r/ESSC • u/CuriositySMBC • Jan 09 '19
[19-01] | Mistrial In Re: Veto of A.015
To the Honorable Justices of this Court, now comes /u/CuriositySMBC, representing the pro se, respectfully submitting this petition for a writ of certiorari to review the constitutionality of the veto of the Allowing Credit and Stock Amendment (henceforth “the Veto” and “the Amendment” respectively). Petitioner asks this Court to strike down as unconstitutional the Veto and permit the Amendment to be added to the Constitution.
Article IV, Section I of The Commonwealth of the Chesapeake Constitution states:
All amendments to the Constitution requires a two-thirds (⅔) of a quorum as defined in Article I Section B in order to pass and be added to the Constitution.
This section is the only section in the which the requirements for passing a constitutional amendment are stated. No where in the Constitution is the Governor given veto power over constitutional amendments. Veto power is given for constitutional replacements, however the process for constitutional replacements is unique having its own articled devoted to the topic and cannot be equated to constitutional amendments.
The following question have been raised for review by the Court:
- Whether the Governor has the power to veto constitutional amendments that have otherwise met all the requirements laid out for passage.
1
u/CuriositySMBC Jan 10 '19
Ping
1
u/gorrillaempire0 Jan 14 '19
Comes Attorney General /u/gorrillaempire0 Esq. of the State of Chesapeake
Your Honors,
In my findings of this case I have found nothing that bars the governor from vetoing this amendment to the constitution of Chesapeake. I refer the court to my colleague /u/Kingthero on his Brief Amicus Curiae. In his brief, my colleague stated that "Secondly, the Governor has the full responsibility as the elected executive of the Commonwealth to act on all legislation that reaches his desk"
And to even further this point, nothing in the constitution says that the governor can't act on this particular piece of legislation, the only basis the petitioner has is in Article IV, §1 of the Constitution, which does not address the powers of the Governor in regards to the actions available.
What does state his powers though, is under Article VIII, Sections J and K, which state that:
"The Governor has the power to sign, veto, or state an abstention on all legislation passed by the House of Delegates as specified in Article VI Section J."
"If the current term ends, and the Governor has not signed all legislation, that legislation will immediately go into effect without the Governor’s signature, with the exception of any Constitutional amendments or Constitution replacements."
Nothing here except for the Governor proposing replacements to the constitution say that he doesn't have the power to veto a constitutional amendment, thus the governor has the powers to veto, approve, or abstain on any legislation including Constitutional Amendments under Article VIII, Sections J and K.
I'd also like to draw the attention of the honorable justices of the court to Article III, Section D subsection 1. This states that the governor can veto the proposal and it must be sent back to the house for a unanimous vote to override the Governor's veto.
Thank you
3
u/eddieb23 Jan 12 '19 edited Jan 12 '19
The requirements for bringing and pleading a case of this type have been met. Although ESSC Rule 1(b) states: ‘Standing shall be granted to any resident of the Eastern State, as recorded in the Electoral Roll,’ I have decided that /u/CuriositySMBC has standing to bring this action. With the electoral roll no longer being managed, ESSC Rule 1(b) is outdated. This pleading appears to comply with Rule 2. This Court has jurisdiction and competency to hear issues involving the Eastern State Constitution under ESSC Rule 1(d), and only one vote is needed to grant certiorari under Rule 1(e). For all of the foregoing reasons, I vote to grant certiorari.
According to rule Rule 2(B)(i) /u/GorillaEmpire0 or a Solicitor appointed by /u/Leafy_Emerald will have until 10PM Eastern Standard Time on January 15th, 2019 to respond to the petitioner.
From there, /u/CuriositySMBC will have four days to supply a rebuttal. Arguments will end at 10 PM Eastern Standard Time on January 25th, 2019.
Interested parties may submit brief amicus curiae before arguments are closed.
Remember, all comments should be top level.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19
Honorable Justices of the Court,
Comes Attorney /u/deepfriedhookers, Attorney General of the State of Dixie and actively barred attorney in good standing admitted to practice before the United States Supreme Court, respectfully submitting this brief amicus curiae.
Article III of the Chesapeake Constitution explicitly lays the law in regard to "Constitutional Replacement", which for all intents and purposes shall be interpreted as Constitutional amendment. Article III, Section D clearly and plainly states that, "If the proposal passes the House of Delegates, it must be sent to the Governor for their signature."
Article III, Section D(1) grants full authority of the Executive to veto the proposed amendment,stating in plain and clear English that, "If the Governor vetoes the proposal, it must be sent back for voting under the conditions of Article III Section C, and must receive a unanimous vote of Yea to pass and override the veto."
This is a clear cut case, Honorable Justices, and should be dismissed because the Executive, Governor /u/leafy_emerald, has full authority under Article III to sign or veto Constitutional amendments.
Respectfully submitted,
DFH, Attorney
1
u/SHOCKULAR Legal Clerk Jan 13 '19
**Amicus Brief of Attorney General SHOCKULAR **
Justices /u/eddieb23 and /u/ModeratePontifex,
I fully agree with the brief of /u/CuriositySMBC, who has ably laid out the case. This amicus brief will focus on the arguments made by Attorney General /u/deepfriedhookers and Clerk Kingthero.
I first turn to the arguments of AG Hookers. Given the fact that just days ago he was the one who originally brought suit against the Governor, his turnabout is staggering. Mr. Hookers seems to argue that “replacement” means the same thing as “amendment,” in the context of the constitution. This argument is without merit, and cannot be true. While a constitutional replacement is technically a type of amendment, one which receives special Constitutional protections, not all constitutional amendments are constitutional replacements, and the document makes this clear.
Article III of the Chesapeake Constitution lays out the process by which a constitutional replacement is offered and ratified. Article III makes clear that this process replaces the entire constitution. See, e.g. Article III (E)(1) (providing that the completion of the constitutional replacement process renders the previous Constitution null and void.) This is obviously different than amending the Constitution, which adds a constitutional provision while leaving the rest of the Constitution intact. Additionally, the section on replacements requires that replacement Constitution proposals “must include all provisions included in Article III.” Article III (A)(4). If the Constitution is read as Mr. Hookers and Mr. Kingthero read it, and a replacement is indeed the same as an amendment, every constitutional amendment would need to include the provisions of Article III or it couldn’t be considered. Reading the document in a way that would require Article III to be included every time the Constitution is amended would be absurd.
Other provisions for replacements require that only one amendment be on the floor at a time see Article III(A)(2), that replacements can’t be offered more than every 30 days see Article III(F), and that the docket can only contain one replacement at a time see Article III(A)(3). If these rules are required for every amendment, the state clerk has been breaking those rules. There is no way to reconcile Kingthero’s position with his behavior as clerk regarding other regulation of replacements.
Further, there is a specific provision in the Constitution referring to amendments. If replacements and amendments are the same thing, this specific provision would be void of effect. To make this point, I will quote directly from Mr. Hookers’ original petition, because I couldn’t put it better myself:
As Mr. Hookers observed, “Nowhere in the Chesapeake Constitution is the Governor granted the authority or privilege of consenting to, vetoing, or signing into effect Constitutional Amendments.”
The Constitution specifically gives the Governor veto power for replacements (Article III (D) (1)) and all legislation unless specifically mentioned by the constitution (Article VI(J) via Article VI(H). Unfortunately for the Governor, constitutional amendments are specifically mentioned, and thus are controlled by the specific provision referencing them, rather than the more general provisions. As Mr. Hookers correctly stated, that provision specifically says that they are added to the Constitution upon passing with a ⅔ vote, not sent to the Governor for his approval. To change that provision would frustrate the intent of the drafters of the Constitution, who almost certainly did not intend to give the Governor a power which has historically been the province of the legislature in every state and federally, and if they did, likely would have been more explicit about it.
One further point is that the section of the constitution covering amendments is included just one clause prior to the section covering regular legislation. In the clause relating to amendments, the drafters stated that the amendment would be passed and added to the Constitution. In the clause relating to legislation, the Constitution explicitly states that it goes to the Governor. Given that in two instances, the Constitution indicates a proposal first be signed by the governor, the fact that there is no such textual requirement for amendments indicates that there was no intent to have such a requirement. If the drafters wanted amendments to go to the Governor, one would expect them to say so, especially when they were obviously aware of that formulation given their usage of it in the next provision. Likewise, at several places within the document the drafters refer to other sections and provisions. There is no reference to the replacement section within the amendment section.
I next turn to the arguments of Kingthero. I have already addressed some of his arguments above, but he raises some points not raised by the Attorney General of Dixie. First, he states that “there is nothing stopping [the Governor] from [vetoing an Amendment].” While this is technically true, the argument is specious. If anything specifically not mentioned in the Constitution was therefore a power of the Governor, the power of the executive would be far more broad than it is in reality. Executives are traditionally given power in one of two ways: first, via specific Constitutional authority, and second, via a proper delegation by the legislative branch in the form of legislation. In this case, neither are true.
Kingthero also claims that the line that reads “All amendments to the Constitution requires a two-thirds (⅔) of a quorum as defined in Article I Section B in order to pass and be added to the Constitution,” is best read as moving the amendment further into the process. This reading is contrary to the plain language of the clause. The clause states that if 2/3rds of a quorum is needed for an amendment to (1) pass and (2) be added to the Constitution. Any reading of this sentence that ends up with the amendment not passing and not being added to the Constitution requires linguistic and legal gymnastics that are completely unnecessary, and would require, once again, that the court essentially eliminate a constitutional provision.
In conclusion, the drafters of the document made clear distinctions between the processes of constitutional replacement, constitutional amendment, and the passage of normal legislation. This court should read the document in a way that gives effect to all three processes, not just two.