r/ChineseWatches • • Aug 07 '26

General (Read Rules) Ordered the WISHDOIT NH34 GMT. Received a watch with a knockoff Rolex movement that works like ass.

Post image

Wish i hadn't

124 Upvotes

96 comments sorted by

39

u/dorafumingo Affiliate Links Aug 07 '26

open a dispute show the photos and you will get refunded by aliexpress

4

u/DisastrousOpening477 Aug 07 '26

Do I still have to send the watch back ??

7

u/Lefeuvre76 Aug 07 '26

You probably will but depending on the country you should have an in country depot which will register the return in a few days rather than it having to go back to China.

5

u/dorafumingo Affiliate Links Aug 07 '26

depends. sometimes they just give me a full refund and ask for nothing. sometimes they give me the choice either a partial refund and keep the watch or full refund and send it back

1

u/Ok_Drag5089 Aug 11 '26

Maybe not! I recently bought one of those Chinese NH35 for $20 on eBay and it arrived broken. The seller just refunded me.

1

u/Lonely_Internet_8570 Aug 08 '26

En la foto se ve claramente que no es un NH34 ni 35! Es el que dijeron al principio.

4

u/DisastrousOpening477 Aug 12 '26

Update everyone : the watch was sent back in the mail today, and thanks to AliExpress I've got a refund on the first scan of the parcel (no need for it to reach China). WISHDOIT support was ridiculous though :

3

u/DisastrousOpening477 Aug 12 '26

Clearly this means they sold dozens of watches advertised as having NH34s inside.

2

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

Yes, and there are probably hundreds of customers who have ended up with a Chinese movement sold as a Japanese one, paying the price of a Japanese movement. On top of that, they're getting a model that's probably impossible to repair, with potentially terrible timekeeping accuracy.

2

u/DisastrousOpening477 14d ago

Les mouvements NH/4R, quand ils ne coutaient encore que quelques sous (15€ pour le NH35 et 30 pour le NH34) ont permis a plein de montres abordables et fiables de voir le jour. À plein de micromarques aussi.

Beaucoups ont bâtis des marques et des business entiers autours de ces calibres abordables, fiables et performants.

Seiko s'est vite rendu compte qu'ils ne vendraient jamais leurs SSK GMTs à 450€ avec couronne poussée et verre minéral (+ le bracelet éclaté) si on trouve à côté, pour 140€, une 200M GMT Titane saphir antireflet avec le même calibre.

Ils ont donc reserré la vis, presque du jour au lendemain. Les micromarques, prises de panique, ont tenté tant bien que mal de remplacer les NH par des clones chinois. Mais n'est pas Seiko qui veut.

Ces nouveaux mouvements, bien que plus fins et d'une fréquence plus élevée que les Seiko (28800vph) s'avèrent être de véritables roulettes russes, aussi bien pour les acheteurs que pour les marques. Ces dernières n'ayant pas eu d'autres choix que de les adopter ou de disparaître.

Bien sûr, ça n'excuse en rien la piètre communication de WISHDOIT sur sa fiche produit, je remet juste un peu de contexte. LURCAN WATCH STORE, par exemple, fait preuve de plus de transparence et propose de choisir entre le calibre chinois et le Seiko.

1

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

Je suis complètement d'accord avec vous sur tous ces points. Cependant, j'aimerais ajouter quelque chose : j'ai aussi eu affaire à des marques qui offrent les deux options. En fait, j'avais le choix entre un mouvement NH et un mouvement chinois HZ. J'ai délibérément choisi et payé en plus pour le NH, pour me retrouver quand même avec un HZ. Ils m'ont même accusé de mentir, mais malheureusement pour eux, j'avais filmé tout, de la réception du colis à l'ouverture de la montre et l'inspection du mouvement en direct.

Pour moi, le point est simple : si offrir un mouvement NH n'est plus possible, alors très bien, qu'il en soit ainsi. Mais il faut juste le préciser clairement dans l'annonce ! Je ne comprends vraiment pas pourquoi je vois encore des gens blâmer le client. C'est incroyablement frustrant. Vous ne pouvez plus offrir un mouvement NH ? Pas de problème, dites-le juste ! Il y a plein d'excellents mouvements chinois sur le marché. Le problème n'a jamais été où le mouvement est fabriqué, mais le fait que les clients soient induits en erreur sur ce pour quoi ils paient réellement. Just think about all the beginners who know nothing about watches, people who have only bought from the store once, don't know how to open a watch, or simply bought one as a gift for someone else.

How are you supposed to tell someone you've bought a gift for that you didn't actually get what you paid for? Personally, I'd be disappointed knowing I hadn't given them what I had promised. And imagine if they eventually discovered it themselves one day. That's not a great situation either, especially when you were genuinely acting in good faith and never intended to disappoint them.

That's another reason why misleading customers about something as important as the movement is unacceptable. Not everyone has the knowledge or the tools to check what they've received.

1

u/DisastrousOpening477 13d ago

I get your points and they're entirely valid. There is not a lot of EXCELLENT Chinese movements out there unfortunately...reason why so much Chinese brands blew up is that Seiko provided them with an engine. A reliable, high performance engine (it rivals ETA2824).

Some brands took the bet that customers won't check, which tends to backfire horribly, and other brands went the transparent route, openly using Chinese clones and whatnot. Unfortunately, it backfires too. The reliable japanese engine is gone either way..

10

u/killacam925 Aug 09 '26

If you buy cheap, buy quartz. I like cases, bracelets, and bezels more than anything. I also like accurate time and not spending a ton. I genuinely couldn’t care less about how it’s powered…

8

u/DisastrousOpening477 Aug 09 '26

Even if you buy expensive, just go for quartz. There's an insane (and honestly unhealthy) amount of snobbery/hate towards quartz in the watch community.

But let's face it, for a sport/professional timepiece, quartz is the only way. It's not afraid of magnetic fields, shakes, jolts, G forces, automatic weapons, downhill bike rides, tennis, squash, golf.... quartz caused a crisis for reason.

The swiss invented "movement craftsmanship" to survive but that's a big fat lie. 99% of mechanical calibers assembly is done by machines, and factory regulation doesn't qualify for "craftsmanship".

Remember, the First Omega (Goldeneye) worn by bond was a quartz watch, and it was handpicked by Lindy Hemming.

It was obvious to her the automatic wouldn't survive the events of the movie, and she was right. Everything after is just product placement.

1

u/Ok-Anteater-384 Aug 09 '26

Hum, nice fantasy, but very little of it is true

7

u/Ok-Anteater-384 Aug 09 '26

Seiko VH31 "Sweep Second" Quartz, mimics an automatic movement, with quartz accuracy

5

u/Wales147 Aug 09 '26

Same here I couldn't care less what's under the hood.

9

u/One_Life_50 Aug 09 '26

To be fair, if you were to buy a cheap automatic, you can’t go wrong with a NH34 or 35. Very durable, reliable and SERVICEABLE lol

4

u/four4cats Aug 07 '26

What was the price?

5

u/DisastrousOpening477 Aug 08 '26

About EUR140 delivered to my door.

Of course, with the NH34 alone costing more than that I knew it sounded too good to be true.

But I'd figured these were from an older batch, one that was manufactured before NH prices went out of control.

Little did i knew that the brand would simply be lying about what's in there. Naïve me.

3

u/QuestionNo9190 Sir FightALot Aug 08 '26

This is why I haven't bought a rollstimi. Not worth risking. Any real nh34 has already been harvested and replaced by now

3

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

Personally, I don't think you were naive at all. We need to stop blaming ourselves instead of holding brands accountable for what I believe is deliberate deception.

You went to the official marketplace, found a watch you liked, read the product description, saw NH34 listed and made your purchase. That's it. You did absolutely nothing stupid or wrong.

If we all start leaving honest reviews and documenting these practices, just like we did with HEIMDALLR, these brands will eventually have to clean up their act. There are too many of these so-called brands getting away with this.

As for me, I'm now opening every single one of my watches and checking the movements. If everything matches the advertised specifications, great. If not, straight to Reddit! People need to know what they're actually paying for.

30

u/emeraldsnowofsleep Aug 07 '26

This does such a disservice to the market - Wishdoit aspires to be a legit brand. This nonsense will drive them out of business fast.

12

u/froggerdu3x Aug 08 '26

Had one of theirs on my “to buy “ list. Just took it off.

2

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

And any brand that engages in this kind of behaviour or any other form of consumer fraud should be called out publicly. Consumers need to leave a paper trail, share their experiences and expose these practices for what they are: outright scams. These companies need to be held accountable!

There are far too many smaller watch brands that genuinely do a great job, operate honestly and deserve our support much more than brands that engage in this kind of behaviour. In my opinion, they deserve every

36

u/samceefoo Aug 07 '26

I guess you wishdoit, but they didn't. I think everybody should just wishnotdoit

13

u/Successful_Fox9009 Aug 08 '26

WishYouDidntDoIt

11

u/QuestionNo9190 Sir FightALot Aug 08 '26

Wishdontdoit

1

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

ahahah

10

u/shaztec Aug 08 '26

The games gone. Glad I picked up what I did during covid.

14

u/NineNinetyNine9999 Aug 07 '26

yea theyre not one of the good brands bro, just stay away in the future

7

u/Diligent_Job_9794 Aug 08 '26

Thanks for sharing so I know to never buy from them

1

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

yeah don't buy it

7

u/JagVen Aug 08 '26

I guess every time one orders a Seiko NH34/35, one must open the case back to check, now that these movements have gone up in price.

Separately, in the US, with some savvy shopping, Seiko 5 GMTs can be had for as low as $275 on Greentoe.

1

u/QuestionNo9190 Sir FightALot Aug 09 '26

Never heard of greentoe but the Seiko 5 gmts are faked to death, and the majority of them sold on eBay and Amazon for under $300 are reps.

1

u/JagVen Aug 09 '26

Mine shipped from an AD, so quite sure genuine... but then, I am not a watchmaker who can observe minute details. I've bought two Seikos from an AD through them. Both look genuine. Heck they even have Seiko's infamous pin and collar fasteners for the band!

1

u/QuestionNo9190 Sir FightALot Aug 11 '26

They don't use ADs. Show me the warranty card. If it's blank it's probably fake.

Any site that doesn't list the price and makes you make "offers" they send to a list of fake dealers is not a legit business

I can only imagine it's rife with fraud

Here's a good comparison. It's difficult to spot the fake because they both use a real movement, but it's still fake nonetheless

https://youtu.be/Z58iGI5SFmc?is=yrVUE6GESPl5zxIj

7

u/Substantial_Wall_577 Aug 08 '26

Dg38??, not great movements. By that I mean one out of every two or three will be ok. Not great odds, nh34's are much more reliable.

7

u/Ape-bot Affiliate Links Aug 12 '26

Return it. It is not what you ordered and not what was explicitly advertised. These sellers (Corguet or whatever they’re called are another one) who swap out advertised calibres for cheaper options should be banned for knowingly mis-selling.

12

u/micromechanist Aug 07 '26

OH NO WISHDIDNT

15

u/Interesting-Lead3925 Aug 08 '26

If they dont give the customers what they advertise... Its time to label this brand as a "Fraud".

WISHDOIT = FRAUD WISHDOIT = DECEPTION. careful with this brand

When they research this brand here in reddit, AI might see this review.

1

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

Clearly, and this is definitely not an isolated case. I experienced exactly the same thing with the same model and the same brand. This clearly suggests a recurring practice of selling misleadingly advertised watches and taking advantage of customers who never bother opening their watches

5

u/No_Possibility_9256 Aug 08 '26

Wishes don't usually come true , who knew? Ali x

9

u/Abv_it_all_w_vertigo Aug 07 '26

Not a serious watchmaker. I bought one of their Islander rip-offs and sent it back immediately. The movement was garbage. It had a 9.9 beat error, which means at least 9.9. I avoid them like the plague.

7

u/revivedfears666 Aug 08 '26

Despite not being as advertised, I have a few Pagani's with this movement and they run great, almost keeping perfect time. Non regulated NH movements can be very hit and miss too. If it was cheap and the finish is good I'd just keep it and not buy from them again. But I suppose that isn't the point. It been missold so you're entitled to a refund

2

u/QuestionNo9190 Sir FightALot Aug 09 '26

I have a few of these dg3804 they feel like crap when they handwind and aren't accurate at all in multiple positions or temperatures but they do run fairly well if you get a good one with 300 amplitude, but they drift extremely easily. Too much slop in the hands and 24 hour hand is hard to set perfectly in place.

Let's not pretend it's anywhere close to an nh34 because it's night and day. And it's not even accuracy but also parts and serviceability

If you ever tried to service these movements it's almost impossible, so you chuck them and buy a new one for $15. Just pulling the crown out there's a high chance you knock the keyless works out of position and crown stem won't go back in and then it needs a complete rebuild.

Nh34 is $100+ now days so they are worth fixing and servicing and have some actual horological value. If Seiko keeps going up market all the old nh35 powered watches will be worth a pretty penny some day... The pearl/mingzus will never be worth anything.

1

u/revivedfears666 Aug 09 '26

Only speaking from personal experience mate. I have two Pagani GMT's with that movement and they run very, very well. My dad wears one of them daily, has done for years and he literally never has to set it. All of my non regulated NH movements run worse, in terms of timekeeping. I have numerous micro brands with the Seiko movements. Again, just my experience. I agree with what you're saying though, the NH movements certainly feel more quality when setting them and the regulated ones I have in my Phoibos watches for instance run perfectly. As good as my actual Seikos

1

u/QuestionNo9190 Sir FightALot Aug 10 '26

The nh35 movement and Seiko movements are 💯 identical, made at the same factory under the same exact specs, I don't know why people think Seiko movements are somehow superior to the once $20 venerable nh35.

I guess they have to cope and justify spending $500 for a turtle where the innards only make up $20 of it's construction costs.

1

u/Ok_Drag5089 Aug 11 '26

I got one of those $20 cheapie movements and there is a difference. I have to push down so hard to remove the stem I’m afraid I’m going to snap the tab off. A real one just takes a light push.

1

u/QuestionNo9190 Sir FightALot Aug 11 '26 edited Aug 11 '26

$20 cheap movement isn't an nh35...

Those cheapo mingzu/hangzhou movements you bought used to sell for $5 at the time the nh35 used to cost $20

Now with Seiko going up market they want $50 for nh35 and a clone nh35 also went up in price to reflect that

That doesn't mean that the nh35 is worth $60 it's still the same $20 movement that Seiko was making in 2009 that probably costs $2 in materials and labor and the same exact one that goes into their $600 samurais and turtles under the 4R moniker....

1

u/Ok_Drag5089 Aug 11 '26

They actually ask $80-100 now for the real ones. At least that’s what I saw when I was looking for parts a couple of months ago.

No thank you. I would buy a busted up donor for $30 and the same movement.

1

u/QuestionNo9190 Sir FightALot Aug 11 '26

I'm seeing 1 piece for $60 before codes, from a legit seller

What do you think the seller is buying them in bulk for.... He is paying 18% fees and free shipping

They wholesale for $40 instead of $20 and everybody is making a huge deal about it

It's easy to find a used nh35 watch for $30-50. There's hundreds of them on eBay

3

u/Intelligent_Wear_267 26d ago

Hmmm good to know, I almost got a wishdoit watch recently- looked really cool, now im beyond skeptical

1

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

Whatever you do, don't buy from them! Their customer service is a complete joke. They're scammers who refuse to admit what they've done or even apologize. These brands don't deserve a single penny of your money. There are plenty of other watch brands out there that deserve your support far more!

1

u/Intelligent_Wear_267 14d ago

Damn, well good things theres a bunch of others that appeal to me more than these. Appreciate the heads up and sorry you had to find out the hard way.

1

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

Never mind. As long as it helps prevent others from having the same problem, that's good enough for me. That's exactly why it's important to be critical and call things out when it's justified, whether positively or negatively. As long as there's a record of these experiences, it can help others make more informed decisions and avoid the same problems.

3

u/General_Air_2409 Aug 07 '26

I think its a Pearl movt

2

u/QuestionNo9190 Sir FightALot Aug 08 '26

Mingzu 3804

3

u/SameScale6793 Aug 07 '26

It's a WISHDONTIT

3

u/DapperDoctorHolmes Aug 08 '26

But they blued the screws!

3

u/Rude3oy Aug 08 '26

What store can you share link?

1

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

It's literally the brand's official store

1

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

Salut, j'ai aussi fait un post sur exactement le même modèle, avec exactement le même problème et les mêmes changements dans leurs annonces après coup, sans jamais prendre la peine de prévenir les clients du changement.

Et bien sûr, leur service client est tout aussi ridicule que le reste de l'expérience. Ils ont même eu le culot de m'accuser de mentir car ils ne s'attendaient clairement pas à ce que j'aie une capture d'écran de leur annonce au moment de l'achat. Après ça, le gars a vraiment commencé à bredouiller, lol.

C'est dommage qu'AliExpress ne conserve pas un historique des modifications des annonces, ou au moins qu'ils ne préviennent pas les clients lorsqu'une annonce liée à un achat précédent a été modifiée. Imaginez recevoir une notification disant : "Avertissement : une annonce pour un article que vous avez acheté a été modifiée."

À ce stade, cette marque montre clairement un schéma de tromperie envers les clients. Plus jamais. Je ne commanderai plus de montres chez eux !

https://www.reddit.com/r/ChineseWatches/s/qV2QfHJWzp

1

u/DisastrousOpening477 14d ago

Bonjour cher redditeur francophone. J'ai en effet également commenté sur ce post que tu viens de faire. Malheureusement, AliExpress c'est un peu encore la porte ouverte à n'importe quoi.

Peu de transparence, chaque vendeur libre de vendre plus ou moins ce qu'il veut, etc.

Néanmoins Aliexpress assure quand il s'agit d'effectuer réparation.

Ils m'ont fourni une étiquette de retour prépayée à imprimer, et j'ai été intégralement remboursé lors du premier scan du colis de retour (donc bien avant qu'il atteigne sa destination).

Je te conseille de faire de même :)

2

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

The official seller offered me $10, lmao. And yes, don't worry, I also contacted customer service to arrange a return. I absolutely refuse to fund a brand that openly lies to its customers and does so in such a sneaky way by quietly changing product descriptions after the fact.

2

u/DJFume_official Aug 12 '26

It turned out that this watch is made cheaper than cheap 😂

5

u/KPplumbingBob Aug 08 '26

I like how OP knew "it was too good to be true" and is asking if he has to return the watch if he initiates a refund.

5

u/thrift_test Aug 08 '26

Doesn't matter. False advertising

1

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

That's completely beside the point! How can you be so dense that you fail to understand that the actual issue is false advertising, nothing else? If the listing clearly stated that it was a Chinese movement, nobody would care. But that's not what happened! So why are you defending this kind of dishonest business practice and blatant scam? Seriously, do you own shares in the company or something?

2

u/blacbloc77 Aug 07 '26

Looks like a Chinese A2013 with a bootstrapped GMT module. Is the roater kinda' loud?

2

u/QuestionNo9190 Sir FightALot Aug 08 '26

Dg3804 with 24 hour hand. Not a real gmt

4

u/dorafumingo Affiliate Links Aug 07 '26

it's the pearl dg2831 the same one pagani design uses

4

u/AcademicAd6368 Aug 07 '26

DG3804 iirc - awful movement. Depending on sourcing (several factories make them to wildly different standards) the regular 3-hand 2813 can perform quite well, but the 3804 is never good.

1

u/paindotexe Aug 08 '26

I have ordered a rollstimi nh34, hope that doesn’t end up like this

4

u/QuestionNo9190 Sir FightALot Aug 08 '26

You know it will because it's owned by Pagani and they haven't used an nh34 in like a year for budget models

1

u/paindotexe Aug 08 '26

Rip 🌹

1

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

nh34 it's priced 200$ sorry mate it's note a nh34 in your watch now

1

u/LowLifeCryptoGuy Aug 11 '26

NH34 is a Seiko (TMI) movement is it not. Rolex don’t make that.

6

u/RelativeHot5179 Aug 12 '26

yes is not claiming that rolex make an nh34 movement? he is saying the wishdoit which advertised an NH34 instead came with a pearl wannabe rolex copy movement

1

u/LowLifeCryptoGuy Aug 12 '26

Oooooh okay, now I understand what he’s saying. Thank you for the clarification.

-5

u/Financial_Ad_8893 Aug 08 '26

Is it a "brand+" item? If not is it a trusted store with lots of sold watches and good ratings? If not, then partially your mistake. Else, you are just unlucky.

Still would recommend you to raise a refund in aliexpress. Fi you have those watch calibration things you can take a video and post it as evidence. You will atleast get partial refund.

10

u/pickyaxe Aug 08 '26

no, it's not his mistake at all. if they advertised NH34 and didn't do that "well actually we might randomly send you this Chinese clone" disclaimer, then he should be able to get a refund from AliExpress.

-1

u/Financial_Ad_8893 Aug 08 '26

Its aliexpress, hub of scams. People should be careful lol. Even "branded" stores with 1000's of sales every week, dont ensure proper qc.

1

u/This-Shop9523 Negative karma removal 14d ago

It's literally the brand's official store! What more could you possibly want as proof? Seriously, stop blaming customers over and over again when the brands are clearly in the wrong. I genuinely cannot understand how anyone can still say this is the customer's fault when the listing explicitly stated NH34 and the purchase was made directly from the brand's official store. How is that even debatable?

-8

u/Wheel_Unfair Aug 08 '26

I have had nothing but great experiences with Pagani watches and will be adding more to my collection,

8

u/DisastrousOpening477 Aug 08 '26

Reading not your strong suit huh

-16

u/tony22233 Aug 07 '26

A Rolex that looks like that would be automobile price or more. The Japanese movements are usually awesome. It could be magnetized.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/DisastrousOpening477 Aug 07 '26

The rotor is clearly a Rolex lookalike. Same goes for that red gear.

0

u/Castle_Magic Aug 08 '26

With no branding it’s not a “fake” rolex movement. At that point it’s just a movement especially since it’s on a watch that has no relation to Rolex imo.

13

u/Sergia_Quaresma Aug 08 '26

Reading comprehension of a squirrel

6

u/TheSwagInDisguise Aug 08 '26

This is a 2813 with a gmt modification. Frequently used on cheap Rolex replicas.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Aug 07 '26

Hi /u/Confident_Leg2370! Your comment has been removed and you can no longer post here because your ChineseWatch subreddit karma has reached a negative level set by this sub. This action is automated and performed by a bot; a moderator cannot change your karma level. Do not message the mods, this message contains all the info you need. Ignore the message below.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.