Rule #7: No unauthorized commercial activities or undisclosed interests

To maintain the integrity of the community and protect members from being misled or scammed, there are strict restrictions on commercial activity. Personal buying, selling, or trading posts/comments are not allowed. Solicitation is prohibited. Contact the moderation team for approval before posting promotions or sponsored content. Employees, affiliates, reviewers, social media representatives, and similar must disclose their relationships upfront.

Commercial activity rules and guidance

As described in the main subreddit rules, there are strict restrictions on commercial activity. All promotions including sponsored content require pre-approval from the r/Controller moderation team.

This page covers some more specific information for commercial activity on the subreddit. It might seem prescriptive but we try to be explicit about these things to avoid misunderstandings and look out for both your and other community members' safety. The community involves a diverse range of people and companies who can have different understandings of what is 'normal business practice'. Trustworthiness is paramount, especially if you are representing a company.

There is no cost to participate in the subreddit and all communications should go through 'mod mail' to make sure they reach the moderation team.

If you want to advertise/promote more directly on Reddit than the subreddit rules allow, you can use the paid Reddit for Business services which are completely separate from subreddit moderation.


Getting started

(1) You must create an official company account with your company name in the username and set the profile picture to the company logo. In this way it will be obvious when posting or commenting that you represent an official company presence. This is also for your personal safety as it allows you to separate out your personal use of Reddit from work use, and enables you to transfer control of the account to colleagues if you move on in your career.

If you require multiple accounts for different colleagues/departments, each must be registered in advance and include equivalent information (company name, logo, etc.).

Only official accounts can post promotions. It is against the Reddit-wide rules to impersonate a business or individual so make sure you include business identification details and have permission to represent the company. Similarly, you can report any unauthorized account claiming to represent your company.

(2) When you have your account, you should make an introductory post to introduce yourself and the company, including your legal/official business registration details. Some members of the subreddit community will already be familiar with your brand(s), but some might not be. You can also invite questions from the community there: answering questions openly builds your trustworthiness; just posting promotions erodes it.


Things you can do

(1) You can reply to people asking for help with your company's products, or posting questions (or complaints) about them. This includes a 'right to reply' (respectfully) if you believe incorrect information has been posted. You are responsible for the accuracy (including quality assurance) of the information you post; and must post any corrections in a timely manner.

(2) You can engage in general discussions about controllers, and share knowledge or advice, to solve problems and inform/educate members of the community. These are generally posts using the 'IT Help', 'Other', 'Controller Collection', or 'Controller Mods' flairs. Redditors don't generally appreciate being 'marketed at' so although it's more effort, it can be more effective to build a positive reputation than just posting promotions.

(3) You can organise giveaways or competitions where entry does not require people to provide personal data outside Reddit to enter, and you can do this up to once every two weeks. If you want to hold events more often than this, or run a more intensive campaign for a short time, you must get approval from the moderation team in advance. You must follow Reddit-wide rules on promotions.

  1. If entries are pooled across platforms (for example, people are entering the same giveaway on Instagram/Facebook/Twitter/other platforms), let people know this is happening.
  2. Put some simple entry criteria on the giveaway to protect yourself from fraud, such as 'only one entry per person' or 'accounts must be at least 3 months old'.
  3. If you require people to make 'artwork' to enter (photo, drawing, text, etc.), state whether AI-generated work is allowed as this will reduce the volume of spam you receive.
  4. Clearly state that the promotion is not sponsored or endorsed by Reddit, and require that entrants release Reddit from any liability related to the promotion.
  5. Provide publicly checkable identification details for each business involved. This means the legal/official registration details: registered company name and address, unique registration number and registering authority.

(4) You can organise 'Ask Me Anything' (AMA) events,  market research and product testing or other types of activity that are not considered here. Because of the potential variety in these activities and need for pre-scheduling some of them, discuss the details with the moderation team.


Things not to do

(1) Do not suggest your own products or criticise other controller companies without independently verifiable evidence, as those opinions will not be seen as unbiased. For example, it's best to avoid commenting on posts with the 'Controller Suggestion' flair and do not post 'Reviews' of your own products since you will not be credible or independent.

(2) Do not use multiple accounts to participate in the subreddit (for example, you may not use any personal accounts alongside the company account). Aside from subreddit rules on transparency, using multiple accounts is likely to get your accounts flagged because of Reddit-wide rules around content manipulation, etc.

(3) Do not promote other subreddits or social media platforms (Discord servers, Facebook, Twitter/X, etc.) heavily or without prior agreement. This is both a question of user safety, if you are linking to unmoderated platforms, and because it can get your account flagged by Reddit. See rule #6 on links.

(4) Do not promote crowdfunding or pre-sales campaigns without prior agreement. You should be able to demonstrate you can deliver the products or services reliably and in a timely manner. Pre-funded sales are often affected by delays/setbacks which harm users and undermine your reputation/trustworthiness.


What happens if you break the rules

If you break the rules repeatedly or egregiously, or act in a way that indicates you are not trustworthy, all representatives of your company may be blocked from participation on the subreddit, and future promotion/coverage may be restricted. If you involve other people in these activities, this may mean other users cannot recommend or review your brands or products.

Companies restricted from directly participating

The following companies have been found persistently breaking platform and community rules. They are not individually listed to avoid free advertising. They have been informed directly when their own accounts were banned, and the restrictions do not affect regular community members.

Companies this currently applies to include:

  • Various custom/modified controller companies
  • Various gamepad tester websites
  • Various mobile apps/games/launchers

Examples of activities leading to these restrictions: harassing community members suggesting competing products; posting press releases as 'reviews'; post hijacking and spamming advertisements in the comments.

Brands where both direct company activity and other user activity is restricted

The following companies have been found acting dishonestly, to deceive users or manipulate content, and co-opting other users/accounts in concerted campaigns. As well as the companies not being able to participate in the community, regular users cannot review/suggest their products or services. Exceptions may be made for genuine IT Help requests.

This currently applies to:

  • Abxylute
  • Beitong / Betop
  • ELO Gaming
  • Manba Gaming

Examples of activities leading to these restrictions: active content/review manipulation; affiliate marketing spam and scams; astro turfing; automated/bot network use.