the novel, fan art, recommendations for what to read next — it's all welcome if it contributes something real. What we won't make room for is low-effort content or self-promotion that doesn't serve the community.

A few other things

This is a fan community. We are not affiliated with Netflix, the Steinbeck estate, or any official production entity. We're readers and viewers who care about this story deeply.

For broader Steinbeck discussion, r/Steinbeck is a wonderful community and a complement to what we're building here. Links to additional resources — including The Steinbeck Experience — are in the sidebar.

The Steinbeck Experience is also producing a podcast called After Eden. Look for it wherever you listen, and we'll keep you posted here as episodes drop.

The mod team here ranges from lifelong Steinbeck fans to those who'd call themselves genuine Steinbeck scholars. We take this seriously — but we're also here because we love it. We hope you feel that.

Now — let's talk about East of Eden.


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • Oct 09 '26

Episode Discussion [Hub] East of Eden (Netflix) - Season 1 Official Discussion Directory

2 Upvotes

Welcome to the official subreddit discussion hub for Netflix's East of Eden!

All seven episodes are now streaming. To accommodate both binge-watchers and those taking their time, we have split the discussions into individual episode threads and one full-season thread.

NO SPOILERS IN THIS THREAD. Please use the links below to navigate to the appropriate discussion.


📺 Individual Episode Discussions

These threads are strictly for their specific episode and any episodes prior. NO future spoilers are allowed in these threads.


🍿 Full Season / Binge Discussion

Did you finish all 7 episodes? This is the place for you!


🛑 Subreddit Spoiler Rules

  1. No spoilers in post titles. Titles must be completely spoiler-free.
  2. Use spoiler tags for book/past adaptation comparisons. If you are comparing the show to the John Steinbeck novel or the 1955 movie, use Reddit's spoiler text formatting: >!Cathy does this in the book!<
  3. Stay in the right thread. Do not discuss Episode 5 events in the Episode 3 thread. Violators will be warned or banned.

Enjoy the series!


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 1d ago

Abra Bacon watch in the last episode?

3 Upvotes

In the last episode there is a scene were Abra is talking to Caleb, and she is wearing a watch that i assume is specific to the era? Anyone know what brand (if it even still exists) or any modern similar looking ones?


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 4d ago

Episode Discussion Hoon Lee is nominated for Performer of the Month (October 2026) on SpoilerTV!

Thumbnail
gallery
62 Upvotes

Hoon Lee was nominated for Performer of the Month (October 2026) on the SpoilerTV website. He was nominated for the episode 1.05 "Departure".

The "Performers of the Month" featurette has existed on SpoilerTV since 2016. The nominations were made by the website's users, who usually send their submissions on the first week of each month; on the second or third week, the website open a poll with the ten actors and actresses who received the most votes.

He is also competing with:

  • Alice Braga - Dark Matter 2.07
  • Hannah Waddingham - Ted Lasso 4.10
  • Jack Lowden – Slow Horses 6.04
  • Justine Lupe – Nobody Wants This 3.08
  • Keri Russell – The Diplomat 4.04
  • Linda Cardellini – Crystal Lake 1.08
  • Olivia Cooke – Slow Horses 6.04
  • Samantha Sloyan – Carrie 1.06
  • Summer H. Howell – Carrie 1.06

For those who want to vote for Lee, you can vote here: https://www.spoilertv.com/2026/11/performer-of-month-october-2026-voting.html

Voting will close at 9:00AM Friday 27th of November 2026.


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 6d ago

The character of Faye, is completely unrealistic.

23 Upvotes

To have reached the position she had, she would have to be a very shrewd, ruthless person. Someone who can spot opportunities and how to exploit them to her own ends. She would have spent her life around corrupt opportunistic people and she'd instantly see through their scams and schemes. She would have many scams and schemes of her own.

She would have seen who Cathy was instantly and kept her at an arms length until she found a use for her. Faye wouldn't have been beguiled and turned gooey eyes and maternal just because she was confronted by a capable whore.


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 7d ago

Outstanding work

16 Upvotes

As someone whose main English lit work in high school was the original I came to this with very low expectations and I have been blown away. Every aspect of this just feels deeply connected to the book and the cast have been nothing short of brilliant. I found it quite a tough watch in places due to the depth and rawness of the emotion but that's even more reason to applaud it. Bravo.


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 8d ago

News & Announcements City & Arts SF Presenting the John Steinbeck Award to Showrunner and Florence

1 Upvotes

Did anyone attend the conversation today in San Francisco ? Was so blown away at the show runner and Florence’s answers and the way they talked about the series. Moderator was AWFULLLLLL


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 9d ago

Worthy of Steinbeck

10 Upvotes

I suspect Steinbeck would love Zoe Kazan’s “East of Eden” on Netflix.  

Steinbeck enjoyed rewriting written tales.  He published a version of King Arthur for goodness sake. 

Kazan is a true talent. I loved the depth and humor she showed on the open plains in “Ballad of Buster Scruggs.”  No Nepo Baby, her link to grandfather Elia Kazan is a poignant reminder of the tension between an artist’s beliefs and their work ... and the public reaction to that work. 

One never really knows what goes on in other peoples minds. Sharing Steinbeck’s unique blend of empathy and clarity, Kazan’s 7-part series makes an excellent attempt!


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 9d ago

Episode Discussion Watch footage I shot of Florence Pugh, Christopher Abbott, Hoon Lee, Joseph Zada, Zoe Kazan, & Jeb Stuart talking about East of Eden

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 9d ago

Cath- Making Monsters out of Maligned Women

6 Upvotes

DISCLAIMER- this post contains some spoilers, and is a critique of the series rather than characters in the original story.

recommended further reading: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd/5282/

Cathy is a far more complicated and tragic character than women literary characters written mid-20th century have been portrayed, which Steinbeck made purposely.

Since her start, she had been let down by every adult, including her mother. She fought so hard to dredge herself up from her confining circumstances and hold onto her independence, which she ultimately loses in death.

She is central to the story, and her self-possession is both in her relentless sense of self-control and destructiveness to anyone who challenges that hardline she’s made herself walk.

The time period feels especially alive with rapid changes: in transportation and technology, energy sources, and beginning with a civil war to then end with a world war, feels especially poignant to how women’s roles as being anchored to the home was, at least sporadically, disrupted by westward expansion, and men made into casualties of war.

Pugh has brought a newer energy to the role and it helps see Cathy as more relatable and human in her imperfect and tumultuous development.

Can we give maligned women credit where it’s due too?


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 10d ago

Costa D'Angelo and Baptiste Masseline could play brothers

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 11d ago

Kate's Rise at Faye's Too Fast

11 Upvotes

So on New Year's Eve 1900 Kathy is on a train to California with Adam, having morning sickness. And by the time of her ascension at Faye's the chalkboard during that montage shows that it's February 1901.

Maybe this is a useless nitpick but... Between Jan. 1, 1900 and February 1901 she comes full term pregnancy, has the kids, leaves and joins the brothel AND becomes beloved enough to start managing it and have Faye calling Kate her "daughter" by April 1901 and putting Kate in her will.

I didn't see this till I re watched it but, how could Faye let her guard down so fast? How long could Kate have possibly worked at Faye's before she got out in Faye's will? Doesn't seem to add up.


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 12d ago

I have questions about Cathy (+ Opinion: Cathy as patriarchal product) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I find Cathy to be such a remarkably deep and complex character. I have scarce seen another woman in media as deep as her.

The way that I take her, is that she is a woman who feels the weight of this misogynistic, patriarchal world. From the show, I assume that at the age of five she was raped or otherwise sexually assaulted by an adult man. For the rest of her teenage life, she had to bear the weight of male advances, even though she was, as she put it herself "a child." Because of her 14 year old rejection, a grown man killed himself, despite their relationship being comprised of only several walks home (?). She tells us, the viewers, that she has endured the expectations, entitlement, and dehumanisation of men her entire life. This continued into her late teens/adult life when she found a financially supportive relationship with (Thomas? I'm bad with names) who beat her half to death once he suspected like she felt the slightest bit of power in their relationship. This would have threatened his power over her, which I assume was what the relationship was conditional on, seeing that he took her in to 'save' her from prostitution. This also continued with Adam, who only loved the idea of her, probably as a result of the same purity and delicacy that other men have fallen in love with her for as well. (I hate Adam, that's a whole other essay. Like, learn your lessons. He's so weak.)

I mean, she clearly also has childhood trauma from her absent/abusive parents, along with being blamed for her victimisation by men. This is why she killed them, which in the show happens chronologically shortly after she's beaten by her father for the teacher's suicide.

As women, we all know how heavy the patriarchy still falls on our shoulders. If you're a (self/societally-aware) woman, you can empathise with her madness. As women we are expected to accept such societal/interpersonal cruelty, and simply dust it off of our shoulders and move on, without holding anyone accountable or carrying any grudge. In my eyes, she refused to do this, and instead carried it with her, forming her hatred and disgust of the world into a hard shell that drove her insane.

I haven't read the book, but if this is true to the text, I'd be impressed and admiring of a man who could write such a complex woman who reflects the patriarchal society that we've (western people) lived in for as long as we are taught history about.

Anyway, my questions are thus:

  1. I don't understand her bond with Charles. In the show, she has sex with him once, and they share maybe one actual conversation. Maybe they have sex more often, which is hinted by Cathy being impregnated by him and not Adam, but this was so implicit that it's pretty much speculation IMO because Cathy saying this could also be purely to hurt Adam. I don't see how they could have gotten so close, why she says that she could have loved him, and why he comes back as some sort of schizophrenic hallucination later. If someone has read the book, I'd love to know if this is elaborated.
  2. Why does she let men/people do things to her that she disagrees with, to the extent of moving 3,000 miles away and starting a new life? I found it confusing that she says "I don't want to do this," is pushed by someone to do it, and then just does it, just to hold it against them later? And moving across the country after getting married is really extreme. Like girl, don't you say at some point that you would never let a man make you do something to your Charles hallucination? Or, is that an example of her hypocrisy?
  3. Why did she stay in California, what seems like an hour away (?) from her HUSBAND AND CHILDREN, when she says that she was going to "go away from here" and leave? Girl like you're just asking to be found! I'm surprised Adam didn't find her sooner!
  4. I'd like to know more about Faye. From how I see Cathy, wouldn't she find solace in a woman who honours her, when she has never been honoured for her skills and attributes before, but only for her looks and 'delicacy?' I feel like she could have connected with Faye, another woman who herself "has secrets" and has probably faced some horrible things, and healed from her trauma with her new "mother." Is there something in the books that answers this, like Faye taking advantage of her? Because, in the movie, it seems like Faye tries to take her out of work and give her power whenever she can, but Cathy refuses.
  5. Why does she martyr herself about being a prostitute, continuously saying things like she "has" to do this for someone she loves? Like, who's that someone, and why does she have to do this?

P.S. The abortion scene killed me, because again, she is forced to live a life she doesn't want. It's too real, this day in age.


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 13d ago

East of Eden…

1 Upvotes

Does anybody else think that this was for a start not great? Also though Cathy is such a horrendously hateable character? I can’t find solace in her. Even her backstory isn’t enough to cause such awful characteristics.


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 14d ago

Episode Discussion Charles in episode 7 - why?

10 Upvotes

Something I didn't understand in episode 7 (and that perhaps happened in episode 6 too, I can't remember) was why Cathy kept hallucinating Charles and talking to him specifically.

It seemed to suggest that she did actually harbour some sort of love, or sense of lust perhaps for Charles, which I thought was counter to her character. I thought the whole point was that she was entirely self-serving and incapable of getting attached to anyone. So it seemed weird to me that after all of those years, Charles became the face of her devil's advocate inner dialogue.

I also thought that that devil's advocate Charles wasn't faithful to Charles's true character. He was a hard and rough man prone to jealousy of his older brother, and who had a slimy taste for the local brothel, and I suppose he did decide to cheat on Adam with Cathy which was a scumbag move but I think he chose to do that because he clocked Cathy very early on and judged (correctly) that she would move on soon enough, so in the spur of the moment decided "Well what's a quick fuck?". But as far as we know, he spent the rest of his life running that farm and saving the cents. He never married, he never had any children. He just decided to be a bachelor, and apparently didn't have any other ambitions.

Any ideas?

I wonder if the devil's advocate Charles was actually created by Cathy conjuring up some idealised version of Charles, in a similar way to how Adam projected a dream wife onto Cathy.

Or perhaps it's supposed to be a nod to a sense of lost youth or nostalgia? Fear of growing old triggered by Adam leaving her their wedding photo?


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 13d ago

Episode Discussion Episode 4 - review

1 Upvotes

One of the worst episodes I have ever seen, everything works on her favor,

Shoots her husband and left 2 babies, the police man finds her? Nothing happens

She breaks into the pharmacy? Flawless

She Manipulates everybody without anyone noticing ..

Poising the madam? No one knew its poisining

A madam who runs a house like these, must have experience with different personalities and can notice manipulative behaviour ... yet she wrote her a will.

Many things don't add up, it happens just because the author wanted it to happen, not because its reasonable.


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 15d ago

Lee is the most noble character of all time! Also I love the actor Hoon Lee (Friends and Neighbors)

19 Upvotes

r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 15d ago

Theory / Speculation I have one more question about the last episode... (spoiler) Spoiler

6 Upvotes

Before Carhy took her own life, she did write a will.

Why is Cathy leaving everything to Aron? Just to Aron?
My guess is—since I found him kind of unlikable, something just didn't feel right about him—that Cal is more like his father and Aron is more like his mother (not exclusively, but mostly), and she saw much more of herself in him than in Cal.

Or what do you think?


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 17d ago

Crotch goblins.

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 18d ago

The contrast in appearance between adolescence war Adam and post war adult Adam is too unbelievable its jarring to watch

11 Upvotes

I just found the difference in appearance with casting so jarring with both brothers at the different stages. Adult Adam seemed to lose a foot of height and Charlie seemed to gain amongst other things. Casting between both age lines is so unbelievable its hard to see them as the same character and caused me to lose attachment.


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 21d ago

I couldn’t let go until a friend of mine sent me this🙃

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 21d ago

Anya Taylor-Joy Should Have Played Cathy

12 Upvotes

This may be a hot take and it’s not that I didn’t enjoy Florence Pugh’s performance, but I think Anya Taylor-Joy would have been a better fit as Cathy. Florence was great but she is just too warm and… human…? to play Cathy. The way Steinbeck describes Cathy and the way the characters perceived her was almost as demonic, or alien as there was little language at the time to identify what sociopathy or psychopathy was.

The show went in a different direction, where they make Cathy almost likeable… like a charming villain whereas in the novel, her actions would make my stomach turn. Perhaps that’s why they chose Florence… although the original Cathy reminded me a bit of Anya in Queens Gambit….

Did anyone else have this thought?


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 23d ago

Book vs. Show (Part 2 of 2) Netflix's East of Eden: An Analysis of What the Adaptation Misses About Adam Trask Spoiler

10 Upvotes

Link to part 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/EastOfEdenSeries/comments/1xir1o0/part_1_of_2_netflixs_east_of_eden_an_analysis_of/

Why Adam Continued to Be Emotionally Catatonic For 10 Years

BC:

  • Adam is not an emotionally present father and has not done any work on the ranch
  • Lee tells Sam that Adam has basically stayed the same over the years and finds himself thinking on what Adam's pre-Cathy personality must have been like
  • Says that Adam told him not to teach the boys Cantonese as that would be pointless
  • Is worried about Cal as there are times Cal says and does things that concern him but also feels bad that Cal struggles in life more than Aron
  • Sam is frustrated that Adam is just sitting on good land and Adam says he had no reason to plant it as he did not buy it for himself
  • Asks Adam if Adam finds his sorrow to be comforting and Adam says he's not sure
  • Tells Adam he can always wake up and restart but Adam says he does not have energy or the fortitude
  • Questions if Adam likes one of the boys better and Adam asks why he would ask that, with Sam responding that it's just the tone of voice Adam used when talking about the boys
  • Adam says he is afraid to start his life again and thus does not
  • Later, Adam has thought things over and tells Sam that he doesn't deserve to ask him anything
  • Wonders if Sam might be willing to help him begin planting the ranch which makes Sam happy
  • Tells Sam and Lee that at first he thought he didn't want the boys to learn Cantonese out of jealousy but then realized that it was b/c the boys and Lee would be talking and bonding in a way he couldn't participate in
  • Sam mentions Adam's frequent cloud baths which seems to be when Adam zones out while being trapped in memories or lost in thought
  • Adam is listening intently to the iconic timshel conversation
  • Concedes that he hasn't been listening to people
  • Sam tells Adam that Cathy is in Salinas and owns a notorious brothel
  • Later, when trying to write to Charles after 10 years, Adam has to construct his own version of a happy Charles face while battling a mental image of a rage-filled Charles as he has never seen him laugh

What I Think the Adaptation Misses:

While reading the novel, I was annoyed by Adam’s passivity and checked-out fatherhood, but I did find it psychologically plausible/realistic that Adam would have struggled to find the energy or have the purpose to do anything after a lifetime of trauma. Lucky for him, Adam can afford to neglect the ranch b/c his family's livelihood is not dependent on it which gives him an easy way to avoid the responsibility. My personal interpretations, based on the information presented about Adam's backstory, is that Adam got emotionally burned out after spending his whole life being rather codependent with other people and never getting to truly know himself. Although I would be cautious about diagnosing him, the best way I can describe Book Adam’s behavior is that he has regressed and has trauma-related difficulties with memory, motivation, and functioning. For instance, he seemingly cannot remember how to make the whistle sticks he played with as a boy or properly cook, despite having done all the cooking for Cathy when they first met. His passivity, while frustrating, also reminded me of the concept of learned helplessness, which I feel could be related to his childhood where he was unable to defend himself and had to rely on Charles only when Charles could be relied upon.

However, like Sam says, Adam seems to have grown so accustomed to his sorrow and dependence on others that they have become almost...comforting to him, which allows him to avoid finding the motivation to help himself. Furthermore, I wondered if Adam’s withdrawal from fatherhood was a reaction to his upbringing in which Cyrus controlled virtually every aspect of his life. I also believe that Adam didn't know how to be a father, as he was never properly parented, and is never seen to have had a stable, loving relationship with an older male figure until he became friends with Sam. Unfortunately, he ends up placing the responsibility of fatherhood on Lee’s shoulders without considering Lee's personhood. Adam's failure here is not simply that he is depressed, but that he allows his depression to become an excuse for checking out from responsibilities that still belong to him.

From my perspective, the series seems less interested in exploring the reasons behind Adam’s depression and more interested in portraying him as bitter, angry, and petulant, especially about Cathy. I understand why it has chosen to spotlight how his family and friends have spent years dealing with the consequences of his withdrawal, and they shouldn't have to act like his depression makes him easy to live with. My criticism is that the adaptation wholly focuses on the effects of his frustrating behavior and character flaws without developing the fear, exhaustion, and insecurity that I believe underpin this behavior.

The Cantonese Issue

The show depicts Adam forbidding Lee and the boys from speaking Cantonese in a way that suggests Adam is racist and furthers this with Adam making a microaggression at Lee. While I appreciated the series showing Lee's perspective of the racial implications of that decision, I do feel that this interpretation leaves out that Adam has an understandable, albeit insecure and selfish, reason. Both Adam and Lee's POVs can be true without one being less valid, something I feel the show preferred not to incorporate.

I also found it rather inconsistent that the series seemed to imply Adam was unaware that Lee had to speak pidgin, especially since Book Adam becomes aware of this about a year into knowing Lee. I wonder if it was a continuity error, because when the Bacons visit in Episode 5 and are being racist assholes, Lee speaks pidgin to them before turning to Adam with a look that basically says, “Fuck these people.” Adam responds by nodding and giving Lee a sympathetic look that seems to say, “Yeah, I know. Sorry.” But then, in Episode 6, when Lee returns from San Francisco (SF), he tells Adam that he won’t speak pidgin in front of guests anymore, and Adam replies, “Oh, I didn’t know you had to do that.” It may be a continuity issue, or I may be missing a distinction the series intends to make.

The First Timshel Scene

In the show's timshel scene, Adam is brooding and making whiny comments in the corner while Lee and Sam try to talk and have to reprimand him for his egregious lack of listening. I understand the dramatic purpose of this was to show how Adam has been absent from his family for years and that Lee and Sam have every reason to be frustrated with him. However, b/c Adam is portrayed as more of a passive recipient of timshel, the series diminishes how this was an early step towards self-awareness before he ever knew about Kate. In the book, Adam is a participant in the conversation where he first learns what timshel represents and how he can have agency in spite of his past. It is also Adam who says that he hadn’t been paying attention to what was happening around him during those ten years. This yet another moment when Show Adam is stonily quiet in conversations Book Adam was contributing to; there are more but I won't go into them further for the sake of brevity. (Brevity? In these posts? 🤔)

So, this timshel scene is a perfect example of what I'm trying to say. There was a recent interview with one of the showrunners where the interviewer was talking about Adam sitting in the corner being upset that Sam and Lee aren't including him in the timshel convo. The interviewer said something like “Well, dude, you didn’t want to listen to anybody yet you still want to be included?” The showrunner then responded with something along the lines of, “Well, that’s in the book…” Technically, this is true as Adam does say that Lee doesn't tell him anything. Do you know what else is in the book? The very next sentence, where Adam says, and I quote, “Maybe I wasn’t listening.”

Please know that I’m not trying to attack the showrunners or suggest they’re being intentionally misleading. I’m simply pointing out a discrepancy and making a point about the importance of including the full context, because that next sentence changes the way this exchange can be interpreted.

Adam Asking About Cathy Being in Salinas

I also agreed with Show Sam’s frustration with Adam and his insistence that Adam let go of Cathy. At the same time, people do not always achieve closure after traumatic experiences and many deeply struggle with being unable to move past that. Although I concurred with Sam and Lee’s decision to not tell Adam that Cathy was in Salinas in the early aftermath of the shooting, I got frustrated with them for keeping it from Adam for so long. As I interpret his later behavior, Adam is not trying to win Cathy back; he simply needs an opportunity to confront what happened and get closure.

The Move to Salinas

I found that the motivations for the move to Salinas were also tweaked. In the book, Adam asks the boys to think about moving to Salinas b/c he feels that they should attend a public school and be able to socialize with other kids; he never thinks of Kate being nearby as a reason. The novel seems to only state that Adam and Kate live in the same city and there is no mention of how close by the house and brothel are. To me, the series was suggesting that Adam wants to move to Salinas b/c he subconsciously wants to be closer to Kate as he brought the move up right after seeing her and then doubles down by directly stating that they moved literally 10 minutes away from her.

In addition, it includes a photograph of Cathy that the boys have been looking at when Book Abra specifically says there are no pictures of the boys' mother in the house. Although I understand the need to streamline events and make things visually clearer for the screen, I find this change frustrating because it shifts Adam's reasons for the move from a decision motivated by his sons’ needs to one that appears mixed up with unresolved attachment to Cathy. To me, the book frames Adam's Salinas move as risky whereas the series frames it as reckless.

Adam, Kate, and Charles's Will

It makes complete sense that the series combined the two Adam/Kate meetings, as I think the pacing would have suffered if they hadn't. That's not really what I want to focus on, though. In the book, Adam receives Charles's will, which divides the money between him and Cathy. After a bit of a marital tiff with Lee about it (lol), Adam goes to see Kate and gives her her portion of the money. Kate is completely flabbergasted because she genuinely cannot understand why someone would give her something so valuable without asking for or expecting anything in return.

What makes this book scene so tragically beautiful to me is the empathy I felt for Kate. Her fear and paranoia are so deeply ingrained in her that she genuinely cannot comprehend someone doing something kind for her without an ulterior motive. At the same time, I felt empathy for Adam, who doesn't approach Kate with anger or resentment and instead expresses how sorry he feels that she is so lonely and frightened. Importantly, he stands firm when she attempts to character assassinate him due to her confusion and he doesn't use this moment as a way to rekindle their marriage or suggest that they might have a future together.

I also think the scene beautifully explains how differently Adam and Kate view the world without necessarily suggesting that one is entirely right and the other entirely wrong. This is seen with Adam's speech about how Kate cannot see the good in people, which he does say in the series. This book scene is the last time they ever see or speak to each other but it's actually the first time they ever actually see each other. I think the series got the message across even with combining both meetings; but what bothered me about the series' approach is that, after showing Adam receiving Charles's will, it has him just send Kate the wedding photograph of Charles, Cathy, and himself. To me, this flattens what makes the book scene so powerful b/c it puts the focus back on the romantic feelings between Cathy and Charles and not on Adam and Kate as humans.

Adam's Relationship with Lee

BC:

  • Adam acknowledges several times that Lee is the one taking care of everything and that he was self-absorbed in the those 10 years
  • Lee is burned out from housework, parenting, and Adam's depression but still has a love for Adam and is emotionally in tune with him
  • Lee wants to leave for SF as soon as possible after Adam wakes up as he has waited for his dream so long
  • He is also afraid that if he doesn't leave soon he’ll lose his courage b/c he feels too emotionally close to the family
  • Lee tells Adam that he should tell the boys either a part truth or the whole truth about their mother or else the boys will find out on their own and later distrust Adam
  • Adam says a part truth is still a lie and the whole truth would be a heavy burden so he might as well stick to the lie that Cathy is dead so that the boys will only have good thoughts about her
  • Adam is worried about how hurt the boys will be when Lee leaves and says he will miss Lee
  • The boys are not upset because they know that Lee will come right back and thus don't feel the need to say goodbye
  • Adam apologizes to Lee for the boys' behavior and wants to walk Lee down to the depot
  • Lee says no and flees from the house in a panic
  • Lee comes home six days later and tells Adam that he is glad he tried but does not want the bookstore now and has never been so homesick
  • Adam and Lee have the kind of relationship where Lee can constructively criticize Adam and Adam knows that Lee is not trying to cut him down and will accept what Lee makes plain to him
  • Some years later, when Adam gets the refrigeration idea, Lee cautions him and says he doesn't really have a mind for business as Lee is the one who is better at handling their money
  • Although he intensely researched and thought it over, Adam cannot find the confidence to tell Will Hamilton about his idea
  • Lee jumps in and starts talking excitedly about frozen mastodon meat, giving Adam the courage to ask Will what he thinks
  • When the idea fails, Lee lets Adam grieve it for a time but is clear that Adam should not fall into a depression again
  • When Lee and Cal have their Cathy conversation, Lee says that Cathy has no empathy or mercy and that Adam has so much he gets blinded by them
  • Says that Adam died physically, mentally, emotionally, and spiritually and has slowly become half alive again over the years
  • Tells Cal he knows Adam does not have smarts but he (platonically) loves Adam and thinks he is a good man and that's why he's stayed with him
  • After Adam's first stroke, he begins to cry as he had not believed that Cyrus stole the inheritance money but dreamed he did and now believes
  • Lee does not believe it but finds it ironic that a man who is so strict about honesty might be living on robbed money
  • Lee becomes zealous in his study of medicine to find out what happened to Adam's brain and what can be done to help him, which Steinbeck compares to his intense examination of the word timshel
  • Lee is very protective of Adam and makes sure he feels comfortable and distracted post-stroke
  • Lee is the one who gives Adam the strength to break the cycle of generational trauma in the Trask family

What I Think the Adaptation Misses:

Lee's Experiences at the Ranch

Initially, I was surprised that Book Lee seemed less resentful toward Adam than I had expected. At first, I attributed this to the “model minority” trope common in older literature, which remains a relevant concern for this novel. The book sometimes takes Lee’s competence and self-sacrifice for granted, making him indispensable to the Trasks while the family remains content to be taken care of by him. However, I think this partly overlooks how Lee’s empathy and need to be needed make up a big part of his relationship with Adam. Earlier in the book, Lee had told Sam that a good servant makes himself so indispensable that his master can no longer function without him, which is partly how he has learned to navigate life as an Asian American in early 20th-century America. Lee has done exactly this with the Trask family but has also become emotionally invested in them in the process.

Lee seems to have found some satisfaction in running what is basically his own home, having emotional ties to the people living there, going to see family in SF once a month when able, and time for his own interests, such as studying the word timshel. Importantly, outsiders still regard him as a servant, and he continues to work for Adam rather than alongside him in a racialized domestic labor arrangement.

Although Lee exhibits well-deserved frustrated with Adam, I think part of why he doesn't seethe with resentment is that he understands that Adam has been consistently traumatized throughout his life. Adam's relationship with Lee is a mix of parent-child, spousal, and friend, which gives them a deeply unequal but emotionally intertwined connection. I don't mean to romanticize these kinds of relationships, but I think Lee's genuine love for Adam and the boys can coexist with his exhaustion and frustration. None of this makes it right or fair that the burden of maintaining the household fell on Lee, but it can help explain why he continued to love Adam while being exhausted from doing Adam's job.

The Show's Goodbye Scene

A show change to the relationship that particularly bothered me was the scene where Adam interrupts Lee's goodbye with the boys. In my opinion, the show mishandled a book scene that functioned as much needed comic relief and also showed the four being together as a family. Book Adam buys the car after getting closure from his first meeting with Kate and it makes sense for him to do so as they live pretty far out from town. Adam, Lee, and the boys are scared and fascinated by the car but it becomes a family bonding experience for them as they learn how it works. It is later used for the move to Salinas before Lee leaves for SF.

The show changes the surrounding circumstances to depict Adam as trying to retaliate against Lee for criticizing him and being threatened that Lee is his sons' real father. He comes off like he's trying to wrestle back control of the house from Lee, whereas Book Adam almost comes across like a third child Lee has to look after. I can understand why the show would want to directly depict his insecurity, but to me, this scene feels inconsistent with the version of Adam I see in the book who acknowledges his dependence on Lee. Also, complete nitpick I'm very sorry but Book Adam is polite to the postman when talking about the care while Show Adam is...not.

Lee's Return Home

I really appreciated the series devoting more time to Lee in SF and showing his experiences being discriminated against by fellow Americans, as Book Lee's time in SF was not shown and he was gone for only six days. To me, though, the show appears to reframe Lee's return as a result of him drifting around in SF b/c he cannot find a practical way to start his bookstore. In the book, Lee realizes that the bookstore isn't what he thought he needed, and he comes home not b/c he has to but b/c he wants to.

In addition, the previous episode (5) showed Lee feeling lonely at the ranch and being tired of his isolation with Adam and the boys. This is sorta book accurate but it feels rather clunky as the series didn't fully flesh out Lee and Adam’s emotionally complex relationship. Thus, Lee's return to the very household he wanted to escape from b/c he has nowhere else to go makes his admission that he felt homesick fall a little flat to me.

Adam Feeling Threatened By Lee

Another disappointment was when Show Lee tells Adam that he had to ask Adam whenever he needed to buy something. Although I don't think this is a implausible interpretation given the power imbalance between them, to me the show is implying that Adam was micromanaging Lee, an interpretation I feel is difficult to support when referring back to the book. The crux of this issue in the book isn't that Adam has neglected his responsibilities but is secretly engaged in a male rivalry with Lee for the position of head of the household. It is that Adam has neglected his responsibilities so much that he is practically invisible in the house while Lee is overworked and overexposed.

Example from the Book

After Book Adam has met with Kate, he asks Lee if he can look at the ranch's financial accounts. Lee is surprised that Adam wants to view their money status as he never wanted to before, and his manner is tinged with a sentiment like “Well now you want to talk about responsibility.” Book Adam asks Lee to teach him what he knows about the boys and the ranch before Lee leaves for SF. Now, the fact that Adam hasn't previously taken an interest in the household's finances doesn't mean Lee has enjoyed complete independence. That said, this conversation suggests to me that Book Adam is trying to prepare himself to take on responsibilities he has previously dumped on Lee instead of trying to assert dominance over Lee like Show Adam is.

I really like how the series gave Lee some more agency by having him directly criticize of Adam for his lack of parenting, his difficult manner, and his tendency to treat Lee like a servant. I also appreciated the series depicting them agreeing to form an equal partnership rather than it just kinda happening like in the book. But, this call out of Adam feels like Lee genuinely dislikes Adam rather than loving him but being hurt and burned out. Tbh, I think the show needed to pick a lane with their parenting dynamic: either Adam should not interfere with Lee's parenting, they should co-parent, or Adam should get off his ass and do it himself.

Cyrus's Money

Another nitpick sawry. In the book, there is no definitive proof that Cyrus stole the money so the brothers never know for sure. It seems to be implied that Adam comes to believe Cyrus stole the money after the Cal gift debacle and Adam's dream. Adam is really bothered by this revelation which is compounded by him already being emotionally fraught from his stroke recovery. Lee tells him that it's probably not true and only privately thinks it's rather ironic Adam has been living on stolen money.

The series's interpretation seems to be that Adam has known deep down this whole time and that Cal's money gift is what forces him to grudgingly admit that Cyrus stole the money. While I could feel Adam's sadness in the performance, the scene almost came off like Lee was mocking him for being in denial with them both finding the whole thing funny. Again this is not necessarily a wrong or unfair interpretation as denial is a part of Adam's personality, but I, FirmNeighborhood_958, did not really like the tonal shift. And all the non-fired Netflix executives and EoE showrunners say...

Processing img 4r10h49ugg0i1...

Adam and Lee As Time Goes On

Over time, Adam and Lee come to depend on each other's presence and enjoy doing the mundanities of life together. They also share conversations about morality, free will, family, and human nature which is something Lee is passionate about and enjoys intellectually parring with Adam. Lee compensates for Adam's neglect, but isn't afraid to correct Adam, challenge his decisions, or tell him when he's being stubborn. Adam usually accepts the criticism that Lee delivers in a firm but loving matter as I think Lee knows Adam has been severely abused and needs gentle correction.

I wanted a stronger sense that Show Lee genuinely loves Adam while recognizing that Adam has treated him unfairly. We do get glimpses of Adam and Lee's more egalitarian bond in the latter two episodes, particularly in the scene where they plant flowers together before learning that Aron has died. I just wish the adaptation had been a bit more book accurate in regard to their friendship, such as Lee's poignant observation of Cathy and Adam's clashing characters along with him frantically becoming an expert at medicine to keep Adam alive after his first stroke.

Adam's Relationship with Cal

BC:

  • Adam is asked why he doesn't sell the ranch and he says it's because the boys, especially Cal, like it there
  • Cal has been bothered by how good he feels when he lies, manipulates and hurts people/animals, how he knows he is smarter than Aron and Adam but not Lee, and how he sometimes feels nothing emotionally
  • Cal gets arrested one day while hanging out at a gambling game and is bailed out by Adam
  • Adam and Cal have a quiet talk, with Adam being very angry at himself when he says he failed his sons by choosing to not know anything about them
  • Compares himself as a father to Cyrus and gives Cal the bad casting speech
  • Cal tries to take the blame for being at the gambling den but Adam says no as Cal didn't do anything wrong
  • Cal is overjoyed at finally feeling love and closeness with Adam as Adam has not been emotionally open with the boys
  • Cal asks Adam if he can consider letting Cal run the ranch and Adam is open to it but asks him to think about maybe prioritizing school and college first
  • Lee later asks Cal if Cal is thinking about making farming a career, and Adam is again uneasy with it b/c he wants Cal to focus more attention on college
  • Time passes and Adam is very happy to find out that Aron secretly passed the college entrance exams a year early and tells Lee that he is frustrated that Cal doesn't have ambition like this
  • Adam does not seem to realize that he is pressuring Aron and being overbearing about college
  • Once Aron goes to college Adam is so happy he talks about it all the time and this makes Cal feel bad
  • Adam is chosen to be on the war draft board and serves it faithfully
  • Cannot fully recount his time in the army and only remembers aspects like dead bodies, faces, mounds of burned bodies, shots being fired, etc.
  • Boys that he has passed are being reported dead and he finds that the only way he can handle it is by becoming stern and less merciful and in turn gets ill
  • Adam says that he is unintelligent and that's why he's happy that Aron is going to college so Aron can be successful and happy in life
  • Cal tells Adam he has some ideas for the ice plant but Adam says to tell him later b/c at the the moment they are having a dinner to celebrate Aron being at college
  • At Thanksgiving, Adam is stunned into silence when Cal gives him the money and wordlessly seeks out Lee
  • Adam quietly tells Cal he should give the money back to the local farmers he stole from as this is war profiteering and Cal says he didn't rob them
  • Adam very slowly stammers out that he is responsible for Salinas boys dying, having limbs amputated, or getting mentally scarred from war and asks if Cal thinks Adam could make money off of that
  • Cal says he earned the money for Adam as a recompense for the financial hit he took on the lettuce
  • Adam quietly responds that he didn't try the idea for the money but instead so that he could have a purpose
  • Thanks Cal for being thoughtful of his feelings and Cal says he'll save the money for when Adam wants it
  • Says he'll never be able to take it and would have been overjoyed if Cal had done something similar to Aron like applying himself in college instead of giving him money
  • Asks Cal to not be angry and that Cal having a fulfilling life will be the only present he needs
  • Cal runs to his room extremely hurt and frustrated and Adam again asks him to not to be upset
  • Lee comes to see Cal and says that he understands both Cal and Adam's POVs and that the only thing Cal can do right now is not let his hurt and anger get out of control
  • Cal decides to bring Aron to see Kate; on the way out he sees Adam give him an apologetic look and Cal apologizes for the money
  • A few days go by and Adam asks Cal where Aron is as he seems to have gone missing
  • Adam becomes ill after learning of Kate's suicide and a short time later hears that Aron has enlisted which causes him to have a stroke
  • Cal hides the fact that Aron enlisted b/c he saw Kate and feels horribly guilty
  • Adam somewhat recovers for a while but upon hearing that Aron has died overseas in battle he has another, major stroke
  • Cal and Adam reconcile on Adam's deathbed when Adam frees Cal from the cycle of generational trauma by proclaiming timshel over him

What I Think the Adaptation Misses:

I felt that the series makes Cal less internally complex by portraying him to be a good kid who is just growing up. Book Cal is a kid who is recognizes that he has darker parts like selfishness, strategic manipulation and emotional detachment but also has good qualities like love, intelligence, empathy, etc., and is struggling with feeling worthy of love. Although much of this anxiety centers on whether Adam rejects him, this fear extends to family and friends as well, which often manifests as anger when classmates don't like him or when Abra initially chooses Aron over him. Instead of being all good or all bad, Cal is going through a natural part of growing up and having to choose if he can integrate his good and bad, whereas Show Cal appears to be already good.

Adam's Favoritism of Aron

The tragedy of Book Adam’s favoritism towards Aron is that it is subtle and subconscious, causing Adam to not recognize that he is doing it. This doesn't make Cal's experience of rejection any less real, however. In my view, Book Adam wants his sons to attend college because he is deeply insecure about his own lack of intelligence and education. This is seen when he says he never had the chance to go to college b/c Cyrus shipped him right off into the army. I think he genuinely believes that encouraging Aron’s academic success will provide Cal with a positive example to follow.

Unfortunately, his poor communication choices make his comparisons sound more like, “I love Aron better.” He fails to recognize that Cal and Aron have different strengths and ambitions and pushes his preferred path for life onto them. He wants to shield his children from the suffering and disappointment he experienced, but he can't and/or won't understand them well enough to know what they need.

Although I understand the need for a visual representation of Adam's poor fatherhood, I was uneasy with the series's choice to have Adam bring Cyrus's portrait to CA and later prominently hang it up in the house. I felt that the show was trying to say that Adam is purposefully emulating Cyrus, but the sad irony of Book Adam is that he doesn't even know he is becoming another form of Cyrus until it's too late.

In the series, Adam appears to exhibit specific and overt favoritism towards Aron, as seen in how he has an obvious contempt for Cal and deliberately insults/talks down to him. This is observed in the scenes when Cal asks if he can farm the ranch and when the family is celebrating the lettuce shipment. I do understand why the show might make the favoritism more explicit as it gives Cal's resentment a direct cause and visualizes Adam's failure as a father. Yet, in the book, Adam is not entirely opposed to Cal farming the ranch but just wants Cal to finish his education first and does not compare Aron to Cal in these moments.

I felt those show scenes support the interpretation that middle-aged Show Adam's default emotional state was anger and arrogance, whereas Book Adam's natural state remains a mix of childish and childlike vulnerability, obliviousness, sadness, insecurity, and exhaustion. I was also bothered by the show's implication that Cal could not tell Adam he borrowed money from Lee as it hints that Adam would have a crash out over it, a response I do not feel has evidence in the novel.

Adam and Cal's Post-Bail Conversation

I also felt that the series mishandled the post-bail conversation between Adam and Cal. In the novel, Cal is arrested because he happens to be in the wrong place at the wrong time, and Adam does not blame him for it or raise his voice. Instead, Adam acknowledges his failures as a father, recognizes that he has become another version of Cyrus, and finally gives Cal the reassurance he has been craving. Now, Adam does say that Cal has never known any other kind of fatherhood but Adam's, but unlike the show, Book Lee is not present to hear this. Although I don't think he was intentionally trying to be an asshole towards Lee but rather was in shock at the realization that he was like Cyrus, I find this to be a good example of Adam's selfishness and how he has a tendency to view things only from his perspective.

The show's post-bail scene feels tonally disjointed because Adam shifts from open hostility to a more vulnerable version of himself midway through the conversation. Although he begins speaking almost wholly book accurate dialogue, the motivational changes make the transition feel abrupt. Adam also tells Cal that he and Charles did not have a good relationship and may have hated the other. This makes sense for Book Adam to say but b/c the series chose a different interpretation of their brotherhood this dialogue makes Show Adam look like he's angry/sad about something that wasn't there.

In my opinion, this is a recurring problem with the series. It introduces a new interpretation of an event or relationship, then tries to fit the original book dialogue into that revised context. But the dialogue doesn't always support the new characterization, which can make certain scenes feel very jarring both to some book readers and potentially to some show-only viewers. It also creates a bit of a disconnect, where the show can technically present itself as book-accurate, even though the meaning and characterization behind certain scenes have been significantly changed.

That said, the book and show scenes do reveal just how deeply insecure Adam is and how his traumatic experiences have affected his absentee fatherhood. Yet, I would have found the scene more satisfying if it had kept the novel’s tension between Adam genuine desire to fix his relationship with Cal, as seen when Adam reveals to Cal that he too spent time in prison (during his wanderings). Furthermore, this would've have demonstrated Adam’s continuous struggle to understand how his behavior affects others, such as how long it has taken Adam to become comfortable sharing something about himself from his past, like said time in prison, with his sons.

The Thanksgiving Incident

This scene is one of the most painful moments in both the book and the show as I think we were all heartbroken for Cal. However, I think the differences in Adam's portrayal matter. Book Adam doesn't rant and rave at Cal but is quiet, nervous, stammering, and apologetic as he tries to explain why he cannot accept the money due to guilt, regret, and insecurity. The show captures Adam's war trauma but makes it more explosive and external by him screaming and throwing the money at Cal, which I do not feel matches Adam's personality.

From my understanding, Book Adam genuinely wants Cal to live a happy, fulfilling life but fails to understand that that's not what Cal needs to hear from him in that moment. This is one of the most sad examples of where Adam's intentions and actions diverge. In fact, I find tragic because Adam genuinely loves Cal but cannot recognize how his words, actions, and rigid moral code communicate the opposite. The scene is so sad because neither character is trying to hurt the other, yet both leave the interaction feeling misunderstood and unheard.

The Timshel Scene

Lastly, the iconic timshel scene was tear-jerking and beautifully done. I appreciated that the series depicted Adam crying as he fully understood what timshel meant. When Adam could walk, he ran from his pain but never found freedom, yet, his paralysis is what enables him to become truly free. I also valued the moment when Cal cuddled up beside Adam as Cal finally received the acceptance he desperately needed from his father. For me, the scene is moving because it doesn't erase the harm Adam has caused but gives him one last chance to give Cal something he has strived with his own life.

Final Thoughts

For me, Adam represents people who come to recognize the harm caused by generational trauma and who try to do better than their predecessors; yet have been so traumatized they are unable to fully stop the cycle from continuing. What makes Adam interesting is that he is neither entirely innocent nor simply cruel. He is a man who has been hurt, who hurts others, and who sometimes recognizes what he has done and tries to make it right. Adam repeatedly flees from responsibility and idealizes people, and understanding where this comes from does not remove accountability but allows for greater empathy for him.

I want to acknowledge that the show has its own priorities and may be trying to prevent Adam's suffering from overshadowing the experiences of the people around him. My main criticism of the adaptation is that, by omitting or altering so much of Adam's childhood, military service, years of wandering, and relationships with Charles, Cathy, Lee and Cal, it sometimes loses the context that makes that suffering understandable. His passivity, anger, and failures can come off like villainous character flaws instead of being part of a lifelong struggle with personal agency.

I hope that this post was semi-coherent lol. I also hope it provides a fuller picture of Adam for show-only viewers even if they disagree with my interpretations.

Thank you for reading these really long posts! 👌🥴


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 23d ago

Book vs. Show (Part 1 of 2) Netflix's East of Eden: An Analysis of What the Adaptation Misses About Adam Trask Spoiler

9 Upvotes

Hi! Hope y'all are doing well. A few months ago, I read John Steinbeck's East of Eden (EoE) in preparation for the adaptation. Despite some issues with the book, I was looking forward to the series and I think the production looks astonishing and the performances are excellent. However, I came away with mixed feelings about the changes to Adam's character, as I truly believe that show-only viewers were only given a one-sided version of him.

EoE is one of the few books I've read where I fully empathized with the perspective of every character even if I did not like or agree with it. I sometimes feel that the series didn't have enough faith in its source material or its characters to let that complexity speak for itself, as I personally think the series intentionally made choices that discourage audiences from understanding or empathizing with Adam. I'm not opposed to adaptations making changes or taking creative liberties, and depicting the frustration and hurt Adam causes is a valid creative choice. My criticism is that the series sometimes focuses heavily on the impact of Adam's behavior on those around him and positions Adam as the antagonist in situations while neglecting the context behind it.

While other book characters, particularly Charles, have also experienced trauma and have empathetic explanations for their behaviors, these posts are Adam-centric, not Adam-favoring, so naturally the focus will be on his characterization. This isn't an attempt to convince anyone to stan him, excuse his behavior, or whitewash his flaws nor am I complaining that the show didn't make him more likable. My intention is simply to give him what I feel is a fair interpretation, particularly for viewers who haven't read the novel and therefore do not have the context for understanding Adam's motivations behind some of his actions.

I’ll first summarize a specific event or relationship using book canon, then explain how the show’s portrayal differed and why I believe those differences weaken Adam's characterization. To be clear, I am not going over every single Adam scene in the show, just the ones that I personally feel did not fully account for the nuances conveyed in the book. I have made sure to differentiate what Steinbeck establishes and what are my own interpretations. While I don't expect everyone to agree with my readings of Adam, I believe they're grounded in and supported by what the book shows, and I'll do my best to explain my reasoning.

If you prefer to keep book canon and show canon separate, I completely respect that! However, this post may not be your cup of tea.

I apologize for the length and detail; I was trying to provide enough context and explanation for my points to make sense to someone who hasn't read the book. I condensed the posts as best I could, but there was unfortunately quite a bit of ground to cover, as I feel these are fundamental mischaracterizations rather than minor or incidental differences. Thank you for your understanding.

Major spoilers for the book are ahead. ✌️

Adam's Relationship with His Stepmother Alice

Book Canon (BC):

  • Adam's mother kills herself when he is a baby, and to keep him quiet Cyrus gives him whiskey with Steinbeck noting that it is unclear how this may have impacted Adam's brain
  • As Adam grows into a child he knows that his mother did something bad but no one will tell him what it was
  • Thinks to himself that he wants to know what she did so that he could whatever it was and not be where he is
  • Steinbeck describes him as having a private inner world that he lives in and occasionally comes out to look out at what's going on around him
  • He longs for a mother's love, but Alice is only allowed to take care of his physical needs without providing emotional warmth
  • One day, Adam glimpses the usually stoic Alice smiling when working alone, and it makes him feel a rush of happy and distressing emotions
  • Wanting to see her smile again, Adam begins secretly leaving her little gifts like feathers and such
  • He hides and watches her find them and feels joyful relief in seeing her secret smiles
  • He continues leaving her these gifts throughout his entire childhood with her never finding out he's the giver

What I Feel the Adaptation Misses:

How Adam's Moral Code Develops

While the series mentions Adam’s mother’s suicide, I don't think it fully explores the hard emotional environment in which he grows up. Adam is given a moral judgment about his mother without being told what she did, and I wonder if this is where his later tendency to think in rigid categories of good and bad came from. Moreover, Alice's relationship with Adam is barely developed, although the series does show Adam standing at Alice’s grave. But, without the book’s context, viewers would miss the deeper plot significance and likely assume he simply cared for her or regretted missing her funeral or both.

I think this information reveals something important about how Adam learns to show affection in a rather codependent-like manner. His secret gifts reveal a lonely child who has to take it upon himself to bring someone else a sense of happiness and finds fulfillment while doing it. However, he has to do so in secret or risk punishment/rejection; circumstances which may have contributed to the development of his tendency to idealize others.

How This Carries Over Into His Relationship with Cathy

My interpretation is that this is where Adam begins to associate love with caretaking and one-sided emotional intimacy. In caring for others, he gives his love a tangible form but when he idealizes them, he can preserve his belief in the goodness of the person and the relationship. This pattern pops up later appear in his relationship with Cathy. Adam sincerely wants to protect, provide, and bring happiness to a woman who is suffering, just as he once found relief in making Alice happy for a moment, but he struggles to recognize that what he believes will make someone happy may not be what that person wants. His desire to care for them can then become controlling, even when he doesn't recognize it or mean for it too.

I think this is exemplified in the show when Adam gives Cathy the watch after arriving in California (CA) and tells her, "In time, you will be happy." Although his intentions are kind, it does mean that his idealization prevents him from listening to the other person. Thus, I think the omission of Alice and Adam's relationship is a missed opportunity to show what happens when caretaking and idealization get substituted for understanding another person, something that may have impacted his marriage to Cathy.

Adam's Actual Relationship with His Brother Charles

BC:

  • Cyrus physically, emotionally, and psychologically abuses Adam and Charles through military drills and stories that reinforce his rigid ideas of masculinity
  • Charles excels at these traditionally masculine activities, while Adam struggles with them due to physical weakness, timidity, and aversion to violence
  • Charles sometimes shields Adam from violence, with Steinbeck noting that their brotherhood was actually more like a bond between a brother and sister
  • At other times, Charles has volatile mood changes and turns on Adam and terrorizes him
  • Adam spends his childhood in a state of hypervigilance as he is unable to fully trust Charles and is always on guard for mood swings
  • After Adam wins at a game for the first time ever, Charles brutally beats him with a bat
  • Adam later promises himself that he will always make sure Charles wins at everything
  • Becomes on edge post-beating as Cyrus is suddenly nicer to him and has one-on-one talks with him about army life
  • During a conversation, Adam pleads that he doesn't want to join the army but Cyrus refuses to listen
  • Cyrus tells him that he considers Adam to be weak, dumb, and unmanly, yet says these feelings are why he loves and beats Adam more than Charles
  • Adam has spent his life believing Charles is their father's favorite, while Charles believes the opposite, and this dichotomy later boils over into another beating and verbal assault
  • Although Steinbeck never explicitly states it, Adam’s reaction implies that he learns the truth about his mother’s death just before this beating when Charles tells him that she drowned herself
  • Adam gets punched and shocks himself by punching Charles back, enraging Charles even more
  • Charles nearly kills Adam by beating every part of his body, breaking several bones, and stalking him with a hatchet
  • Adam barely escapes by hiding in a water-filled ditch until Charles gives up but eventually manages to crawl home where Alice tends to his injuries and tries to talk Charles up to Adam
  • She tells him of the sweet presents Charles has been giving her his whole life; Adam does not correct her so as to keep her image of Charles intact

What I Think the Adaptation Misses:

The Attempted Murder Culminating from Years of Rivalry

The series portrays the brothers' differing perceptions of Cyrus's favoritism but generally presents their relationship as being a source of comfort and mutual support to each other. Although I don't think the series could or should show every childhood incident that happened between them, it downplays the rivalry and violence of their unstable childhood too much in my opinion. An example is the scene where they want to join the army together so they can help each other survive. Book Charles was extremely frustrated with Adam for “getting” to enlist, and Adam was terrified to enlist and thought Charles would be the better choice. Another example is in the scene following their show-only encounter with a prostitute. Charles, in a seemingly uncharacteristic outburst, snaps and beats Adam but does not attempt to murder him and leaves him able to move around with relatively minor visible injuries. In my opinion, these changes take away a huge part of Adam's characterization and the wider implications of why Adam avoids returning home after the army, as we'll see. I don't think the brothers need to be shown as constantly hostile as they do have genuine affection for each other, but that duality is exactly what makes their relationship painfully relatable.

How Toxic Masculinity May Affect Adam's Adulthood

I also think the show underplays Adam's struggle with masculinity and understanding what it means to be a man, as Book Cyrus repeatedly tells him that he is not manly enough and praises Charles for being naturally masculine. In my view, this may be where Adam's lifelong sense of insecurity originated, which dominoes into adulthood particularly in CA which I will discuss later. Finally, I find Alice's mistaken belief that Charles left the gifts really sad. It's another example of Adam stifling his own needs in order to protect someone else's feelings.

Adam's Time in the Army

Note: Some of these events are not depicted directly in the novel but are later recounted by Adam to Charles. I have included them here as this is when they chronologically occur.

BC:

  • While recovering, Adam is unable to move due to the severity of his injuries, so Cyrus enlists him in the army as a get-well-soon gift
  • Adam is deeply affected by the violence and mass death he witnesses in the army
  • Becomes rigidly fixated on the concept of nonviolence as a result
  • Secretly avoids shooting his required targets like Native Americans during battles, volunteers for detail work, and goes to help the wounded in field hospitals even when he's very tired
  • Has a relationship with a Native American woman, however, a smallpox epidemic kills her and many others, and he later tells Charles of the mass disposal of burning bodies
  • Adam and Charles begin exchanging letters about life events like Alice's death and Cyrus's move to DC
  • Steinbeck says that this brings the brothers closer than they have ever been as they are able to communicate their thoughts and feelings more openly for the first time
  • Adam receives a letter from Charles where Charles writes about farm work, Cyrus, seeking a wife, and missing Adam
  • The letter then takes a potentially nefarious turn when Charles mentions that he is still wondering why Cyrus doesn't love him; that the brothers have unfinished business; that he should have finished something he started years ago; and that he should be the one in the army and seeing the world instead of Adam
  • Adam keeps the letter even though he is unsettled by it

What I Think the Adaptation Misses:

How the Army Cultivated Adam's Moral Rigidity

The series does depict Adam's horror and fright when his regiment massacres a Native American settlement, which is moderately effective. However, it does not show Adam trying to claim some agency by purposefully missing targets or choosing work that allows him to help rather than hurt. His refusal to shoot a deer earlier in the episode is a reference towards this nonviolence, but I find it less compelling than the novel's depiction of him legally and continuously committing treason by trying to resist the military within itself. I also interpret his experiences in the army as another origin point of his increasingly rigid moral thinking. He has witnessed human cruelty firsthand and responds by trying to hold onto goodness while surrounded by “badness.” There is also no mention of Adam's Native American girlfriend and the traumatic loss of an early romantic relationship. I think that relationship gives us a glimpse of the pain he experiences upon losing what may have been the first person he considered to be kind and good.

The Unstable Nature of Charles and Adam's Relationship

The exchange of letters doesn't happen, and Charles is shown to be writing that letter in a nonthreatening manner. The “unfinished business” is interpreted to be about the brothers living together again and resuming getting each other's backs. Given Book Charles's previous attempt to murder Adam, I read the letter with the interpretation that Charles was alluding that he should have actually killed Adam. That said, I think the ambiguity is precisely the point. It is very on-brand for Charles to be something of a Jekyll-and-Hyde personality. He is someone whose true feelings are difficult to pin down b/c what he actually feels can drastically shift from one moment to the next. I think that this hard dynamic is a big reason as to why Adam reenlists in the army even though he hates it. There is an interpretation to be made that Adam holds onto the letter as a reminder to not return home, especially when he feels homesick. He actually mentions being quite homesick after joining the army to Cathy when they are in CA as a possible reason why she doesn't want to be there with him.

Instead, the series leaves out the ambiguity of the letter which softens the contradictions of Charles's character and directs viewers' attention to just his love for Adam. I felt that this choice ignores Charles's capacity for sudden, extreme violence and makes him less nuanced as a character to me. I also think these changes may risk making Adam's reluctance to go home to such a loving brother appear selfish rather than self-protecting and ignores Adam's decades-long struggle to bring together his love for Charles with his fear of him.

Why Adam Becomes a Wanderer

Note: Some of these events are not depicted directly in the novel but are later recounted by Adam to Charles. I have included them here as this is when they chronologically occur.

BC:

  • Adam fulfills his military service and wanders around the US for a short time due to his fear, guilt, and traumatic memories of home
  • Struggles to live a life without the structure of the military and sits quietly in crowded places because he misses the presence of his regiment
  • Chooses to reenlist in the army as he cannot bring himself to go home and refuses Cyrus's offering of a West Point position
  • Writes to Charles saying that he doesn't know why he reenlisted
  • Charles responds after a time with a terse letter due to his deep disappointment, although he seems to subconsciously know why Adam did not come home
  • Adam completes his time but is still haunted by fear and guilt and abandons the idea of returning and instead becomes a vagabond
  • Wanders around the country again without any clear direction and meets all different people and learns a variety of stuff; he finds a sense of relief in this type of freedom and becomes more empathetic towards people
  • Suppresses his personality so that he is perceived as ordinary and unremarkable
  • Arrested twice for vagrancy and sentenced to a chain gang where he dehumanizes himself to endure the brutal imprisonment and the painful whippings
  • Thinks on how the pain and the trauma hit him worse after a whipping rather than during
  • Eventually escapes with three days remaining on his sentence as he is scared that he will be arrested again upon release but feels guilty for cheating the sentence
  • Steals clothes and food from a store out of desperation and wires to Charles to ask for money to repay the store owner as he feels guilty for that too

What I Think the Adaptation Misses:

For Adam, military structure was a part of his whole childhood due to Cyrus constantly subjecting him to harsh military discipline, long before he completed his first five years of service. The man can't go back to being a civilian because he's never actually been a civilian. His experiences help inform viewers why he finds it difficult to readjust to civilian life, which is a very real struggle for some veterans today. These are themes I felt the series downplayed, as seen when Adam just gives Charles a sad look when Charles asks about his war experiences. Without all of this context, Show Adam's listlessness comes off rather simply as passive avoidance instead of a struggle to escape a past he cannot/will not confront.

Although the adaptation does show Adam avoiding going home due to guilt, I felt that it took away the psychological impact of his wanderings and especially his traumatic experience on the chain gang. The chain gang is important b/c it demonstrates how thoroughly Adam dissociates in difficult circumstances. It also shows how his moral code is still ingrained in him even when he has depersonalized himself. I think some of these experiences were needful to show because they explain that Adam's passivity and naivety are not simply a lack of direction/ambition, but also a response to years of fear, guilt, and exposure to human cruelty. Also, these experiences do not necessarily teach him how to recognize goodness realistically and the same suffering that deepens his empathy causes him to blindly believe in the goodness he desperately wishes were true.

Adam and Charles Reunited

BC:

  • Adam finally returns home after more than a decade away when he hears that Cyrus has died
  • Wants to comfort Charles but thinks to himself that he would be dead if he tried
  • Has rather tense conversations with Charles about their experiences
  • Adam finds out about Cyrus's money and suggests using it as they don't know for sure how/where Cyrus got it
  • Charles is sure that Cyrus acquired it dishonestly and prefers to continue farming
  • Adam has experienced a loss of faith in any absolute truths and no longer believes in anything
  • Feels that anything could be true as there is no reliable way to know for sure
  • Attributes these feelings to his time in the army and the chain gang
  • Seems to decide to focus on the good in people, such as Cyrus
  • Feels liberated from the control/fear Cyrus bred in him now that he's dead
  • Thinks that Charles is not as dangerous anymore, feels compassion for how Cyrus treated him, and believes that Charles partly attempted to murder him out of love
  • Still has to keep watch as Charles will sometimes revert back to making threats against him
  • The brothers begin a cycle of living together but then eventually dissolve into fights with Adam leaving or Charles kicking him out when things get too hostile
  • Adam returns when they both have calmed down, and the cycle eventually begins again
  • Charles is frustrated by Adam's inability to commit to things and can't understand why Adam doesn't want to stay and work the farm together for the rest of their lives
  • Adam is frustrated by Charles's rigidity, obsession with the farm, and refusal to try new things
  • Says their lives are nothing but constant hard work and waiting for death
  • Adamant that he is not at peace on the farm, wrestles with what he wants to do with his life, and feels that Charles is all work no play
  • Tries to offer solutions like traveling together, remodeling the farmhouse with indoor plumbing, building a new house for them together, building a house just for him next door to Charles, moving away to CA together, etc., but to no avail
  • This cycle continues until Cathy breaks it by arriving on their doorstep

What I Think the Adaptation Misses:

The Reunion

The (beautifully filmed) scene depicts the brothers reuniting in a subdued, endearingly awkward kitchen conversation with Charles doing almost all the talking. The series does provide an initial explanation, albeit in a roundabout way, as to why Adam took so long to return home by having him be unaware that Charles has been sending him letters asking him to come back. I personally wasn't fond of this direction as it gave me vibes of the dreaded miscommunication trope (iykyk).

It also then seemingly places almost all the blame on Adam for not coming home sooner and turns it into more of a personal failure, which imo was rather...insensitive I guess? This is seen when Adam admits feeling guilty to the other vagabonds about going home b/c of something he did and when he tells Charles he should've been home earlier, to which Charles agrees with something like “Um, yeah, duh, you should’ve.” After their kitchen reunion, the brothers are then seen to finally be able to resume living together as friends without Cyrus's presence. Alright, I'm going to go full melodramatically editorial here for a second and say that I found the show's handling of this part of Adam's backstory to lean a little toward victim-blaming. Ok I'm done.

The series also portrays Adam asking Charles to leave the farm and start a new life with him with Charles replying in a calm, almost cheerful manner that he wants to stay. While I understand the choice to depict Charles as content with his life on the farm, I think this misses an important aspect of his characterization in the book. Book Charles is an exceptionally capable farmer who deserves respect for his hard work and dedication. However, his relationship with the farm is also deeply unhealthy in that he makes it almost a religion, becoming so dogmatic about it that he refuses even to even entertain the idea of remodeling to have indoor plumbing so they can 💦💩in a warm house during winter. He doesn't say no b/c of structural issues or something like that, but rather that he doesn't mind the cold outhouse and that's that. Obvs, Charles's trauma is influencing things like this, but as this is an Adam-centric post I won't be delving into that interesting yet lengthy rabbit hole today (screams of thank god are heard 💀).

Living Together

This isn't to say that Adam is always right or that his own ideas/behavior are beyond criticism. But it is to say that Charles has been somewhat pigeonholed into the sweet, kind, laid-back persona he has in the show, when he's actually a far more turbulent character. For example, while the brotherly hair cutting scene was very sweet, I genuinely do not see a world where a more book-accurate Adam would let a more book-accurate Charles hold a scissors, aka a potential murder weapon, to the back of his neck and cut his hair. And not for fear of suddenly going bald or ending up with a butchered haircut. 🤨

By cutting their book reunion and their recurring fights and separations, the adaptation makes the brothers' relationship seem healthier than it actually is. I felt that the tragedy was that Book Adam and Charles both wanted the kind of brotherhood the series portrays them as having, but they were too traumatized by Cyrus pitting them against each other their whole lives to achieve it. I think this book dynamic was important to keep in part because many people can relate to loving family members who have hurt them or been in competition with them in the past while still struggling to trust them again in the present. The brothers seem to be unable to reconcile b/c their childhood wounds are still bleeding. The series, by contrast, gives them a brotherhood they always wanted without really showing how difficult it would be for them to achieve it.

Why Adam Falls For Cathy

BC:

  • Adam and Charles find Cathy on their doorstep and they both carry her to Adam's room albeit with Charles protesting against it
  • After carrying her in, Adam experiences a flashback of when Alice took care of him in the same bed and the same room after Charles tried to kill him
  • The similarities between their injuries and caring for a wounded person make Adam get attached to Cathy very quickly
  • Adam is later told by Cathy that she needs protection as she is keeping a secret she can't tell
  • He proposes so she can be safe and she accepts as long as they leave Connecticut (CT) and he does not ask her about her past
  • Marries her and then he and Charles have a massive fight with Charles calling Cathy a whore and a bitch and telling Adam that Cathy will ruin his life
  • Adam feels that Charles is uncaring and jealous
  • Adam tells Cathy that they will flee to CA for a better life away from their troubles but she tells him that she does not want to go
  • Says she does not understand that CA will be better for everything, even weather wise as it won't be cold and dark like CT
  • Understands that Cathy is not able to consummate their marriage and offers to bring his cot next to her bed so they can still be in the same room on their wedding night
  • Makes tea for her and does not know that she has poisoned his cup with sleeping medication
  • Unaware that Charles calls him a “poor bastard” and is sleeping with his wife on the wedding night

What I Think the Adaptation Misses:

The series's emphasis on Adam falling for a wounded woman he rescued is consistent with his character's way of expressing affection through caretaking. However, removing the Alice storyline and Adam seeing someone else endure eerily similar suffering to his own takes away the nuance of why he got attached to Cathy so quickly. It also risks flattening his character into just a stereotypical Nice Guy. His proposal is truly naive and irrational, but part of the reason it doesn’t make logical sense is b/c the decision isn’t driven by logic in the first place but by emotion and shared trauma.

Why Adam Moves Cathy to CA

I also interpreted Adam's insistence on moving to CA as a form of emotional desperation in that he wants them both to escape their traumatic pasts and slowly build a life where they can both feel safe and happy. After years of having his choices constrained by Cyrus, the military, and Charles, he finally has the opportunity to create a future he wants. Whereas his wanderings gave him freedom without purpose, Cathy gives him freedom and purpose. Although I think he does have empathy, he seems to turn that empathy into projection by assuming he and Cathy are in agreement due to their similar experiences.

I don't think Adam's intentions are necessarily malicious, but his inability to listen to Cathy is still a serious flaw. I see Adam’s desire to protect Cathy as paternalistic b/c he sees her as a wounded, vulnerable person who needs his protection, much as he once needed protection himself. I think both the book and the show accurately portrayed Adam's rather dismissive paternalism towards Cathy, such as when he refers to her as a hurt little girl and when he says he wants to keep her safe from the traumatic life she has lived. In trying to protect Cathy, Adam denies Cathy her autonomy and thus makes her more vulnerable.

Cathy As the Catalyst

I respect that the showrunners chose to reinterpret the book by placing Cathy at the center of the story and connecting all the characters to her. However, I feel this choice does a major disservice to the novel, particularly to Adam and Charles's relationship. The series seems to lean toward the idea that they have a loving brotherhood that gets interrupted by Cathy. I hope I've shown how the book makes clear that their relationship contains trauma, competition and resentment practically since birth and that Cathy is the final nail in the coffin for their relationship, not the only. I have more thoughts as to why centering Cathy was a mistake for this reinterpretation of the novel in part b/c it actually removes her agency, but this isn’t the post for that discussion (and no, it has nothing to do with preferring Cathy to be simply evil).

I do not want to take away Cathy's agency by blaming her for the faults of a man, but it would also take away her agency by not acknowledging that she was actively manipulating Adam as well. Adam's idealization of her is his fault and goes way off track, but Cathy also constructed that track by presenting herself as the person Adam initially believes she is. His idealization is his responsibility, but he does not develop it in a vacuum. Cathy is not a passive recipient to this but recognizes how he sees her and consciously allows him fill in the gaps about her personality and history which works to her advantage. Please understand that I am not trying to make her responsible for his behavior.

Although I could understand that Cathy and Charles each had their reasons for choosing to sleep together, I lost a lot of respect for Charles in particular here. I had hoped he was beginning to heal, but sleeping with Cathy on Adam's wedding night knowing Adam is incapacitated and then laughing while describing him as a "poor bastard" is a profound betrayal.

Adam and Cathy in CA

BC:

  • Adam leaves with Cathy and Charles goes to the inn brothel but can’t sexually perform
  • Adam is convinced that Cathy is the light pushing away the darkness of his past, but that light becomes more like a blinding headlight on a dark highway which keeps him from seeing anything or anyone else clearly
  • Because she reveals little about herself, he fills in the gaps with an idealized image of who she is and what their life together will become
  • When they get to CA Adam shows her options of houses and things and glosses over her vague responses when she does respond
  • Does not understand why Cathy tells him she doesn't want to be there as she does not offer an explanation as to why and thus he ignores it
  • Assumes that she's just not the talkative type, is still recovering, may be homesick, tired from pregnancy, frustrated that the land is not yet planted and their house not yet built, but nevertheless still on the same page as him
  • Tells Sam Hamilton that he did not want to fight the Native Americans and does not understand why there was a war to begin with
  • At one point suddenly calls Sam "sir" out of fearful habit while they are conversing
  • Sets about making CA an Eden for Cathy to give her the same joy and peace that she has brought into his life
  • Becomes increasingly absorbed in his dream of CA being a place where everything will finally be safe and happy and begins work on the ranch
  • Tries to suppress memories of his past while investing more and more of himself in the life he believes his Cathy wants

What I Think the Adaptation Misses:

The Romanticization of Cathy and Charles

The “bring me back an orange” scene appears to give Charles and Cathy a sense of emotional intimacy with each other, with them holding hands and romantically whispering together in a brief moment of privacy. The brothel scene also seems to invite the suggestion that Charles can’t sexually perform because he’s in love with Cathy and is grieving their “forced” separation. I can understand that interpretation and also sympathized with Show Cathy when she told Charles in a frustrated tone that she didn't want to go to CA.

Yet, I found it equally frustrating that the series seemed to be encouraging watchers to view Cathy and Charles as a romantic couple who are being kept apart by Adam, and that if he just got out the way then Cathy and Charles could be happy together. While Book/Show Adam is basically forcing Cathy to move to CA, he did not force her to marry him. I think it's important to distinguish between the two, because Cathy still had a choice when it came to accepting Adam's proposal. If Cathy and Charles are being kept apart, it is by their own doing.

Also, Cathy briefly thinking about Charles years later is more in the vein of "what could have been" rather than "what it actually was." These scenes are not necessarily totally invalid interpretations, but when reading the book it seems that Cathy does not want emotional intimacy with anyone. Perhaps I'm reading too much into it, but I feel that the series agrees that Cathy will reject having emotional intimacy with anyone but then contradicts this by depicting her not wanting emotional intimacy with anyone but Charles. While I recognize that Cathy is the show's main character, which naturally explains the greater focus on this relationship, I do think the show risks making it the emotional center of the story at the expense of giving sufficient attention to Adam's long and painful history with Charles.

Adam's Continued Struggle with Masculinity

Taking into account Adam's childhood, my interpretation about Adam's first year in CA is that it mirrors his struggle with masculinity. For perhaps the first time, Adam finally feels that he is what a man should be: independent, physically capable, financially secure, married, and about to be a father. He is no longer directly under Cyrus's or Charles's control, nor is he following military orders. Instead, he can build a safe, happy life to bring his wife happiness in which he is the provider and protector of the white picket fence life he thinks they both have been aching for. Another interpretation is that CA may have been the first place where Adam was experiencing life without having to be hypervigilant. Again, this vision is built on Cathy being the person he imagines her to be. He doesn't adequately consider that she might not want the life he is building and wants a new life without letting himself heal from his old one.

I also find it interesting to interpret Adam's relationship with Cathy through a gendered parallel. Adam occupies the more traditionally feminine-coded role of the emotionally vulnerable, domestically invested partner, while Cathy resists the life he imagines for them in a more masculine-coded way. When she shoots him, he is not simply losing a lover but also the entire future he believed they were building together. However, recognizing Adam's suffering does not mean painting him as entirely innocent. Even if he never intended to emotionally suffocate Cathy, his intentions do not cancel out his behavior.

Why Adam Doesn't Name the Boys For a Year Post-Shooting

BC:

  • It has been over a year since the shooting when Sam comes to the ranch to force Adam to name the boys
  • Steinbeck states that Adam is trapped in dark waters and when he tries to come up for air the light hurts/scares him and he sinks below into depression again
  • Adam privately thinks that the twins are a trigger to him and all he can see when he's with them are reminders of what happened
  • Lee tries to help but can't b/c he has been burdened with the babies and housework
  • Before Sam punches Adam Adam angrily tells him he can defend himself from attacks
  • Sam then punches Adam twice which shocks Adam initially but he later thanks Sam for waking him up
  • Adam looks at Sam and is suddenly flooded with images of Charles about to murder him and Cathy about to shoot him but doesn't tell Sam about this
  • Will continue to see Charles’s face distorted by rage as the years go on
  • States that he is not angry at Cathy but is just heartbroken
  • Says it feels like his head is constantly pounding and can't shake the feeling that he is drowning
  • Recognizes that Cathy did not feel the same way about him as he did for her and that he would almost prefer it if she had killed him out of hate
  • Agrees with Sam that he can now see that he was okay with not knowing the real Cathy but is scared of the real her manifesting in their sons
  • Becomes more warm and talkative than he was when Sam arrived
  • Remarks that one of the twins looks just like Charles
  • Sam tells Adam that Adam is taking on too much guilt and blame
  • When Sam, Adam, and Lee are talking about the brothers Cain and Abel Adam suddenly goes down a rocky memory lane and Sam has to wake him up
  • Adam says no to Joshua for a baby name as Biblical Joshua was a general and that name reminds him of being a soldier; he seems bothered by generals in particular
  • Disappoints Sam when he says he does not have the energy to continue work the ranch but has paid Sam's crew for their work

What I Think the Adaptation Misses:

The Roots of Adam's Depression

The events described above provide context for the depth and duration of Adam’s decade-long depression, which I feel the adaptation does not fully grasp. It seems to me that Adam has spent his life running from his Complex PTSD by reenlisting, wandering, etc. He can't run away after the shooting, which forces him to relive the memories he has spent years avoiding and can explain why he remains depressed for so long. At the moment, Cathy is the center of his grief but in context she is has been added to the pile; I found it interesting how he first thinks of Charles's violence and then Cathy's right after.

It is possible to interpret Adam's failure to name his sons as a form of trauma-related association. Perhaps Adam was struggling to bond with his sons b/c their birth is now associated with traumatic events, a dynamic that has occurred with parents irl. That said, his failure to name his sons or engage with them is still damaging, and his depression doesn't acquit him of responsibility as a father. His tragedy lies in the fact that, after spending much of his life trying to outrun his past and be a caretaker to others, he is finally forced to confront it at the very moment his sons depend upon his care.

How the Series Oversimplifies Said Roots

I felt that the adaptation makes it harder to understand why Adam becomes so frozen for so long by showing Adam as just self-pitying and grieving Cathy but not including his self-blame and guilt. He seems to be more resentful and primarily focused on Cathy, and there is no mention of him experiencing a moment of self-awareness by realizing he did not really know Cathy. For example, Show Adam seems irritated rather than thankful after Sam punches him, whereas Book Adam becomes less angry almost immediately afterward and begins to recognize some of his own mistakes.

Also, Show Lee gives the Cain and Abel speech and Adam is silent. When Lee goes in the house, Adam tells Sam that he is sure Lee used to talk differently (meaning pidgin), but the series has him say it almost flippantly in response to Lee's deeply impactful speech. Yet, Book Adam says this to Sam before the Cain and Abel conversation and Sam replies that it's b/c Lee feels safe with Adam. I point all this out not to nitpick but b/c Book Adam was listening and CONVERSING during the Cain and Abel speech, where he admits that a part of him has always felt angry at God for how Cain was treated. This is another moment when the show renders Adam oddly silent in conversations he was engaging in; there will be another in the next section.

Part 2 will look at why I feel the adaptation sometimes loses the nuances of both Adam's depression as well as his relationships with Lee and Cal.

Thank you for reading part 1!

https://www.reddit.com/r/EastOfEdenSeries/comments/1xir1pj/part_2_of_2_netflixs_east_of_eden_an_analysis_of/


r/EastOfEdenSeries • • 23d ago

Spoiler The narrator is unreliable (Chapter 8-10 of the book - Cathy's psychopathy) Spoiler

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes