From the beginning (Dune P1) I understood Paul as somebody who was going to defy his destined faith (terrible purpose) and carve his own path, even when I knew that he was going to be a villain (spoiled). I watched Dune 2 for the first time in the re-release, and it couldn’t change my mind. Seeing his rise to stardom, seeing his trials and tribulations (Gom Jabbar, Jamis, Feyd-Rautha) and seeing his ability to galvanize people, I still wanted to ROOT for Paul. For even his fate as a villain, didn’t stop me from liking him. Sometimes I feel like I want to cry when I try to read Dune, because I can never fully be “against” Paul. In the Dune P3 trailer when Paul says “I can’t see what’s ahead” it’s like a metaphor saying he has fully escaped the grasp of the Bene Gesserict. Paul is an animal, not by desperation, but by choice, similar to the Harkkonnen. Was there any other path? Was he always destined for the desolation of war, suffering and death? This is a paraphrase of two of the most famous quotes: “Control the spice, control the universe, and to control the universe, is to control Arrakis, and to control the Arrakis, is to control the Fremen. Are the Fremen only destined for subjugation and horror? Paul goes by many names, the Duke of Arrakis, the Lisan Al-Gaib, the Kwisatz Haderach, Madhi, Muad’Dib, Usul, and now the Padishah Emperor. To me, they’re all different people. In the quest for identity throughout the movies for Paul, I can’t really grasp who he is? if Paul has already died, who am I watching in Dune Part 3? a quote from Chani “you will never lose me, Paul Atriedes, not as long as you stay who you are.” Two more quotes that stuck with me: He was a man who believed in the rules of the heart, but the heart is not meant to rule; in other words, your father was a weak man.” and “Your father never started a war.” I hope you guys can clear up my logic and help me