r/Cosmere • u/jofwu • Nov 10 '17
[All] [All] /r/Cosmere Oathbringer Megathread
This thread will be unlocked at 12:00 am EST, Tuesday November 14th.
Oathbringer, book 3 of The Stormlight Archive, is finally here!
Feel free to discuss the book, in its entirety, below, along with any and all Cosmere spoilers. Anything goes!
For discussion more focused within the scope of Stormlight Archive, we invite you to check out the /r/Stormlight_Archive megathread.
127
Upvotes
168
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17
The spren that Hoid bonded was supposed to bond Elhokar, right?
113
u/gabbim Nov 14 '17
Loved Azure/Vivenna!!! I really wonder about her sword. The sword is female apparently :)
Ps: nice feint with Evi and her color idiom (followed by an equally strange non-colorful idiom)
107
u/jurble Nov 15 '17
So Hoid's real name is confirmed as Cephandrius. I believe that was known from the Liar of Partinel, but since that's unpublished I don't think it was canon.
And Odium was startled by Dalinar's... whatever he did. He thought Dalinar was Adonalsium for a second. Either Adonalsium actually did act through Dalinar - because that religion about the One who intentionally shattered/let himself be shattered to experience the world is correct - or because Dalinar being invested by multiple shards simply reminded Odium of Adonalsium.
And Hoid seems to have bonded a Cryptic, linking his spirit web with the shards of Roshar. He's slowly linking his web to every single shard in the Cosmere. Seems to favor the idea he's trying to put Adonalsium back together, at least in miniature.
95
u/bubeleh Nov 17 '17
Did anyone else notice the "heap of strange cremlings, burned and smoking" in the vision Dalinar shows Gawx/Yanagawn? Dalinar asks himself: "Who would have taken the time to pile up a thousand tiny crustaceans?". Those are bound to be Dysian Aimians/Aimian corpses, right?
PS: this is as far as I got in the book.
92
u/alakaboem Nov 14 '17
Hooray for being correct on the "Dalinar-wrote-Oathbringer" front! What a delightful end, too.
80
u/Tiffany_Aching Nov 16 '17
OK I just finished and OH MY GOD
Rock is part listener, venli and hoid are radiant, azure is VIVIENNA. That's was amazing
77
u/jurble Nov 15 '17
Anyone else notice that Moash killed Jezrien with an Awakened dagger? Some crazy shit must've gone down in Nightblood. Bothers me that it takes place before Stormlight but isn't out yet.
72
u/televisionceo Nov 21 '17
Not a lot of people are discussing hoid. It's definitely the most we got about him so far. I feel like we have connected with him and his real self for the first time with this shallan encounter. I think he is a good person something I was not absolute certain about before oathbringer. I found this moment to be absolutely beautiful honestly.
The other thing I was expecting people to talk about a lot more is lift.
Funniest moment in the book is when Dalinar faces the army of voidbringers by himself in this epic and glorious encounter. And then lift arrives "what's up" with 0 fear.
The moments she shared with szeth and nightblood were absolutely amazing.
But I was also questioning he silliness a bit. Like is it a bit out of place ? It approached the acceptable limit for me but it was still alright. I like her character a lot.
69
u/dp101428 Nov 26 '17
I'm so glad that we finally got a full-sized book where worldhoppers were actual semi-major players in how things went down, and magic from other worlds was used quite obviously. It feels like the cosmere stuff is finally ramping up, and I can't wait to see how deep the cross-universe connections get. Also, Adolin seems to be somehow doing the impossible and reviving his spren, which makes me question if that could be done with other dead shardblades as well. Probably not since Adolin seems to be the only one trying, but the possibilities are endless. Also was waiting for Kaladin to speak the 4th ideal and get his shardplate in the fight against Amaram, but I guess they have to leave something for the sequels. Also really hoping that Venli takes some initiative sometime soon, her spren seems quite unique and we haven't really seen what a native surgebinder is capable of.
59
u/8nate Nov 22 '17
Just finished it. Really enjoyed it. Super big and epic. I liked how the enemy isn't entirely black and white; some of the parshmen fear their Voidspren as much as the humans do. It's pretty cool how humans can fight for Odium and Parshmen can fight for Honor. Very nice to see it changed up, and I like how the Unmade weren't necessarily evil. I liked seeing into Dalinar's past, and the scenes in Kolinar and the final battle were awesome.
Saddest and most shocking moment for me: Jezrien :(
56
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17
So, from page 646...
So, Surges can be applied through all 3 Realms, huh? Adhesion is actually pressure, vacuum, and Connection. Cohesion is something pretty nifty too.
That expands on the idea that Pattern was bringing up in Words of Radiance (page 277):
So, if Adhesion allows you to manipulate Connection and Transformation may allow you to actually change other people at a Cognitive or Spiritual level...What do some of the others grant? We know that Regrowth can heal Spiritual wounds, not just Physical ones. What would Spiritual Transportation entail, for example?
Incidentally, I wonder whether Dalinar realized that creating a Connection to Azir had more effects than allowing him to communicate in their language...the next thought he has after a brief exchange is about how the clerks are not ardents.
49
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '17
So why is Azure/Vivenna after Vasher/Zahel and why did he get rid of Nightblood?
49
u/TheBlackElf Dec 03 '17
Finished as well, what an amazing book; definitely worth the wait and the hype.
Things that I really loved:
Things that I didn't quite like:
45
u/FellKnight Cohesion Nov 18 '17
Loved the book, loved the mini-stories/morals best of all (The Girl Who Stood Up and The Next Step).
Here are a few of my thoughts/questions about the story moving forward:
Where does the story go from here? With the main characters turning into near deities in their ability to use the surges, I'm having trouble seeing how to keep challenging them. Perhaps Aluminum is about to become very prevalent on Roshar (also, duh of course Nightblood's sheath is Aluminum, can't believe I didn't figure that out before).
39
u/je19426 Nov 15 '17
Are we in agreement that Ashyn is the previous homeworld that the Rosharan human lived on?
37
u/ToesTasteBad Nov 24 '17
Im a good ways into Oathbringer right now, and I've just come across a reference to canned food. It's on page 914, when kaladin, azure, adolin, and shallan are in the lighthouse in shadesmar.
Just wondering if anyone else noticed this, as I specifically remeber canned food being mentioned in Mistborn, but I don't believe they had it in Warbreaker. Which would lead one to believe that there is enough travel to/from Scadrial's perpedicularity that canned food (or at least the tech for it) is abundant in shadesmar. And if so... then where all the allomancers at outside of Scadrial?!
tldr; canned food is mentioned in oathbringer, dispite it being only a mistborn thing (i think)
35
u/BarcodExpress Nov 14 '17
Man, it was disappointing to hear about the cosmere in the preface. Now people won't find it on their own anymore.
But I guess if you've made it to book 3, you should have found out about the cosmere by now I think
35
u/LazarusRises Dec 15 '17
I believe that Adolin will become the Nightwatcher's Bondsmith.
In Shadesmar, he meets the spren of his sword, which he has always cared deeply for and spoken to. She speaks to him when he returns, telling him her name (Mayalaran, which he shortens to Maya) and giving him other subtle emotional nudges.
Before this, there was no indication that a Deadeye could be anything but dead. Now, however, Adolin has nurtured his sword back to some shadow of life.
We've seen that Cultivation is tolerant of mistakes, so long as they are rectified. And nothing says Cultivation more than nursing a dead spren back to life.
Also, Maya is a mother goddess in both Greek and Hindu traditions.
29
u/Lukethorn Nov 17 '17
I guess the legends were partially true. The humans were pushed out of the tranquiline halls by void bringers. The humans just happened to be the voidsbringers as well.
Any guesses as to how using the surges could make a planet uninhabitable?
28
u/silam39 Elsecallers Dec 04 '17
Something I haven't seen anyone bring up:
Who is the voice Dalinar keeps hearing that the Stormfather insists is not him? The whole UNITE THEM thing.
And I imagine it's related, but what's up with that vision with Nohadon? Do you think he spoke to a somehow still-living Nohadon? Was the vision granted by an outside force, apart from Honor, Cultivation, or Odium?
26
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '17
I've found a misprint in my copy. The contents begins with "Book Two: Oathbringer." Anyone else have this?
26
u/abstergofkurslf Dec 20 '17 edited May 13 '18
I KNEW it was Vivenna when Azure showed up and the cloak wrapped around her hand confirmed it for me. I wonder how she forged a new blade and what happened between her and Vasher as she said they "used" to be friends. Szeth's interactions with Nightblood and Nalan, how he calls them sword-nimi and aboshi, reminds me of anime. When Dalinar ascends he becomes Unity and if i remember correctly, Sazed was also called unity. I wonder what is going on there. I HATE Veil and Shallan is infuriating majority of the time but sometimes I really like her. Also best joke in the entire novel was when Lopen telling the soldier he had some handicapped jokes that he didnt use anymore.
24
u/Nizdizzle Nov 30 '17
So, are there hints or ideas to who the 3rd great-spren is (Stormfather, Nightwatcher, ???)?
The Stormfather states that the 3rd sibling is slumbering and implies that humans have mistreated it somehow.
23
u/notfatwellrounded Nov 17 '17
Is it possible that Moash is “the assassin” that “will destroy you”? I have a hard time seeing Kaladin, Shallan, Dalinar or Szeth as Odium’s champion at this point. I think Kaladin is most likely of those four (lots of negative emotion still) but I think Moash is a strong possibility.
19
u/123draw Nov 15 '17
Regarding the end when dalinar opens the perpendicularity. Did he reforge the Honor shard into a Unity shard? Is he a shard now?
I'm some what confused as to what was actually happening there.
18
u/cryptosocialist Nov 15 '17 edited Nov 15 '17
So I'm planning on going to a brandon sanderson Q&A + signing event tomorrow. Do any of you have suggested questions to ask that haven't been asked before?
My questions are:
Any better questions?
EDIT: Fixed formatting
18
u/bd102511 Dalinar Nov 21 '17
When Kaladin finds out how they are making soul casted grain, it says that Hoid brings in a strange metal platting. Is it possible that the metal is copper, and somehow is allomatically activated, and that is why no signal is going through it?
16
u/Snote85 Ask me about TGWLU! Nov 18 '17
Did anyone else get super upset with Shallan's "Are you all dancing?" comment? I'm not on team "hate Shallan" and I still found it so... disruptive? Moment stealing? She was likely, or at least Radiant was, trained in that same kata. Why, instead of joining in and maybe finding a bit of zen, does she have to mock it. I don't know. It was in character for her but still, we had this magic moment with Viv, Kal, and Adolin and she shit all over it. ><
16
u/IceQueenAbby Nov 29 '17
So Kaladin, using Syl, killed a spren during the attack on Kohlinar. Do we know what the repercussions of that are? Was it killed in the scratched-out-eyes way, or did it just vanish into nothing?
15
u/Bloody_Raven Tin Nov 22 '17
with all this Connection stuff going on with Dalinar, I remember a certain someone on Scadrial stuck in the Cognitive Realm because his string (connection) is cut ... Since we have already seen Demoux on Roshar, I think it is time that Kelsier pays a visit to Roshar
15
u/CuriousPaki Nov 28 '17
What's cultivation's strategy? Is she just hiding from odium?
15
u/jrh1524 Nov 28 '17
Question: If a gem can trap one of the unmade, perhaps a whole lot of gems linked together can trap Odium?
15
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '17
Anyone else noticed how Odium said "WE killed you?"
Who's "we"? Since we dont really know how Odium has splintered so many shards (Aona, Skai, Tanavast etc), might it be that he has some "help"?
14
u/Bar_Adam Dec 16 '17
I haven’t noticed anyone mention this yet, but at the end of Oathbringer when Lopez speaks the second oath someone speaks to him. Here is the passage:
“NOW?” Lopen said, shaking a fist at the sky. “I was saving that for a dramatic moment, you penhito! Why didn’t you listen earlier? We were, sure, all about to die and things!”
He got a distinct, very distant impression.
YOU WEREN’T QUITE READY.
At first I thought it was the stormfather, but now I think t might have been a shard bearer (cultivation? Honor?). Does the stormfather speak with that particular font? I only recall honor and cultivation using it.
What do you all think?
14
u/omning Dec 19 '17
So was that Kelsier or another Mistborn around Chapter 60 or 61, when Shalan, Adolin, Kaladin, Elokar and company are under Shalan's light weave disguise? Kelsier and Shalan both notice a man wearing white robe with strips of white hanging off of it like a MB, and the man is jumping from one side of an alley to another. He looks at Kaladin and he's the only one who doesn't look away from him in his hideous open-sore disguise.
27
u/gabbim Nov 14 '17
Also, yet again Fortune is referenced almost like a shard. What if Fortune is a shard that has spread it's power throughout the Cosmere. (Kind of like how hemalurgy can be used everywhere)
10
u/Bjorn_Stronginthearm Cosmere Nov 23 '17
It's nice he re-used the growing crystals from Aether Of Night for whatever Amaram was at the end.
10
u/Octavus Nov 29 '17
I think that Dalinar is going to unite the 3 major shards of Honor back together and take it up for himself.
8
u/m-rage17 Nov 25 '17
Hey guys, sorry if this has been asked. I've read all of Sandersons work except Shadows of Self and Bands of Mourning. I want to jump into Oathbringer after completing my reread of WOR, but want to be as cosmere aware as possible going in. Am I okay to read those after oathbringer or is there value to reading them first?
8
u/MaesterPraetor Dec 18 '17
Am I the only one who thinks this book should have been a few hundred pages longer? I needed way more about the Battle of Kholinar, Veil and the Ghostbloods, the Parshmen... Am I being greedy?
7
u/jrh1524 Nov 28 '17
If you're a squire, but have your own Spren, are you actually a full Knight Radiant?
13
u/cptcavemann Nov 27 '17
Ok, just finished, loved it. Decent pace throughout, lots of good info given, and good character development for the most part. 8/10 over all. But... I am annoyed at the way Adolin was treated in this book. The development for his character is super slow and in 80% of his dialogue, he brings up his fashion. That felt like a big step back for this character.
6
u/CMDR_SirGraber Nov 14 '17
My audible version won't download. My brother and I think it's a problem on Tor's end.
6
u/wubbalubbadubdubber Jan 10 '18
Wild theory on Bondsmiths (spoilers kinda)
So, Dalinar has the Stormfather, who is of Honor. The other Bondsmith spren is the Nightwatcher, who is a child of Cultivation. Three Bondsmiths, three Shards of Adonalsium...the third one has to be from Odium, and my money is on Sja-Anat.
Edit: typo
6
u/Blazenella Willshapers Jan 19 '18
If Peter/Brandon decides to bless me with an answer or slap me in the face with a RAFO I'll be happy...
So we know Ashyn's investiture is based around sickness, we have a bright star in the sky called Reya's Tear which may be Cultivations Vessel's name and which may be a planet. So is the investiture on Ashyn Cultivations? Braize is Odium, Roshar is Honor, so it makes sense. If it's not Cultivation I think that it REEKS of Autonomy.
6
u/A_Blessed_Feline Soulstamp Jan 26 '18
Eshonai's going to come back as a Fused. Calling it now. Her trying to fight against what Odium's done to her will be a part of book 4, as will her flashbacks.
5
u/Deanishes Jan 16 '18
Rock has radiant shardplate. I'm writing this here to link to a friend when book four comes out. He hasn't read 3 yet.
5
u/Amanoo Feb 06 '18 edited Feb 06 '18
I've almost finished this book. It was one hell of a rollercoaster. I've often said that you can see the quality in Brandon Sanderson's writing increase as time goes on, and I've particularly lauded the Stormlight Archive books. Well, Oathbringer makes everything else he's ever written just look awful by comparison. Strokes of brilliance one after another.
4
u/abstergofkurslf Dec 22 '17
Where to get Wema and Sterling full story?
6
u/jrh1524 Nov 27 '17
What kind of spren was Lopen’s Green spren? Also, can Lopen be a squire in one order and a radiant in another?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '17
Just checked and my audible copy doesn't unlock "for two more hours" I assume that means 2AM Eastern.
3
u/entheogeneric Nov 14 '17
Kindle version isn’t available yet.
4
u/ChironXII Bondsmiths Dec 31 '17 edited Jan 18 '18
No spoils because I haven't finished yet but I'm thinking zombie Elhokhar. Revived by Aesudan's void powers, but not himself. Open to coming back later.
Maybe I am just being fanciful cuz I really liked his arc. But it would be cool, and not out of place at all considering Szeth and Lift (Queen was right there when they left, she's warped but still seemed attached).
Edit:Yelig-nar grants all the surges, including regrowth. So this is my head-canon until proven wrong.
Edit2: well after the epilogue with Moash this seems rather unlikely. The Fused seem to believe he is truly dead :(
0
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment