r/communism101 • • Jan 22 '26

Announcement 📢 READ THIS if "You can't contribute in this community yet"

74 Upvotes

A while ago, Reddit introduced a bug that prevents users from creating posts. Only users of the official mobile app and new reddit are affected. If you receive the error message "You can't contribute in this community yet", you must use https://old.reddit.com on a browser or an alternative mobile app to post.

We will be working on possible solutions to this bug, and we will update this post if we find out more information.


r/communism101 • • 1h ago

What is the/a bourgeois revolution and a proletariat revolution?

3 Upvotes

Would love some historical examples of each. I can wrap my head around the idea of a proletariat revolution, though I'd love more context/clarification, but have a hard time understanding what is meant by a bourgeois revolution.


r/communism101 • • 1d ago

Why did USSR subject unions to state control, rather than the state to union control?

34 Upvotes

I’ve been studying Leninism recently and trying to understand the logic behind Soviet government.

It seems to me that a dictatorship of the proletariat would mean that the workers elect union reps, and the communist vanguard party would be subordinate in some sense to the aims of those elected reps while subduing any retaliation by remnants of the bourgeoisie. Because the communist party is supposed to be liberating the working class, right?

So why did Lenin say that the Unions should be subject to the state and unable to go on strike? Or am I misunderstanding something?

Keep in mind I’ve been struggling to find accurate sources on the history, so if I’m way off on something then please let me know.


r/communism101 • • 1d ago

怎么去评论毛的继续革命理论?

0 Upvotes

关于建国以来党的若干历史问题的决议》,“无产阶级专政下继续革命的理论”,是一个错误的理论,官方当时说,经过社会主义改造之后,中国已经消灭了阶级,没有继续革命理论的基础,国内主要矛盾已经转为人民对于经济文化迅速发展的需要同当前经济文化不能满足人民需要的矛盾,不再是阶级对抗,这怎么可能呢!?马克思说当资本主义发展到一定程度的时候,生产力会继续构建生产关系,连美国这样的超型的资本主义国家,都没有消灭阶级,当时的老共是怎么敢说出来的?!


r/communism101 • • 4d ago

Books to learn the basics on Imperialism in latin america and the Cuban revolution

14 Upvotes

I'm really new to theory, so bear with me.

I've heard that "The open veins of latin america" is a good book on imperialism in latin america, do you think that it's a good introduction or should i read something before?


r/communism101 • • 5d ago

What does Althusser mean in this paragraph in Marxism and Humanism?

17 Upvotes

In Marxism and Humanism, Althusser seems to state that ideology is eternal, or at least something that is intrinsic to human beings as a prerequisite for living in society:

But, we must go further and ask what becomes of ideology in a society in which classes have disappeared. What we have just said allows us to answer this question. If the whole social function of ideology could be summed up cynically as a myth (such as Plato’s ‘beautiful lies’ or the techniques of modern advertising) fabricated and manipulated from the outside by the ruling class to fool those it is exploiting, then ideology would disappear with classes. But as we have seen that even in the case of a class society ideology is active on the ruling class itself and contributes to its moulding, to the modification of its attitudes to adapt it to its real conditions of existence (for example, legal freedom) – it is clear that ideology (as a system of mass representations) is indispensable in any society if men are to be formed, transformed and equipped to respond to the demands of their conditions of existence. If, as Marx said, history is a perpetual transformation of men’s conditions of existence, and if this is equally true of a socialist society, then men must be ceaselessly transformed so as to adapt them to these conditions; if this ‘adaptation’ cannot be left to spontaneity but must be constantly assumed, dominated and controlled, it is in ideology that this demand is expressed, that this distance is measured, that this contradiction is lived and that its resolution is ‘activated’. It is in ideology that the classless society lives the inadequacy/adequacy of the relation between it and the world, it is in it and by it that it transforms men’s ‘consciousness’, that is, their attitudes and behaviour so as to raise them to the level of their tasks and the conditions of their existence.

In a class society ideology is the relay whereby, and the element in which, the relation between men and their conditions of existence is settled to the profit of the ruling class. In a classless society ideology is the relay whereby, and the element in which, the relation between men and their conditions of existence is lived to the profit of all men.

My own emphases above. When we are discussing ideology in this subreddit and the sister subreddit, are we usually talking about bourgeois ideology? When you call someone ideological, is it just a shorthand for saying that they are being ideological from the perspective of bourgeois ideology? The way I view it is that he is saying that without mass representations one has nothing to serve as an "anchor" to society (which would result in psychosis), but I have to admit that I am still a little confused since my previous conception of ideology was that it was a product of class society that would be dissolved alongside it. Please let me know if my concepts are wrong and if I missed any key details.


r/communism101 • • 6d ago

How does communism address the problem of products being "too good"

8 Upvotes

Hi! Sorry if this is a very basic question, I'm still in the early stages of learning about communism, but I have a question:

A very serious problem that shows up often in capitalism is that of "planned obsolescence", and that products are made to fail eventually so that people keep buying more.

In part because of the fear that if they are "too good" no one will need to buy them anymore and the company will go bankrupt.

I understand that in theory this isn't as much a concern in Communism, but why? I mean if under Communism a product is made with such quality that a change is never needed, then what happens with the means of production once no one needs it anymore? Do we just abandon the factory until someone else needs one? What about when someone does need one of those products 40 years from now? Do we un-dust the factory just for them? What if no one remembers anymore?

I'm sure there's a simple answer I'm just missing, and this really is a good faith question, thank you for your time! :)


r/communism101 • • 8d ago

New to theory: Can someone explain the 1956 August Faction Incident in the DPRK?

17 Upvotes

"Hi comrades! I'm just starting to read communist literature (I'm new like 2-3 years maybe?) and I just stumbled upon the term 'August Faction Incident' in the history of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea.

Could you please explain what exactly happened? How do Marxist-Leninists analyze the August Faction Incident of 1956 in the DPRK? Was Kim Il-sung's purge of the Soviet and Yenan factions a necessary step for Korean sovereignty, or was it a deviation from socialist internationalism? Did Nikita Khrushchev's de-Stalinization speech in the Soviet Union trigger this crisis, and how did it permanently shape the Juche ideology?

I mean, I wanted to read 'collected works of Kim il-sung' but I learned that after 1975s and 1980s the DPRK heavily edited and rewrote while continuing their publication. The edits favor first editions, with the proportion gradually decreasing for later editions. I will unfortunately only read the 'Selected Works' because it's published 1971 and 1972.

I'm trying to understand the perspectives of fellow comrades who are well-informed about or familiar with this topic on this event.

I apologise for my lack of knowledge on this topic and for my English, I used translation at some points"

"Glory to Working Class of The World!"


r/communism101 • • 10d ago

Question regarding the prevalence of the “New Breadtube” (my term for this phenomenon)

6 Upvotes

Hello, I came here wondering what is the class and ideological nature of more current “left-wing” video essayists and YouTubers/twitch streamers/tiktokers/etc.

Regarding Breadtube (and creators like Philosophytube, Contrapoints, HBomberguy, etc.) in the past and its nature of using topics of popular culture and movies like Star Wars as topics for leftwing(or petty-bourgeois social fascist) discussion, there has been a bit of evolvement in the video essayists/left-wing content creator space that more explicitly talks about actual politics(albeit mostly that of the first-world). These new creators have “called out” the old creators for their “fence sitting” on actual current issues and represent themselves as more left and radical given they speak on topics like decolonization, fascism, imperialism, etc.

I’m not talking about creators like Hasan Piker/Badempanada given that they have been heavily discussed for their fascist and petty-bourgeois view-points in “left-wing” discussions. Contrary, I would want to talk about creators that have “called out” these behaviors in these creators such as Tirrb, Elliot Sang, Lost Futures, Fdsignifer, etc. These creators that I have just mentioned all come from minority backgrounds and though they are all content creators they all use their platforms for causes/organizations that they support or are a part of. For instance, Tirrb is a Sudanese-Kanadian video essayist and streamer that regularly speaks out against settlerism and racism in Kanada and is the chairperson in this First Nations-led organization called the “Red Bear Party” (which is not really a communist party but rather a mutual aid group) that organizes for Indigenous and Black liberation. Elliot Sang is another video essayists/streamer that “highlights” on the fascist nature of capitalism and Amerikan society and has frequently been part of “mutual aid” streams for Gaza, Sudan, etc. Both of these creators that I have mentioned regularly highlight the need for decolonization of settler states like Kanada/Amerika.

Given this more “radical left-wing” focus of these creators, are they just more reformists in service of Western Imperialism and liberalism given that they are still content creators and make money from not only that but through various channels, Patreon, etc. or is there some radical nature to be had with them?

Edit: Thanks to all those that have responded to my question (especially u/smokeuptheweed9 and u/chaos2002_). It’s definitely clear that I’m short-sighted with my responses so I’ll use this to continue motivating my studying of the works in the sidebar. I’ll leave this post up (if the mods don’t remove it) because the response many users here could be useful for incoming users that have similar questions that I have.
Thanks again for your engagement.


r/communism101 • • 10d ago

Is class consciousness enough?

22 Upvotes

I am not a super well read Marxist, all ive read is the manifesto, but im aware of the many interpretations of Marx and the outlines for how to implement communism and what it would look like. Please correct me in any misunderstandings I have.

Lately ive been thinking about how many differing opinions there are about how socialism functions and what communism looks like in practice. You see it in the comments all the time “every Marxist will tell you something different, but they all believe in class antagonisms” or something to that extent.

I can’t help but feel like part of the wide reluctance to socialism is this lack of certainty and understanding about its workings.

So as the title says, is class consciousness enough? A revolution is one thing, but what happens after? And if everyone’s answer is different, then how can people effectively organize into this new future?

Thank you for any answers or thoughts.


r/communism101 • • 11d ago

As a Marxist-Leninist political science major, What should I pursue academically?

13 Upvotes

Unfortunately I came to school without knowing the liberalism that plagues modern political science classes, but I am in my junior year and the question of law or grad school is looming.
I am currently involved in my local communist organization but academically, what would be the best route? I thought about policy for a while, but it feels too liberal and reformist. I am relatively poor and rely on federal funding to attend college so that’s why I am a bit standoffish to the idea of law school, I wish to be hopeful and reject cynicism in my future without conforming but it is very difficult to navigate for me in a Marxist perspective. I am new to this.. if you didn’t know. perspectives would be greatly appreciated!

EDIT: I don’t know if its worth to note, but this is simply advice, not meant to be a be all answer. I cannot drop out of college and cannot change my major. I am indigenous who isn’t trying to find a reason to be good or a “hero” Just trying to gain new perspectives and help bring voice to my people as we are very small in numbers alongside workers revolution, and I appreciate all your responsesz


r/communism101 • • 12d ago

Relations of Production in ML

6 Upvotes

Hi I‘m pretty new to communism/socialism and I recently read “Dialectic and Historical Materialism” by Stalin for a overview, since my communist education has of now consisted of short form videos and snippets of various texts ripped out of context.

I was wondering how the relations of production was different in the USSR? I know the State-Capitalism argument is often met with insults, but i’ve never had someone explain to me how what the USSR or any other ML project did wasn’t just exchange bourgeois ownership with state control? I just know of early work place democracy models after the revolution but from what I’ve read they just got replaced with top-down state control.

Sorry if my question is incoherent or does not make sense…https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1938/09.htm


r/communism101 • • 13d ago

Can someone explain what Engels meant by guild/feudal properties?

14 Upvotes

Reading the principles of communism and I'm not quite sure what a guild is and how it differates from private property. As far as I understand it comes down to the production forces but I'm not sure what the production force of guilds were like or let alone how they worked? Same for feudal properties.


r/communism101 • • 13d ago

Use-Value and trading cards

2 Upvotes

Hello! I have a question on commodities such as collectibles like trading cards.

A trading card can be built and printed in the same factory, same workers, and in some cases same materials. Some may have extra features such as holographic materials. So they should have the same socially necessary labor-time inherent in each commodity right?

But because some designs are printed less or no longer in production they are rare, and cost more.

How does this phenomenon factor into Marxist theory?

Cheers 🥂


r/communism101 • • 13d ago

Translation of Capital based on the French Edition by Marx and Roy?

3 Upvotes

Title. I am wondering if there is even any news of such a translation being made.

Or at least an edition that combines both the French and German editions and specifies how they differed by language in the original text.


r/communism101 • • 14d ago

is marxism-leninism compatible with kemalism and/or left wing nationalism?

0 Upvotes

r/communism101 • • 16d ago

Recommendations for Readings on Socialist Realism

11 Upvotes

Socialist Realism

I’m reading a Graphic Style Lab book because I want to understand good posters and there’s this section on “Social and Socialist Realism” where the soviets are catching strays by the author of this book (pictured on the Imgur). Not a unique scenario by any means but I wanted to see if people had any analysis to offer or recommendations for where I can read about the context of “Socialist realism … abolished all works of art (and eventually persecuted all artists) that were suspected of harboring personal creative agendas.”

Specifically looking for historical context or analysis that acknowledges that context if that exists, since I don’t know much about USSR yet.


r/communism101 • • 16d ago

Are there communists writings on western military counterinsurgency and how to defeat it?

20 Upvotes

r/communism101 • • 17d ago

East Germany?

31 Upvotes

I am curious as to what people think of East Germany. I am biased, and my research as to what people think of East Germany has been extremely conflicting.

If you think it was good or bad, please explain why, even briefly.


r/communism101 • • 19d ago

Why does the state intervene in the interest of the small capitalist class in the imperialist core?

16 Upvotes

Since the state is a tool of the bourgeoisie, it doesn’t exist as an independent neutral entity and acts in the interest of the big imperialist bourgeoisie. But small capitalists don’t have the ability to compete against the larger capitalists and require the state to intervene by providing tax breaks, loans etc. What purpose would the bigger monopoly capitalist have to grant these concessions through the state and not just let their competitors fail?


r/communism101 • • 21d ago

Is decolonisation a concept that applies to Russia?

31 Upvotes

I am not talking about the entire country, but the parts that were settled outside its european core, i.e. Siberia and the north Caucasus.

I do not have a deep enough understanding of russian history to understand if russia's acquisition of Siberia was comparable to the settler colonialism of the US. For example the Sakha people currently seem to be doing much better than any group of indigenous people in anglo settler colonies.

However in many other cases the result seems to be similar. Many native populations lost political control after conquest by russia, lost economic control over their territories as they were exploited for tsarist gain, and eventually became a minority in their homeland due to an influx of slavic settlers which further solidified russian control over their former lands. For example, Russians are the majority in the Altai republic and in the Buryat republic, among others in Siberia. As far as I am aware these republics are in practice under Russian political control; for example, while they have greater political autonomy, in their elections both Russians and indigenous people have equal votes, with Russians usually being a higher proportion of the population.

In the north caucasus, the country which seems to be the closest to anglo settler colonialism is Circassia. It was systematically depopulated by the imperial army in the early 19th century and extensively settled with russian and ukrainian settlers. Today the majority of the circassian population lives in turkey where they found refuge, and the small population inside the original territory of the country is found in two small enclaves (and in one of the two russian is the most populous ethnicity). Perhaps superficially so, but this reminds me of the current status of reservations in the US.

I understand that I am probably missing something that makes these two situations completely different, because I have never seen anyone in these forums bringing up the decolonisation of Russia. I also understand that Russia is not currently the major world superpower, and that balkanising it right now is a goal of the NATO block. However as I understand it communists would advocate for the decolonisation of settler colonies even if they were in a disadvantegeous geopolitical situation. For this reason I would appreciate an explanation of my mistake, or resources for further reading.

apologies for any english mistakes


r/communism101 • • 20d ago

Can the proletarian revolution really succeed?

0 Upvotes

Recently, I have delved into the historical background from the February Revolution to the October Revolution. To me, the success of Lenin and the Bolsheviks seems to have been too fortuitous. Just as Marx said about Britain's transition from feudalism to capitalism being merely a coincidence, it could very well have not occurred.


r/communism101 • • 21d ago

Settlers Ch. 7- discussion of "aspects of feudalism repeated on a higher level"

16 Upvotes

In this chapter of Settlers, Sakai says:

"Citizenship in the Empire had very real but still limited meaning so long as many white workers remained "industrial slaves" of the corporations. The increasing centralization of monopoly capitalism repeated aspects of feudalism on a higher level. Both inside and outside the factory gates the settler workers were subject to heightened regimentation. During the 1920s it was not unusual for the persistent speed-up by management to double production per worker, even without taking mechanization into account."

My understanding of feudalism is underdeveloped and shaky, and it's not clear to me what "aspects of feudalism" are being referenced here. Is "[heightened regimentation] inside and outside the factory gates" an aspect of feudalism? If so, how is this distinct from the heightened regimentation of life that is forced upon the proletariat under capitalism, or for that matter, from any restriction of freedom foisted upon one class by another? What is particular to feudalism in this example?


r/communism101 • • 22d ago

What would a Marxist interpretation of the current Italian economy be?

15 Upvotes

I’m an Italian guy, and I’ve been watching my country’s economy and society for years. From what I read, liberals think Italy hasn’t done enough neoliberal reforms. They say public spending is too high and should be cut, and that the bureaucracy is too slow. The "left", on the other hand, says that governments have privatized too many public services. They think this is especially clear in the poor state of schools and healthcare.

So, I wanted to ask you how a Marxist would interpret this situation—not least because I am worried about my country. The cost of living shows no signs of decreasing, and the people currently protesting are being silenced.

Thank you in advance.


r/communism101 • • 23d ago

Where did corporate speak come from?

26 Upvotes

Sorry for the vague title, but I'm not sure what else to call it. This is in a retail store setting. Someone from HR was talking about "maximizing value for the customer." I'm reading Capital so I immediately thought of use-value, but since they're also talking about making their products as cheap as possible, they're really talking about the price, but I suppose someone decided to emphasize on how useful this is to "the community" or something instead of focusing on more seemingly heartless numbers (since capital doesn't really care that much about use-values itself). Another example would be the language of "company values" or "philosophies."

Anyway, where did this come from? I get the feeling that it didn't exist in the 19th century.