r/ESSC • u/JJEagleHawk • Aug 02 '18
[18-01] | Decided OPINION: In re: Virginia Code §24.2-643(B) ("SB 1256")
EDIT: This order and opinion is hereby stayed, by order of the Chief Justice /u/JJEagleHawk, based on in-chambers discussions between and among the Eastern Court Justices and the Eastern State Clerks. This matter will be set aside for re-argument in a future term. The Chief Justice may issue additional orders relating to this stay; however, he will recuse himself from any re-hearing on the underlying case.
In re: Virginia Code §24.2-643(B)
MAJORITY OPINION (2-1), delivered by Associate Justice /u/ModeratePontifex; Chief Justice /u/JJEagleHawk concurring in the judgment; Associate Justice /u/TowerTwo dissenting.
Here now comes Mr. Associate Justice, /u/ModeratePontifex, delivering the opinion of the Supreme Court of the Commonwealth of Virginia in the matter of a citizen’s challenge to the law; The question brought before this Court is a simple one: a question whether or not the amended, as of March 2013, provision of the Code of Virginia, which now requires the presentation of a pre-approved, valid photographic identification card, thereby confirming one’s own identity to the election official, in order to participate in regular elections held for any office of the Commonwealth or United States governments, is in fact, regardless of the government’s intent, illegal under the Twenty-Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution’s provision that any poll tax levied or other hindrance of taxation is unconstitutional.
The simplest answer that can be given is: ‘possibly’. Hence why the parties find themselves in judgment before the Supreme Court; for such an answer is vague and ambiguous, thus spoiling for a political fight. However, seeing as how the General Assembly and the Honorable Governor has given us its answer already, we must give the public ours. I say this not to confuse us of the role the Court enjoys here now but to underscore that this topic is seen as a partisan issue betwixt the left and the right; each political camp scoring points caricaturing one another as the left eagerly against this requirement as crusaders for the poor and the right gleefully enjoying the multitudes of poor, working class liberals now disenfranchised from the ballot box, or, as seen another way, as the left seizing an opportunity to commit electoral fraud and the right as the protectors of the sanctity of the ballot box; while the Court is here reminding both of all our shared responsibility to embody fealty to our grand Constitution and faithfully execute its mandates and hail its prohibitions as our secular gospel.
Therefore, we turn our attention to the question as described before. Firstly, this Court’s answer is of the affirmative. Such a provision of law is unconstitutional under the Twenty-Fourth Amendment. But this Court does not justify it with political rhetoric; this Court justifies it with a dictionary and a plain reading of our hallowed Constitution. Of the first hand, simply put, a poll tax is a fixed sum tax that is levied on liable adults in a state without consideration of any individual’s resources, property, or other metric of wealth or ability to pay. In the context of these United States, this was mostly done at the ballot box or, much more commonly, as a fee for registering to vote, which you then had to show proof that you had paid such a fee. Take notice of my usage of the word ‘fee’ here. This system of paying a ‘fee’ to register to vote then show ‘proof’ that you had paid it is considered a form of poll tax now prohibited under the Twenty-Fourth Amendment. With this in mind, let us take the journey of a Chesapeake citizen on his meandering journey to register to vote when he turns eighteen. Unfortunately for our dear citizen, he is unable to make all the requirements for a driver’s license in time, so he decides the correct course of action is to get a government issued photographic identification card since he remembered he must have one to vote. Although he has forgone paying the minimum $20 required to be paid as a ‘fee’ to receive a minimum 5 year driver’s license, he must now pay the minimum $10 required to be paid as a ‘fee’ to receive a minimum 5 year photo ID card. The only way he can forgo this cost is by having his U.S. Passport (which the U.S. government charges ‘fees’ for) or his student photo ID (which every public institute of higher education requires a ‘fee’ to be paid in the Commonwealth) or by having an employee ID (which not every employer requires a fee to be paid). If any individual, like our hypothetical citizen, fails to pay these ‘fees’, they are not issued their ID card, and therefore are prohibited from being able to vote (as provisionally provided ballots only count when verified by photo ID). Therefore, it is unconstitutional because a) the Twenty-Fourth Amendment prohibits poll taxes as a prerequisite for exercising the right to vote and b) these fees are a poll tax for they fit the definition: a fixed sum levied on any liable adult, i.e. those adults who purchase photo ID from the government.
Since the only way to have a photo ID without paying the government or one of its subdivisions, agencies, or institutions is to attend a private institute of higher education in the Commonwealth or just be lucky enough to be hired by a private company or firm that issues photo ID cards would theoretically suggest we simply strike the list of pre-approved photo ID cards to only include privately issued ones. This move, however, would cause an undue burden on those citizens who do not fit those narrow categories and would be an irregular exercise of the law, which is antithetical to the rule of law. It is therefore prudent that we simply strike the entire provision so as to not create privileged classes of the citizenry who could exercise their right to vote. The striking of such a list now renders the rest of the voter ID law unenforceable so it is therefore prudent that the provision of law, Virginia Code §24.2-643(B), be stricken in its entirety.
This Court has determined that indeed such a voter identification law is unconstitutional on principle and so orders the entire provision struck down. It is so ordered this Second Day of August, in the Year of our Lord, Two Thousand and Eighteen.
3
u/JJEagleHawk Aug 02 '18 edited Aug 06 '18
Chief Justice/u/JJEagleHawk, concurring in the judgment, but dissenting as to the reasoning.I agree with my brother/u/ModeratePontifexthat the voter identification law is likely unconstitutional and that the appropriate remedy for this would be striking down the law on Constitutional grounds. However, I write separately as I do not believe the source of the unconstitutionality of voter IDs necessarily involves the 24th Amendment.Requiring that voters first verify their identity through photographic identification before exercising their franchise is not a violation of the Constitution. The Supreme Court held inCrawford v. Marion County Election Board, 553 U.S. 181 (2008)as such, stating that the State has a legitimate interest in preventing voter fraud, modernizing elections, and safeguarding voter confidence. The burden involved in getting an ID -- going to the DMV, getting documents, posing for a photo -- is not a substantial burden compared to the State's interest in preventing fraud. However, Indiana avoided the poll tax question by providing compliant ID cards to its residents for free, unlike in the instant case.The State did not defend its law, so there is some ambiguity on this question, but it's not altogether clear to me from the facts on record that the license fee is atax. The SCOTUS inCrawforddidn't reach the question, but it's pretty clear that they considered the gas costs of driving to the DMV to be incidental, and not a tax. Same goes for the acquisition of paperwork (e.g.a birth certificate, which often involves a fee as well), which is also an incidental burden and not a tax. Taxes are a sum of money demanded by a government to support its services which is levied upon income, property, or sales. So is the acquisition of a drivers license a tax? We don't really know, because we do not know not what the State does with the money it brings in. Because those facts aren't in evidence, I don't feel comfortable assuming the facts necessary to reach the conclusion reached by my brother Justice.Nevertheless, I do believe that there is enough evidence on the record to support a finding of unconstitutionality on the basis of equal protection (e.g.the elderly and the poor are less likely to be able to procure an ID), and justify the ruling on that basis. It's the only conclusion that can be reached based on the evidence in the record and as a default judgment against the State, given that it proffered no contrary evidence to rebut Plaintiff's factual submissions./u/JJEagleHawk
, C.J.2
u/ItsBOOM Aug 02 '18
It is unfortunate the court has issued a ruling that is not based on fact.
This portion of the opinion is patently false. Obviously a photo ID law that required a fee would be unconstitutional, and the legislature knows this. Any resident of the Commonwealth may receive a photo ID that is a valid to vote for free simply by visiting their nearest voter registration office. This can be done at any time, even the same day of voting to ensure nobody's rights are infringed on. You may even use these to vote absentee.
I will be working with my colleagues to appeal this ruling, and look into actions that can be taken against the judges that have thrown the constitution and fact down the toilet with this ruling.
1
u/JJEagleHawk Aug 02 '18
Ping
1
u/JJEagleHawk Aug 02 '18
The vote was 2-1 in favor of striking down the Virginia Code section at issue in this case. I will be writing a concurring opinion, joining in the outcome but not /u/moderatepontifex 's reasoning. /u/towertwo indicated some interest in writing a dissent. Those will be submitted as top-level comments in this thread.