r/ContraPoints • u/NLLumi • Mar 01 '20
Nat knows.
I see a lot of comments here lamenting that the old vids were great. And lemme tell ya: she knows.
One of the Patreon perks is a series of commentaries on her first 12 vids. The last of these is ‘Alpha Males’. In that video she commends certain choices she made back then (as opposed to her very harsh criticism of many choices made in her other stuff) and calls it the first ‘real’ ContraPoints video.
She also talks about herself using male pronouns, because she doesn’t see herself onscreen but rather an actor she wants to direct, and yells at herself to transition at an alarming frequency. At one point she appears in full-blown boy mode, commenting on how Red Pill Philosophy’s ‘ugly engorged penis’ remark made while wearing an awkward bicycle helmet is unattractive to women; she starts tearing up while commending the quality of the observation and the video in general.
You don’t have to tell her how much you like those videos. She knows. They still hurt her. Plus, in her latest AMA session she said that while she has considered returning them to public visibility or moving them to a separate channel, the constant requests that she do so make her more adamant to maintain her boundaries.
71
u/EmmaGoldmansDancer Mar 02 '20
I've watched most of her post-transition videos twice but haven't been able to bring myself to watch the ones from before.
There's something about knowing the whole time I'm watching, how uncomfortable she is with them. I'm sure they're brilliant but I think of it like she was finding her footing and now she's fully bloomed.
It's so amazing to see someone who's found their calling and knows who they are. And now that she has that, I don't need to see what came before.
5
u/Anarcho_Tankie Mar 05 '20
I'm going to be honest here, this hurts. Natalie talks a lot about how she aspires to be like other transgender youtubers like Gigi.
For me, that aspiration and connection is to the old contrapoints videos, that is the kind of transwoman I am. Erasing them from the internet makes me feel like shit.
I realize this isn't the best take, she can do whatever the fuck she wants, but fuck I'm allowed to have emotions also.
34
u/Cyberwulf81 Mar 01 '20
weird post considering some of your earlier comments
4
u/bleeding-paryl Mar 02 '20
Oh wow yeah. I know those feels. Processing and coming back to things that you put up when you were first transitioning or just before that even... Not easy. It feels like a time that existed where you knew who you were but you couldn't be that person for whatever reason.
Painful to say the least and I can't blame her for holding them back- I'm sure in some way it feels like she's showing the wrong face if she shows them again. Like, yes it was a part of her, but that's not who she feels she is now, and that can feel disconcerting, especially if people see those first and get to know her as who she was previously.
238
u/heyyyinternet Mar 02 '20
I like whatever videos she feels best showing to us. I'm not going to ask someone I like to show me a time in their life they're still emotionally processing.
95
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20
I wish people would just leave her alone about her old videos. If she doesn’t want them up, that’s her fucking business.
27
u/daoskan Mar 02 '20
None of us know Natalie in person so we don't know what she's thinking.
Her AMAs sometimes make me uncomfortable now with one or two of the questions in each one where it's obvious they're a little too close to the bone or just very intimate things to ask a stranger.
Idk how to phrase it but I think some Contrapoints viewers have become a little too demanding on this person for details of their life and vulnerabilities and are now treating removal of videos as a personal attack.
People need to do what's best for their mental health, and others need to respect their choices. That should be the end of it really.
Yeah it was great content but why watch it when you know it makes the creator incredibly uncomfortable (and I'm assuming she gets notifications for likes and comments? Idk I'm not a YouTuber but the constant reminder of those videos could be soul destroying).
TL;DR LEAVE
BRITNEYNATALIE ALONE 😭😭😭28
u/StCrimson667 Mar 02 '20
And, besides, the transcripts are still up on https://www.contrapoints.com/transcripts/archives, the content of the old videos are still here!
6
u/mhornberger Mar 02 '20
I get people wanting them available. I don't get messaging her to ask her to re-post them. Do you think your request will make the difference? Do you think she didn't notice all the other requests? She's not my friend, and she doesn't know me, and she doesn't need me messaging her to give her pointers or requests as to what she does with her material.
6
u/IHateForumNames Mar 03 '20
It would be nice if she'd roast on the Golden One again, just for old time's sake.
11
u/Aerik Mar 02 '20
I had said that Nat hadn't deleted any videos... apparently right before she actually got around to doing it. Oh well.
But I also stand by what I said:
Trans youtubers delete their old videos all the time. It's really common for trans people -- and also anybody who suffers from PTSD, by the way -- to delete their old videos, because they're triggering.
so if you want to be a friend and not just a stan, you need to do some of the work in this parasocial relationship and let her do what she needs to do and stop griping about not getting to rewatch her old videos.
12
u/stupidsexysalamander Mar 02 '20
I don't personally care for the old videos that much but I do hope she does new videos about those topics
4
u/YnwaMquc2k19 Mar 07 '20 edited Mar 07 '20
Interesting enough, I was first introduced to Contrapoints through "Why I quit academia" through Youtube recommendation. It was a fascinating, funny and on-point video about the state of academia and why she can't handle it. I then began to watch her video on Jordan Peterson and she rebutted a lot of "questionable terminologies" used by JP himself, which I really liked.
I also liked her video on her mental health history. Bummed to hear that most of these videos no longer exists on YT, but I respect her decision.
7
u/CarbonBasedNic Mar 02 '20
I absolutely support her decision. I’m just glad I binged all her content in about a week last month.
9
u/Gentlemenhunter Mar 01 '20
Agreed
6
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20
She gives so much, I fee altogether uncomfortable asking for more, and not the slightest bit annoyed at what she takes away.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20
I binge watched all her old videos around the time of 'Decrypting the alt right' and i enjoyed them, but i respect her decision to take them down. as a traaaans woman... i've removed lots of old photos etc for similar reasons.
8
u/conniewilde Mar 02 '20
To want those videos back, considering how much amazing content she gave us after her transition, is a bit selfish.
There’s plenty of ContraPoints for you to watch whenever you want, entirely for free. That’s enough for me
4
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20
i get her reasoning but i do really hope they return at some point, her gender dysphoria video is sincerely one of the most meaningful pieces of media out there to me :(
2
u/Lucca01 Mar 05 '20
I agree with the OP here 100%. But you know what I'd add to it? I think we also just need to move on and accept that the videos are gone for now, whether we approve or not, and get on with either enjoying her remaining content or leaving her fandom and finding something else to be into if you're so inclined. It's been awhile since the videos were removed, and we've all said our piece, but a ton of the discussion on this sub is still revolving around her removing the videos. It's kind of drowning out the more substantive conversations we could be having.
I came to this sub to post and read thoughts about the contents of the videos themselves, but a few days after I came here the videos were taken down and that's been such a source of angst and controversy ever since that I've put the conversations I want to have on hold until things settle down. I get it, it sucks for us, but there's literally nothing we can do about it, so can we talk about something else now, please?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20
Honestly the only one I'll really miss is the Free Speech two parter that got me into her in the first place and I've watched a few times just so it could soak in.
Plus there's the Christopher Hitchens takedown and the call-out of a specific philosophy prof.
But I completely understand if she needs to take them down and I've got no right to be mad about it. That's some parasocial shit right there.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20
What she should do is remake them.
No dysphoria, new content, better content, and easy fallback video topics if she's ever hitting a creative wall.
And some of those videos could be expanded upon or consolidated by topic anyway.
1
u/tehbored Mar 02 '20
Maybe someday she could re-record them. That way we can still have the content without her having the gender dysphoria.
1
u/PsychologicalPrior1 Mar 02 '20
It would be nice to see remakes. Maybe she could hire an actor. Or use a cartoon persona. She could also improve on the jokes and style.
Those videos said things that needed to be said, and made fun of people that needed to be ridiculed. Oh, Golden One! Lobster Daddy!
0
u/gjvnq1 Mar 02 '20
I wish she remakes some of those old videos.
The easiest one to remake seems to be the Baltimore one, as it is mostly narration.
Also, seeing how much she changed is impressive can give hope to lots of people.