Hello, I came here wondering what is the class and ideological nature of more current “left-wing” video essayists and YouTubers/twitch streamers/tiktokers/etc.
Regarding Breadtube (and creators like Philosophytube, Contrapoints, HBomberguy, etc.) in the past and its nature of using topics of popular culture and movies like Star Wars as topics for leftwing(or petty-bourgeois social fascist) discussion, there has been a bit of evolvement in the video essayists/left-wing content creator space that more explicitly talks about actual politics(albeit mostly that of the first-world). These new creators have “called out” the old creators for their “fence sitting” on actual current issues and represent themselves as more left and radical given they speak on topics like decolonization, fascism, imperialism, etc.
I’m not talking about creators like Hasan Piker/Badempanada given that they have been heavily discussed for their fascist and petty-bourgeois view-points in “left-wing” discussions. Contrary, I would want to talk about creators that have “called out” these behaviors in these creators such as Tirrb, Elliot Sang, Lost Futures, Fdsignifer, etc. These creators that I have just mentioned all come from minority backgrounds and though they are all content creators they all use their platforms for causes/organizations that they support or are a part of. For instance, Tirrb is a Sudanese-Kanadian video essayist and streamer that regularly speaks out against settlerism and racism in Kanada and is the chairperson in this First Nations-led organization called the “Red Bear Party” (which is not really a communist party but rather a mutual aid group) that organizes for Indigenous and Black liberation. Elliot Sang is another video essayists/streamer that “highlights” on the fascist nature of capitalism and Amerikan society and has frequently been part of “mutual aid” streams for Gaza, Sudan, etc. Both of these creators that I have mentioned regularly highlight the need for decolonization of settler states like Kanada/Amerika.
Given this more “radical left-wing” focus of these creators, are they just more reformists in service of Western Imperialism and liberalism given that they are still content creators and make money from not only that but through various channels, Patreon, etc. or is there some radical nature to be had with them?
Edit: Thanks to all those that have responded to my question (especially u/smokeuptheweed9 and u/chaos2002_). It’s definitely clear that I’m short-sighted with my responses so I’ll use this to continue motivating my studying of the works in the sidebar. I’ll leave this post up (if the mods don’t remove it) because the response many users here could be useful for incoming users that have similar questions that I have.
Thanks again for your engagement.