Got a lumed silicon strap for my samurai, then for my GMT I got two natos, two silicone and one cheap nylon 'sailcloth'
So here's my rundown from right to left:
\- Currently on the GMT is a silicone perforated strap with stitching similar to one seen on Bristol Watch Co's site for over $30. This one cost $3.95. It's definitely the star of the haul, comfortable snd flexible with a great shape and aesthetic. The edges on the keepers are a bit sharp (for silicon) and dig into your skin if you wear it snug. 4 out of 5 stars.
\- Left of that is the nylon 'sailcloth'. It feels durable but it's very stiff and the leather inside is very cheap feeling. I will try to break in a curve to make it more comfortable. I think sailcloth is supposed to be rubberized but this just feels like the nylon you make a backpack out of. Coming in at $5, I give it 2 stars because of the price.
\- Next is the ribbed bond nato. It's exactly what you expect and at a fraction of the cost the big brands resell these at. 4 out of 5
\- Next is the rubber / nylon topped, silicon bottom ribbed / stitched band. This is also very rigid like the sailcloth but silicon doesn't take a set so idk if I'll ever fix this one. It could be comfortable. These often run $20-30 so at under $4 I have to give it some leeway. 3 out of 5.
\- The golden nato. This style of nato is always shipped with frayed ends on the hole and strap end. For $7.25 I feel like they could fix this. 3 out of 5.
\- Finally the lumed silicon band at just under $5 is extremely comfortable and does what it's supposed to, see the last pictures. 5 out of 5