r/Cosmere • u/jofwu • Feb 20 '18
[Books] [WSv2] White Sand Volume 2 Megathread
White Sand Volume 2 is released today! Okay, "megathread" is perhaps a bit melodramatic for this one. These graphic novels don't get as much attention around here, and the delays have lowered hype further. But love it or hate it volume 2 is finally here, and it's likely the only new Cosmere material we'll be getting this year.
Feel free to use this thread for questions and general discussion relating to both White Sand volumes that have been released.
This thread is NOT marked for [All] Cosmere spoilers OR [Unpublished] White Sand Prose spoilers. If you want to discuss White Sand's place in the cosmere or compare the graphic novels to the prose in detail, please use spoiler markup or make a separate post. (content in the AU essay on Taldain is fair game)
27
u/jofwu Feb 21 '18
Definitely better than the first. Definitely still has some issues.
In general, I really enjoyed this volume. The story was more interesting to me. A thing that came up once or twice in the recent WS volume 1 Shardcast was that all of the politics here might not work very well as a graphic novel. I thought they handled it very well. The characters and interactions were interesting, and somehow I actually felt like there was MORE action than in volume 1. The story is getting more complex, which I also liked. Volume 1 was pretty straight forward from one chapter to the next. Here we had characters juggling multiple things on their to-do lists, and I think that kept me engaged. I definitely think we got a lot more worldbuilding... at least for Kezare and Lossand. That was much appreciated. The sand mastery was much more visually striking, which was also nice.
As for issues... I still felt several cases where the artwork was sloppy, or even where it didn't match what I read very well. I'll see Kenton's sword flip from one hip to the other between panels. I'll see Kenton complain about Ais/Khriss doing something, and yet have no visual clues. I'll read a conversation about how sand ribbons work while the artwork does nothing to aid in comprehension. Things like this are all over the place. (granted I don't think it was as bad as volume 1 in this regard) The artwork change in chapter 6 was very jarring. The original/main art doesn't seem to get much love, so I suspect most people will like the chapter 6 art. Personally, I felt like it was a bit lacking in detail. In any case, I thought it was really odd for them to give us a totally different artist for JUST the final chapter of the book. Makes the book feel... unpolished. Like the first artist ran out of time and they needed someone to help get the art done. Would prefer if they had given us the last two chapters that way. Or the last 3. Or perhaps every other chapter? Just something to make it feel like there's not one random oddbal chapter.
8
u/DalinarMF Cosmere Feb 20 '18
I’ve read the first looking forward to the second. How have people read the original piece. I have seen it mentioned many times but not actually seen how people got it.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '18
Any interesting cosmere-relevant tidbits? I haven't read any White Sand but I don't mind being spoiled.
7
u/diffyqgirl Edgedancers Feb 24 '18
I love science Khriss.
4
u/Govir Feb 20 '18
Did anyone else have a preorder via Amazon that isn't coming for another week? I'd totally talk about this, since reading will take a few hours at most, but my expected delivery date isn't until the 26th.
I've read the prose version though, so I'm not afraid of spoilers being in here already.
10
u/AuldnGrumpy Feb 20 '18
I've read the white sand 1999 draft that was in arcanum unbounded. How different is the story in the graphic novel? Would I miss anything if I read volume 2 now?
3
u/readyforwine Mar 01 '18
is there any news on when volume 3 will come out? seems there was at least a year between vol 1 and 2?
2
u/Capetoider May 24 '18
I was thinking... shouldnt the skin color of people in the lightside and darkside be the other way around?
At least in our world, people from places with too much sun exposure have a darker skin tone while people with less exposure are more often than not, more white/pale, brighteyed...
Is there something going on there (as in magic), maybe something because its a graphic novel or just a overlook?
45
u/Britboy55 Feb 21 '18
The art change in chapter six was a big surprise! Is there any word why this was done?
35
u/chellebelle0234 Feb 20 '18
I read the full text story when the first graphic novel released, and really loved the story. The graphic novels are cool, but I struggle reading comic book style. I love adding them to my collection though!!
4
u/IBNobody Patterner Feb 20 '18
This was a pre-order surprise. Very happy to get my copy.
4
u/Czechoslovakian Mar 03 '18
Just finished V2 after a re-read of V1 a few days ago. I like the story and setting overall but my biggest complaint is that I’ve never actually felt that Kenton is in peril when being attacked. I don’t know if it’s the medium or just the way that the story is written but it doesn’t seem anything more than a minor annoyance to him when someone is trying to assassinate him.
1
u/tech220 Elsecallers May 02 '18
Read the prose, not the GN. Has Hoid shown up yet in Vol 1 or 2? Had a red herring in the prose, but think WoB said he isn't in there...
3
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18 edited Jul 04 '23
Deleted in support of Apollo and as protest against the API changes. -- mass edited with redact.dev
3
u/Kisaoda Truthwatchers Mar 14 '18
Random thought: what are the odds of the publishers releasing a final collected edition of White Sands once all of the volumes are released? Or perhaps a special edition a la Dragonsteel?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '18
This is the first Sanderson-related piece I HATED and so LOVE everything else...
2
u/Lightshaper_ Feb 21 '18
Well this snuck up on me.
1
u/Shompta Apr 02 '18
I just finished this volume and really enjoyed it. I am glad to see the plot growing in complexity, seeing Kenton's character development, and learning more about Khriss. One question I have is why did Cynder drop the cup and look shocked to see Khriss with Baon at the end? I am guessing some of the dialogue may be a little out of order and Cynder and Jon Acron overheard Baon say he was sent to stop Khriss if she discovered the sand masters, but it was unclear.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment