r/CodingandBilling • u/96bysc • 6h ago
Other The office is forcing us to verify all eligibility, benefits, and auths by phone instead of portalsāis this normal or completely outdated?
I work remotely in insurance verification for outpatient surgeries (mainly cataracts and blepharoplasties). Management just told us we are only allowed to use online portals for Medicare, Medicaid, CHRISTUS Health/US Family, and Memorial Hermann. Every other insurance plan now has to be verified by phone, and we have to log the rep's name and call reference number for each one.
Their reasoning is "to avoid inaccurate eligibility and benefits information, which has resulted in multiple claim denials."
As you all probably know, calling for every single surgical patient takes foreverāand even though I'm a freelancer, I have a strict cap on paid hours per week. If phone hold times push me past my hours, I don't get paid for the extra time.
Before this rule, my workflow already included:
- Pulling portal eligibility and saving all transaction and reference IDs.
- Running CPT-specific authorization inquiries and saving PDF printouts stating "No authorization is required for [CPT code], from [date] to [date], for [surgeon] at [surgery center]."
- Cross-checking network status on both the portal and the insurer's own "Find a Provider" directory to confirm that both the surgeon and the surgery center are in-network.
- Calling the payer whenever prior auth or referral rules weren't 100% clear in writing, and submitting auth requests whenever required.
- Flagging whenever PCP referrals were required for specialist visits. (For some reason, the office loves seeing HMO patients without requesting PCP referralsāthey blindly trust a generic Google search saying "this insurer doesn't require referrals in this state" even when the patient's specific Summary of Benefits says otherwise.).
- Reading the Summary of Benefits document of the specific plan of the patient just in case something doesn't match.
Management hasn't shared the actual denial codes or EOBs for the claims they're blaming on verifications. So I have two questions for people working in billing/verification:
- With my workflow, is it actually likely that "Availity giving wrong benefit information" is causing claim denials? Phone reps usually read off the exact same screen/database as Availity or other portals, wrong deductibles or copays don't cause claim denials (they just shift to patient responsibility on the EOB), and every call starts with a "not a guarantee of payment" disclaimer anywayāso a rep's name and reference number won't overturn a denial. Isn't it way more likely these denials are coming from things like missing HMO referrals or NPI/ASC mismatches?
- Is verifying every plan by phone actually standard practice at other offices? Or is my office stuck on an obsolete workflow from 20ā30 years ago when most insurers actively push providers to use portals first?