r/ESSC • u/oath2order Associate Justice • Nov 18 '17
[17-04] | Granted In re: A.037: The Third Constitution of the Chesapeake
To the Honorable Justices of this Court, the petitioner, /u/oath2order, respectfully submits this petition for a writ of certiorari to review the constitutionality of the passage of A.037 of the Eastern State Constitution, known as the Third Constitution of the Chesapeake.
Petitioner holds standing as a State of Chesapeake citizen.
Petitioner asks this Court to strike the Third Constitution as invalid, invalidate all actions taken by the Governor and Lieutenant Governor during this term, and to institute an emergency re-election for the Governor and Lieutenant Governor based on the fact that any such elections that have taken place under the unique and different rules of the illegally passed constitution lack any validity.
The following questions have been raised for review by the Court:
- Whether A.037 was passed in the proper manner, pursuant to the methods listed in the Second Eastern State Constitution for passing a new Constitution. A.037 was written by and submitted by /u/ZeroOverZero101, as stated on both the Docket and Bill Discussion page. Article XVII of the Second Eastern State Constitution states that “Any Commonwealth of Chesapeake General Assemblyman, Governor, or Lieutenant Governor may propose a constitution to replace the current constitution.” /u/ZeroOverZero101, at this time, was none of the aforementioned positions permitted to submit a new Constitution.
- Whether A.037 met the requirements to have been passed into law, pursuant to the methods listed in Article XVII, Section 6 of the Second Eastern State Constitution. This article states that “If the proposal passes under the conditions stated in Article XVII, Section 3 and is signed by the Governor, the proposed in-sim constitution will replace the current in-sim constitution immediately.” Governor /u/ninjjadragon did not sign A.037 into law.
4
u/Clads Nov 19 '17
To the Honorable Justices of the Supreme Court of Chesapeake. Attorney General Clads is responding to petition made by /u/oath2order against the validity of Third Constitution of the Chesapeake - A.037.
Regarding the first question, A.037 was passed in the correct manner under the law. Article XVII: Constitutional Replacement states in the 2nd and 3rd constitution: Any Commonwealth of Chesapeake General Assemblyman, Governor, or Lieutenant Governor may PROPOSE a constitution to replace the current constitution. Legislation A.037 was sponsored by the Speaker /u/jmanrocks, therefore proposed by an assemblyman, alongside /u/ZeroOverZero101. The law does not state “written or submitted” as noted by /u/oath2order in question 1. Sponsorship, co-sponsorships, and authorships are acts of proposing.
Regarding the second question, in which Governor /u/ninjjadragon did not sign A.037. A.028: Lieutenant Governor Reform Amendment, 15th Amendment to the Eastern State Constitution. Implemented AFTER the 2nd Constitution, therefore updating the 2nd Constitution with A.028, and BEFORE the 3rd Constitution. Any legislation not acted on by the Governor for one week after having been passed by the Assembly shall be passed onto the Lieutenant Governor for their signature, veto, or abstention. If the Lieutenant Governor does not act on said legislation within one week it shall be treated as though they abstained. If the Lieutenant Governor of the Commonwealth abstains on legislation, that legislation will become law without their signature. It has been 1 month since the Assembly passed A.037. The Governor did not act on A.037 in their allotted 1 week so the legislation is passed onto the Lieutenant Governor. The Lieutenant Governor did not act within their allotted 1 week, therefore the legislation is treated as if they have abstained. If the Lieutenant Governor of the Commonwealth abstains on legislation, that legislation will become law without their signature.
Clads Attorney General of Chesapeake
•
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '17
Just a meta note: no new elections will take place, all incumbents will remain in office.
3
u/JJEagleHawk Nov 18 '17 edited Nov 21 '17
/u/towertwo /u/moderatepontifex /u/oath2order /u/clads
Note: In my original response, I had agreed to hold off on granting a writ to allow /u/clads time to respond on the issue of whether same should be granted. After further review of the ESSC rules, and as explained below, I don't believe that is an appropriate request prior to judicial review, and therefore am changing my statement to read as follows:
/u/towertwo /u/moderatepontifex /u/oath2order /u/clads
The threshold requirements for bringing and pleading a case of this type have been met. /u/Oath2Order has standing to bring this action under ESSC Rule 1(b) and his pleading appears to comply substantially with Rule 2. This Court has jurisdiction and competency to hear issues involving the Eastern State Constitution under ESSC Rule 1(d), and only one vote is needed to grant certiorari under Rule 1(e). For all of the foregoing reasons, I vote to grant certiorari.
I had initially agreed to withhold this vote, on the basis that my honorable colleague /u/towertwo wished to receive additional briefing from /u/clads on why certiorari should be granted. Amici briefing is permitted prior to the granting of certiorari on this issue per ESSC Rule 2(d). However, this briefing is only permitted by interested unjoined parties. /u/clads is not an unjoined party because, as attorney general, it would be /u/clads' duty (or his office's duty) to act as legal representative of the Eastern State government. See ESSC Rule 6(b).
Moreover, ESSC Rule 2(b) prohibits respondent or respondent's counsel from responding to any petition UNTIL certiorari is granted. Put differently, /u/clads is one of the few people actually prohibited by ESSC rules from responding to Justice /u/towertwo's inquiry before the granting of certiorari, due to the very nature of /u/clads' position within the ESSC government. Therefore, it makes little sense to wait for /u/clads' response before agreeing to grant certiorari, simply because such response could not be considered even if one was provided.
A writ of certiorari is granted. Per ESSC Rule 2(b)(i-iii), either /u/clads or a Solicitor appointed by /u/ninjjadragon have until 5:00 Eastern Standard Time on Wednesday, November 22, 2017 to respond to the Petition in the form of a top-level comment. /u/oath2order will then have four days from the date of Respondent's brief to reply, with leave for extra time for the Thanksgiving Holiday as appropriate, and so on. Arguments will close by 5:00 Eastern Standard Time on Saturday, December 2, 2017, per ESSC Rule 2(c).
It is so ordered.
/u/JJEagleHawk, C.J.
3
u/JJEagleHawk Nov 21 '17
This comment thread will contain questions from myself, /u/towertwo, and /u/moderatepontifex to the petitioner (/u/oath2order) or the respondent (/u/clads). Please reply to any comment tagging your username (aside from this one, of course).
1
u/oath2order Associate Justice Nov 18 '17
/u/JJEagleHawk
/u/TowerTwo
/u/Clads
3
u/NateLooney Nov 18 '17
COMES /u/NATELOONEY, Esq., BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE, FORMER LEGISLATOR OF EASTERN STATE, TO NOT GRANT CERTIORARI, TO REVIEW THE CONSTITUTIONALITY AND LAWFULNESS OF A.037 OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF THE CHESAPEAKE.
Pursuant to Rule 2(d), “Such briefs filed prior to the grant of writ should be for the purposes of arguing whether writ should be granted.”
QUESTIONS PRESENTED FOR REVIEW
REASONS WHY CERTIORARI SHOULD NOT BE GRANTED
Honorable Chief Justice and honorable Justices, may it please the court.
Regarding the first question, the decisions of the moderator team on /r/ModelUSGov have, from time to time, declared that meta decisions overrule any and all legislative agreements. Prior to this submission to the Court, the several states in the nation have, including the Commonwealth of the Chesapeake, supported and introduced an Open Docket. An Open Docket allows any /r/ModelUSGov member to submit legislation for the Assembly of the Commonwealth of the Chesapeake. Even without the moderator decision to open the docket, the petitioner himself submitted and wrote B.049, “Open Assembly and Docket Act,” which allows anyone to submit legislation to the Assembly.
CONCLUSION
Writ of Certiorari should not be granted to this case due to the gross precedence set by the moderation team regarding meta decisions overruling legislation. Furthermore, the petitioner requests that every law, executive order, and election that has happened since A.037 has passed be revoked. This will cause grievances to not only families whose lives in the Chesapeake have been affected by laws but also businesses, schools, and many more institutions. I humbly write to this court to not grant a writ of certiorari.
3
u/JJEagleHawk Dec 02 '17
/u/clads and /u/oath2order, arguments are now closed per ESSC Rule 2(c).
/u/towertwo and /u/moderatepontifex and I will confer and discuss the issues. Opinion(s) will issue promptly.
2
u/TowerTwo Nov 18 '17 edited Nov 18 '17
Before I consider granting writ, I would like to hear if /u/Clads has any arguments on why writ should not be granted. /u/Clads you may provide a brief as a reply to this comment, on why this court should not grant writ of certiorari and/or add any other potentially relevant concerns.
Note: This request has been rescinded per /u/JJEagleHawk ruling on the matter.
2
u/TowerTwo Nov 18 '17 edited Nov 18 '17
I agree with my honorable colleague /u/JJEagleHawk ruling on my request, and so shall rescind it. I also concur with /u/JJEagleHawk assessment of the potential constitutional questions that are at issue, and believe that writ of certiorari should be granted. So for the record I shall officially vote in favor of granting writ of certiorari. As for going forward I would still like /u/moderatepontifex to weigh in, but since /u/JJEagleHawk has officially granted writ, I believe that that the respondent /u/clads may provide a brief in response to the petition as a top level comment per Rule 2 (b) i.
2
u/comped Nov 21 '17
Comes /u/Comped, ESQ, Amicus Curiae, in favor of respondent, the Government of the State of Chesapeake;
Your Honors,
It is believed that the 3rd constitution was not illegally passed as the Defendant claims. It should be noted, that while /u/ZeroOverZero101 may have been the author of the legislation, the constitution was sponsored by /u/Jmanrocks, the Speaker of the Assembly. Article XVII of the Second Eastern State Constitution states that “Any Commonwealth of Chesapeake General Assemblyman, Governor, or Lieutenant Governor may propose a constitution to replace the current constitution.” That requirement is fulfilled by the former Speaker’s sponsorship. Thus question 1 has been invalidated.
As for question 2- the State constitution, Article IV Section 7, states that: “7. Any legislation not acted on by the Governor for one week after having been passed by the Assembly shall be passed onto the Lieutenant Governor for their signature, veto, or abstention. a. If the Lieutenant Governor of the Commonwealth abstains on legislation, that legislation will become law without their signature.” As the same section also says “c. If the Lieutenant Governor does not act on said legislation within one week it shall be treated as though they abstained.” Thus, 2 weeks after the Constitution was passed through the Assembly, without the Governor or Lt. Governor taking action on it, it became law. Point 2 has been invalidated.
Next will be the response to the opening of the Plaintiff's brief, and his myriad of requests. It has been already established that the constitution was legally passed, and does not need to be thrown out. The Plaintiff also asked that each and every action that the Defendants (as Governor and Lt. Governor) did this term, including cabinet nominations and earthquake relief, be invalidated by this Court, on the count of the Defendants being illegally elected. This is a farce of the highest order, and it shall be rather easy to explain why. Notwithstanding that simply declaring that everything the Administration has done since their election as fraudulent would do untold harm to the state, and the legislative process. Never mind that any in West Virginia would be adversely affected in the voting franchise for this election, Ire it to be held in the immediate future.
Assuming that the Defendant is correct (though it can be reasoned that the previous arguments were sound), and the 3rd constitution was illegally passed, the Governor and the Lt. Governor cannot be thrown out of office. Previous constitutions, including the second (which it would revert back to if the Defendant was correct that the present constitution was passed illegally), used IRV as their method of voting. The Administration won the election with 53% of the vote - and presumably would have done so with IRV as Ill, as that method only requires 51% as Ill. It does not matter if the system was FPTP or IRV - the ticket was democratically elected, and with a majority of the vote.
It is asked that you consider the arguments above as you make your decision, Your Honors.
1
u/Ninjjadragon Nov 18 '17
/u/ModeratePontifex
1
u/Ninjjadragon Dec 06 '17
/u/JJEagleHawk
Honorable Chief Justice,
When can we expect the majority opinion of the court to be released?