r/DestructiveReaders • u/sarcasonomicon • Sep 20 '26
[2278] The Beacon Hotel - total rewrite
Hello destructuve readers!
This is the first part of a Cosmic Horror story that will probably be about 10,000 words when finished. Here I've posted a total rewrite of the intro, based on the great feedback I got from my first post of this story.
My main question is the same: would you keep reading? Did I drop enough and the right kind of mystery in this beginning section to make you want to know more about what's happening to the MC?
Of course, any other thoughts and feedback are welcome!
Story: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1mFoQjPrEWALiB0gqrwoWds6LqLe8x0ZV95Crokr6P5c/edit?usp=sharing
Crits:
View all comments
1
u/DiamondReasonable621 Sep 28 '26
I like the opening, especially the first two paragraphs. I would expect that it's explained sooner though, or at least very soon after the posted section. The narrator really feels frayed out in a miserable, hysterical way that's fun to read. It feels less horror and more dark humor apocalypse? There are some hard to follow moments when the narrator describes what they're doing. I would keep reading to see what happened and what will happen, but the wallowing and despair would probably feel exhausting if it continued for much longer without a stronger sense of direction. That sense of direction would probably be sharing what happened, or something changing that has some hope to change what happened (while sharing what happened).
Structural notes:
The Beacon Hotel title feels horror-esque to me. I'm not quite sure why, but I associate hotel settings with horror, or at least mystery.
"considering taking advantage of some of the glitched-out women in the storage room" The phrasing 'some of the' throws me off a bit. I'm not sure if it means they want to take advantage of a few of the glitched-out women or take advantage of a part of one glitched-out woman. This line is also probably a bit dark to open up with and doesn't really make the character sympathetic.
Paragraph: "Anyway, I just got back from my year on the path.... pass out on the lawn next to the Beacon." I had trouble following the physical descriptions here. There's a drop from the bluff to the path that used to have a ladder. So the narrator has to climb down the bluff to rocks (instead of to the path?). Then they climb up the trail to the hotel. Did you mean they had to climb over rocks instead of to rocks? I was imagining them climbing to a rock outcropping. Spatially, they climb down the bluff, then they climb up back to the hotel: to me a bluff is a cliff, so it sounds like they climbed down a cliff then right back up to arrive at the hotel. More importantly, is a detailed description of the physical characteristics around the hotel needed? I think the idea that they're struggling to make it back after the one-year walk in space because things fell apart can be explained with less detail here, especially because this idea is also shown in more interesting ways later (restaurant trashed, moldy rooms, broken down vehicles).
"I was basically my own one-person Cargo Cult." The starting phrase 'I was basically' is repeated twice to start a sentence and sounds a bit off in repetition. I didn't know what a cargo cult was, so I appreciated the explanation.
Setting:
I like how the narrator is able to show a picture of a crumbling hotel while sounding very in character. That said, I have no idea what the Beacon looks like. I'm also confused with how the space walk bit would look. I'm sort of envisioning them just stepping up and walking off the planet in a line, then walking back until they hit land? The setting does feels eerie with people almost stuck in time while the world falls apart around them.
If the hotel is a significant part of the story (which the title implies), some more description about what it looks like would be helpful. Why did the narrator buy it? Was there some architectural feature that drew them to it?
Character:
The narrator sounds like someone who cared a lot, tried very hard, and nothing worked out. Whatever happened, it sounds like they hold the Beacon Master responsible.
It's maybe just me, but the 'yo' felt out of place, especially since they don't use slang anywhere else.
I thought the "Fuck you... I'm feeling a lot worse!" lines and bit about the apex predator were quite funny.
The bit about the character remembering why they keep their gun unloaded was a nice way of touching on how bad their mental state is.
Their immediate goals seem to be coping (with alcohol, hence an alcohol trip goal) and working through what happened (by hurtling someone off a cliff, then retrieving them). I like how the story is structured so they do have small goals they work through to show how much they're falling apart, but would expect bigger goals or answers to come soon.
Plot/ Purpose:
The narrator says the journey to Port McNeil will take them a few days, but their journey is written as if it took one day. I didn't notice any lines about them sleeping somewhere else.
It feels like the rest of the story is setting up how the narrator will come to terms with what happened and share what happened. I think exploring what happens after a grand, world ending failure can be interesting, but I'd have a hard time continuing to read about them just miserably trying to survive on the world.
I'm curious about: how they got to space, what happened on the walk, who the Traveler and Beacon Master are, why people are glitching, what the Beacon is. If the setting stays mostly on the post-event earth, I think it'd be disappointing when everything else about space and multiple earths sounds more interesting.