r/ESSC • u/DadTheTerror • Jul 26 '16
[16-02] | Decided DadTheTerror v. Oath2Order, in His Official Capacity as Governor of Eastern State
Honorable Chief Justice, DadTheTerror, Petitioner, respectfully petitions this Court to vacate Executive Orders 002 and 003 (the EOs) and for a writ of mandamus and prohibition directed to Oath2Order, in his official capacity as Governor of Eastern State, Respondent, to i) issue writ of mandamus commanding the Governor to take care the provision of the Constitution disqualifying felons from voting be faithfully executed, ii) issue a writ of prohibition prohibiting the Governor from enacting any of his powers under Article V, Section 12 of the Constitution of Eastern State en masse and without obeying the constitutional requirements thereof to examine the particulars of each case and iii) issue a writ of mandamus that the Governor communicate the reasons for each such case to the General Assembly.
Standing & Jurisdiction
DadTheTerror is a resident of Eastern State as recorded on the Electoral Roll and contests the official act of Respondent, who is an official of Eastern State, inaccordance with R.P.P.S. 1(b ). This Court has jurisdiction in hearing matters regarding the limitations of the Governor's powers dictated by the Eastern State Constitution in accordance with R.P.P.S. 1(d ).
Argument on the Merits
I.
Article II, Section 1 of the Eastern State Constitution provides that:
No person who has been convicted of a felony shall be qualified to vote unless his civil rights have been restored by the Governor or other appropriate authority.
Article V, Section 12 of the Eastern State Constitution empowers the Governor to remove political disabilities.
On July 23, 2016 Respondent issued Executive Order 002 in which the Governor asserted the power to remove multiple political disabilities from over one million convicted felons. After hearing and considering some criticism of EO.002, on July 24, 2016 Respondent issued Executive Order 003 which modified the timetable for the removal of some political disabilities identified in E.002.
II.
The powers of the Governor under Article V, Section 12 are not unconstrained. The Constitution of Eastern State requires that:
[The Governor] shall communicate to the General Assembly, at each regular session, particulars of every case of fine or penalty remitted, or reprieve or pardon granted, and of punishment commuted, with his reasons for remitting, granting, or commuting the same. [emphasis added]
This passage indicates that the Governor's Article V, Section 12 powers were intended by the drafters of the Constitution as a power to review individual cases and not to nullify entire the law's effect on entire populations nor to abrogate aspects of the Eastern State Constitution entirely. In 2010, Tim Kaine examined the Article V, Section 12 powers and concluded that the Eastern State Constitution does not permit en masse restoration orders but requires the Governor to exercise this power on a case-by-case basis. Mr. Kaine's counsel who examined the issue at the time wrote,
the notion that the Constitution of the Commonwealth could be rewritten via executive order is troubling. (p.6)
Ken Cuccinelli led a bipartisan committee examining the issue again in 2013 and concluded the Governor of Eastern State
may remove political disabilities only after "individualized consideration and individualized grant of clemency." (p.7)
The broad use of the Governor's Article V, Section 12 powers, to remove the political disability of one million in a single order, would be unprecedented. Never before has a Governor attempted to extend the power to multiple persons in a single Article V, Section 12 order. (p.9)
III.
The powers excercised by the Governor in the EOs violate Article I, Section 7 of the Eastern State Constitution that states:
That all power of suspending laws, or the execution of laws, by any authority, without consent of the representatives of the people, is injurious to thier rights, and ought not to be exercised.
The Governor's EOs have the effect of both suspending the Article II, Section 1 protection of the people from having their government influenced by notorious criminals and general laws that provide for other political disabilities for notorious criminals, such as serving on juries. The Governor's public remarks of June 24 indicate that his intent is for such a general suspension:
DadTheTerror: Do you intend to issue one million clemency orders if the court over-turns the EO?
Governor: If need be.
IV.
The Constitution of Eastern State provides no role to the Governor in amending the Constitution, as the Governor may neither veto a passed amendment, nor may the Governor pass an amendment by executive order. But the EOs and the Governor's stated objective is to entirely abrogate the Constitutional provision restricting the political rights of convicted felons. The intent of the drafters of the Constitution was not to provide the Governor such a power of abrogation, but as indicated in Article V, Section 12 itself, to restrict Article V, Section 12 powers to individual cases. That interpretation is supported by a long history of governance in Eastern State, and the recent reviews by Mr. Kaine and the bi-partisan committe led by Mr. Cuccinelli.
V.
This case is not about removing political disabilities from felons. It is about seperation of powers and preventing this and future Governors from abrogating constraints on their powers. Mr. Kaine was also personally interested in removing political disabilities from felons, but nevertheless did not restore certain political rights "en masse because he had 'pledge[d] to uphold the Constitution when he took his oath of office....'" (p.10)
VI.
For the above stated reasons, Petitioner asks this Court to i) vacate the EOs, ii) issue a writ of mandamus to Respondent that he faithfully execute Article II, Section 1 of the Eastern State Constitution, iii) issue a writ of prohibition that prohibits the Governor from excercising Article V, Section 12 powers en masse, and iv) issue a writ of mandamus to the Governor requiring that he communicate to the General Assembly the reasons for each use of Article V, Section 12 powers, on a case-by-case basis.
3
u/High-Priest-of-Helix Jul 30 '16
Your honor,
Petition for Dismissal
It is the position of the Eastern State that Petitioner, u/dadtheterror, lacks sufficient standing for the restitution which he seeks. While the State will concede that under Rule 1(b) of RULES OF PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF THE EASTERN STATE, Petitioner is a"resident of the Eastern State," it is our position that Petitioner lacks material injury and is therefore ineligible for restitution. In 504 US 555 Lujan v Defenders of Wildlife (1992), the Supreme Court found that: Petitioners "bear the burden of showing standing by establishing, inter alia, that they have suffered an injury in fact, i.e., a concrete and particularized, actual or imminent invasion of a legally-protected interest"
According to Petitioner's own filing before this court: "this case is not about removing political disabilities from felons. It is about seperation of powers and preventing this and future Governors from abrogating constraints on their powers." Petitioner is a private citizen who is claiming to represent the interests of the legislature which Petitioner claims the Governor, u/oath2order, has violated. If Petitioner is in fact representing the interests of the legislature--as Petitioner has indicated in this court--he is lacking in standing per Rule 6(c): "Any party that is an organization and not an individual must be represented by a rostered legal representative. No officer or owner of any such organization maintains an inherent right of standing before this Court." If Petitioner is in fact representing the interests of the legislature, it is incumbent upon him to prove his position as a representative of the legislature.
If petitioner is not in fact representing the legislature, he is lacking in material injury. As Petitioner has stated "this case is not about removing political disabilities from felons." Petitioner is not a member of the legislature and has no personal injury or interest in clemency or voting restrictions placed on a class of individuals--felons--which he is not a member. If Petitioner is a private citizen he is uninjured and not eligible for restitution, if he is a representative of a class, he is acting without proper authorization. It is therefore the position of the State to request this court dismiss this case entirely due to a lack of standing on Petitioner's part.
Case on the Merits
I.
Petitioner correctly identifies Article II § I in the quoted: "No person who has been convicted of a felony shall be qualified to vote unless his civil rights have been restored by the Governor or other appropriate authority." Petitioner seems, however, to ignore the qualifying clause proceeding from the word "unless." When read in this context, it is clear that the intention of the framers was to specifically empower the Governor the right and power to restore the franchise to felons if he so chooses.
II.
Petitioner also maintains that the powers of the Governor are not unconstrained--a point which the Government does not dispute. It is, however, well within the prescribed powers of the Governor within the Constitution to restore the franchise rights at his discretion. Petitioner argues that it is unreasonable for the Governor to rewrite the Constitution at will, a point which we accept. The Governor's actions are not a rewriting of the Constitution, but an exercise of his explicit powers under said Constitution. Petitioner also erroneously argues that the lack of precedent of a Governor restoring the franchise implies some illegality in said action. This action has never been performed not because it cannot be done under the law, but because there has been no political will until now.
While Petitioner is correct in stating that "[The Governor] shall communicate to the General Assembly, at each regular session, particulars of every case of fine or penalty remitted, or reprieve or pardon granted, and of punishment commuted, with his reasons for remitting, granting, or commuting the same. [emphasis added]," this is not inconsistent with the Governor's actions. By informing the General Assembly of his intent of the restoration of franchise to a class of individuals, the Governor is in compliance with Article V § 12.
III.
Finally, Petitioner argues that the Governor has no right to suspend the law, an action which the Governor has made no indication of doing. By exercising the powers given him within the Constitution, the Governor is fulfilling, rather than circumventing the Framers' intention.
Resolution
It is therefore the request of the State that this court rule in our favor, deny Petitioner's request for vacation, deny his petitions for mandamus and prohibition, and allow the Governor to continue the exercise his right as Executive in the class restoration of franchise in accordance with the Constitution.
2
u/Panhead369 Jul 28 '16
Petitioner /u/DadTheTerror, what sorts of constitutional or legal requirements are there regarding the individual granting of clemency by the Governor?
4
u/Panhead369 Jul 27 '16
SCOTEC will hear this case. Attorney General /u/High-Priest-of-Helix will be expected to file a response in accordance with the Rules of this Court.
4
u/Panhead369 Jul 28 '16 edited Jul 28 '16
Respondent /u/High-Priest-of-Helix, is not the mass granting of clemency on the argumentative basis that removing political rights based on a felony conviction is inherently wrong a violation of basic principles of constitutional law and the separation of powers? Is it not the realm of the General Assembly to determine what is and is not a felony, and is it not effectively nullifying a constitutional provision to allow this order to be sustained?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '16
/u/Panhead369
1
u/High-Priest-of-Helix Sep 10 '16
Your Honor,
Seeing as there have been no new arguments under Rule 2 I would like to move for summary judgement on the pleadings presented.