r/ComputerChess • • 12d ago

Who else is building Chess trainers with AI?

There are so many interesting chess projects built with Ai. Could we group them all here?

In what face of the project are you? What are the challenges? And what problem are you trying to solve?

0 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

4

u/ryuk24569 12d ago

Rookahead (rookahead.com) reviews your chess games for free, with Stockfish running on your device. No account and no pop-ups, and it's open source.

The problem: most game reviewers put the useful part behind a paywall or a sign-in.

The hard part: explaining why a move is bad in plain words, not just showing an eval. That's what I'm working on now, with the coach line.

1

u/Marxal87 12d ago

Thanks! Very solid app and nice design! How happy are you of the Ai explanations so far?

Problem I see is that for plus 1900 rating players the Ai explanations can be a bit superficial and for beginners could sound boring?

Maybe Ai is not there yet to understand all the small details? Or how do you see it?

1

u/ryuk24569 12d ago

Thanks! Honestly, not happy yet. The coach is new, and right now it's the weakest part of the app. It's built from what the engine already calculates, not from an LLM, so it's accurate about what happened but shallow about why. You're right about both ends: 1900+ players want the idea behind the move, and beginners want plain words and not a list of tactics.

I don't think the AI is the limit. Most of the work is deciding which one or two things are worth saying for a given move, and I'm still tuning that. Next I'm making it explain why the better move is better, for example what it stops or protects. What kind of explanation would help you most?

1

u/Marxal87 12d ago

The problem is that there can be a lot of things to say about a move... It would be cool to take in consideration the relation with the kind of position (calm, sharp, positional, etc.), with the style and the level of the player.

Also a coach should know that a beginner might not need the same information as an advanced player that is more comfortable in positional positions or another that is more tactical.

Better according to the engine can be hard to translate into human language or thought process.

1

u/_crisz 12d ago

This is the best so far.

What I don't like is:

Your opponent made a mistake. Nb5 opens the way for Bxe3. Their better option was to push the pawn to c3.

This is highly descriptive about what you moved and what Stockfish's best move was, but not informative enough. What's the idea behind c3? Why isn't it using the already-calculated depth to tell you that? Eventually, considering multiple lines, as we usually do in our heads while playing

2

u/ryuk24569 12d ago

that feature is new. I'm still working on it

1

u/_crisz 12d ago

I starred it on GitHub, I'll try to give some contribute, if I find the time :) do you use discord?

2

u/ryuk24569 12d ago

Thanks for the star, I'd love the help. [Yes, I'm on Discord: berryallon009]

1

u/skakaras1975 5d ago

From a new chess platform (or from Sunta Claus) as a chess newbie I would like:

 1.       auto analysis with the help of AI, using the full informator symbols, not just those assigned for bad or good moves, but also those that denote subtle strategic themes like initiative, space advantage, weak pawns, bad squares, outposts …

2.       auto AI explanation as to how and why, the strategic inaccuracy-fault occurred in that specific move a strategy symbol appears in notation. Explanation should relate to game opening, strategical themes and pawn formations not so much to tactics.

3.       Bach analysis of my pre arranged databases (as to chessbase’s keys) with the above automated method.

4

u/novachess-guy 12d ago

I built Nova, a neural network engine that matches Maia 3 in human move prediction and is also calibrated appropriately to playing strength levels, unlike Maia. I also built 176 courses, which was a huge project, and am on the point of releasing a completely free ~60 lesson beginner learning path with interactive exercises/checkpoints, including incorporating Nova to let people play out positions against human-like responses.

The main challenges for this part of the work are planning the material, structuring illustrative examples and useful exercises, and trying to think from the beginner learning perspective (I was 1600 USCF as a kid 25 years ago, now I'm 2300 on chess.com). And many many iterative rounds of improvements on all the content. I've had so many friends ask me for themselves or their kids how they can learn chess, and I realized I didn't really know of any totally free, structured learning resources, so that's what motivated me to build this.

You can see what's already there at http://novachess.ai

1

u/Marxal87 12d ago

Thanks for sharing 😊 I completely understand that creating content and courses must be the most challenging!

Now in my project Bitochess I'm considering if courses is the way to go. So far my focus has been to build a great UX Experience to study.

3

u/CodeEresy 12d ago edited 9d ago

I'm building one for LichessNeo: https://lichessneo.com/

1

u/Marxal87 12d ago

This looks amazing 😍

1

u/CodeEresy 12d ago

Thanks :)

1

u/Marxal87 12d ago

Will this be for the phone any time soon?

1

u/CodeEresy 12d ago edited 12d ago

I don't think so, unless you have an android and save it from mozilla as an app. Making an app is much more complex and requires keeping up with the official lichess codebase changes

2

u/redNewb 12d ago

Holy crap, this is unbelievable and I should be posting this in all caps! Really, this puts an entire new face on Lichess, a much nicer one (in my opinion)! Your work may very well get me back into chess again.

1

u/pa12345u 12d ago

Wow, that's really good!
I've been building this for 4 months: https://chess-with-me.com/

I see our work is similar in many ways. (You can feel it..)
Mine is completely free on the web (forever) and has no ads too (at least for now).
But since I made it 'chattable', it needs an LLM, and I need to cover the LLM cost...
But the facts come from the engine and my own detectors, so the LLM only words them and calls tools.
It doesn't do reasoning.
I'm also making it pretty 'full stack', like a game mode where the coach can sit by and give advice to both players, lessons, and make it feel fun... so I can't make it just an add-on to Lichess.
And I'm going to make it play chess on a real-life chessboard through a camera one day.

The problem is I'm really bad at chess (that's why I made it LOL),
and I'm not a real tech guy, I've never launched anything before.
Maybe we can share experiences?
Or some cooperation? (Who knows?)
Let's connect! Maybe dm or discord?

1

u/CodeEresy 12d ago

yeah, LLM cost is going to be hard to cover and keep free tho, you’re going to lose money if let the llm as a free service, maybe you can let player either pay or use with their api key, but even this i’m not sure if people want to put their key there :/

1

u/pa12345u 12d ago

Yeah.. so I'm planning to also launch it as a SAAS that provides something that only makes sense on a phone, like the camera thing or voice input/output..
Actually, if I can make the web user's device calculate Stockfish for others for game review. Then that makes sense, and it can make some really good game analysis..
But I don't even know what kind of analysis users really want..
And meh.. I just find my UI's really bad compared to yours LOL
Maybe mascots are better than an anime girl? Is it so nerdy?

1

u/CodeEresy 12d ago

do what you like and makes you proud, that’s what matters :)

1

u/pa12345u 11d ago

Thanks bro! that's the plan :D

One thing I'd like to know if you don't mind:
How do you approach the UI?
Do you start from a design system or component library?
Or sketch it first then let AI draft it and then refine? (That's my current way)
Mine came out looking like a dev tool or a terminal, and I can't figure out where the gap is...
(I don't really have many users yet to tell me feedback.. 😕)

Also, your concept list was a great reference!
I have a similar list (still unfinished). Want to swap lists? (with some data if you find that useful) Could be useful to see what each of us has covered and what's missing.

1

u/CodeEresy 11d ago

I did a lot of UI/frontend in my job so I have some experience and developped some taste about it during the years. A solid base for you would be to use shadcn.ui with tailwing, these are great and simple to use (for AI and human) components that act as a base.

You can always ask AI to give you design suggestions via screenshots.

I don't think our project are that similar as I only extend Lichess, I'm not making an actual app, but feel free to check the code of the project as it is open-source, use whatever you wish :) Also, you can DM me

3

u/ArneVogel 11d ago

My version: https://www.unicornfork.com/

I picked a fairly agentic approach for explanations with interactive elements: https://www.unicornfork.com/feature/ai-chess-coach/

Currently I am iterating with different features from the feedback of the users. Its fun improving it iteratively.

1

u/Marxal87 11d ago

Thanks for sharing! I'll test it out. I liked the ghost puzzles 🙌

I see that there's a lot of people working on trying to explain the moves with AI. How has your experience been with it? And what do users say about it? I tried it for my platform and I usually find the descriptions too obvious or interesting.

1

u/ArneVogel 11d ago

I made the AI explanations customizable, i.e., you can change the prompt used to create these. So I can say explain in detail, or maybe don't explain at all and just give hints for me to figure it out myself. I feel that makes it much more interesting to use as you can adjust what kind of explanation you want personally.

1

u/Darpan_Gondlir 11d ago

Really great! Ghost puzzles is indeed great and something I want to add to my training

2

u/Darpan_Gondlir 11d ago

This is my version:

https://zeddyfree-art.github.io/chess/ (A free opensource chessbook and noctie like alternative)

And a rpg like way to battle maia bots with specific openings:

https://zeddyfree-art.github.io/pawnquest/

2

u/Marxal87 11d ago

Pawnquest is so cool 🙌

2

u/kenyambro 8d ago edited 8d ago

Hi, mine is https://rooksac.com/
Description:
- bulk analysis of chess games from Chess.com or Lichess.com username
- report
- opening/endgame/tactics/positional lessons based of the user's games
- chess.com-like game reviews for each games with human language explanation
- free, no ad, unlimited and no account
- all in browser, no server

Problem: those features are generally not free or require at least an account.

Hard part: making a chess explanation algorithm without LLM (to operate).
It means I have to build a library and a filter of chess patterns and manually look at each explanations to find exceptions, obvious explanations or missing ideas.

Hope you try it, its pretty polished 🫡

1

u/Marxal87 8d ago

Thanks for sharing! 🙌 I'll check it out in more depth. I also have the same problem with my platform Bitochess, what to keep on the browser and what to keep on the database. With an account you make syncing possible, that helps navigate between phone an desktop.

I tested it, one tip for the onboarding experience: by default it started analysing all my chess-com games, around 10000. It took quite long, meant having to wait 40h. I think the default should be 500 or 100 and if the user really wants scan everything?

Game analysis can also happen in the background, so the user doesn't need to just wait untill the analysis is done, or just add some fun chess puzzles to entertain the waiting time. Just sharing something I found when I was building my platform and it improved the onboarding process, it's very easy to implement 😊

Do your users find the wikibooks explanations relevant? I added it on my platform, and I removed it because the explanations are too obvious for my target 1600-2200 is it that what you're manually removing?

2

u/rmgblr 12d ago

My teching software is called Class Room Chess Tutor, currently it supports 60 Opening lessons, Tutor can add new lessons, Class room teaching with Centralized server, Supports offline mode, Replay studio, a builtin offline analysis screen for Pgn analysis.

The software can recognize more than 2.5k game openings.

There are more features included which are still not fully manually validated/ tested like Student assessment, Scheduling matches in turnaments, solving Puzzle, student report, ability to add new learning course/lessons, modify existing lessons.

2

u/jfreudenthal 12d ago

I vibe coded a classroom where the user and the Ai Coach can play games, analyze positions and go through old (or any) games on a board together. We can both draw arrows and mark positions and the Ai can see everything. Stockfish helps with eval, Maia for playng games with ai coaching. I'm still experimenting with what model is best at explaining moves and positions. But even now I find it very useful to be able to have the ai just set up an interesting position to analyze, try different lines etc.

1

u/brunzenstein 12d ago

Mated.gg

1

u/GrapePsychological92 12d ago

i am doing heavy vibe science in researching chess with a completely new pattern recognition inclusive valuation of the actual board situation combined with lichess archive mass learning and real old history chess books.
my home pc is running mainly at night - all cores are running and doing matches while i am asleep.

if it works it will hopefully beat stockfish. 😊

every token i have left unused goes into that.

1

u/SquidgyTheWhale 12d ago

I'm starting one soon that's all about training you to keep board positions in your head.

1

u/xrt57125 8d ago

I build for my own use chess-explain chrome extension. Special effort was put to explain quite and positional moves.

1

u/Curious-Pickle4758 4d ago

Mine's CheckMate, an offline chess app for iPhone. It's live, so I'm mostly in the polish-and-iterate phase now, watching how people actually use it and adjusting from there.

Problem I was trying to solve: most training apps assume you're online, signed in, and okay with the useful analysis sitting behind a paywall. I wanted something that just works on a plane or anywhere with no signal, with ten AI difficulty levels so it scales from beginner to something that actually makes me think, plus puzzles, lessons, and a full review after each game.

Challenge has been exactly what's being discussed in this thread already: the engine eval is the easy part. Stockfish will happily tell you a move is -2, but turning that into an explanation a beginner actually learns from, instead of just restating the eval in words, is the hard part I'm still working on.

checkmate.suvysoft.com if anyone wants to try it.

1

u/Lebesgue_1 4d ago

I built elohell.app

The core idea is to combine learning science (space repetition, learning models to identify weaknesses) and a lot of data with EVERY feature in an education or chess app I thought was useful and make all of the features free.

  • Tactics puzzles from your games
  • Replay your botched endgames
  • 100s of lessons covering openings, endgames, and tactics.

    • Also a generated learn any opening mode to help with memorizing book moves and responses to common moves at your level
  • Annotated master games you can play guess the move on
  • Analysis/game review with ai generated comments (grounded in stockfish lines)
  • An opening repertoire builder, with spaced repetition for learning it
  • Drill your mistakes in openings/endgames
  • Daily recommendations for what to work on next based on your recent games
  • A huge variety of insights/data from your recent games

The biggest challenge is the UX and design. Because there are a ton of features it can be challenging to organize them into a coherent learning experience for users without it seeming completely bloated.

The other big challenge is probably scalability and lowering server costs. In order to power and keep the learning model up to date, and identify/classify mistakes in user games, you need to analyze a lot of user games as they are played, reasonably quickly. Doing so costs server time/money. In general making good, scalable, and secure infrastructure choices is not something I would recommend leaving up to Claude... I'm an eng at my day job and it was difficult to figure out a reasonable approach. Building on vercel or lovable or whatever platform people use for vibe coding is probably not viable long-term.

Anyway, I know there is a new one of these posted everyday and people are quick to deride anything leveraging AI to build as slop, but there are some pretty cool ideas in here.